Search This Blog

1. Theodore Fearnow & Cal Price at Beartown

 

 


 ⛰️ We could explore the Cheat Mountain Club's private fish hatchery on Shavers Fork, or look into Theodore Fearnow's expedition with Cal Price to explore the caves and fissures of Beartown on Droop Mountain.

1. Theodore Fearnow & Cal Price at Beartown

In his Pocahontas Times writings on Droop Mountain, editor Calvin W. Price chronicled joining an expedition into Big Beartown and Little Beartown.

  • The Expedition Party: Cal joined the expedition alongside his nephew, state geologist Paul H. Price, and Theodore C. Fearnow. Cal noted that the State had recently hired Fearnow to study fish life, improve breeds, and stock local streams. Fearnow was a second-generation fish culturist, being the son of E. C. Fearnow of the National Bureau of Fisheries in Washington, D.C.. Because of his unusual surname, Cal jokingly nicknamed him "Dreadnaught".
  • Droop Mountain Sandstone: The geologists and writers examined the rimrock formation of Droop Mountain. Cal observed that Droop Mountain was a geological oddity—having eroded down after rising from an ancient sea and shedding thousands of feet of superstructure to expose a rare, fine glass sand known as Droop Mountain sandstone.
  • Little Beartown's Crevice & Year-Round Ice: The explorers first encountered Little Beartown, characterized by a gaping fissure about three feet wide, fifty feet long, and twenty feet deep. Cal noted that a fall into the crevice would be fatal or cause severe injury without outside rescue. In the deepest, sunless clefts, ice remained throughout the entire summer, though local settlers had recently begun carrying it off for domestic use.
  • Big Beartown's "Streets and Neolithic Apartments": Entering Big Beartown, the party found a labyrinth of towering perpendicular walls rising as high as two-story houses. Walled passages between ten and twenty feet wide resembled ancient avenues. Cal described the group walking through a silent rock city along "Rock Street," turning onto "Stone Street," and exploring sheltered recessed chambers they dubbed the "Neolithic Apartments" before picking up an old Indian trail to return home.
  • Frontier Lore & Revolutionary Skirmishes: Cal connected the natural rock fortress to local frontier warfare. Investigating the history of Captain William Poage (whose fortified home on the Levels Terrace was known as Poage's Fort during the Revolution), Cal reviewed the Revolutionary War pension claims of Jacob Hess [48–50]. Hess claimed that Poage’s scouts had pursued an Indian raiding party from Anthony’s Creek and Tygarts Valley, routing them among the rock fissures of Beartown.

2. The Cheat Mountain Club & Shavers Fork Hatchery

Farther north on the high plateau of Cheat Mountain, private sportsmen’s groups established their own trout propagation waters:

  • The Club on Shavers Fork: The Cheat Mountain Club was located along Shavers Fork of the Cheat River, approximately two miles above the Cheat River covered bridge along the Staunton and Parkersburg Turnpike. The club property encompassed an antebellum log clubhouse and thousands of acres spanning Randolph and Pocahontas counties. It was later consolidated with the Allegheny Sportsmen’s Association.
  • The Private Fish Hatchery: To maintain trout fishing for its members, the club constructed its own fish hatchery directly on the grounds. Surviving archival photographs show the Cheat Club fish hatchery complex featuring a rustic hewn-log operations cabin flanked by long, parallel wooden rearing troughs and stone raceways fed by cold mountain spring water.
  • A Fisher's Paradise: Club elevation and stream charts measured the first floor of the clubhouse at 3,450 feet, with private fishing trails and footbridges stretching upstream past Chad's Run, Grass Island (3,650 ft), and Fallen Trees Meadow (3,670 ft). The high, cold waters were stocked with brook and rainbow trout, complementing the wild native populations that had drawn anglers and naturalists to Cheat Mountain since before the Civil War.

🎣 We could explore the Civil War battle fought on Cheat River right where the Cheat Mountain Clubhouse stands, or look into the legendary bear hunts that took place along the high cliffs of Droop and Black mountains.

