Search This Blog

Clogging vs. Flatfooting

 


Your note captures a vivid intersection of Appalachian vernacular, early 20th-century logging camp culture, and traveling stage entertainment. Here is additional historical and linguistic context to support your research.

Linguistic & Folkloric Context

  • "Shaking a foot" in American vernacular: The idiom was widespread across 19th- and early 20th-century Southern and Appalachian speech, referring specifically to lively, percussive solo or partner dancing. It appears in classic American folk songs—most famously in Buffalo Gals ("I thought that I might have a chance / To shake a foot with her")—as well as in Appalachian regional literature of the era, such as John Fox Jr.'s The Heart of the Hills ("you two just git out thar an' shake a foot!").

  • Clogging vs. flatfooting: In 1907, "clog dancing" in a newspaper dispatch typically referred to hard-soled, rhythmic step dancing (a precursor to modern clogging and tap, closely related to buck dancing and flatfooting). In Appalachian communities, these styles were performed improvisationally to fiddle and banjo tunes, with rapid, close-to-the-floor footwork.

Historical Setting: Richwood & Cranberry Camp (1907)

  • The timber boom: Incorporated in 1901 as a sawmill town for the Cherry River Boom and Lumber Company, Richwood, West Virginia was in the middle of its peak logging boom by June 1907.

  • Camp life: The lumber company operated temporary logging camps—such as those along the Cranberry River—complete with bunkhouses, blacksmiths, and cookhouses, which were dismantled and moved once a tract was "sawed out". Because these camps were remote and populated by both single timber workers and families, local newspapers regularly ran "camp news" dispatches chronicling visitors, mishaps, and social gatherings.

Entertainers in the Logging Camps

  • Vaudeville and vernacular crossover: Describing Rastus McCoy as both a clog dancer and contortionist places him squarely in the tradition of early 1900s regional variety performers—artists who worked small-town theaters, medicine shows, and lumber or coal camps.

  • Informal instruction: Having a visiting stage performer return to camp to teach "local youngsters" highlights how rural Appalachian dance traditions were not purely isolated; they were regularly cross-pollinated by traveling professionals who brought stage steps (like buck-and-wing or precision clogging) into mountain communities.
     
    While Appalachian flatfooting, buck dancing, and early 1900s clog dancing all share roots in percussive, rhythmic footwork—and frequently blended together in mountain communities—they differed sharply in foot elevation, rhythmic phrasing, footwear, and performance setting.

    Understanding the distinction is especially important for 1907 sources like the Cranberry camp dispatch, because the term "clog dancing" meant something very different in 1907 than it does today.

    FeatureAppalachian FlatfootingBuck DancingEarly 1900s Clog Dancing
    Primary RootsScots-Irish, English, Cherokee, and African American vernacular fusionAfrican American rhythmic traditions blended with European step dancingBritish (Lancashire) & Irish clog traditions adapted for American vaudeville
    Foot ElevationVery low; feet barely leave the floor (gliding, sliding, brushing)Moderate to high; distinct knee lift and energetic heel-toe dropsHigh precision; crisp, deliberate lifts and sharp ankle work
    Rhythm & FeelSmooth, driving, continuous; locked tightly to the fiddle/banjo melodyHeavy syncopation, accents, and off-beat "chugs" or stampsMetronomic, crisp, and theatrical; built around showcase routines
    FootwearEveryday leather-soled work or dress shoes (no metal taps)Hard-soled leather shoes (occasionally with metal plates on stage)Wooden-soled clogs or hard-soled stage shoes (precursor to tap)
    Typical SettingFront porches, kitchens, barn dances, and informal community gatheringsJuke joints, informal gatherings, minstrel shows, and early vaudevilleTheaters, variety stages, medicine shows, and traveling camp exhibitions

    Appalachian Flatfooting

    Flatfooting is the quietest and most grounded of the three styles. The dancer keeps the feet close to the floorboards—often sliding, shuffling, and brushing the leather sole rather than stomping—while maintaining a relaxed, upright, and largely still upper body.

    • Improvisational nature: There are no fixed routines or unison choreography; a dancer responds directly to the fiddle or banjo tune.

    • Acoustic role: Because it was danced in everyday leather shoes on wooden floors, the dancer essentially acted as a subtle percussion instrument accompanying the string band.

