Search This Blog

Christmas in Pocahontas County

 


Forgotten Holidays, Ghostly Fiddles, and the Wild Woods: 6 Mind-Bending Realities of Early Frontier Appalachia

1. Introduction: Unlearning the Appalachian Myth

Modern commercialized holidays and simplistic media caricatures often paint early mountain life in broad, flat brushstrokes. Popular imagination tends to picture cozy, standardized log cabin scenes filled with modern festive greenery and store-bought trinkets, or dismisses frontier dwellers as crude, isolated survivalists. However, for the early 19th-century pioneers migrating into the Greenbrier Valley and Pocahontas County—such as the McNeal and Van Meter families—the reality of winter in the Alleghenies was far more complex, mysterious, and deeply self-reliant. Life in these high mountain hollows was governed not by retail calendars or manicured farmsteads, but by severe winter isolation, archaic calendar systems, and an unwritten forest economy.

How did these frontier families survive, organize their communities, and find genuine joy before the advent of paved roads, standardized modern timekeeping, and commercial supply chains? The answer lies in a rich cultural tapestry where ancient European superstitions, distinct musical mechanics, and wilderness foraging intertwined. The following six high-impact truths offer a curated dive into the counter-intuitive realities of frontier holidays, ghostly string music, and environmental survival in early Appalachian history.

2. Christmas Was Celebrated on January 6th—And Included Midnight Superstitions

Old Christmas, the 1752 Calendar Shift, and Mountain Mysticism

When the British Empire officially adopted the Gregorian calendar in 1752—dropping eleven days to realign with the solar year—many isolated Appalachian settlers stubbornly rejected the new December 25th date. Viewing the shift as a man-made, politically motivated decree, early Greenbrier Valley and Pocahontas County families preserved "Old Christmas" on January 6th (the Feast of the Epiphany) as the true, holy anniversary of Christ’s birth. Throughout the early 1800s, December 25th was observed merely as a solemn day of fasting or routine winter chores, reserving true feasting, house visiting, and music-making for the January 6th holy day.

This twelve-day span between "New Christmas" and "Old Christmas" was saturated with supernatural lore and household omens. Mountain families carefully tracked the weather during these "Twelve Ruling Days," believing each consecutive day forecast the climate for its corresponding month in the coming year. On Old Christmas Eve (midnight on January 5th), the natural world was believed to undergo miraculous transformations. Well water, mountain springs, and creeks were said to briefly turn into wine or blood, making it terrible luck to draw water during that hour. Lore also held that the native elderberry bush would spontaneously sprout green shoots or blooms straight through the snow, a phenomenon echoed in the traditional Old World ballad "The Cherry Tree Carol," which recounted nature itself bowing to the divine.

At the domestic hearth, families practiced careful divination before retiring on Old Christmas Eve. Fireplace ashes were swept completely flat; if a mark resembling a footprint pointing toward the front door appeared by morning, it foretold that a family member would die or depart the hollow before the next winter. Heavy labor like wood-chopping or wool-spinning was strictly forbidden, as violating the holiday Sabbath was thought to bring ruin upon the farmstead.

The season also showcased a vibrant blend of Scotch-Irish and Germanic customs. At dawn on Old Christmas morning, Scotch-Irish woodsmen practiced "Shooting in the Christmas," stepping onto snow-covered porches to discharge their black-powder long-rifles, sending thunderous echoes across the hollows to signal neighbors that the holy day had arrived. Meanwhile, in pockets of Germanic settlement, children awaited visits from the "Belsnickel"—a fur-clad, masked figure with a soot-blackened face who rewarded well-behaved youths with rare dried fruit or walnuts while playfully threatening mischievous children with a hickory switch.

Mountain lore strictly warned that any human who stayed awake to watch the farm animals kneel, and overheard them speak at midnight, would die within the year.

3. Appalachian Fiddle Styles Were Split Between "Dance Halls" and "Isolated Parlors"

Rhythmic Saw-Strokes vs. Crooked Long-Bows: Two Distinct Musical Legacies

While both preserved pre-radio, 19th-century West Virginia string traditions, central West Virginia fiddling and eastern Allegheny fiddling developed along radically different lines. The primary cultural catalyst for this music was the twelve-day Old Christmas season, where seasonal "play parties" and house dances provided the backdrop for traditional performance. Fiddlers drove night-long celebrations centered around seasonal tunes like French Carpenter's and Sherman Hammons's alternate-tuned "Old Christmas Morning," as well as the rowdy, season-ending breakdown "Breakin' Up Christmas," whose traditional refrain echoed through the rafters: "Hooray Jake, Hooray John, Breakin' up Christmas all night long..."

Yet, geography and social function split the mechanics of mountain fiddling into two distinct schools. In central West Virginia (Braxton County), legendary fiddler Melvin Wine preserved a style forged in crowded coal camps, timber gatherings, and riverboat culture along the Kanawha and Ohio rivers. Designed to propel square dancers on noisy wooden floors, Wine's playing favored steady, driving 4/4 meters and bright, standard-tuned breakdown pieces like "Lady's Fancy." Even his modal masterpieces, such as "Yew Piney Mountain" (named for the high-elevation red spruce forests) and "Cold Frosty Morning" (which shifts moodily from an A-minor first part to a bright A-major second part), utilized a short, highly articulated "saw-stroke" bowing technique in the middle of the stick to cut through ambient noise.

In contrast, the Hammons family—including Burl, Sherman, Lee, Maggie, and Edden—lived in the deep geographic isolation of Pocahontas County's Williams River basin. Edden Hammons famously carved his very first fiddle out of a wild dried gourd, while his sister Maggie Hammons Parker became a legendary repository of archaic ballads and herbal lore. Playing primarily for solitary parlor listening and home entertainment, the Hammonses developed a style that was famously "crooked"—spontaneously dropping or adding half-beats to fit the emotional contour of a song. Favouring dark, brooding cross-tunings (such as AEAE or DDAD), they used sweeping, fluid "long-bow" strokes across open strings to produce a mournful, bagpipe-like drone punctuated by delicate left-hand slides.

Feature / Aspect

Central West Virginia Style (e.g., Melvin Wine)

Eastern Allegheny Style (e.g., Hammons Family)

Primary Social Purpose

Propelling community square dances and public halls

Solitary parlor listening and family storytelling

Rhythmic Structure

Driving, steady 4/4 meter with infectious dance pulse

Asymmetrical ("crooked") phrasing with dropped/added beats

Bowing Mechanics

Short, punchy "saw-stroke" in the middle of the bow

Long, fluid bow strokes creating continuous continuous drones

Tonal Palette

Bright, standard-tuned breakdown tunes (Keys of G & D)

Brooding, modal cross-tunings (AEAE, DDAD) with drone strings

"Melvin Wine’s fiddling pulls you out of your seat to dance, while the Hammons’ fiddling pulls you into your chair to listen."

4. The Banjo Was Reimagined as a Percussive Drum to Match Ghostly Fiddles

Translating Fluid Fiddle Drones into Percussive Banjo Driving Rhythms

To carry the brooding, long-bow fiddle sound of the Hammons family onto an inherently staccato instrument like the clawhammer banjo, Pocahontas County native Dwight Diller fundamentally altered traditional banjo mechanics. Spending years sitting knee-to-knee in remote mountain cabins with Sherman, Burl, and Maggie Hammons, Diller absorbed their archaic repertoire not as a rigid set of notes, but as a visceral expression of the rugged Allegheny landscape.

Recognizing that a plucked banjo could not sustain notes like a bowed fiddle, Diller adapted the instrument into a percussive engine designed to capture the primal "pulse" of the bow stroke through four distinct technical shifts:

  • Rhythm Over Melody: Rather than engaging in fast, note-for-note melodic copying, Diller stripped the tune down to its rhythmic skeleton. He anchored the fluid, crooked phrasing of the Hammons fiddle tunes by heavily striking the downbeat, emphasizing the underlying pulse over complex ornamentation.
  • The Signature "Cluck": To replicate the sharp percussive bite of a fiddler changing bow direction, Diller perfected a strike known as the "cluck." By striking a string with the back of his fingernail and instantly damping it with the fleshy portion of his striking finger or palm, he produced a snare-drum-like pop that gave the instrument a driving bite.
  • Playing Over the Neck: To match the hollow, ancient modal tones of cross-tuned fiddles, Diller moved his right hand away from the banjo bridge, striking the strings high up over the scooped wooden fretboard neck. This altered the acoustics, replacing bright twang with a dark, round, and woody resonance.
  • Strategic Silence: Instead of filling every beat with standard "bum-ditty" frailing patterns, Diller used silence as an expressive tool. He intentionally dropped notes out of standard patterns, leaving unexpected rhythmic gaps while letting the high fifth drone string ring against syncopated off-beats.

