Research the theme of "Thanks" as a word, an emotion, an expression. Correlate the story of the 10 lepers in which only one returned to give thanks. Include the KJV text of that Bible Story.
The Wholeness of Thanks: A Multi-Disciplinary Inquiry into Gratitude
Introduction: The Ubiquitous and Profound Nature of Gratitude
The expression "thank you" is among the most common and seemingly simple phrases in human language, a piece of social lubricant applied to countless daily interactions, from receiving a cup of coffee to accepting a life-altering gift. Yet, beneath this veneer of mundane politeness lies a concept of profound complexity and power. Gratitude is at once a word with a deep cognitive history, an emotion with the capacity to reshape the human brain, a social act governed by intricate cultural rules, and a spiritual posture that stands at the heart of philosophical and religious traditions worldwide. To truly understand "thanks" is to embark on a multi-disciplinary inquiry into the very nature of human connection, well-being, and meaning.
This report undertakes such an inquiry, arguing for a central thesis: the true, transformative power of gratitude is unlocked not in the passive reception of a benefit, but in the active, conscious, and expressed return of thanks. It is an act that completes a circuit, turning a one-way transaction into a reciprocal, life-affirming relationship. To navigate this exploration, the report will journey through several distinct but interconnected domains. It begins with a linguistic deconstruction, tracing the etymology of "thanks" to its surprising roots in the concept of "thought," thereby establishing gratitude as a fundamentally cognitive act. From there, it moves into the realm of science, examining the vast body of psychological and neurological research that documents gratitude's remarkable effects on mental and physical health. This scientific foundation then gives way to a deep theological analysis, which uses a single, powerful biblical narrative as its analytical touchstone: the story of the ten lepers from the Gospel of Luke.
This ancient parable, in which ten men are healed of a devastating disease but only one—an outsider—returns to give thanks, dramatizes the report's central theme. It poses a question that echoes through the ages: "Were there not ten cleansed? but where are the nine?".1 This report is, in essence, an extended answer to that question. It explores why the nine might not have returned by examining the complex cultural and social grammars that govern the expression of gratitude, revealing how what seems polite in one context can be perceived as rude or distant in another. Finally, the report synthesizes these findings with the wisdom of global philosophy, religion, and literature, weaving a tapestry of voices that speak to gratitude's status as a cardinal virtue and a universal path to a richer life. By moving from the word to the mind, from society to the soul, this investigation aims to reveal that the simple act of returning thanks is the catalyst that elevates mere healing into a state of profound and lasting wholeness.
Section 1: The Genealogy of a Word: From "Thought" to "Thanks"
The journey to understand gratitude begins with the word itself. An etymological excavation of "thank" and its cognates reveals that the concept is not primarily rooted in emotion or reciprocity, but in the faculty of cognition. The history of the word demonstrates that, for the progenitors of the English language, to thank someone was, fundamentally, to think of them. This cognitive foundation distinguishes the Germanic concept of gratitude from other world traditions and provides a crucial framework for understanding its psychological power.
The Proto-Indo-European Root
The linguistic lineage of "thank" traces back to the Proto-Indo-European (PIE) root *tong-, which meant "to think, feel".2 This ancient origin point immediately establishes an intrinsic link between the expression of gratitude and the internal processes of thought and sentiment. It suggests that the act of acknowledging a benefit was, from its earliest conceptualization, inseparable from the mental state of the beneficiary. This is not a mere linguistic curiosity; it is the conceptual DNA from which a specific philosophy of gratitude would evolve.
Germanic Evolution
As PIE evolved into its daughter languages, the root tong- gave rise to the Proto-Germanic term *þankaz. This word carried a potent dual meaning, signifying both "thought" and "gratitude".4 This fusion of concepts was passed down into Old English, where the words
þanc and þonc flourished. The semantic range of þanc was remarkably broad, encompassing "thought, reflection, sentiment," "mind, will, purpose," and also "good thoughts, gratitude, satisfaction, favor, pleasure, and grace".4
The evolution from "a thinking of" to "a thinking of with gratitude" appears to have been a natural semantic shift.3 For early English speakers, gratitude was not an abstract emotion but a specific kind of thought: a "good thought" or a "grateful thought" held in the mind for a benefactor. The verb form, Old Englishþancian or þoncian, meant "to give thanks," but also "to recompense, to reward," indicating an action that stemmed from this internal cognitive state.2 This direct connection is preserved in the phonetic relationship between the modern English words "think" and "thank," which are related in the same way that "sing" is to "song".2 Thus, when the phrase "I thank you" emerged around the 14th century, it was more than a polite formula; it was a cognitive declaration. Its loose translation, based on its etymological heritage, is "I will remember what you have done for me" or "I will hold a good thought for you".7 Gratitude, in its very essence, was an act of willed remembrance.
This cognitive framing of gratitude was not merely a feature of English. The Proto-Germanic root þankaz gave rise to a family of related words across Germanic languages, all of which retain this connection. German has danken ("to thank") and Dank ("thanks"), Dutch has danken and dank, and Swedish has tack.4 All share a common ancestor that inextricably linked the act of thanking with the process of thinking.
Comparative Etymology
The "thought-based" model of gratitude found in the Germanic languages becomes even more distinct when contrasted with the etymological roots of "thanks" in other major linguistic traditions. These comparisons reveal that different cultures have encoded entirely different philosophical priorities into their words for this fundamental social act.
Latin-Derived "Grace"
In the Romance languages, the concept of gratitude is tied not to thought, but to grace and mercy. The Spanish gracias and the Italian grazie both derive from the Latin phrase gratias agere, which means "to express thanks" or, more literally, "to perform graces".7 The root word,
gratia, meant "favor, goodwill, kindness," connecting the act of thanking to the reception of unmerited favor or grace.
The French word merci has a particularly layered history. It stems from the Latin mercēs, which originally meant "wages, fee, or price".7 This suggests a transactional origin. However, the word was filtered through Old French mercit, which had a much broader meaning: "reward, gift, kindness, grace, and pity".7 It is from this Old French term that the English word "mercy" also derives. Therefore, to say
merci is to acknowledge an act of kindness that is simultaneously a gift, a show of grace, and an act of pity or mercy.5
Japanese "Rarity"
The Japanese expression for thanks, ありがとう (arigatou), offers yet another distinct philosophical framework. The modern word is a contracted form of the older arigatou gozaimasu, which derives from the adjective arigatashi.7
Arigatashi is a compound of two words: aru, a verb meaning "to exist" or "to be," and katai, an adjective meaning "difficult." Combined, arigatashi literally meant "difficult to exist" and was used to describe things that were "extremely uncommon" or "rare and precious".7 To say
arigatou, then, is not primarily to state a thought or acknowledge grace, but to express wonder at having received something rare and valuable. It frames the act of beneficence as an exceptional event, worthy of special note precisely because of its uncommonness.