 

1. The Civil War Encounter at the Cheat Mountain Clubhouse Site (September 1861)

The battle fought where the Cheat Mountain Clubhouse later stood on Shavers Fork was the climax of General Robert E. Lee’s ill-fated Cheat Mountain Campaign in September 1861:

  • The Staging & The Night March: Union General Joseph J. Reynolds held fortified camps at Elkwater in Tygart’s Valley and atop Cheat Mountain Summit (known as White’s Top, at an elevation of roughly 4,200 feet along the Staunton and Parkersburg Turnpike). Lee devised a coordinated assault: while troops from Valley Mountain moved down Tygart's Valley, an assaulting column of roughly 1,500 to 2,000 men under Colonel Albert Rust (3rd Arkansas) was ordered to leave the pike at Camp Bartow, climb Back Allegheny Mountain, cross the high spruce wilderness and Shavers Fork at night, and take the Cheat Summit fort in the rear.
  • The "Jungle of Cheat": The Confederate troops—largely lowlanders unaccustomed to mountain wilderness—became hopelessly entangled in the dense red spruce, tangled rhododendron ("hobblerod" and laurel), and windfalls during a freezing rain that turned into the season's first snow. Although portions of the flanking force succeeded in cutting the telegraph line and capturing three Federal supply wagons west of the summit on the morning of September 12, Colonel Rust took counsel of his fears after interrogating prisoners, believed the fortifications impregnable, and failed to launch the agreed-upon dawn assault.
  • The "Whip Chase" & Battle at the Clubhouse Site: On Friday, September 13, the 14th Indiana infantry stationed at the Summit began sweeping the mountain woods. Realizing the Confederates were disorganized and retreating eastward toward the Greenbrier River, the Federal commander at the Summit dispatched troops down the Staunton and Parkersburg Pike to line the river:

    “Learning that a whip chase was under way to the west and that the Confederates were working out towards the Greenbrier River, with the Indiana boys driving them, the commander at the Summit sent some companies of soldiers east over the pike and had them line Cheat River above the bridge, and a battle was fought on that river about two miles above that bridge at a point near where the Cheat Mountain Clubhouse now stands”.

  • The Panicked Retreat: Federal reports recorded that a blocking force of roughly 300 men stopped and drove back the disorganized Confederate columns. The retreat became a rout, with woodsmen reporting that the mountainsides were strewn with discarded knapsacks, blankets, coats, and muskets as the Confederate troops struggled back through the brush to Camp Bartow, not arriving until late that night. Years later, when the virgin spruce around Shavers Fork was logged off, lumber crews routinely uncovered rusted muskets, sabers, and bayonets left behind in those mossy gorges.

2. Legendary Bear Hunts Along the High Cliffs of Black Mountain & Droop

The rocky rimrocks of Black Mountain and the limestone crevices of Droop Mountain were notorious throughout the county as the lairs of giant black bears that raided valley livestock:

  • Francis McCoy’s Bear Hug on Black Mountain (c. 1880): Around 1880, local woodsman Francis McCoy and Rev. Asa Shinn McNeill traveled into the Black Mountain wilderness to watch a deer lick. At dusk, McCoy heard a stick snap behind his blind and saw a massive 400-pound, seven-foot bear closing in.
    • McCoy fired his set rifle, aiming for the head, but the bear jerked at the discharge; the bullet shattered its lower jaw.
    • The wounded beast lunged forward and locked McCoy in a crushing hug. McCoy, celebrated as one of the strongest men in the mountains, wrestled the bear through the rocks and fallen timber. The bear attempted to bite him, but its broken jaw prevented it from getting a grip—a stroke of luck, as old hunters knew a bear could not effectively rake with its hind claws without biting.
    • Hearing the commotion, Rev. McNeill rushed up with his gun. Working carefully in the dark to avoid shooting his friend, McCoy wrestled the thrashing beast around until McNeill could thrust the muzzle of his rifle directly against the bear's ribs and shoot it dead.
  • The Hunt for "Three Foot" on Black Mountain: One of the most famous rogue bears in Pocahontas County history was "Three Foot," an old sheep killer that had escaped a 40-pound steel spiked trap near Mill Point years earlier by tearing off its right front foot.
    • After "Three Foot" killed dozens of sheep across Cranberry and Stamping Creek, a massive hunt was organized. Veteran bear hunter Emory Miller took command, posting an armed cordon of twenty-five men and fresh hounds stretching from the High Rocks to the Big Loop on Black Mountain.
    • Master hunters Charles Tacy, Dick Smith of Edray, and Ernest Jackson slipped their fighting hounds (including Smith’s prized trailer, Ratler) onto the cold trail.
    • After hours of tracking through the cliffs, the hounds cornered the three-legged bear on Little Black Mountain near Barlow Top. Charles Tacy worked through the thick brush and placed a shot into the bear's flank, followed by fatal rifle rounds from Jackson and Dick Smith.
  • Hunting the Rocks of Droop & Cheat: Whenever livestock was killed in the Little Levels or along the upper Greenbrier, calls went out for Charles and Dallas Tacy and their famous pack of bear-fighting dogs.
    • On one hunt originating near Linwood, the Tacy hounds trailed an old 300-pound sheep-killing bear across the mountain, over the Western Maryland tracks at the Big Cut near Spruce, and cornered it in a deep rock crevice on the Tygart's Valley side. The hounds perched on a rock ledge eight feet above the den until Charles Tacy climbed down and dispatched it.
    • Local chroniclers noted that the jagged fissures of Beartown on Droop Mountain and the rocky overhangs of the Allegheny rim were favored winter dens where bears holed up before the heavy snows.