5. Deep-Woods Settlers Refused Agrarian Farming in Favor of a "Forest Commons"

Deeded Valley Farms vs. Unfenced Backcountry Foraging

In the fertile bottomlands of the Greenbrier Valley, early agrarian families like the McNeals and Van Meters built their survival on formal land patents, extensive clearings, cash crops, and domesticated livestock. In stark contrast, deep-woods woodsmen like the Hammons family in the Williams River basin rejected the labor-intensive model of deeded property and permanent fields. Operating on the fringes of settled society, they treated the vast, unfenced wilderness as a shared "forest commons."

Rather than conquering the forest with the plow, these mountain woodsmen lived in intimate harmony with the microclimates of the old-growth canopy, sustaining themselves through three specialized practices:

  • "Sangin'" (Ginseng Harvesting): Without cash crops or large surplus grain harvests, deep-woods families relied on wild American ginseng (Panax quinquefolius) as their primary currency. Harvesting the wild roots from the cool, damp shade of mature hardwood canopies, they dried the "sang" and traded it at country stores for essential mercantile goods they could not forge—primarily salt, coffee, and black powder.
  • Trapping & Hunting: Pasture management required endless labor clearing brush and putting up winter hay for cattle. Mountain woodsmen bypassed livestock farming by running extensive trap lines for mink, fox, raccoon, marten, and muskrat to trade pelts. Their primary winter protein came from wild game—venison, black bear, and wild turkey. Women like Maggie Hammons Parker supplemented this diet through master-level knowledge of wild herbs, greens, and forest medicines.
  • Patch Farming: Instead of plowing large, permanent acreage, woodsmen maintained small, hidden "patch" gardens tucked into natural forest clearings. Planting modest plots of corn, beans, and potatoes provided essential winter carbohydrates without binding the family to a single piece of real estate or requiring clear-cut fields.

6. Steam Locomotives and Clear-Cutting Obliterated the Mountain Commons Overnight

Old-Growth Forest Collapse and the Forced Shift to a Wage Economy

The historical balance of the mountain commons came to an abrupt, violent end in the 1890s and early 1900s. Industrial timber conglomerates—such as the West Virginia Pulp and Paper Company and the Cherry River Boom & Lumber Company—pushed rail lines deep into the Allegheny backcountry. The rapid growth of industrial boomtowns like Cass and Spruce brought heavy machinery, band-saw mills, and geared Shay steam locomotives to the mountains, resulting in total clear-cutting that dismantled the climax ecosystem within a single generation.

This industrial assault destroyed the environmental foundation of the backcountry commons through three devastating ecological mechanisms:

  • Destruction of Ginseng Microclimates: Wild ginseng requires a dense hardwood canopy offering 70% to 90% shade. Clear-cutting completely exposed the forest floor to direct, scorching sunlight, baking the delicate humus soil and instantly obliterating the ancient microclimates required for "sangin'."
  • Wildfires and Wiped-Out Trap Lines: Striping away red spruce and hardwood forests destroyed the specialized habitats of fur-bearing mammals. Furthermore, logging crews left behind massive fields of dry waste wood ("slash"). Sparks thrown by Shay locomotives frequently ignited this debris, causing catastrophic wildfires that burned the organic soil down to bare bedrock and wiped out native game.
  • Stream Siltation and Warming: Stripped of mountain shade, water temperatures in pristine rivers like the Williams and Greenbrier rose rapidly. Massive soil erosion choked cold mountain streams with silt, destroying the spawning grounds of native brook trout.

Deprived of their traditional foraging grounds, independent woodsmen were forced into the fringes of the modern wage economy. While resisting formal shift-work in logging camps, traditionalists like Edden Hammons adapted to survive: carving and selling hickory axe handles to timber crews, distilling moonshine for railroad workers, and playing fiddle for dances in bustling lumber camps.

7. Creating a National Forest Saved the Ecology—But Fragmented Mountain Property

Municipal Tax Shifts, Property Inholdings, and the Criminalization of Tradition

Following the timber boom, millions of acres of clear-cut, fire-ravaged mountain land were left abandoned. Under the authority of the 1911 Weeks Act, the federal government began purchasing these ruined tracts in 1920 to establish the Monongahela National Forest (MNF). While this massive conservation movement successfully re-established the forest canopy and stabilized mountain watersheds, it fundamentally altered local governance, property rights, and traditional mountain lifeways.

Because federal land acquisition eventually grew to cover roughly 60% of Pocahontas County's total land area, vast swathes of real estate were permanently removed from the local property tax base. To keep county governments and public school systems solvent, municipalities became permanently dependent on federal safety-net funding mechanisms, such as Payment in Lieu of Taxes (PILT) and the Secure Rural Schools (SRS) Act.

For private citizens, federal land accumulation created a complex geographic quilt, leaving remaining homesteads as "inholdings"—islands of private land entirely surrounded by national forest. This spatial reality created enduring legal and practical friction:

  • Chain of Title Disputes: Establishing historical land boundaries required navigating complex transitions between 19th-century state land patents and post-1920 federal acquisitions.
  • Access and Easements: Historic logging paths and traditional access roads were frequently absorbed into federal land, leading to long-standing right-of-way disputes over locked forest service gates.
  • Environmental Oversight: Private parcels situated adjacent to federal property faced intense ecological monitoring, particularly regarding groundwater protection within fragile, porous karst limestone watersheds.

Ultimately, federal conservation created a profound cultural paradox. While the Monongahela National Forest saved the Allegheny ecology from total ruin, the introduction of federal game wardens, strict hunting seasons, and regulated foraging laws effectively criminalized the historical subsistence lifestyle that deep-woods mountain families had maintained for generations.

8. Conclusion: Preserving the Echoes of the Alleghenies

The frontier history of early Appalachia reveals a world far richer and more nuanced than standard historical accounts suggest. The quiet mysticism of Old Christmas, the rhythmic mechanics of mountain fiddling, the percussive transformation of the clawhammer banjo, and the fragile economy of the forest commons form an irreplaceable heritage. Though industrial logging and subsequent federal conservation altered the physical landscape forever, the spirit of this mountain culture survived through oral tradition and dedicated field recordings captured by researchers like Dwight Diller, Carl Fleischhauer, and Alan Jabbour for the Library of Congress.

As we navigate a modern world increasingly dominated by digital hyper-connectivity, uniform commercial calendars, and global supply chains, the world of the early Alleghenies offers a sobering point of reflection: What essential human connections, quiet wonder, and deep ecological intimacy have we surrendered in exchange for the conveniences of modern life?

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 

Comprehensive Briefing Document: Cultural Heritage, Musical Traditions, and Environmental Governance in Pocahontas County and the Greenbrier Valley

Executive Summary

This briefing document provides an exhaustive synthesis of the historical, cultural, musical, ecological, and administrative dynamics of Pocahontas County and the surrounding Greenbrier Valley region in West Virginia. Rooted in the isolated frontier reality of the early 19th century, the region's early history was defined by an agrarian subsistence lifestyle, quiet religious observance, and a distinct body of mountain folklore associated with "Old Christmas" (January 6th). The blending of Scotch-Irish (e.g., McNeal) and Germanic (e.g., Van Meter) settler traditions produced unique social customs, seasonal rituals, and an enduring corpus of modal string band music.

In the musicological realm, the region preserved an unbroken link to 19th-century backcountry soundscapes. A comparative analysis highlights the stark contrasts between the central West Virginia driving square-dance style of Braxton County’s Melvin Wine—characterized by short "saw-stroke" bowing—and the isolated, highly syncopated, "crooked" long-bow style of Pocahontas County’s Hammons family. Native musician Dwight Diller systematically adapted the Hammons' fluid fiddle sound into a percussive clawhammer banjo technique through rhythmic simplification, neck placement, and signature percussive strikes.

Socioeconomically, the Hammons family exemplified an intentional, forest-based commons economy in the Williams River basin, relying on wild American ginseng harvesting ("sangin'"), pelt trapping, patch farming, and wilderness foraging. This lifestyle directly conflicted with the deeded, clear-title agrarian models of the lower valleys. The arrival of industrial timber conglomerates in the late 19th and early 20th centuries—such as the West Virginia Pulp and Paper Company—dismantled this climax ecosystem through total clear-cutting, stream degradation, and slash fires. Subsequent federal land acquisition creating the Monongahela National Forest (MNF) transformed over half of the county's landmass into public property. Today, this legacy dictates local municipal governance, shaping school finance formulas under W. Va. Code § 18-9A-2, solid waste infrastructure setback constraints, private land inholding right-of-way disputes, and hydrogeological environmental management across karst limestone topographies.