    Buck Dancing

    Buck dancing shares the improvisational spirit of flatfooting—and in many parts of Appalachia, the two terms were used interchangeably—but stylistically it is more athletic, louder, and more heavily syncopated.

    • Heavier accents: Dancers lift their knees higher and strike the floor more forcefully with the heel and toe, creating sharper rhythmic contrasts and off-beat accents.

    • The "Buck-and-Wing": By the late 1800s and early 1900s, buck dancing had crossed heavily into professional theater as the buck-and-wing, adding flashy, high-energy kicks and side-flings ("wings") that eventually evolved into modern tap dancing.

    Early 1900s Clog Dancing (The 1907 Context)

    When the June 7, 1907 dispatch described Rastus McCoy as a "clog dancer and contortionist," it was not referring to modern Appalachian team clogging—which did not crystallize until the late 1920s and 1930s (most famously through Bascom Lamar Lunsford's Mountain Dance and Folk Festival in Asheville, North Carolina, and Sam Queen's Soco Gap Cloggers).

    • Stage clogging: In 1907, "clog dancing" meant precision stage step dancing, descended from 19th-century Lancashire and Irish wooden-soled clog dancing and popularized across America by vaudeville and variety performers.

    • Why it mattered in logging camps: Traveling entertainers like McCoy brought formal stage steps, crisp rhythmic routines, and showmanship into remote timber camps. When he taught "foot shaking" to the Cranberry camp youngsters, he was passing along a hybrid of professional stage technique and regional mountain vernacular—exactly the kind of cross-pollination that later gave rise to modern Appalachian clogging.

    Watching these styles in motion makes the differences in knee lift, foot height, and rhythmic phrasing immediately clear.

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    The shift from early 1900s solo flatfooting and stage clogging to modern Appalachian team clogging happened because two previously separate traditions collided on a competitive stage in the late 1920s.

    In 1907—the era of Rastus McCoy at Cranberry Camp—mountain dancing was split into two distinct worlds: social group square dancing (where couples glided smoothly through called figures without heavy footwork) and solo percussive dancing (flatfooting, buck dancing, and traveling vaudeville clog dancing). Over the next three decades, festivals, competition, and a royal visit fused them into a single art form.

    The Two Separate Traditions
    Early 1900s
    Appalachian communities danced "smooth" mountain square dances in big circles at home gatherings, while percussive flatfooting and buck dancing remained strictly solo, improvisational displays. Meanwhile, traveling entertainers brought British-derived stage clogging steps into lumber camps and small-town theaters.

    The Stage Competition Catalyst
    1928
    Folklorist and musician Bascom Lamar Lunsford founded the Mountain Dance and Folk Festival in Asheville, North Carolina, to preserve mountain music and dance. By placing local square dance teams on stage to compete for prizes, Lunsford inadvertently changed the tradition—teams began adding flashier, louder footwork to win over judges and audiences.

    The Soco Gap Fusion
    1930s
    Led by Sam Queen of Maggie Valley, North Carolina (known as "the dancingest man in the land"), the Soco Gap Square Dance Team revolutionized the Asheville competitions—winning in 1937 by having every dancer freestyle flatfoot and buck dance continuously while executing traditional square dance figures.

    The White House & the Name 'Clogging'
    1939
    Lunsford and Sam Queen's Soco Gap Dancers were invited to the White House to perform for King George VI and Queen Elizabeth. Queen Elizabeth remarked that the rhythmic footwork reminded her of British clog dancing; the press picked up the label, permanently rebranding Appalachian percussive square dancing as "clogging".

    Metal Taps & Precision Choreography
    1950s–1970s
    As string bands began using electrical amplification in the 1950s, dancers added metal taps to both toes and heels (and later double "jingle" taps) so their steps could still be heard. Teams gradually shifted from individualized freestyle footwork to synchronized precision clogging, prompting traditionalists at the Mountain Dance and Folk Festival to ban precision routines in 1972 to protect the older freestyle team style.

    How the Style Actually Transformed

    As dance historian Phil Jamison observed in his work on Appalachian dance, Lunsford set out to preserve mountain square dancing but ended up creating a new genre altogether. Three specific changes drove that evolution:

    • From smooth gliding to continuous percussion: Traditional mountain square dancers used a smooth, gliding "shuffle" step to move quickly through figures called by a caller. When teams like Soco Gap grafted flatfooting and buck-dance steps onto those figures, the entire square became a percussive ensemble.