🐾 We could look into the old pioneer stories of panthers and wolves in the county, like the night hunters were chased into trees along the Greenbrier River or early settlers using wolf calls to collect county bounties.

The dense laurel tangles and limestone cliffs of Pocahontas County and the Trans-Allegheny border were once home to prowling timber wolves and mountain panthers (cougars). Surviving court records, pioneer histories, and hunting memoirs preserve vivid accounts of early encounters with these predators:


1. Treed by a Pack: The Peril of the Wolf Call

Pioneer hunters frequently imitated the howls of wolves to locate packs or lure them within rifle range to collect the cash bounties paid for their scalps:

  • Henry Glaze's Decoy Call: Late one evening while hunting along the mountain base near the Buckhannon trail, hunter Henry Glaze discovered fresh wolf sign. Seeking to decoy one within range for the bounty, he sounded a wolf howl. An answering cry echoed back through the timber, followed by calls from multiple points in the woods.
  • The Narrowing Circle: Elated, Glaze repeated the howl. Each successive cry drew responses closer and from a rapidly tightening ring. Suddenly hearing the rapid patter of feet through dry leaves, Glaze realized he was surrounded; he dropped his rifle and scrambled into the branches of a large dogwood bush.
  • A Night in the Dogwood: Within moments, a starving pack surrounded the tree, their froth-covered jaws snapping and eyes glowing in the starlight. Glaze was forced to spend the entire night perched in the branches while the wolves fought and snarled at the base, only descending after daybreak when the last animal slunk away into the laurel.

2. Wolf Scalps as Currency & The "Wolf Breeders"

  • Scalps as Frontier Legal Tender: During the early settlement of Augusta and Botetourt counties (which initially governed the Greenbrier Valley), wolves multiplied so rapidly that special acts were passed to levy taxes specifically to hire wolf hunters. In 1750, Augusta County paid bounties on 256 wolf heads, and in 1751 on 224 heads. Pioneer leader William Preston turned in 103 heads in 1754, with court historians noting that "wolf heads constituted a kind of currency" used to pay debts and purchase land. In 1770, Botetourt recorded 169 wolf heads brought in for bounty ($5.00 for a grown wolf and $2.50 for a cub). By the 1850s, Pocahontas County court records show bounties maintained on predatory livestock pests, including wildcats ($1.00), red foxes ($1.00), gray foxes (50 cents), and black bears ($1.00).
  • "Farming" the Dens: The state bounty of eight dollars a scalp (later reduced to four) was so lucrative that some settlers deliberately managed known dens. Settler George Hurst discovered a cavern on the Cheat River watershed where a mother wolf whelped. Rather than killing the breeding female, Hurst captured the pups year after year just before they left the den to claim the bounty, letting the mother escape to raise another litter.