1. Early Frontier Life and the Cultural Mysticism of Old Christmas

1.1 Calendar Shifts and the Preservation of "Old Christmas"

Following the British Empire's adoption of the Gregorian calendar in 1752—which shifted dates forward by eleven days—many isolated rural Appalachian settlers rejected the "New" December 25th holiday, viewing it as a man-made, politically motivated mandate. Instead, settlers across the Greenbrier Valley and Pocahontas County observed "Old Christmas" on January 6th (the Feast of the Epiphany), treating it as the authentic holy anniversary of the nativity.

  • December 25th Observance: Frequently treated as a solemn, quiet day restricted to standard winter chores, fasting, or routine labor.
  • January 6th Observance: Reserved as the primary occasion for feasting, visiting, play parties, and social gathering.

1.2 Mountain Folklore and Midnight Miracles

Appalachian oral tradition maintained that at the exact stroke of midnight on Old Christmas Eve (January 5th), the natural world briefly underwent supernatural transformations:

  • Kneeling and Speaking Livestock: Farm animals—specifically cattle, oxen, and horses—were believed to kneel in their stalls to pray at midnight. Mountain lore imposed a strict taboo against spying on the animals; individuals who overheard livestock speak were warned they would die within the year.
  • Water Transformation: Springs, well water, and creeks across the Alleghenies were believed to briefly turn into wine or blood at midnight. Drawing or consuming water during this hour was considered an omen of severe misfortune.
  • Spontaneous Botanical Blooming: Settlers maintained that the elderberry bush (elderbrush) and the "Rose of Jericho" would spontaneously shoot green sprouts or blooms through the snow at midnight, only to wither moments later.

1.3 Hearth Superstitions, Weather Forecasting, and Taboos

The twelve-day period spanning New Christmas (December 25th) to Old Christmas (January 6th) carried deep mystical significance for mountain households:

  • The Twelve Ruling Days: Settlers meticulously observed and recorded the weather conditions on each of these twelve consecutive days, believing each day accurately predicted the weather for the corresponding month of the coming year.
  • Hearth Ash Footprints: Fireplace ashes were swept completely flat on Old Christmas Eve. If a print resembling a footprint pointing toward the exterior door appeared in the ashes by morning, it foretold the death or permanent departure of a household member before the following winter.
  • Labor Restrictions: Manual labor—including spinning wool, splitting firewood, or heavy agricultural work—was strictly prohibited on Old Christmas. Engaging in work was viewed as a severe sin that would bring bad luck to the farmstead.

1.4 Cultural Synthesis: Scotch-Irish and Germanic Customs

The cultural blending of Scotch-Irish migration streams with Dutch and Germanic settlers created specialized frontier rituals:

  • Shooting in the Christmas: A Scotch-Irish custom where men stepped onto porches or into snowy fields at dawn on Christmas morning to discharge black-powder muskets and long rifles into the air, signaling the arrival of the holiday across mountain hollows.
  • The Belsnickel: Derived from Germanic heritage, this fur-clad, masked (or soot-faced) figure visited homes prior to Christmas. The Belsnickel rewarded obedient children with dried fruits or walnuts while playfully threatening disobedient children with a hickory switch.
  • Winter Feasts and Play Parties: Because winter weather temporarily suspended heavy timbering and field labor, families cleared furniture from log cabins for evening "play parties." Fiddlers played reels and square dances that lasted until dawn. Meals relied on stored autumn harvests and wild game, featuring venison, bear, wild turkey, salt-cured pork, preserved apples, dried beans, and cornmeal.

2. Preservation and Evolution of Appalachian Traditional Music

2.1 Traditional Winter Repertoire and Balladry

The deep winter isolation of the Alleghenies generated a distinct repertoire of modal string band tunes and ancient oral ballads:

  • "Old Christmas Morning" / "Christmas Morning": Embedded in West Virginia fiddling traditions. French Carpenter of Clay County famously recorded a cross-tuned version of "Old Christmas Morning," whereas Sherman and Lee Hammons of Pocahontas County performed a driving, rhythmic tune titled "Christmas Morning." Both used alternate fiddle tunings to produce droning, resonant tonalities suitable for unamplified performances in dark hollows.
  • "Breakin' Up Christmas": The definitive string band breakdown of the Blue Ridge region, marking the final, rowdiest house party on January 6th at the conclusion of the 12-day visiting season. Traditional vocal verses called out during performances include:

"Hooray Jake, Hooray John, Breakin' up Christmas all night long. Santa Claus come, done and gone, Breaking up Christmas right straight along."

  • "Cold Frosty Morning": A signature modal tune associated with central West Virginia fiddler Melvin Wine, capturing the stark atmosphere of mountain winter by shifting from a brooding A-minor first section to a brighter A-major second section.
  • "The Cherry Tree Carol": An apocryphal Old World ballad preserved through oral transmission. It recounts Joseph and Mary walking through an orchard, where a cherry tree miraculously bends down to offer fruit to the unborn Christ. The narrative parallels local folklore regarding elderbushes blooming spontaneously in the snow on Old Christmas Eve.

2.2 Stylistic Comparison: Melvin Wine vs. The Hammons Family

While both Melvin Wine (1909–2003) of Braxton County and the Hammons family of Pocahontas County preserved pre-radio 19th-century West Virginia string music, their technical execution and musical intent diverged significantly based on geographic and social contexts.

Feature

Melvin Wine (Central WV Style)

The Hammons Family (Eastern Allegheny Style)

Primary Region

Braxton County (coal camps, farming, riverboat influences)

Pocahontas County (Williams River basin isolation)

Social Purpose

Square Dance / Community Gathering: Driving, highly rhythmic meter designed to propel dancers.

Solitary Parlor Listening / Conversational: Highly personal, unconstrained by strict dance rhythms.

Rhythmic Structure

Generally steady, infectious meter (with occasional asymmetrical tunes).

Famously "crooked"; regularly drops or adds half-beats to match ballad contours or spoken stories.

Bowing Technique

Short-Bow / "Saw-Stroke": Played primarily in the middle of the bow; punchy, bright, clear articulation.

Long-Bow Style: Long, fluid, sweeping bow strokes; continuous ghostly right-hand drone.

Left-Hand Technique

Clean melodic articulation across bright breakdowns.

Extensive left-hand ornamentation, including slides and hammer-ons.

Tonality & Tuning

Frequent use of standard tuning in bright keys (G and D), alongside modal pieces.

Heavy reliance on dark modal cross-tunings (e.g., AEAE, DDAD) creating bagpipe-like sympathetic resonances.

This cultural contrast is summarized by an established regional adage: "Melvin Wine’s fiddling pulls you out of your seat to dance, while the Hammons’ fiddling pulls you into your chair to listen."

Melvin Wine (Braxton County)        --> Saw-Stroke Bowing --> Bright / Driving Dance Meter
The Hammons Family (Pocahontas Co.) --> Long-Bow Drone   --> Crooked / Solitary Modal Sound

Melvin Wine's Repertoire & Honors

Melvin Wine learned his traditional repertoire directly from his father, Bob Wine, and his grandfather. Awarded the National Endowment for the Arts (NEA) National Heritage Fellowship in 1991 and recognized as the first recipient of West Virginia's Vandalia Award, Wine preserved a 250-tune repertoire featuring:

  • "Yew Piney Mountain": Quintessential West Virginia modal tune played in cross-tuning (AEAE or DDAD), named after high-elevation red spruce (yew pine) forests.
  • "Boatsman" ("Boatsman's Dance"): A driving breakdown tracing back to 19th-century riverboat workers on the Kanawha and Ohio rivers.
  • "Hannah at the Springhouse": A distinct "crooked" tune with asymmetrical phrasing outside standard 4/4 meter.
  • "Lady's Fancy": A bright, melodic breakdown in the key of G.
  • "Rainy Day": An atmospheric tune characterized by heavy bow drones.

2.3 Dwight Diller's Clawhammer Banjo Adaptation

Pocahontas County native Dwight Diller studied directly under Burl, Sherman, and Maggie Hammons. To translate the fluid, long-bow fiddle style of the Hammonses to the staccato, percussive clawhammer banjo, Diller systematically altered standard playing techniques:

  • Rhythmic Framing over Melodic Complexity: Diller abandoned dense melodic note-runs to focus on the skeletal framework and raw downbeat pulse of the fiddle's bowing stroke.
  • The Signature "Cluck" (or "Chuck"): Diller striking the string with the back of the fingernail while instantly damping it with the fingers or palm created a percussive pop resembling a snare drum, replacing the rhythmic turnarounds of the fiddle bow.
  • Neck Placement for Tonality: Rather than striking strings near the bridge (which produces a sharp bluegrass twang), Diller played high over the scooped neck of the banjo, yielding a dark, hollow, round tonality that mirrored cross-tuned modal fiddles.
  • Rhythmic Gaps and Syncopation: Diller frequently omitted notes from the standard "bum-ditty" frailing pattern, utilizing deliberate pauses and heavy fifth-string drone placement to align with the off-beat syncopations of mountain fiddling.