This comparative analysis reveals that the words we use for "thanks" are not neutral placeholders. They are cultural artifacts, encoded with deep-seated philosophical assumptions about the nature of a gift. Where the Germanic tradition emphasizes cognitive remembrance, the Latin tradition emphasizes social or divine grace, and the Japanese tradition emphasizes the preciousness of a rare event. These foundational differences in the conceptualization of gratitude, embedded in the very fabric of language, provide a powerful lens for understanding the diverse cultural norms surrounding its expression, which will be explored in a later section. The word itself primes a speaker to view a kind act through a specific cultural lens—as something to be remembered, as a form of grace, or as a precious rarity.
The following table crystallizes these conceptual differences, providing a clear, comparative foundation for the report's subsequent analysis.
Table 1: Etymological Roots of 'Thanks' Across Languages
Language | Word/Phrase | Etymological Root | Core Conceptual Meaning |
English | Thank you | Proto-Germanic *þankaz (from PIE *tong-) | Thought, Remembrance 2 |
Spanish | Gracias | Latin gratias agere | Grace, Favor 7 |
French | Merci | Latin mercēs (via Old French mercit) | Mercy, Reward, Pity 5 |
Japanese | Arigatou | Aru ("to exist") + Katai ("difficult") | Rareness, Preciousness 7 |
German | Danke | Proto-Germanic *þankaz | Thought, Remembrance 4 |
This linguistic journey reveals a profound starting point for our inquiry. In the English tradition, gratitude is not something that merely happens to us as a passive emotional response; it is something our minds actively do. It is a conscious cognitive act of holding a "good thought" and choosing to remember. This active, cognitive framing provides a powerful and direct bridge to the modern scientific understanding of gratitude, which demonstrates that practices designed to force this very kind of cognitive engagement—such as journaling and reflection—have a measurable and transformative impact on the human psyche. The ancient wisdom embedded in the word foreshadows the discoveries of modern psychology.
Section 2: The Grateful Mind: Psychological and Neurological Dimensions of Thankfulness
Transitioning from the ancient history of the word to the contemporary science of the mind, this section examines gratitude as a psychological phenomenon. Over the past two decades, a robust body of research has emerged, primarily from the field of positive psychology, that elevates gratitude from a simple nicety to a powerful determinant of human flourishing. Scientific inquiry has not only cataloged the extensive mental, physical, and social benefits of a grateful disposition but has also begun to map its neurological underpinnings. The evidence is clear: gratitude is not merely a pleasant feeling but a trainable skill that can intentionally and fundamentally alter an individual's psychological state and overall well-being.
Gratitude in Positive Psychology
Gratitude has become a cornerstone of positive psychology, a field dedicated to the scientific study of what makes life most worth living. Researchers like Robert Emmons have been at the forefront of this work, moving the study of gratitude from the philosophical to the empirical.8 Within this framework, gratitude is defined as a two-part cognitive-emotional process: first, the recognition that one has obtained a positive outcome, and second, the appraisal that there is an external source for this positive outcome.9 This source can be another person, a divine entity, or even nature or fate. It is this recognition of an external benefactor that distinguishes gratitude from simply feeling happy about a good situation. This definition aligns remarkably well with the etymological origins of "thank" as a cognitive act of remembrance directed toward a giver.
The Overwhelming Benefits of a Grateful Disposition
A wealth of correlational and experimental studies has established a strong link between the practice of gratitude and a wide array of positive life outcomes. Individuals who are dispositionally more grateful, or who engage in practices to cultivate gratitude, consistently report higher levels of well-being across multiple domains.
Increased Psychological Well-being
The most well-documented benefit of gratitude is its powerful effect on subjective well-being. Grateful individuals report significantly higher levels of happiness, life satisfaction, optimism, hope, and positive affect (i.e., positive moods and feelings).10 Studies have shown that gratitude interventions, such as keeping a gratitude journal, can increase optimism and overall life satisfaction over a period of weeks.10 Furthermore, gratitude appears to counteract hedonic adaptation—the human tendency to quickly return to a relatively stable level of happiness despite major positive or negative life events. By encouraging people to savor and appreciate the good in their lives rather than taking it for granted, gratitude helps sustain feelings of happiness.10
Enhanced Resilience and Mental Health
Gratitude functions as a powerful buffer against psychological distress. Research indicates that gratitude can promote positive outcomes following traumatic experiences, helping individuals build resilience against the adverse effects of negative events.10 Studies of veterans, survivors of natural disasters, and other trauma survivors have found that higher levels of gratitude are associated with lower symptoms of Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) and a greater capacity for "post-traumatic growth"—the experience of positive psychological change following adversity.10
In terms of general mental health, gratitude is negatively correlated with a host of negative states. Grateful people are less likely to suffer from depression, anxiety, envy, and jealousy.8 By shifting focus from what others have to what one possesses, gratitude directly reduces feelings of envy.12 It may also protect against various forms of burnout, with studies showing that grateful teachers, mental health professionals, and athletes report lower levels of professional or sport-related exhaustion.10 Critically, a grateful disposition is also linked to a lower risk of suicidality, with studies finding that grateful individuals report fewer suicidal thoughts and attempts.10
Improved Physical Health
The benefits of gratitude extend beyond the psychological to the physiological. Research suggests that more grateful people may be physically healthier. One study found that cardiac patients with higher dispositional gratitude reported better sleep quality, less fatigue, and lower levels of cellular inflammation.10 Another study, "Counting Blessings vs Burdens," found that participants who kept a gratitude journal reported fewer physical symptoms, such as pain, and were more likely to engage in healthy behaviors like exercise.10 The practice of gratitude has been linked to improved sleep quality, which has wide-ranging downstream effects on overall health.13
Strengthened Social Bonds
Gratitude is fundamentally a social emotion, and its practice significantly enhances the quality of interpersonal relationships. It acts as a "moral motivator," inspiring prosocial behaviors such as generosity, kindness, and helpfulness.10 When people feel grateful, they are more likely to "pay it forward," creating a positive ripple effect. For example, one study found that participants who were thanked for their help were more willing to help again in the future.10 Gratitude also strengthens existing relationships. Couples who express gratitude to each other report higher levels of relationship satisfaction, mutual trust, and loyalty.10 By signaling that one is a good and reliable partner, expressions of gratitude help build and maintain strong social alliances.