3. Torches in the Hemlocks: The Upper Greenbrier Panther Hunt

Early border chronicles record thrilling encounters with panthers along the Greenbrier:

  • Adam Arbogast & John Yeager: Pioneer settler Adam Arbogast of the upper Greenbrier was out hunting when his hounds treed an enormous panther in a massive hemlock tree.
  • Climbing with a Torch: Arbogast called for his neighbor, John Yeager, who was renowned as a fearless climber. Yeager lit a pine torch and climbed the giant tree in the dark, holding the burning brand in one hand. Once he located the crouching panther in the boughs, Yeager set the torch between two limbs, backed down the trunk until he could reach the loaded flintlock rifle Arbogast handed up to him, climbed back to his torch, and shot the beast out of the tree by torchlight.

4. Stalked in the Dark: The 1878 Greenbrier River Ambush

  • Lost in the Laurel: In the autumn of 1878, a hunting party was encamped along the Greenbrier River in Pocahontas County. Five hunters became separated three miles from camp in a pathless, pitch-black tangle of pine and dripping rhododendron during a dense fog and heavy rain, guided only by camp members firing heavy rifle rounds into the night.
  • The Pounce from the Brush: Bringing up the rear of the file, young hunter Cyrus S. McWhorter noticed stealthy footsteps tracking him in the dark. Suddenly, a large panther leaped from the brush, crashing down over the laurel within four to five feet of him.
  • Shooting Blind: Turning instantly, McWhorter thrust his rifle muzzle directly toward the sound and fired. The muzzle flash and roar frightened the predator, which fled screeching into the thickets just as a torchlit rescue party arrived from camp.

5. The Tapping Tail on the Log

Just months prior to that 1878 incident, a young man named Coff was searching for stray cattle in the same Greenbrier forest when night caught him several miles from home. Sitting down on a fallen log to rest, he dozed off, only to be awakened by a persistent, rhythmic "tap, tap, tap" in the dry leaves right behind him. Mistaking it at first for a hopping rabbit, Coff looked back and came face-to-face with a panther that was nervously twitching and beating its tail against the ground as it prepared to spring. When Coff jerked around, the startled animal bounded into the dark and raced over a distant ridge, screaming as it went.


🐾 We could look into the old traditions of pioneer women defending their cabins from predators, like Mrs. Gothrup killing a panther with an axe when her powder ran out.

The pioneer histories of the Trans-Allegheny border preserve gripping traditions of frontier women defending their homesteads, children, and livestock when dangerous predators encroached upon their cabins:


1. Mrs. Gothrup’s Panther & The Axe

In the early days of settlement in what became Taylor County, West Virginia, Mrs. Gothrup faced an intruder right in her cabin clearing:

  • The Attack on the Sheep: One winter day, while her husband was away from home, a large panther slipped into the yard and seized one of the family’s sheep.
  • The Broken Back: Grabbing the cabin’s rifle, Mrs. Gothrup took aim and fired, striking the marauder and breaking its back.
  • No More Powder: The disabled panther collapsed on the snow, thrashing in fury and filling the woods with terrible shrieks and growls. Finding that the cabin’s supply of gunpowder had run out, Mrs. Gothrup called to a passing neighbor, asking him to finish the beast with an axe.
  • Delivering the Fatal Blow: When the neighbor declined the hazardous honor, Mrs. Gothrup stepped forward herself, raised the axe, and dispatched the squirming predator with a single, well-placed blow.

2. Mrs. Wolf’s "Penknife Spear" on Hacker’s Creek

A similarly resourceful defense was mounted on Hacker’s Creek by Mrs. Wolf when she was out in the woods looking for her stray cows:

  • The Bear in the Branches: A small dog accompanying her cornered a black bear and chased it up a tree.
  • Lashing the Penknife: Mrs. Wolf had no rifle with her and saw that the bear was preparing to back down the trunk to attack the dog and escape. Having only a pocket penknife, the intrepid woman quickly stripped strips of tough hickory bark from a nearby sapling and lashed the open knife blade to the end of a long pole.
  • Prodding Bruin at Bay: Standing beneath the tree, she used this improvised spear to repeatedly prod and jab the bear every time it attempted to climb down, keeping the animal pinned on its high limb until her husband heard the commotion, ran to the scene with his rifle, and shot it.