3. The Hammons Family: Isolation, Forest Subsistence, and Economic Contrasts

3.1 Settlement Dynamics in the Williams River Basin

Originating in 18th-century Kentucky, the Hammons family migrated into West Virginia prior to the American Civil War. Under patriarchs such as Paris Hammons, the family bypassed populated river valleys and established homesteads deep within the rugged Williams River basin along the Pocahontas and Webster County border.

While industrial speculators like John T. McGraw acquired timber tracts in the 1880s to expand railroad infrastructure and establish Marlinton as the county seat, the Hammons family remained deliberately insulated on the geographical and social periphery.

3.2 Subsistence Strategy vs. Valley Agrarianism

+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
|                            LAND AND ECONOMIC MODELS                               |
+--------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------+
| Hammons Forest Commons Model                     | Valley Agrarian Model          |
| (Williams River Basin)                           | (e.g., McNeals / Van Meters)   |
+--------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------+
| • Unfenced wilderness treated as a "commons"     | • Formal land patents & deeds  |
| • Wild American Ginseng ("Sangin'") as currency  | • Cash crops & grain surpluses |
| • Pelt trapping (mink, fox, muskrat, raccoon)    | • Pasture & domesticated herds |
| • Small, hidden forest "patch" gardens           | • Extensive cleared plow-fields|
+--------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------+

The Hammons family operated a mobile, forest-based subsistence economy that contrasted sharply with the formal agrarian land-patent models established by valley families like Lt. John McNeal and Elizabeth Van Meter on Lot 9 of the South Branch Manor:

  • Forest Commons vs. Deeded Holdings: Valley farmers maintained fixed property lines, cleared large acreage, and built permanent outbuildings. The Hammonses treated the unfenced wilderness as a shared resource, moving across the landscape without purchasing vast acreage.
  • "Sangin'" vs. Cash Crops: While valley agrarianism relied on surplus grains and market cattle, the Hammons family relied on wild American ginseng ("sangin'") as a primary medium of exchange. Harvested roots were dried and traded at local general stores for essential commodities that could not be manufactured at home, such as black powder, salt, and coffee.
  • Trapping vs. Pasture Fodder: Valley farmers invested labor into fencing, pasture management, and growing winter hay or corn for livestock. The Hammonses bypassed livestock maintenance by running extensive trap lines for mink, fox, raccoon, and muskrat, trading pelts and hunting wild game (bear, venison, wild turkey) for protein.
  • Patch Farming vs. Broad Clearing: Instead of plowing permanent fields with oxen, the Hammons family cultivated small, temporary "patch" gardens of corn, potatoes, and beans inside natural forest openings, allowing them to relocate further up the hollows when desired.

3.3 Archival Legacy and Recognition

Because the Hammons family avoided deeded real estate transactions and formal employment, their history left minimal paper trails in municipal contract registries or property land deeds. Instead, their culture was preserved orally. Edden Hammons famously carved his first fiddle from a dried gourd.

In the late 1960s and 1970s, as Hammons descendants moved closer to communities like Stillwell near Marlinton, researchers including Dwight Diller, Carl Fleischhauer, and Alan Jabbour recorded their narratives, photos, and repertoire for the Library of Congress. In 2020, the Hammons family was collectively inducted into the West Virginia Music Hall of Fame.

4. Industrialization, Ecological Shift, and Modern Municipal Governance

4.1 Industrial Timber Operations and Ecological Destruction

During the 1890s and early 1900s, industrial timber conglomerates—such as the West Virginia Pulp and Paper Company (WVP&P) and the Cherry River Boom & Lumber Company—introduced geared Shay locomotives and heavy band-saw mills to clear-cut the Allegheny old-growth canopy, founding timber towns like Cass and Spruce. This industrial expansion caused systemic ecological degradation that disrupted the traditional mountain commons:

  • Destruction of Ginseng Microclimates: Wild American ginseng requires 70% to 90% shade provided by intact, mature hardwood canopies. Total clear-cutting exposed the forest floor to direct solar radiation, drying the topsoil and eradicating ginseng growing habitats.
  • Decimation of Trapping Grounds and Slash Fires: Clear-cutting removed red spruce and hardwood habitats supporting fur-bearing animals (mink, marten, fox). Locomotives ignited leftover branch debris ("slash"), causing widespread wildfires that burned organic soil layers down to bedrock.
  • Stream Degradation: Eliminating the canopy elevated water temperatures across the Williams River watershed, while unmitigated soil erosion silted creeks, devastating native brook trout populations.
Industrial Clear-Cutting & Shay Locomotives
  │
  ├──► Loss of Canopy Shade (70-90%) ──► Soil Desiccation ──► Eradication of Ginseng
  ├──► Locomotive Slash Fires         ──► Topsoil Burned   ──► Destruction of Traplines
  └──► Canopy Removal & Erosion       ──► Stream Siltation ──► Brook Trout Collapse

4.2 Forced Economic Adaptation

Deprived of historical foraging grounds, mountain families were pushed toward the perimeter of the industrial wage economy. Men like Edden Hammons adapted by:

  1. Carving and selling wooden axe handles to commercial logging camps;
  2. Performing fiddle music at timber camp dances;
  3. Distilling moonshine for sale to immigrant railroad and timber workers.

4.3 Creation of the Monongahela National Forest and Modern Administrative Impacts

Following total timber depletion, the federal government utilized the Weeks Act of 1911 to purchase hundreds of thousands of acres of cut-over, burned land starting in 1920, establishing the Monongahela National Forest (MNF). Today, federal land encompasses approximately 60% of Pocahontas County's landmass. While federal administration restored timber growth, it established strict regulatory oversight, game laws, and wardens, effectively outlawing traditional subsistence foraging and hunting on public lands.

                                Pocahontas County Land Distribution
                              ┌──────────────────────────────────────┐
                              │     Monongahela National Forest      │
                              │                (60%)                 │
                              ├──────────────────────────────────────┤
                              │         Private / Municipal          │
                              │                (40%)                 │
                              └──────────────────────────────────────┘

Municipal Finance and School Funding Constraints

Removing over half of the county's real estate from tax rolls eliminated significant potential property tax revenues. Local municipal operations depend heavily on federal offset mechanisms:

  • Federal Offsets: Payment in Lieu of Taxes (PILT) and the Secure Rural Schools (SRS) Act supply critical operational revenue.
  • State Aid School Formulas: Variations in federal timber yield receipts directly impact state funding formulas governed by W. Va. Code § 18-9A-2. This statutory formula dictates operational budgets for local primary schools and Pocahontas County High School, directly affecting public education operations and standardized student assessment tracking (such as WVGSA and SAT School Day metrics).
  • Solid Waste Infrastructure Setbacks: Public waste management planning—such as decisions by the Pocahontas County Solid Waste Authority regarding direct-haul solid waste systems versus centralized transfer stations—must accommodate strict exclusionary setback zones and environmental mandates imposed by surrounding federal land.

Real Property, Boundary Conflicts, and Environmental Analysis

The interspersing of public national forest lands with historical homesteads created a fragmented map of private "inholdings," creating unique legal and logistical challenges:

  • Title Chain & FOIA Delineation: Conducting title searches or executing statutory Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) requests for county records requires parsing 19th-century land grants against post-1920 federal land acquisitions, maintaining precise boundaries between county and federal jurisdictions.
  • Easement and Access Disputes: Historic logging corridors and private farm roads were widely absorbed into MNF boundaries, generating long-standing right-of-way disputes over private landowner access through gated federal forest roads.
  • Environmental Hydrogeology in Karst Topography: Private agricultural lands and federal holdings frequently share complex, interconnected karst limestone aquifers. Groundwater dye-tracing and hydrogeological risk assessments must navigate overlapping regulatory frameworks, as subsurface water flows seamlessly across private property lines into federally protected watersheds.

--------------------------------

Study Guide: Pioneer History, Folklife, and Environmental Transitions in Pocahontas County and the Greenbrier Valley

Section 1: Core Review Modules

Module 1: Pioneer Traditions, Calendar Shifts, and Old Christmas Folklore

During the early 19th century, migration into the Greenbrier Valley and Pocahontas County brought pioneer families—including early settlers such as Lt. John McNeal and the Van Meters—into an isolated frontier. Early winter holiday traditions were defined by agrarian relief, religious observance, and community survival during harsh Allegheny winters, standing in stark contrast to modern commercialized celebrations.