The Neuroscience of Gratitude
Recent advances in neuroscience have begun to reveal the biological mechanisms behind these psychological benefits. When a person experiences gratitude, it activates specific neural circuits in the brain. Functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) studies have shown that feelings of gratitude are associated with activity in the limbic system, particularly the hippocampus and amygdala, which are central to emotion regulation, memory, and learning.13 This suggests that gratitude engages deep, foundational parts of the brain's emotional processing centers.
Furthermore, the practice of gratitude appears to influence the brain's neurochemical environment. It has been linked to the regulation of neurotransmitters like dopamine, often called the "reward chemical," which can increase feelings of vitality and pleasure and may play a role in reducing subjective feelings of pain.13 Simultaneously, gratitude has been shown to reduce levels of cortisol, the body's primary stress hormone. One study found that participants who cultivated feelings of appreciation showed a marked reduction in cortisol levels, indicating that gratitude can directly counteract the physiological stress response.13 This neurochemical shift helps explain why a gratitude practice can lead to reduced stress, anxiety, and depression while increasing feelings of contentment and well-being.12
The Efficacy of Gratitude Interventions
Crucially, the benefits of gratitude are not limited to those who are naturally predisposed to it. A significant body of research has demonstrated that gratitude is a skill that can be cultivated through simple, targeted exercises known as gratitude interventions.
Gratitude Journaling: The most widely studied intervention is gratitude journaling. In their seminal 2003 study, Emmons and McCullough had participants write down five things they were grateful for on a weekly or daily basis. Compared to groups that wrote about hassles or neutral events, the gratitude group reported more optimism, higher life satisfaction, and greater positive affect.10 A popular variation, the "Three Good Things" exercise developed by Martin Seligman, asks participants to write down three things that went well each day and their causes. This practice has been shown to increase happiness and decrease depressive symptoms for up to six months.8
Gratitude Letters and Visits: Another powerful intervention involves writing a letter of gratitude to someone who has never been properly thanked. Studies have found that this practice can significantly increase the writer's happiness and life satisfaction.10 The effect is even more potent when the letter is delivered and read in person, an act known as a "gratitude visit." Seligman's research found this intervention produced a massive and immediate increase in happiness and a decrease in depressive symptoms, with the positive effects lasting for at least a month.8
The consistent success of these interventions demonstrates that gratitude can function as a proactive strategy for enhancing mental health, rather than just a reactive emotion. By deliberately focusing one's cognitive attention on the good—an act that mirrors the etymological root of "thank" as "thought"—individuals can consciously and systematically improve their own well-being.
This body of research reveals a pattern of reciprocal causation that can be described as an "upward spiral."
Gratitude improves social relationships, which in turn provide more reasons to be grateful. Gratitude fosters optimism, which makes it easier to notice the good in life. Gratitude motivates prosocial behavior, which elicits gratitude from others, reinforcing the cycle. One study explicitly identified a "dual upward spiral" between gratitude and the fulfillment of basic psychological needs like autonomy and relatedness.10 This self-perpetuating positive feedback loop helps explain why the sustained practice of gratitude often leads to transformative and lasting changes in an individual's life outlook, far exceeding the sum of its individual parts. It is a practice that not only feels good but actively builds the psychological resources needed for a flourishing life.
Table 2: Summary of Key Psychological Benefits of Gratitude with Supporting Studies
Benefit Category | Specific Outcome | Key Supporting Studies (Example Citations) |
Psychological Well-being | Increased happiness, life satisfaction, optimism, hope, and positive affect. | McCullough et al. (2002); Emmons & McCullough (2003); Seligman et al. (2005) 10 |
Mental Health | Reduced depression, anxiety, envy, materialism, and suicidal ideation. Protection against burnout. | Wood et al. (2008); Polak & McCullough (2006); Kleiman et al. (2013) 10 |
Physical Health | Better sleep quality, less fatigue, reduced physical pain symptoms, and lower cellular inflammation. | Emmons & McCullough (2003); Jackowska et al. (2016); Mills et al. (2015) 10 |
Social Functioning | Strengthened relationships, increased prosocial behavior (kindness, generosity), and greater trust. | Algoe et al. (2010); Bartlett & DeSteno (2006) 8 |
Resilience | Enhanced ability to cope with trauma, lower PTSD symptoms, and greater post-traumatic growth. | Vieselmeyer et al. (2017); McCanlies et al. (2018) 10 |
Section 3: The Parable of Gratitude: An Exegesis of Luke 17:11-19
At the heart of this inquiry into the nature of thanks lies a brief but profound narrative from the Christian New Testament. The story of the ten lepers, recorded only in the Gospel of Luke, serves as a powerful parable that dramatizes the distinction between receiving a benefit and the transformative act of expressing gratitude. It moves the discussion from the scientific to the theological, exploring the ultimate meaning and spiritual significance of thankfulness. Through a careful exegesis of the text, its context, and its key terms, the story reveals gratitude not as a mere social obligation, but as the very bridge between physical healing and spiritual salvation.
The Text: Luke 17:11-19 (King James Version)
The full text of the passage, as rendered in the King James Version, provides the foundation for this analysis.1
11 And it came to pass, as he went to Jerusalem, that he passed through the midst of Samaria and Galilee.
12 And as he entered into a certain village, there met him ten men that were lepers, which stood afar off:
13 And they lifted up their voices, and said, Jesus, Master, have mercy on us.
14 And when he saw them, he said unto them, Go shew yourselves unto the priests. And it came to pass, that, as they went, they were cleansed.
15 And one of them, when he saw that he was healed, turned back, and with a loud voice glorified God,
16 And fell down on his face at his feet, giving him thanks: and he was a Samaritan.
17 And Jesus answering said, Were there not ten cleansed? but where are the nine?
18 There are not found that returned to give glory to God, save this stranger.
19 And he said unto him, Arise, go thy way: thy faith hath made thee whole.
Contextual Analysis
The Plight of the Leper
In the ancient Near East, leprosy—a term that likely covered a range of infectious skin diseases—was not simply a medical condition; it was a "medical death sentence".17 According to the religious laws detailed in the book of Leviticus, a person diagnosed with leprosy was declared ceremonially unclean.18 This status brought with it devastating social and spiritual consequences. Lepers were forced into total isolation, cast out from their homes, families, and communities. They were forbidden from entering the temple or participating in religious life. They were required to live in colonies with other outcasts, wear torn clothes, and cry out "Unclean, unclean!" to warn anyone who approached.17 Their condition was a living death, a complete severing from the fabric of society. The healing offered by Jesus was, therefore, not just a physical cure but a complete restoration to life.