3. The Panther at the Cradle on Cheat River

Along the upper Cheat River, a young pioneer mother faced a terrifying cabin intrusion while her husband was out hunting:

  • The Open Doorway: The mother was busy inside the cabin while her infant was asleep in a wooden cradle near the open door.
  • Mistaken for a Calf: Seeing a large, gaunt animal enter the yard and approach the doorway, she at first carelessly assumed it was a stray farm calf.
  • Saved by the Cabin Fice: The beast was actually a starving panther, which thrust its head directly through the door to sniff at the sleeping child. Before it could spring into the room, the family’s small pet dog—a noisy little fice—flew across the floor at the predator’s face, barking furiously and driving the startled cat back across the clearing and up a nearby yard tree.
  • Holding the Tree: The tiny dog held the panther bayed on the limbs while the mother ran out and screamed for her husband, who was still within hearing distance and hurried back to shoot it.

4. Chasing Wolves from the Cabin Walls

Frontier women were equally fearless when wolf packs surrounded isolated homesteads:

  • The Wolf at the Corner of the House: On McKinney’s Run, a marauding timber wolf slipped into the yard in broad daylight, caught a sheep, and began throttling it directly against the corner of the log cabin. Hearing the frantic commotion outside the logs, the grandmother of chronicler Lucullus McWhorter dashed out the door unarmed and charged the wolf, chasing the predator away into the timber and saving the stock.
  • Treed in the Beech Tree: In that same valley, Mrs. Edmonds was returning home along the ridge dividing Lost Creek and McKinney’s Run late one evening when she was stalked and pursued by a pack of wolves. Realizing she could not outrun them in the dark, she scrambled up into a beech tree and remained perched on the limbs until family members came searching through the forest with blazing pine torches, which scattered the howling pack.

5. The Frontier Axe as the Ultimate Cabin Weapon

This willingness to wield edge tools was part of a broader border tradition where women turned kitchen and clearing implements into deadly cabin defenses [53, 90, 92–93]. When Native American war parties raided isolated homesteads—such as Mary Bozarth on Dunkard Creek in 1778 or Mrs. John Bush on Freeman’s Creek in 1791—both women grabbed heavy axes from the hearth, cutting down intruders who broke through the doorways and barring the log shutters against bullets and tomahawks [53, 90, 92–93, 150, 157].


🍳 We could explore the old folklore surrounding Appalachian cabin hearths, such as pioneer superstitions about witches bewitching cattle and butter churns, or early hunters relying on omen dreams like the "red doe."

 

The folklore of early Appalachian cabins was deeply tied to the isolation of the frontier, where inexplicable misfortunes—spoiled food, failing rifles, or sudden sickness—were routinely attributed to the occult, witches’ spells, and supernatural portents.


1. Witches, Cattle, and "Blinked" Milk

  • The "Blinked" Milk & The Evil Eye: In mountain dialect, milk that suddenly turned sour was known as "blinked milk". The expression dated back to the belief in the "evil eye"—the ancient idea that if a witch cast a baleful glance (or "blinked") at a cow, pail, or butter churn, her evil machinations instantly soured the milk and ruined the churning.
  • Milking from a Tablecloth & Stump: Settlers firmly believed that a witch could steal the substance of their cows without ever touching the herd. One pioneer tenant on the West Fork was convinced he could never keep a cow because a neighboring woman, reputed to be a witch, "would draw the milk by spreading a tablecloth over a hollow stump and then 'stripping' at the four corners".
  • Exorcising Witches by Fire: When livestock died under mysterious circumstances, settlers believed the animal was bewitched. To destroy the witch responsible, the owner would burn the carcass of the horse or pig on a brush heap and perforate the burning body with a sharpened wooden stake. In one West Fork case, while the carcass was being consumed and pierced, the settler swore he saw a shadowy black cat leap from the flames and vanish, which was believed to be the destroyed witch. Another farmer dismantled and burned his entire log stable with the dead horse inside to eradicate the witch’s curse.