  • The 1752 Calendar Shift and "Old Christmas": Following the British Empire's 1752 transition from the Julian to the Gregorian calendar, many rural Appalachian settlers rejected the "New" December 25th date, viewing it as a man-made, politically motivated calendar shift. Instead, they observed Old Christmas on January 6th (the Feast of the Epiphany) as the true anniversary of the birth of Christ. December 25th was frequently spent quietly doing standard winter chores or fasting, saving feasting and visiting for January 6th.
  • The Midnight Miracles: Mountain lore attributed supernatural phenomena to the stroke of midnight on Old Christmas Eve (January 5th):
    • Kneeling and Speaking Livestock: Farm animals—particularly oxen, cattle, and horses—were believed to kneel in their stalls to pray. Mountain tradition strictly forbade spying on them, warning that anyone who watched and overheard the livestock speak would die within the year.
    • Transformation of Water: Water in springs, creeks, and wells was said to briefly turn into wine or blood. Drawing or drinking water during this hour was considered an omen of severe bad luck.
    • Spontaneous Vegetation: The elderberry bush (and occasionally the "Rose of Jericho") was believed to miraculously sprout a bloom or green shoot from beneath the snow, only to wither moments later.
  • Omens, Superstitions, and Labor Taboos:
    • The Twelve Ruling Days: The twelve days between December 25th and January 6th were believed to forecast the weather for the twelve corresponding months of the coming year.
    • Hearth Ash Footprints: Fireplace ashes were swept perfectly flat on Old Christmas Eve. A track resembling a footprint pointing toward the door by morning foretold that a family member would die or leave the holler before the next winter.
    • Labor Restrictions: Manual labor such as spinning or chopping wood on January 6th was viewed as a severe sin that would bring misfortune to the farm.
  • Cultural Blends in Custom and Feasting:
    • Scotch-Irish Traditions: Men observed "Shooting in the Christmas" by stepping onto porches or into snowy fields at dawn on Christmas morning to fire black powder blasts from muskets and long rifles, signaling neighbors across the hollows.
    • Germanic Traditions: Families with Dutch or Germanic heritage received visits from the "Belsnickel"—a fur-clad, masked, or soot-faced figure who rewarded well-behaved children with rare dried fruit or walnuts, while playfully threatening misbehaved children with a hickory switch.
    • Play Parties and Feasts: As winter halted heavy timbering and farming, settlers cleared furniture from log homes for "play parties" where fiddlers played reels and square dances until dawn. Winter feasts relied entirely on preserved and hunted food: venison, bear, wild turkey, salt-cured pork, dried beans, preserved apples, and cornmeal.

Module 2: Appalachian Winter Repertoire and Musical Lore

Traditional winter music of the Allegheny region consists of modal fiddle tunes and Old World ballads that reflect geographic isolation and the rowdy social gatherings of the 12-day Old Christmas season.

  • "Old Christmas Morning" / "Christmas Morning": Embedded in the West Virginia repertoire, these tunes utilize alternate fiddle tunings to generate a droning, resonant sound suited to isolated hollers. Fiddler French Carpenter of Clay County recorded the cross-tuned "Old Christmas Morning," while Sherman and Lee Hammons of Pocahontas County performed a driving version titled "Christmas Morning."
  • "Breakin' Up Christmas": The definitive holiday string band tune of the Blue Ridge and surrounding mountains, commemorating the final, rowdiest house party on January 6th that concluded the 12-day visiting season. Traditional called-out verses include:

"Hooray Jake, Hooray John, Breakin' up Christmas all night long. Santa Claus come, done and gone, Breaking up Christmas right straight along."

  • "Cold Frosty Morning": A signature modal tune passed down by central West Virginia fiddler Melvin Wine, capturing the starkness of winter by shifting from a melancholic A-minor first section to a driving A-major second section.
  • "The Cherry Tree Carol": An Old World ballad preserved through mountain oral tradition detailing an apocryphal story of Joseph and Mary walking through an orchard, where a cherry tree miraculously bows down to offer fruit to the unborn Christ. This narrative mirrors local Appalachian legends of elderbushes blooming and nature bowing in the snow on Old Christmas Eve.

Module 3: Comparative Stylistic Analysis: Central West Virginia vs. Eastern Allegheny Fiddling

While central West Virginia fiddlers like Melvin Wine (1909–2003) of Braxton County and Eastern Allegheny fiddlers like the Hammons family of Pocahontas County preserved 19th-century pre-radio string music, their styles diverged significantly based on geography and social context.

Stylistic Dimension

Central West Virginia Style (Melvin Wine)

Eastern Allegheny Style (The Hammons Family)

Primary Social Purpose

Community gatherings, coal camps, and dance halls; designed to propel square dancers with a steady meter.

Solitary parlor playing in isolated river basins (e.g., Williams River); conversational and reflective.

Rhythmic Meter

Generally steady and driving breakdown rhythms.

Highly "crooked"—frequently dropping or adding half-beats to fit emotional phrasing or storytelling.

Bowing Technique

Saw-stroke (traditional shuffle): Short, punchy bow strokes in the middle of the bow creating a bright, articulated sound.

Long-bow technique: Sweeping, fluid, and syncopated strokes creating a mournful sound with left-hand slides and hammer-ons.

Tonality & Tuning

Frequent use of standard tuning in bright keys (G and D), alongside modal pieces.

Heavy reliance on cross-tuning (e.g., AEAE, DDAD) to generate a continuous, pipe-like open string drone.

Aural Impact Adage

"Pulls you out of your seat to dance."

"Pulls you into your chair to listen."

Key Repertoire of Melvin Wine:

  • Yew Piney Mountain: A haunting modal tune named after the native high-elevation red spruce (yew pine) forests, played in cross-tuning (AEAE or DDAD).
  • Boatsman (Boatsman's Dance): A driving breakdown learned from his father, Bob Wine, tracing back to mid-19th-century Ohio and Kanawha riverboat workers.
  • Hannah at the Springhouse: An asymmetrical, "crooked" tune played outside standard 4/4 meter, designed for listening rather than formal square dancing.
  • Lady's Fancy: A lively dance breakdown in the key of G major.
  • Rainy Day: A crooked, atmospheric family tune featuring heavy, droning bow strokes.

Module 4: Adaptation of Fiddle Mechanics to Clawhammer Banjo

Pocahontas County native Dwight Diller learned directly from Burl, Sherman, and Maggie Hammons. To translate their long-bow fiddle style onto the clawhammer banjo, Diller adapted his percussive mechanics:

  • Rhythm over Melody: Rather than mimicking every note of a fiddle tune, Diller captured the driving pulse of the bow by heavily emphasizing the downbeat and maintaining the tune's skeletal framework.
  • The Signature "Cluck" (Chuck): To replicate the percussive bite of the Hammonses' bow turnarounds, Diller perfected a percussive strike—striking the string with the back of the fingernail and immediately muting it with the fingers or palm to produce a snare-drum-like pop.
  • Positioning Over the Neck: To echo the deep, modal cross-tunings of the fiddle, Diller played high up over the neck (where the fretboard is often scooped out) rather than near the bridge, producing a hollow, dark tone.
  • Rhythmic Space and Syncopation: Diller utilized unexpected silence by dropping notes out of the standard "bum-ditty" frailing pattern, relying on the drone string to lock into off-beat syncopations.

Module 5: The Hammons Family Settlement and Subsistence Economy

The Hammons family’s history in the Williams River basin (straddling Pocahontas and Webster counties) represents an extreme model of mountain self-reliance compared to valley agrarian settlers.

  • Migration and Isolation: Tracing their lineage to 18th-century Kentucky, patriarch Paris Hammons led the family into West Virginia prior to the Civil War. While settlers like the McNeals and Van Meters established deeded land patents and cleared valley farmland, the Hammons family intentionally settled on the wilderness fringes. As industrial developers like John T. McGraw acquired timber tracts in the 1880s to build railways and establish Marlinton, the Hammonses remained insulated in the forest.
  • The Forest Commons vs. Valley Agrarianism:
    • Land Use: Valley farmers cleared permanent fields and built outbuildings. The Hammonses treated the unmapped wilderness as a open "commons," living light on the land without extensive fencing.
    • Economic Exchange ("Sangin'"): While valley farms produced surplus crops and livestock for cash, the Hammonses harvested wild American ginseng (Panax quinquefolius) from cool, shady forest slopes to trade at stores for essential goods (salt, coffee, black powder).
    • Protein and Resources: Valley farmers managed pastures and hay for livestock. The Hammonses operated traplines (mink, fox, raccoon, muskrat) for fur trade and hunted wild game (bear, venison, turkey).
    • Patch Farming: Rather than plowing fields with oxen, the Hammonses maintained small, hidden "patch" gardens (corn, beans, potatoes) in forest clearings that could be abandoned if they relocated up the holler.
  • Cultural Preservation: Extreme isolation protected the Hammonses' repertoire of Scotch-Irish ballads, riddles, and crooked tunes from commercial radio influence. Family members—including Burl, Sherman, Lee, Maggie, and Edden (who carved his first fiddle from a gourd)—preserved an archaic oral tradition. They were documented in the 1960s and 1970s by Dwight Diller, Carl Fleischhauer, and Alan Jabbour for the Library of Congress, culminating in their 2020 induction into the West Virginia Music Hall of Fame.