The Samaritan "Foreigner"
The narrative takes a crucial turn with the revelation that the one leper who returns to give thanks is a Samaritan. In the time of Jesus, the animosity between Jews and Samaritans was deep-seated and bitter. Samaritans were viewed by many Jews as heretics and foreigners, a people of mixed ancestry who had corrupted the true worship of God.18 This makes the grateful leper a "doubly marginalized" figure: an outcast among his own people due to his disease, and an outcast from the dominant Jewish society due to his ethnicity.20 Luke, the author of the gospel, frequently highlights Jesus's compassion for such outsiders, and the Samaritan's role here is intentional and theologically significant. It underscores the theme that the capacity for true faith and gratitude is not bound by ethnic or religious identity.
Theological Exegesis
The narrative unfolds in a sequence of events that reveals a profound theological argument about the nature of faith and gratitude.
Faith in Action
The story begins with an act of collective faith. All ten lepers, standing "afar off" as required by law, cry out for mercy.1 Jesus's response is not a direct pronouncement of healing but a command: "Go shew yourselves unto the priests".1 According to Levitical law, only a priest could officially declare a leper "clean" and permit their reentry into society after a period of ritual testing.17 Jesus's command requires the men to act on the assumption of their healing before it has occurred. Their obedience—turning and beginning the journey to the priests while still afflicted—is a demonstration of their faith. The miracle happens "as they went," their faith being the prerequisite for their cleansing.18
Cleansed vs. Made Whole
The central interpretive key to the passage lies in the distinction Jesus makes between the nine who continued on their way and the one who returned. All ten were "cleansed" (verse 14). The Greek word used here is katharizō, which means to make clean, to purify, and is primarily concerned with their physical and ritual state.17 They received the benefit they sought.
However, to the one who returned, Jesus says something different: "thy faith hath made thee whole" (verse 19). The Greek word translated as "whole" is sōzō (σῴζω).17 This is a word with a much richer and deeper semantic range than katharizō. Sōzō means to save, to rescue from danger, to preserve, to heal, and to make whole.21 Critically, it is the primary word used throughout the New Testament to refer to spiritual salvation. When Jesus says, "your faith has saved you," he is using this same word.
This linguistic distinction is the theological core of the parable. While all ten men received physical healing, only the one who returned to express gratitude received something more: wholeness, which implies a complete spiritual and existential restoration. The nine were cured; the one was saved.
Gratitude as Worship
The actions of the Samaritan leper are presented as acts of worship. He doesn't just feel grateful; he performs his gratitude. He "turned back," interrupting his journey to social reintegration to prioritize his relationship with the source of his healing. He glorified God "with a loud voice," a public and joyful proclamation. And he "fell down on his face at his feet, giving him thanks," an act of profound humility and reverence.1 In this moment, the man recognizes that giving thanks to Jesus is synonymous with giving glory to God.17 His gratitude is not a polite afterthought; it is an act of worship that acknowledges the divine power at work in his life.
This parable powerfully illustrates that there is a crucial difference between receiving a blessing and being truly grateful for it. The nine lepers who continued on their way were focused on the gift—their newfound health and the social status that came with it. They treated the miracle as a transaction that was now complete, with the final step being priestly certification.23 Their faith was sufficient to receive the gift, but it did not move them to acknowledge the Giver.
The Samaritan, in contrast, was moved by the Giver. His act of turning back demonstrates a fundamental shift in priority from the gift to the source of the gift. This relational act of expressed gratitude is what elevates his experience. It is the catalyst that transforms a physical blessing into a spiritual one. The parable thus makes a profound theological claim: while faith may initiate healing, it is the active, expressed return of thanks that completes it, making one not just cleansed, but "whole." Gratitude is the essential response that unlocks the fullness of God's saving grace.
Furthermore, the identity of the grateful man as a Samaritan outsider creates a powerful paradox. The nine, presumably Jewish and thus "insiders" to God's covenant people, took their healing for granted or saw it as something to be processed through the proper channels of their religion. They may have felt a sense of entitlement that the outsider did not. The Samaritan, having no claim to such a blessing, perceived it as a pure act of unmerited grace. His status as a "foreigner" made him more acutely aware of the magnitude of the gift, prompting a more profound and immediate expression of gratitude.20
This suggests that those who perceive themselves as most needy, most on the margins, may be the most capable of the kind of transformative gratitude that leads to wholeness. This paradox serves as a powerful bridge to the next section, which explores how cultural norms and in-group/out-group dynamics shape the very language and performance of thankfulness.
Section 4: The Grammar of Gratitude: A Cross-Cultural Analysis of Expression
While the emotion of gratitude may be a human universal, its expression is anything but. The act of saying "thank you" is governed by a complex and often unwritten "grammar" that varies dramatically across cultures. What is considered polite and necessary in one society may be seen as strange, formal, or even rude in another. This cross-cultural analysis reveals that the social function of gratitude is deeply intertwined with broader cultural values, particularly the tension between individualism and collectivism. Understanding this diverse landscape is crucial for navigating an interconnected world and for appreciating the deeper social dynamics at play in narratives like that of the ten lepers.
The Universal Emotion vs. the Culturally-Specific Expression
At its core, gratitude is a fundamental human experience, an emotional response to receiving a benefit from another.24 However, the translation of this internal feeling into an external social act is profoundly shaped by cultural norms. Research consistently shows that while the capacity to feel grateful is universal, the rules for when, how, and to whom one should express it are culturally specific.26 This divergence often leads to misunderstandings in cross-cultural interactions, as the meaning behind an expression of thanks—or the lack thereof—can be easily misinterpreted.
Individualism vs. Collectivism: The Core Divide
A primary axis along which expressions of gratitude vary is the cultural dimension of individualism versus collectivism.
Western (Individualistic) Norms
In many Western cultures, such as the United States and Italy, society is organized around the individual. Relationships are often viewed as a series of voluntary interactions or transactions between autonomous agents. Within this framework, explicit, verbal expressions of gratitude are highly valued and frequently expected.24 Saying "thank you" is a crucial piece of social etiquette that acknowledges a personal favor and maintains politeness, even in minor, impersonal interactions like a cashier handing a customer their change.
