Your note captures a vivid intersection of Appalachian vernacular, early 20th-century logging camp culture, and traveling stage entertainment. Here is additional historical and linguistic context to support your research.
Linguistic & Folkloric Context
- "Shaking a foot" in American vernacular: The idiom was widespread across 19th- and early 20th-century Southern and Appalachian speech, referring specifically to lively, percussive solo or partner dancing. It appears in classic American folk songs—most famously in Buffalo Gals ("I thought that I might have a chance / To shake a foot with her")—as well as in Appalachian regional literature of the era, such as John Fox Jr.'s The Heart of the Hills ("you two just git out thar an' shake a foot!").
- Clogging vs. flatfooting: In 1907, "clog dancing" in a newspaper dispatch typically referred to hard-soled, rhythmic step dancing (a precursor to modern clogging and tap, closely related to buck dancing and flatfooting). In Appalachian communities, these styles were performed improvisationally to fiddle and banjo tunes, with rapid, close-to-the-floor footwork.
Historical Setting: Richwood & Cranberry Camp (1907)
- The timber boom: Incorporated in 1901 as a sawmill town for the Cherry River Boom and Lumber Company, Richwood, West Virginia was in the middle of its peak logging boom by June 1907.
- Camp life: The lumber company operated temporary logging camps—such as those along the Cranberry River—complete with bunkhouses, blacksmiths, and cookhouses, which were dismantled and moved once a tract was "sawed out". Because these camps were remote and populated by both single timber workers and families, local newspapers regularly ran "camp news" dispatches chronicling visitors, mishaps, and social gatherings.
Entertainers in the Logging Camps
- Vaudeville and vernacular crossover: Describing Rastus McCoy as both a clog dancer and contortionist places him squarely in the tradition of early 1900s regional variety performers—artists who worked small-town theaters, medicine shows, and lumber or coal camps.
- Informal instruction: Having a visiting stage performer return to camp to teach "local youngsters" highlights how rural Appalachian dance traditions were not purely isolated; they were regularly cross-pollinated by traveling professionals who brought stage steps (like buck-and-wing or precision clogging) into mountain communities.While Appalachian flatfooting, buck dancing, and early 1900s clog dancing all share roots in percussive, rhythmic footwork—and frequently blended together in mountain communities—they differed sharply in foot elevation, rhythmic phrasing, footwear, and performance setting.Understanding the distinction is especially important for 1907 sources like the Cranberry camp dispatch, because the term "clog dancing" meant something very different in 1907 than it does today.
Feature Appalachian Flatfooting Buck Dancing Early 1900s Clog Dancing Primary Roots Scots-Irish, English, Cherokee, and African American vernacular fusion African American rhythmic traditions blended with European step dancing British (Lancashire) & Irish clog traditions adapted for American vaudeville Foot Elevation Very low; feet barely leave the floor (gliding, sliding, brushing) Moderate to high; distinct knee lift and energetic heel-toe drops High precision; crisp, deliberate lifts and sharp ankle work Rhythm & Feel Smooth, driving, continuous; locked tightly to the fiddle/banjo melody Heavy syncopation, accents, and off-beat "chugs" or stamps Metronomic, crisp, and theatrical; built around showcase routines Footwear Everyday leather-soled work or dress shoes (no metal taps) Hard-soled leather shoes (occasionally with metal plates on stage) Wooden-soled clogs or hard-soled stage shoes (precursor to tap) Typical Setting Front porches, kitchens, barn dances, and informal community gatherings Juke joints, informal gatherings, minstrel shows, and early vaudeville Theaters, variety stages, medicine shows, and traveling camp exhibitions Appalachian Flatfooting
Flatfooting is the quietest and most grounded of the three styles. The dancer keeps the feet close to the floorboards—often sliding, shuffling, and brushing the leather sole rather than stomping—while maintaining a relaxed, upright, and largely still upper body.- Improvisational nature: There are no fixed routines or unison choreography; a dancer responds directly to the fiddle or banjo tune.
- Acoustic role: Because it was danced in everyday leather shoes on wooden floors, the dancer essentially acted as a subtle percussion instrument accompanying the string band.
Buck Dancing
Buck dancing shares the improvisational spirit of flatfooting—and in many parts of Appalachia, the two terms were used interchangeably—but stylistically it is more athletic, louder, and more heavily syncopated.- Heavier accents: Dancers lift their knees higher and strike the floor more forcefully with the heel and toe, creating sharper rhythmic contrasts and off-beat accents.
- The "Buck-and-Wing": By the late 1800s and early 1900s, buck dancing had crossed heavily into professional theater as the buck-and-wing, adding flashy, high-energy kicks and side-flings ("wings") that eventually evolved into modern tap dancing.
Early 1900s Clog Dancing (The 1907 Context)
When the June 7, 1907 dispatch described Rastus McCoy as a "clog dancer and contortionist," it was not referring to modern Appalachian team clogging—which did not crystallize until the late 1920s and 1930s (most famously through Bascom Lamar Lunsford's Mountain Dance and Folk Festival in Asheville, North Carolina, and Sam Queen's Soco Gap Cloggers).- Stage clogging: In 1907, "clog dancing" meant precision stage step dancing, descended from 19th-century Lancashire and Irish wooden-soled clog dancing and popularized across America by vaudeville and variety performers.
- Why it mattered in logging camps: Traveling entertainers like McCoy brought formal stage steps, crisp rhythmic routines, and showmanship into remote timber camps. When he taught "foot shaking" to the Cranberry camp youngsters, he was passing along a hybrid of professional stage technique and regional mountain vernacular—exactly the kind of cross-pollination that later gave rise to modern Appalachian clogging.
Watching these styles in motion makes the differences in knee lift, foot height, and rhythmic phrasing immediately clear.

No comments:
Post a Comment