Module 6: Industrial Development, Environmental Shift, and Federal Governance

The late 19th-century influx of industrial logging transformed the ecology and legal structure of Pocahontas County.

  • Ecological Impact of Clear-Cutting (1890s–1900s): Industrial timber companies (e.g., West Virginia Pulp and Paper Company, Cherry River Boom & Lumber Company) used Shay locomotives and band-saw mills to clear-cut old-growth forests, creating timber towns like Cass and Spruce. This environmental destruction shattered the Hammonses' subsistence economy:
    • Eradication of Ginseng: Stripping the 70–90% shade canopy exposed the forest floor to direct sunlight, drying out microclimates required for ginseng growth.
    • Destruction of Traplines: Removing spruce and hardwood canopies eliminated fur-bearer habitats. Locomotive sparks ignited logging debris ("slash"), causing severe wildfires that burned organic topsoil down to bedrock.
    • Stream Degradation: Removing canopy shade raised water temperatures in the Williams River, while soil erosion silted streams, destroying native brook trout populations.
  • Forced Economic Adaptation: Deprived of foraging grounds, family members like Edden Hammons adapted by carving and selling wooden axe handles to timber camps, playing fiddle for lumber workers' dances, and distilling moonshine for railroad crews.
  • The Monongahela National Forest (MNF) and Institutional Governance:
    • Establishment: Following the Weeks Act of 1911, the federal government began purchasing devastated, clear-cut timber tracts in 1920 to form the MNF. This replaced unregulated wilderness with federal land boundaries, game wardens, and strict harvesting laws that curtailed traditional subsistence foraging.
    • Municipal Tax Base Impact: Today, the MNF encompasses approximately 60% of Pocahontas County's total land area. Because federal land is exempt from local property taxes, municipal operations and public school budgets rely heavily on federal Payment in Lieu of Taxes (PILT) funds and the Secure Rural Schools (SRS) Act, directly impacting funding formulas under W. Va. Code § 18-9A-2.
    • Infrastructure and Land Boundaries: High proportions of federal land dictate direct-haul solid waste models and facility placements due to environmental setback zones monitored by entities like the Pocahontas County Solid Waste Authority (PCSWA).
    • Private Land Fragmentation (Inholdings): Surrounding private farms and historic homesteads with federal land created isolated "inholdings." This legacy complicates title chains, generates right-of-way disputes across old timber railway lines or logging roads, and complicates hydrogeological water-tracing through the region's karst limestone topography.

Section 2: Practice Quiz

Instructions: Answer the following ten short-answer questions based strictly on the provided material.

  1. Why did early rural Appalachian settlers celebrate "Old Christmas" on January 6th instead of December 25th?
  2. According to mountain lore, what specific miracles occurred at the stroke of midnight on Old Christmas Eve?
  3. What distinct holiday customs were introduced to the Greenbrier Valley by Scotch-Irish and Germanic settlers, respectively?
  4. What is the cultural and seasonal significance of the traditional Appalachian string band tune "Breakin' Up Christmas"?
  5. How do the primary bowing techniques of central West Virginia fiddler Melvin Wine differ from those of the Hammons family of Pocahontas County?
  6. How did Dwight Diller modify standard clawhammer banjo mechanics to match the Hammons family’s fluid fiddle style?
  7. In what ways did the Hammons family's economic survival model differ from the agrarian model established by early valley settlers?
  8. How did industrial clear-cutting by timber companies in the late 19th and early 20th centuries impact wild American ginseng foraging?
  9. Why does the Monongahela National Forest affect local county tax revenues, and what federal mechanisms offset this effect?
  10. How does the existence of private "inholdings" within federal forest boundaries complicate land access and environmental monitoring?

Section 3: Quiz Answer Key

  1. Why did early rural Appalachian settlers celebrate "Old Christmas" on January 6th instead of December 25th? Answer: Settlers celebrated Old Christmas on January 6th because they rejected the British Empire's 1752 calendar shift from the Julian to the Gregorian system, regarding December 25th as a man-made political change. They considered January 6th (the Feast of the Epiphany) to be the true anniversary of Christ's birth. Consequently, December 25th was spent quietly performing chores or fasting, while holiday feasting was reserved for January 6th.
  2. According to mountain lore, what specific miracles occurred at the stroke of midnight on Old Christmas Eve? Answer: Folklore held that at midnight on January 5th, farm animals would kneel in their stalls to pray, water in creeks and wells briefly transformed into wine or blood, and the elderberry bush would blossom through the snow. Mountain tradition forbade spying on the kneeling animals, warning that anyone who overheard them speak would die within a year.
  3. What distinct holiday customs were introduced to the Greenbrier Valley by Scotch-Irish and Germanic settlers, respectively? Answer: Scotch-Irish settlers introduced "Shooting in the Christmas," a practice where men stepped outside at dawn on Christmas morning to fire muskets and rifles, signaling the holiday to distant neighbors. Germanic settlers introduced the "Belsnickel," a masked or soot-faced figure who visited homes before Christmas to give dried fruit and walnuts to well-behaved children while threatening misbehaved children with a hickory switch.
  4. What is the cultural and seasonal significance of the traditional Appalachian string band tune "Breakin' Up Christmas"? Answer: "Breakin' Up Christmas" marks the final and rowdiest house party held on January 6th, signaling the conclusion of the 12-day Old Christmas visiting season. Driven by fiddle and clawhammer banjo, the tune features traditional call-out verses celebrating the end of the holiday festivities as everyday life resumed.
  5. How do the primary bowing techniques of central West Virginia fiddler Melvin Wine differ from those of the Hammons family of Pocahontas County? Answer: Melvin Wine utilized a short-bowing "saw-stroke" or shuffle in the middle of the bow, producing a punchy, bright sound designed to keep a steady beat for square dancers. In contrast, the Hammons family favored long, fluid bow strokes that created a syncopated, mournful sound, relying on left-hand ornamentation and continuous right-hand drones suited for conversational parlor listening.
  6. How did Dwight Diller modify standard clawhammer banjo mechanics to match the Hammons family’s fluid fiddle style? Answer: Dwight Diller prioritized rhythmic pulse over complex melody by heavily emphasizing downbeats and incorporating a percussive strike or "cluck" to mirror the bow's bite. Additionally, he played high over the scooped neck to achieve a darker, hollow tone and intentionally dropped notes from standard frailing patterns to create syncopated gaps.
  7. In what ways did the Hammons family's economic survival model differ from the agrarian model established by early valley settlers? Answer: Unlike valley settlers who cleared permanent fields, built outbuildings, and raised cash crops or livestock on deeded plots, the Hammons family treated the unmapped wilderness as a shared commons. They sustained themselves by foraging wild ginseng ("sangin'"), setting traplines for furs, hunting game, and cultivating small, temporary patch gardens in forest clearings.
  8. How did industrial clear-cutting by timber companies in the late 19th and early 20th centuries impact wild American ginseng foraging? Answer: Wild American ginseng requires the cool, damp microclimates created by a 70–90% mature hardwood canopy to grow. Total clear-cutting by timber companies exposed the forest floor to direct sunlight, which baked the soil and destroyed the delicate microclimates essential for ginseng propagation.
  9. Why does the Monongahela National Forest affect local county tax revenues, and what federal mechanisms offset this effect? Answer: The Monongahela National Forest covers roughly 60% of Pocahontas County's land mass, rendering that acreage exempt from local property taxes and reducing the municipal tax base. To offset this loss and support county services and school budgets, local government relies on federal Payment in Lieu of Taxes (PILT) funds and Secure Rural Schools (SRS) Act disbursements.
  10. How does the existence of private "inholdings" within federal forest boundaries complicate land access and environmental monitoring? Answer: Private inholdings surrounded by federal land often face century-old right-of-way disputes when landowners cross federal gates via historical timber roads to reach deeded property. Environmental monitoring is similarly complicated because groundwater and hydrogeological flows within the region's karst limestone topography cross property lines, subjecting private parcels to federal watershed oversight.