This transactional view is often embedded in the language itself. American English is replete with economic metaphors for gratitude, such as "I owe you one," "How can I ever repay you?" or "I am in your debt".29 This language frames gratitude as a social ledger that must be balanced, reinforcing the idea that relationships are built on a series of reciprocal exchanges.
Eastern (Collectivist) Norms
In contrast, many East and South Asian cultures, including those of China, Japan, and India, are more collectivist. Social harmony, respect for hierarchy, and the integrity of the in-group are paramount values.24 Within this framework, the expression of gratitude is often more implicit and relational. For close relationships—family, intimate friends—mutual assistance is not seen as a favor to be acknowledged but as a fundamental and expected part of the relationship.
In these contexts, an explicit, verbal "thank you" can be inappropriate or even offensive. It can introduce a sense of formality and emotional distance, suggesting that the relationship is transactional rather than intimate.28 As Indian author Deepak Singh explains, thanking close relations can feel like "violating your intimacy with them and creating formality and distance that shouldn't exist".28 The gratitude is assumed and is demonstrated through ongoing loyalty and reciprocal action, not through words. A verbal "thank you" is reserved for strangers or for situations where someone has gone far beyond the normal obligations of the relationship.29
Forms of Expression
Beyond the verbal/implicit divide, cultures employ a wide range of modalities to express gratitude.
Verbal vs. Non-verbal: While Western cultures tend to prioritize verbal acknowledgment, many other cultures place a strong emphasis on non-verbal cues. In Japan, a bow of a certain depth can convey thanks with more nuance and respect than words alone. In India, a simple nod or a gesture like the namaste can carry the weight of gratitude.24
Concrete vs. Connective Gratitude: Research by Jonathan Tudge on children's expressions of gratitude identified three distinct types: verbal (saying "thank you"), concrete (reciprocating with a tangible item the child likes, such as a toy), and connective (reciprocating with something the benefactor would value, such as friendship or future help).27 Cross-cultural studies using this framework found that children in the United States leaned toward concrete gratitude, reflecting a more transactional mindset. In contrast, children in China and South Korea favored connective gratitude, which aligns with the collectivist value of strengthening relational bonds.32
The "Gratitude-Distance Paradox"
This cross-cultural examination reveals a fascinating social dynamic that can be termed the "Gratitude-Distance Paradox." The same linguistic act—saying "thank you"—can serve opposite social functions depending on the cultural context and the relationship between the speakers.
In individualistic cultures, explicit thanks are primarily used to bridge social distance. They are a tool for initiating or maintaining positive relations with those outside one's immediate circle or for formally acknowledging a transaction. The more distant the relationship, the more necessary the verbal "thank you."
In many collectivist cultures, the opposite is true. The absence of an explicit "thank you" among intimates signifies closeness and solidarity. Mutual support is the default expectation of the relationship, and verbalizing thanks would be redundant and distancing. Here, saying "thank you" creates social distance, imposing a formal, transactional frame onto a relationship that should be beyond such calculations.
This paradox has profound implications for intercultural communication. A Western businessperson might perceive their Japanese counterpart as ungrateful or cold for not verbally thanking them for a small favor, while the Japanese person may be acting from a place of assumed closeness and mutual obligation, believing that verbal thanks would be inappropriately formal. This connects directly back to the parable of the ten lepers.
The Samaritan was a "stranger," an outsider.1 For him, an explicit, public, and reverent expression of thanks was the socially appropriate way to bridge the immense distance between himself and his benefactor. The nine, as insiders, may have perceived their healing differently, perhaps as a blessing to which they had some claim, and proceeded to the next logical step within their system—the priest—without feeling the need for the kind of explicit thanks required of an outsider.
Table 3: Cross-Cultural Norms of Gratitude Expression
Cultural Context | Primary Value | Typical Expression Style | Meaning of "Thank You" to Intimates |
Western (e.g., USA) | Individualism, Politeness | Explicit, Verbal, Transactional | Expected; reinforces politeness and closes a transaction. 24 |
East Asian (e.g., China) | Collectivism, Harmony | Implicit, Relational, Connective | Potentially rude; creates unwelcome formality and distance. 28 |
South Asian (e.g., India) | Relational Intimacy | Unspoken understanding; reserved for extraordinary acts. | Inappropriate; violates the assumption of intimacy and mutual obligation. 28 |
Japanese | Hierarchy, Respect | Formal/Informal verbal levels, Non-verbal (bowing). | Highly dependent on status; can create formality if used incorrectly. 24 |
Finally, it is important to note that even within cultures that prize verbal thanks, the expression is not as ubiquitous as one might assume. One study of recorded everyday interactions found that in English and Italian, thanks were offered in only 14% of situations where a request was complied with.25 This suggests that in most informal settings, social reciprocity relies on a tacit understanding of mutual assistance, not on explicit expressions of gratitude. This finding challenges the assumption that frequent thanking is the norm anywhere and highlights that the true currency of social life is often unspoken cooperation. However, when gratitude is expressed, it carries significant weight, and its meaning is deeply colored by the cultural lens through which it is given and received.
Section 5: A Tapestry of Thanks: Philosophical and Literary Voices
Having explored the linguistic roots, psychological effects, theological depth, and cultural expression of gratitude, this final section synthesizes these threads through the wisdom of philosophy, religion, and literature. Across diverse traditions and epochs, thinkers and artists have grappled with the nature of thankfulness, converging on the understanding that it is far more than a fleeting emotion. They present gratitude as a foundational virtue, a spiritual discipline, and a necessary posture for a life of wisdom, joy, and meaning. This tapestry of voices provides a holistic perspective, revealing the dual nature of gratitude as both an internal state of being and an external moral duty.
Ancient Western Philosophy: Gratitude as Virtue
The classical philosophers of Greece and Rome were among the first to systematically analyze gratitude, elevating it to the status of a cardinal virtue essential for a well-lived life (eudaimonia).
Marcus Tullius Cicero (106-43 BC): The Roman statesman and philosopher famously declared, "Gratitude is not only the greatest of the virtues, but the parent of all the others".33 For Cicero, gratitude was not a passive feeling but an active force that inspires other virtuous behaviors. He argued that the feeling of thankfulness naturally gives rise to acts of kindness, reverence for one's parents and the gods, and loyalty to friends.36 In his view, a grateful person is motivated to do good, making gratitude the wellspring from which other virtues flow.