2. The "Human Steed" & The Silver Bullet

  • The Midnight Ride to Weston: A persistent tradition in the mountain valleys was that witches could cast spells over sleeping men, transforming them into "human steeds" to be bridled and ridden across the mountains at night. One settler living near the headwaters of the West Fork claimed a witch bridled him and galloped him ten miles to Weston and back in a single night. To his astonishment, the invisible rider treated him like a horse, feeding him "eight big y'ars uv yaller co'n jes' like I wus a hoss", leaving the exhausted man to limp seven miles the next morning to consult a witch doctor to break the spell.
  • Elkany Roby, the Lewis County Wizard: When spells afflicted guns, churning, or cattle, families sent for a professional "witch doctor" [133, 138–139]. The most famous in central West Virginia was Elkany ("Elky") Roby of Collins Settlement in Lewis County [138–139].
    • If a hunter’s flintlock continuously missed game, Roby unbreeched the gun and inspected the shot-pouch. If the spell was deep, Roby executed the witch using a silver bullet.
    • He drew a charcoal outline of the witch on a wooden board, propped it against a tree facing south, and charged his rifle with a silver bullet topped with a secret charm from his mouth. Muttering an incantation, he fired; when a splotch of fresh blood miraculously appeared on the board over the heart, the witch was pronounced slain or banished.
    • In Gilmer County, Roby was called to cure a bewitched sugar camp where an entire "run" of maple syrup turned salty and foul [141–142]. After shooting the witch's image with his silver bullet in the center of the grove, sweet sap immediately resumed flowing, and he was paid with fifty pounds of finished sugar [142–143].

3. Hunter Omens: Alexander West’s "Red Doe" and Dropped Lead

Frontier scouts and hunters navigating the wilderness lived by a strict code of auguries and omens:

  • Alexander West & The "Red Doe": Renowned scout Alexander West was famous among border rangers for his prophetic dreams [159–160, 183–184]. While on sentry duty in the wilderness, West sat with his back to a tree, rifle across his lap, and fell into a light sleep. Waking with a start, he leaped up and shouted to his comrades:

    "Boys, look out! Some of us will be killed to-day! I saw the red doe in my dream; that is the sign of death; I never knew it to fail!" [159, 183–184]. That very morning, scout John Bonnett was fatally shot, which the men in camp accepted as an undeniable verification of the "red sign" [159–160, 184]. West maintained that whenever a red doe crossed his dreams, the death or mortal wounding of an associate followed without fail.

  • The "Red Buck" of Elk River: A similar omen preceded the death of pioneer Benjamin Carpenter on Elk River. In March, Carpenter shot a large buck whose coat was bright red—an unnatural sight, as mountain deer never turned red until midsummer. His brother Jeremiah warned him that the unseasonal red buck foretold an awful tragedy. Ben ignored the warning and went to dress the hide on his graining block, where Indian raiders shot and killed both him and his wife.
  • The Dropped Bullet: A universal superstition among early hunters held that if, while rapidly loading a rifle, the hunter accidentally dropped the lead ball on the ground, picking it back up and ramming it down the barrel guaranteed it would miss the target, regardless of how true the aim.

4. Cabin Portents: The Bird in the Room & Premonitions of Doom

  • The Bird on the Hearth: Among Scotch-Irish settlers, it was a terrifying omen if a wild bird accidentally flew into a cabin. It was believed that a member of the household would die. On the day before Indian warriors attacked the cabin of Mrs. Phoebe Cunningham, a small woodland bird flew through the door and fluttered wildly around the room, leaving her with a lifelong terror whenever a bird approached her home.
  • The Thrice-Repeated Scalping Dream: Dreams of impending death were held in great awe. In 1774, while the Battle of Point Pleasant was raging on the Ohio River, the young daughter of Captain John Frogge in Staunton woke her mother screaming three separate times that Indians were killing and scalping her father. The premonition caused an uproar throughout the town; days later, word arrived that Frogge had indeed been killed in the battle that very day while wearing a bright red coat.

🕯️ We could explore the old customs of early Appalachian schoolhouses and "singing schools," where itinerant masters taught four-note shape music by candlelight in one-room log cabins.

 



No comments:

Post a Comment

Restoration of Watoga State Park

  The Cold Concrete Dilemma: 4 Surprising Takeaways from the Hidden History of Watoga State Park's Historic Swimming Pool Introduction W...

Shaker Posts