Section 4: Essay Examination Prompts

Instructions: Select from the following essay prompts for extended critical synthesis. (Answers are not provided.)

  1. Calendar Shift and Cultural Resistance: Analyze the social, religious, and geographic factors that led Appalachian frontier communities to reject the 1752 Gregorian calendar shift. How did the preservation of "Old Christmas" reflect broader patterns of mountain isolation and cultural autonomy?
  2. Comparative Musicology of West Virginia Fiddling: Contrast the musical style, social purpose, and performance mechanics of Melvin Wine with those of the Hammons family. Explain how geographic isolation, economic settings (coal camps vs. remote river basins), and audience expectations shaped their distinct rhythmic structures and bowing techniques.
  3. The Ecological and Economic Shift of Industrial Logging: Discuss the transformation of Pocahontas County during the timber boom of the late 19th and early 20th centuries. Evaluate how the transition from old-growth forest to clear-cut land altered both the natural ecosystem (ginseng, wildlife, watersheds) and the traditional subsistence strategies of deep-woods residents.
  4. Instrumental Adaptation in Old-Time Music: Examine the technical methods used by Dwight Diller to translate the fluid, long-bow fiddle sound of the Hammons family to the percussive clawhammer banjo. Address his use of tone placement, percussive dampening ("clucking"), and rhythmic syncopation.
  5. Federal Land Ownership and Municipal Governance: Evaluate the legal, financial, and administrative impacts of establishing the Monongahela National Forest on Pocahontas County. Consider how federal land acquisition under the Weeks Act of 1911 reshaped local tax structures, public school funding under W. Va. Code § 18-9A-2, and private property rights.

Section 5: Comprehensive Glossary

  • Belsnickel: A traditional Germanic holiday figure clad in furs and wearing a mask or soot-blackened face. Preceding Christmas, the character visited homes to reward obedient children with dried fruit or walnuts and threaten disobedient children with a hickory switch.
  • "Breakin' Up Christmas": A iconic Blue Ridge modal string band tune associated with January 6th, marking the final, rowdy house party at the conclusion of the 12-day Old Christmas visiting period.
  • Clawhammer Banjo: A traditional Appalachian banjo technique involving a rhythmic, downward strike of the fingernail on individual strings followed by a thumb stroke on the drone string, played without fingerpicks.
  • "Cluck" (or Chuck): A specialized clawhammer banjo technique perfected by Dwight Diller, involving a downbeat fingernail strike immediately muted by the fingers or palm to produce a drum-like percussive pop.
  • "Cold Frosty Morning": A signature central West Virginia modal fiddle tune popularized by Melvin Wine, characterized by a transition from an A-minor first section to an A-major second section.
  • Crooked Tune: An old-time musical piece featuring asymmetrical phrasing, dropping or adding beats outside standard 4/4 meter. Common in isolated, unaccompanied listening traditions rather than formal dance playing.
  • Cross-Tuning: The practice of tuning fiddle strings to non-standard open intervals (such as AEAE or DDAD) to generate continuous sympathetic resonance and heavy drones, mirroring traditional bagpipe tonalities.
  • Dwight Diller: A Pocahontas County native, educator, and musician who studied under Burl, Sherman, and Maggie Hammons, adapting their fluid long-bow fiddling into a percussive, rhythmic clawhammer banjo style.
  • Edden Hammons: A legendary 19th-century Pocahontas County fiddler who famously carved his first instrument from a gourd, representing early generations of the Hammons musical lineage.
  • Elderberry Bush (Elderbush): A native Appalachian shrub associated with Old Christmas folklore, believed to spontaneously blossom or shoot up through snow at midnight on January 5th.
  • Hammons Family: A historic West Virginia family of musicians, storytellers, and woodsmen residing in the Williams River basin. Their extreme isolation preserved an ancient, pre-industrial repertoire of Scotch-Irish ballads and crooked fiddle tunes.
  • Inholding: A parcel of privately owned land completely surrounded by federally owned public land, such as a national forest, often giving rise to legal disputes over access rights and easements.
  • Long-Bow Technique: A fiddling method favored by the Hammons family, utilizing long, continuous, syncopated bow strokes to produce a mournful, droning tone driven by left-hand slides and hammer-ons.
  • Melvin Wine (1909–2003): A celebrated central West Virginia traditional fiddler from Braxton County. A recipient of the NEA National Heritage Fellowship and the Vandalia Award, he preserved over 250 traditional tunes performed in an archaic, rhythmic short-bow style.
  • Monongahela National Forest (MNF): A federal reserve established in 1920 following federal timber acquisitions under the Weeks Act of 1911. Covering roughly 60% of Pocahontas County, its creation altered local timber economies, property boundary definitions, and municipal funding structures.
  • Old Christmas: The traditional holiday celebrated on January 6th (Feast of the Epiphany) by Appalachian settlers who rejected the 1752 British calendar transition to the Gregorian system.
  • Payment in Lieu of Taxes (PILT): A federal program allocating funds to local governments to offset tax losses resulting from non-taxable federal land within their municipal boundaries.
  • Play Party: A informal frontier gathering held in cleared log cabins where neighbors danced to live fiddle music during winter slowdowns in farming and timbering.
  • "Sangin'": The traditional Appalachian practice of searching for and harvesting wild American ginseng (Panax quinquefolius) roots in shady hardwood forests to sell or trade for supplies.
  • Saw-Stroke (Shuffle): A rhythmic fiddle bowing technique utilizing short, punchy strokes in the center of the bow. Mastered by Melvin Wine, it created a bright tone suited for square dancing.
  • Secure Rural Schools (SRS) Act: Federal legislation providing financial assistance to timber-dependent counties containing national forest lands, supplementing public school system budgets.
  • "Shooting in the Christmas": A traditional Scotch-Irish holiday custom where settlers fired black powder blasts from long rifles and muskets at dawn on Christmas morning to signal the holiday across isolated valleys.
  • Twelve Ruling Days: The 12 consecutive days between December 25th and January 6th, believed in mountain folklore to predict the weather patterns for the twelve corresponding months of the coming year.
  • Weeks Act of 1911: Federal legislation authorizing the U.S. government to purchase logged-over private lands along headwaters to protect navigable streams, directly leading to the formation of national forests in the eastern United States.
  • Yew Piney Mountain: A traditional West Virginia modal fiddle tune named after high-elevation red spruce forests ("yew pines"), played in open cross-tunings.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 

Historical Primer: Old Christmas Folklore and Mountain Traditions in Early 19th-Century Appalachia

1. The Historical Origins: The Calendar Shift to January 6th

In the early decades of the 19th century, the Greenbrier Valley and Pocahontas County formed a remote, rugged frontier along the spine of the Allegheny Mountains. For early pioneers settling this agrarian landscape, winter holiday observances bore no resemblance to modern commercial celebrations. Instead, the season was governed by agrarian ritualism, seasonal labor suspension, quiet religious devotion, and ancestral folk beliefs.

Central to this seasonal cycle was the observance of "Old Christmas." When Parliament enacted the Calendar Act of 1750, transitioning the British Empire from the Julian to the Gregorian calendar in September 1752, eleven days were excised from the official record. Across the rural Appalachian frontier, isolated settlers routinely rejected this reform. They perceived the "New" December 25th date as an artificial, man-made, and politically motivated imposition by secular authorities. Settlers steadfastly adhered to the traditional Julian date of January 6th—the Feast of the Epiphany—revering it as the true, unalterable holy anniversary of the Nativity. Consequently, December 25th was passed in quiet fasting or routine labor, while January 6th remained the sacred climax of the winter season.

New Christmas (Dec 25th)

Old Christmas (Jan 6th)

Calendar Origin: Introduced via the British Empire's 1752 legislative adoption of the Gregorian calendar, excising eleven days from the Julian year.

Calendar Origin: Rooted in the ancient Julian calendar, directly coinciding with the Feast of the Epiphany on the traditional liturgical calendar.

Settler Perception: Viewed by frontier traditionalists as a man-made, secular, and politically driven alteration of sacred time.

Settler Perception: Revered as the true, divinely ordained, and unalterable holy anniversary of Christ's birth.

Primary Observance Style: Characterized by quiet, solemn fasting, personal prayer, or the continuation of standard winter farm chores.

Primary Observance Style: Celebrated as the true holiday, featuring communal feasting, extended visiting across hollows, and agrarian folklore rituals.

While this calendar schism dictated the timing of sacred reverence, it was the rich synthesis of European folk customs brought by backcountry pioneers that shaped the physical traditions of the holiday.