Lucius Annaeus Seneca (c. 4 BC - AD 65): The Stoic philosopher Seneca explored gratitude extensively in his letters, particularly in his essay "On Benefits." He emphasized that the true benefit of gratitude is for the one who feels it. "We should try by all means to be as grateful as possible," he wrote, "For gratitude is a good thing for ourselves".37 He divorced gratitude from transactional expectations, arguing that its value is intrinsic: "I feel grateful, not because it profits me, but because it pleases me".37 For Seneca, the reward for a good deed is simply in the doing of it. This internal focus aligns with the modern psychological understanding of gratitude as a tool for personal well-being. He also connected gratitude to contentment, stating, "True happiness is to enjoy the present, without anxious dependence upon the future... to rest satisfied with what we have".38
Epictetus (c. AD 50 - 135): Another leading Stoic, Epictetus, framed gratitude as a form of wisdom. His famous dictum, "He is a wise man who does not grieve for the things which he has not, but rejoices for those which he has," is a concise formula for a grateful mindset.39 It posits that wisdom lies in shifting one's focus from lack to abundance, a core principle of modern gratitude interventions.
Gratitude in World Religions
Gratitude is a central tenet in virtually every major world religion, where it is understood as a fundamental aspect of one's relationship with the divine and the cosmos.
Islam (Shukr): In Islam, gratitude, or Shukr, is a cornerstone of faith and a comprehensive way of life.41 It is a three-part practice involving: 1) acknowledgment of blessings in the heart, 2) expression of thanks with the tongue, and 3) showing gratitude through righteous deeds and obedience to God.42 The Qur'an makes a direct promise from Allah: "If you are grateful, I will surely increase you [in favor]" (Qur'an 14:7).43
Shukr is seen as the path to contentment (Qana'ah) and a protection against arrogance and envy. The Prophet Muhammad emphasized that gratitude must also be shown to people: "He who does not thank the people is not thankful to Allah" 41, linking spiritual duty to social conduct
.
Buddhism (Katannuta): In Buddhism, gratitude (katannuta) is deeply connected to the core concepts of mindfulness, compassion, and interconnectedness.45 It begins with an appreciation for the preciousness of human birth, which offers the rare opportunity for spiritual awakening.46 Gratitude is not a denial of suffering but a way of meeting life's difficulties with an open heart, recognizing that even challenges can be teachers.47 The practice helps to counteract the poisons of greed, attachment, and ego by fostering an awareness of our dependence on all things—from the food we eat to the teachings we receive.48 The ultimate goal is a state of selfless gratitude for being part of the web of life itself.
Hinduism (Kritajna): Gratitude (kritajna) is an integral part of dharma, or righteous duty, in Hinduism.50 It is a multifaceted practice expressed through devotion (
bhakti) in prayers and rituals, selfless service (seva) as a way of creating positive karma, and profound reverence for gurus (teachers), parents, and nature. Festivals like Diwali and Pongal are communal expressions of gratitude for life's blessings.50 Hinduism cultivates an attitude of thankfulness for all experiences, both pleasant and challenging, viewing them as opportunities for spiritual growth.51
Literary and Poetic Voices
Beyond formal philosophy and theology, literature and poetry offer intimate glimpses into the felt experience of gratitude. These ten voices capture its diverse expressions, from the grandly cosmic to the quietly personal.
Cicero: "Gratitude is not only the greatest of virtues, but the parent of all the others".33 This classical maxim establishes gratitude as the foundational moral virtue.
Seneca: "He who receives a benefit with gratitude repays the first installment on his debt".52 This quote captures the sense of moral obligation inherent in receiving a gift.
Epictetus: "He is a wise man who does not grieve for the things which he has not, but rejoices for those which he has".39 This is the Stoic formula for contentment through appreciation.
Meister Eckhart: "If the only prayer you say in your life is thank you, that would suffice".39 The 14th-century Christian mystic distills the essence of prayer down to a single, powerful act of gratitude.
Marcel Proust: "Let us be grateful to people who make us happy; they are the charming gardeners who make our souls blossom".39 This beautiful metaphor captures the life-giving, nurturing power of others' kindness.
G.K. Chesterton: In his writings, Chesterton advocated for saying "grace before the concert and the opera, and grace before the play... and grace before I dip the pen in the ink".39 This extends the concept of grace beyond meals to encompass all of life's activities, framing gratitude as a constant posture of reverence toward existence.
Rumi: "Wear gratitude like a cloak, and it will feed every corner of your life".33 The Sufi poet presents gratitude as a protective and nourishing garment that envelops one's entire being.
Mary Oliver: "Someone I loved once gave me a box full of darkness. It took me years to understand that this, too, was a gift".33 This poignant line powerfully illustrates the advanced spiritual practice of finding gratitude even in hardship and suffering, a theme echoed in Buddhist teachings.47
Robert Hayden, "Those Winter Sundays": This poem is a masterpiece of retrospective gratitude. The speaker recalls his father's thankless labors—rising early in the "blueblack cold" to warm the house—and reflects, "What did I know, what did I know / of love’s austere and lonely offices?".55 It perfectly captures the cognitive act of remembrance that lies at the heart of the word "thank," acknowledging sacrifices that were not appreciated at the time.
e.e. cummings, "i thank You God for most this amazing day": This poem is a pure, unadulterated expression of existential gratitude. The speaker thanks God "for the leaping greenly spirits of trees / and a blue true dream of sky;and for everything / which is natural which is infinite which is yes".56 It is a celebration of the simple, sensory miracle of being alive.
These diverse perspectives reveal a fundamental duality in the nature of gratitude. On one hand, thinkers like Seneca and the proponents of positive psychology emphasize gratitude as an internal virtue, a state of mind cultivated for one's own happiness and well-being. It is a practice whose primary beneficiary is the self. On the other hand, religious traditions like Islam and legalistic thinkers like Cicero frame gratitude as an external duty—a moral or spiritual obligation owed to a benefactor, be it God, parents, or society. It is a debt that must be repaid to maintain social and cosmic order.
These two views are not contradictory but are two sides of the same coin. Gratitude is simultaneously a state of being and an act of doing.
It is a virtue that enriches the self and a duty that honors the other. This duality is perfectly embodied in the story of the Samaritan leper. His return was driven by an internal state of overwhelming joy and faith, an act that pleased him and made him whole. At the same time, it was the fulfillment of a perceived duty to honor his benefactor, an external act of worship. In him, the internal virtue and the external duty become one, demonstrating the complete and transformative power of thanks.
Conclusion: The Restorative Power of the Returned Thanks
This multi-disciplinary inquiry into the theme of "thanks" reveals a concept of extraordinary depth, its complexity belying the simplicity of its common expression. The journey from the word's ancient origins to its modern scientific validation, through its cultural variations and its theological and philosophical significance, converges on a single, powerful conclusion: gratitude is a transformative force, but its full power is realized only when it is actively and consciously expressed. It is the return of thanks that completes a circuit, elevating a simple benefit into a state of profound wholeness.
The investigation began with the word itself, uncovering its etymological roots in the Proto-Indo-European concept of "thought." This established that gratitude, in its English conception, is fundamentally a cognitive act—a willed remembrance of a good deed and its doer. This ancient insight finds remarkable confirmation in modern psychology. The science of the mind demonstrates that this cognitive act, when intentionally practiced through interventions like journaling or letter writing, becomes a potent emotion and a psychological tool that can literally rewire the brain for greater happiness, resilience, and health. It initiates an "upward spiral" of well-being, proving that gratitude is not a passive response to good fortune but a proactive cause of it.
However, the expression of this emotion is a complex social performance, governed by a cultural grammar that can affirm intimacy or create distance. The "Gratitude-Distance Paradox" shows that while an explicit "thank you" bridges distance between strangers in individualistic societies, its absence can signify deep intimacy in collectivist ones. This highlights that the act of thanking is never neutral; it is a nuanced social signal whose meaning is deeply contextual.
Finally, the analysis culminates in the understanding of gratitude as a spiritual posture. The parable of the ten lepers serves as the ultimate illustration of this truth. All ten men were cleansed, receiving a miraculous physical benefit born of their initial faith. Yet the nine who proceeded on their way, focused on the gift rather than the Giver, remained merely healed. They represent the passive beneficiary, the recipient of a transaction. It was the one—a marginalized "stranger"—who interrupted the transaction to return, to remember, and to express his thanks through an act of worship, who was declared "made whole." His expressed gratitude was not an ancillary politeness; it was the very catalyst that transformed his physical healing into spiritual salvation (sōzō).
The story of the ten lepers is not just an ancient tale; it is a timeless metaphor for the human condition. We are all recipients of countless blessings, both seen and unseen—from the simple gift of breath to the complex web of relationships that sustain us. The central question the parable poses to every individual is not whether we have received benefits, but whether we will be counted among the nine who take them and walk away, or as the one who turns back to complete the circle. This report concludes that gratitude is far more than a word or a feeling. It is the conscious choice to remember the good, to acknowledge our profound dependence on others and on grace, and, in that very act of remembering and expressing, to become not just healed of our ailments, but truly and lastingly whole.
Works cited
Luke 17:11-37 KJV - And it came to pass, as he went to - Bible Gateway, accessed August 9, 2025, https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Luke%2017%3A11-37&version=KJV
Thank - Etymology, Origin & Meaning, accessed August 9, 2025, https://www.etymonline.com/word/thank
Why Do We Say Thank You? | Psychology Today, accessed August 9, 2025, https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/language-in-the-wild/202211/why-do-we-say-thank-you
thank | Rabbitique - The Multilingual Etymology Dictionary, accessed August 9, 2025, https://rabbitique.com/profile/en/thank
Thanks - Etymology, Origin & Meaning, accessed August 9, 2025, https://www.etymonline.com/word/thanks
thank - Wiktionary, the free dictionary, accessed August 9, 2025, https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/thank
The History of 'Thank You' Around the World - Access 2 Interpreters, accessed August 9, 2025, https://www.access2interpreters.com/the-history-of-thank-you-around-the-world/
What is Gratitude and Why Is It So Important? - Positive Psychology, accessed August 9, 2025, https://positivepsychology.com/gratitude-appreciation/
Positive Psychology and Gratitude Interventions: A Randomized Clinical Trial - Frontiers, accessed August 9, 2025, https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/psychology/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2019.00584/full
The Science of Gratitude - Greater Good Science Center, accessed August 9, 2025, https://ggsc.berkeley.edu/images/uploads/GGSC-JTF_White_Paper-Gratitude-FINAL.pdf
Gratitude and Well Being: The Benefits of Appreciation - PMC, accessed August 9, 2025, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3010965/
35 Scientific Benefits of Gratitude: Mental Health Research Findings for 2025, accessed August 9, 2025, https://research.com/education/scientific-benefits-of-gratitude
The Neuroscience of Gratitude and Effects on the Brain - Positive Psychology, accessed August 9, 2025, https://positivepsychology.com/neuroscience-of-gratitude/
Luke 17:12-19 And as he entered into a certain village, there met him ten men that were lepers, which stood afar off: and they lifted up their voices, and said, Jesus, Master, have mercy on us. And when he saw them | King James Version (KJV) | Download The, accessed August 9, 2025, https://www.bible.com/bible/1/LUK.17.12-19.KJV
Luke 17:11-19 - KJV - And it came to pass, as he we... | Christianity.com, accessed August 9, 2025, https://www.christianity.com/bible/kjv/luke/17-11-19
Luke 17:11-35 And it came to pass, as he went to Jerusalem, that he passed through the midst of Samaria and Galilee. And as he entered into a certain village, there met him ten men that were lepers, which stood afa | King James Version (KJV) | Download The Bible App Now, accessed August 9, 2025, https://www.bible.com/bible/1/LUK.17.11-35.KJV
Luke 17 - 10 Lepers Cleansed - Levittown Baptist Church, accessed August 9, 2025, https://www.levittownbaptist.com/shepherding-notes/post/luke-17-
What is the story of the ten lepers in the Bible? | GotQuestions.org, accessed August 9, 2025, https://www.gotquestions.org/ten-lepers.html
Luke 17:12 As He entered one of the villages, He was met by ten lepers. They stood at a distance - Bible Hub, accessed August 9, 2025, https://biblehub.com/luke/17-12.htm
Commentary on Luke 17:11-19 - Working Preacher from Luther ..., accessed August 9, 2025, https://www.workingpreacher.org/commentaries/revised-common-lectionary/ordinary-28-3/commentary-on-luke-1711-19-3
What is the meaning of “whole” in Luke 17:19? - Amazing Bible Timeline, accessed August 9, 2025, https://amazingbibletimeline.com/blog/q15_thy_faith_hath_made_thee_whole/
Were the 9 lepers who did not return to give thanks to God no longer healed? Luke 17:19 - eBible, accessed August 9, 2025, https://ebible.com/questions/20977-were-the-9-lepers-who-did-not-return-to-give-thanks-to-god-no-longer-healed-luke-17-19
Luke 17:11-19 Commentary - Center for Excellence in Preaching, accessed August 9, 2025, https://cepreaching.org/commentary/2022-10-03/luke-1711-19-3/
The Language of Gratitude: How Cultures Express Thanks Around the World, accessed August 9, 2025, https://www.truelanguage.com/the-language-of-gratitude-how-cultures-express-thanks-around-the-world/
Universals and cultural diversity in the expression of gratitude | Royal Society Open Science, accessed August 9, 2025, https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rsos.180391
www.truelanguage.com, accessed August 9, 2025, https://www.truelanguage.com/?p=120886#:~:text=Cultural%20Values%20Revealed%20Through%20Gratitude&text=Some%20cultures%20lean%20heavily%20on,verbal%20acknowledgment%20is%20typically%20expected.