2. Cultural Synthesis: Scotch-Irish and Germanic Frontier Customs

The early cultural landscape of the Allegheny backcountry was shaped by the intermingling of distinct European lineages. As Scotch-Irish families (such as Lt. John McNeal's kin) and Dutch or Germanic settlers (such as the Van Meters) established homesteads across Pocahontas County and the Greenbrier Valley, their localized traditions merged into complementary frontier customs. These practices served essential social functions: one addressing the outward, topographical realities of mountain isolation, and the other governing inward domestic behavior.

  • Shooting in the Christmas: Serving an outward, community-wide signaling function across expansive mountain topography, this distinctly Scotch-Irish frontier tradition involved men stepping onto log cabin porches or into snowy clearings at dawn on Christmas morning. Firing black powder muskets and long rifles into the crisp morning air produced sharp, echoing blasts that resounded across the hollows, signaling distant neighbors across ridge lines that the holy season had officially arrived.
  • The Belsnickel: Serving an inward, domestic function of moral and behavioral discipline within the home, this Germanic custom centered on a masked or soot-faced figure clad in heavy furs who visited isolated farmsteads in the days preceding Christmas. Acting as an arbiter of youth behavior, the Belsnickel rewarded obedient children with rare luxuries such as walnuts or dried fruit, while issuing solemn warnings and playfully threatening misbehaved children with a hickory switch.

Beyond these visible physical rituals, an unseen layer of sacred mysticism dominated the darkness of Old Christmas Eve.

3. Sacred Mysticism: Supernatural Midnight Beliefs and Hearth Omens

In the deep winter isolation of the 19th-century Alleghenies, the night of January 5th (Old Christmas Eve) was observed as a liminal period when the boundary between the natural and supernatural domains dissolved. Far from mere superstition, these folk beliefs operated as essential psychological coping mechanisms. In a landscape dominated by harsh weather and physical isolation, agrarian ritualism imposed spiritual order on the natural world, channeled existential anxiety regarding sudden winter mortality, and enforced necessary physical rest through strict labor taboos.

The Midnight Miracles

Settlers maintained that at the exact stroke of midnight on Old Christmas Eve, all creation bowed in silent recognition of the Nativity.

"At midnight on Old Christmas Eve, farm animals kneel in their stalls to pray, mountain springs run with wine or blood, and the elderbush sprouts green shoots directly out of the frozen snow."

  • Kneeling and Speaking Livestock: Farm animals—particularly cattle, oxen, and horses—were believed to kneel in their stalls at midnight to offer prayer. However, severe taboos governed this sacred event. Mountain lore explicitly warned that any human who attempted to spy on the livestock and overheard them speaking would suffer a sudden death within the year.
  • Transformation of Water: Mountain springs, creeks, and farm wells were believed to turn briefly into wine or blood at midnight. Drawing or drinking water during this sacred hour was considered a dangerous violation that brought catastrophic bad luck to the household.
  • The Blooming of the Elderbush: Local plant lore held that the elderberry bush—and occasionally the "Rose of Jericho"—would spontaneously sprout green shoots or temporary blossoms directly through the snow at midnight, only to instantly wither back into the frozen soil moments later.

Household Omens & Agricultural Forecasting

The holiday season functioned as an indispensable period for domestic divination and long-range weather prediction for the coming crop year.

"Sweep the hearth flat when the fire dies low; a footprint turned toward the mountain door foretells a chair left empty before the winter snow."

  • The Twelve Ruling Days: The twelve days spanning from December 25th to January 6th were designated as the "ruling days." Mountain families meticulously recorded the atmospheric conditions of each day, believing that each specific day predicted the weather patterns for its corresponding month in the upcoming year.
  • Hearth Ash Footprints: Before retiring on Old Christmas Eve, families smoothed the fireplace ashes perfectly flat across the hearth. If an impression resembling a footprint pointing toward the exterior door appeared in the ashes by morning, it was interpreted as a solemn omen that a family member would die or leave the holler before the next winter.

Labor Taboos

Physical work on January 6th was strictly prohibited by communal custom and spiritual decree.

"To turn the wheel or swing the axe when Old Christmas comes to pass, brings curse upon the summer field and rot within the grass."

Engaging in manual labor—specifically chopping wood, spinning yarn, or plowing—was viewed as a severe sin that invited agricultural failure, illness, or equipment destruction upon the farmstead for the remainder of the year.

The spiritual enforcement of these strict labor taboos created a mandatory pause in daily chores, opening space for community gatherings, winter feasts, and musical house parties.

4. Sustaining the Holler: Winter Feasts and House Parties

The onset of severe winter weather brought a temporary halt to the grueling physical labor of early 19th-century backcountry life, halting field clearing, crop cultivation, and heavy timbering. This seasonal downtime enabled isolated mountain families to convert winter confinement into an extended period of social cohesion and hospitality, operating entirely outside modern commercial supply networks.

  1. The Log Home "Play Party": Families cleared heavy furniture out of their small log cabin parlors to host neighborhood house parties. Guided by the acoustic driving rhythm of traditional fiddling, revelers performed reels and square dances that frequently lasted until dawn, maintaining communal bonds through severe winter weather.
  2. The Frontier Harvest Meal: Relying entirely on autumn preservation and hunting skills, the Old Christmas table represented the pinnacle of seasonal self-reliance. Tables were laden with wild game (venison, bear, and wild turkey), salt-cured pork, dried beans, preserved apples, and baked cornmeal dishes.

As families gathered in crowded log cabins for these winter house parties, the social atmosphere was sustained by a specialized winter repertoire of mountain music.

5. The Soundscape of Old Christmas: Mountain Fiddles and Folk Ballads

The musical repertoire of the Old Christmas season combined haunting modal melodies, ancient oral ballads, and driving dance tunes. Preserved by early tradition-bearers—such as the Hammons family of Pocahontas County and central West Virginia fiddler Melvin Wine—this body of music reflected both the solitary quiet of a snowy mountain holler and the rowdy climax of seasonal house parties.

Ethnomusicologically, this music relied heavily on alternate fiddle tunings (cross-tuning) to produce droning, pipe-like sympathetic resonances that echoed the Scotch-Irish heritage of early settlers. Stylistically, performance practice varied across geographical pockets: while central West Virginia fiddlers like Melvin Wine utilized a rhythmic, short-bowing "saw-stroke" shuffle bow style to propel square dancers, isolated eastern Allegheny players like Burl, Sherman, and Lee Hammons favored a fluid long-bow technique. The Hammons style prioritized continuous, ghostly drones, intricate left-hand slides, and asymmetrical ("crooked") phrasing suited for intimate parlor listening rather than strict dance meters.

Song/Ballad Title

Musical & Stylistic Features

Cultural Meaning / Old Christmas Connection

"Old Christmas Morning" / "Christmas Morning"

Driven by alternate, cross-tuned fiddle setups (AEAE or DDAD); recorded by French Carpenter ("Old Christmas Morning") and Sherman and Lee Hammons ("Christmas Morning").

Utilizes droning, pipe-like sympathetic resonance to capture the dark, quiet atmosphere of a remote January holler on Old Christmas.

"Breakin' Up Christmas"

High-energy breakdown driven by cross-tuned fiddle and clawhammer banjo rhythm; features called-out traditional vocal couplets.

Marks the absolute climax and final, rowdiest house party of the 12-day Old Christmas season on the night of January 6th.

"Cold Frosty Morning"

Archaic modal tune preserved by Melvin Wine; shifts dramatically from a melancholic A-minor section to a driving A-major breakdown.

Musically evokes the stark, biting winter landscape of the Allegheny Mountains through shifting modal tonality.

"The Cherry Tree Carol"

Ancient modal ballad preserved through pure oral transmission; performed with simple acoustic drone or as unaccompanied singing.

Recounts an apocryphal story of a cherry tree bowing down to Mary, directly echoing mountain legends of elderbushes bowing and blooming in the midnight snow.

The end-of-season party tune "Breakin' Up Christmas" served as the definitive structural marker for the end of the holiday period. As the cross-tuned string band reached its high-energy crescendo on the night of January 6th, musicians and dancers shouted its traditional lines over the sound of the instruments:

"Hooray Jake, Hooray John, Breakin' up Christmas all night long. Santa Claus come, done and gone, Breaking up Christmas right straight along."

Through the acoustic ring of cross-tuned fiddles, sacred hearthside omens, and strict adherence to the older calendar, the traditions of Old Christmas served as a vital cultural lifeline for early 19th-century Appalachian pioneers, sustaining community cohesion and spiritual resilience through the deep winter of the frontier.

 

No comments:

Post a Comment

The Court Records

  The historical records detail several major military expeditions and campaigns that traversed the mountain gaps, river crossings, and turn...

Shaker Posts