7 Powerful Ways Mental Health & Gratitude Across Cultures - Insight Therapy Solutions, accessed August 9, 2025, https://www.insighttherapysolutions.com/articles/mental-health-gratitude/
To Thank or Not to Thank? Expressions of Gratitude Around the World, accessed August 9, 2025, https://altalang.com/beyond-words/saying-thanks-around-the-world/
A Multi-Cultural Perspective on Gratitude - YES! Magazine Solutions Journalism, accessed August 9, 2025, https://www.yesmagazine.org/health-happiness/2021/11/25/gratitude-america-multi-cultural
'Thank You' Can Be a Loaded Phrase | Chicago Booth Review, accessed August 9, 2025, https://www.chicagobooth.edu/review/thank-you-can-be-loaded-phrase
How to Say Thank You in Different Cultures - Handwrytten, accessed August 9, 2025, https://www.handwrytten.com/resources/thank-you-in-different-cultures/
How Cultural Differences Shape Your Gratitude - Greater Good Science Center, accessed August 9, 2025, https://greatergood.berkeley.edu/article/item/how_cultural_differences_shape_your_gratitude
Motivation Mondays: THANKSGIVING POEMS & QUOTES, accessed August 9, 2025, https://mirthandmotivation.com/2020/11/23/motivation-mondays-thanksgiving-poems-quotes/
Understanding gratitude: Discover the positive effects of feeling grateful, accessed August 9, 2025, https://thedaily.case.edu/understanding-gratitude-discover-the-positive-effects-of-feeling-grateful/
Quote by Marcus Tullius Cicero: “Gratitude is not only the greatest of virtues, ...” - Goodreads, accessed August 9, 2025, https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/72368-gratitude-is-not-only-the-greatest-of-virtues-but-the
5 Signs You Lack Gratitude According to Cicero - Growing In ..., accessed August 9, 2025, https://www.commonsenseethics.com/blog/5-signs-you-lack-gratitude-according-to-cicero
Seneca on Gratitude and What It Really Means to Be a Generous ..., accessed August 9, 2025, https://www.themarginalian.org/2018/06/29/seneca-letter-81-on-benefits/
Gratitude and Seneca - The Stoic Gym, accessed August 9, 2025, https://thestoicgym.com/the-stoic-magazine/article/778
49 Gratitude Quotes and A Poem of Thankfulness - - Daring to Live Fully., accessed August 9, 2025, https://daringtolivefully.com/gratitude-quotes
Cheerfulness, Gratitude, Joyfulness - Quotes, Poems, Sayings, Wisdom, Poetry, Quotations for Gardeners and Lovers of the Green Way, accessed August 9, 2025, https://www.gardendigest.com/cheer.htm
The Spiritual Benefits of Gratitude (Shukr) in Islam | by Medina Alkadir | Medium, accessed August 9, 2025, https://medium.com/@menaep121/the-spiritual-benefits-of-gratitude-shukr-in-islam-249150a4eec0
The Power of Gratitude in Islam: Appreciation and Action, accessed August 9, 2025, https://www.whyislam.org/the-concept-of-gratitude-in-islam/
The Power of Gratitude in Islam - Tarteel, accessed August 9, 2025, https://tarteel.ai/blog/the-power-of-gratitude-in-islam/
Gratitude in Hadith: A Path to Spiritual and Personal Growth - Islam - Studio Arabiya, accessed August 9, 2025, https://studioarabiya.com/gratitude-in-hadith/
Gratitude in Buddhism - Lion's Roar, accessed August 9, 2025, https://www.lionsroar.com/buddhism/gratitude/
Selfless Gratitude - Dharma Wisdom, accessed August 9, 2025, https://dharmawisdom.org/selfless-gratitude/
Gratitude and Wonder - Jack Kornfield, accessed August 9, 2025, https://jackkornfield.com/gratitude/
The Path of Gratitude | Lion's Roar, accessed August 9, 2025, https://www.lionsroar.com/the-path-of-gratitude/
Timeless Power of Gratitude: Lessons from Ancient Wisdom | Mirage News, accessed August 9, 2025, https://www.miragenews.com/timeless-power-of-gratitude-lessons-from-998570/
Gratitude in Hinduism - Blog - Soul, accessed August 9, 2025, https://blog.bringsoul.life/posts/9_gratitude_in_hinduism
How to thank god properly? : r/hinduism - Reddit, accessed August 9, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/hinduism/comments/1bbrsyl/how_to_thank_god_properly/
Gratitude is not only the greatest of... Cicero - Forbes Quotes, accessed August 9, 2025, https://www.forbes.com/quotes/1814/
Seneca the Younger Quotes About Gratitude, accessed August 9, 2025, https://www.azquotes.com/author/19765-Seneca_the_Younger/tag/gratitude
10 Quotes on Gratitude - emy thiran art, accessed August 9, 2025, https://www.emythiran.com/blog/10-quotes-on-gratitude
Poems That Say Thank You - Poetry Foundation, accessed August 9, 2025, https://www.poetryfoundation.org/collections/101631/poems-that-say-thank-you
My favourite poem that reminds me to appreciate the world around me : r/simpleliving, accessed August 9, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/simpleliving/comments/wsze5o/my_favourite_poem_that_reminds_me_to_appreciate/