    • Freestyle first, precision later: In the 1920s and 1930s, team clogging was still freestyle—every dancer moved through the same square-dance patterns in unison, but each individual improvised their own footwork. Synchronized "precision clogging" (where an entire line executes identical, choreographed steps on the exact same beat) did not emerge until decades later.

    • Footwear followed volume: Through the 1930s, most Appalachian team dancers still wore everyday leather-soled shoes, occasionally fitted with a simple heel plate. The loud, metallic double-tap sound associated with modern clogging came in the mid-1950s as a practical response to amplified music and larger festival stages.

    Watching traditional Appalachian freestyle team clogging shows how the 1930s Soco Gap fusion still looks today: called square-dance figures paired with individualized, percussive footwork.

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
     
    Far from being an isolated musical enclave, late 19th- and early 20th-century Appalachia was a cultural crossroads. As logging railroads and coal spurs pushed into remote valleys—bringing cash wages and dense timber camps like those along the Cranberry River—traveling minstrel troupes, medicine shows, and vaudeville performers followed the tracks, permanently reshaping mountain music and dance.

    How They Reached the Mountains

    Before radio arrived in the 1920s, traveling shows were the primary link between rural Appalachia and national popular culture.

    • Medicine shows: Troupes rolled into county seats, mill towns, and logging camps offering free music, comedy, and dancing to draw a crowd, then pitched patent tonics and liniments between acts.

    • Small-town vaudeville & tent shows: Timber boomtowns like Richwood quickly built opera houses and community halls that booked regional variety acts—singers, banjo players, clog dancers, and contortionists—on circuits stretching across West Virginia, Virginia, and Kentucky.

    • Two-way exchange: Performers didn't just play and leave; they lodged in towns and camps, swapped tunes with local fiddlers, and—like Rastus McCoy teaching "foot shaking" at Cranberry Camp—passed stage techniques directly to local youth.

    Influence on Appalachian Music

    Many elements now treated as "pure" Appalachian folk music were actually forged in the overlap between mountain porches and traveling stages.

    Area of ImpactWhat Traveling Shows IntroducedLasting Effect in Appalachia
    RepertoireMinstrel hits, Tin Pan Alley novelty songs, and ragtime numbersStage songs like Buffalo Gals, Old Dan Tucker, Turkey in the Straw, and Arkansas Traveler became core Appalachian fiddle and banjo standards.
    InstrumentsStandardized 5-string banjos, guitars, mandolins, and Hawaiian steel guitarsMinstrel performers helped spread the 5-string banjo—originally an African American folk instrument—widely across rural white mountain communities in the mid-to-late 1800s.
    ShowmanshipBanjo tricks, slapstick comedy, and dramatic vocal deliveryEarly country and old-time stars carried medicine-show stagecraft directly to the radio and Grand Ole Opry.
    Blues & RagtimeSyncopated rhythms, blue notes, and "yodeling" or vocal breaksBlended with Scots-Irish balladry to create the driving, syncopated sound of early 20th-century old-time string bands.
    Several foundational figures of early country and Appalachian music learned their craft directly on these circuits. Uncle Dave Macon honed his rapid-fire banjo tricks and comedic patter in vaudeville theaters before becoming the Grand Ole Opry's first major star, while Roy Acuff got his start playing fiddle and doing blackface and comedy routines in Dr. Hauer's Medicine Show across East Tennessee and the surrounding mountains.

    Influence on Appalachian Dance

    Traveling dancers introduced flash, volume, and precision to a mountain tradition that had historically been quieter and more restrained.

    • Buck-and-wing meets flatfooting: Traditional Appalachian flatfooting stayed close to the floor in everyday leather shoes. Vaudeville and minstrel dancers brought the high-energy buck-and-wing (featuring higher knee lifts, side kicks, and loud heel-toe strikes) and crisp stage clogging, which local dancers eagerly absorbed and adapted.

    • Novelty and acrobatics: Variety performers frequently paired percussive dancing with physical spectacle—contortion, cane work, or comic pratfalls—turning solo step dancing into a showcase event rather than just a casual accompaniment to a fiddle tune.

    • Standardizing steps: While mountain flatfooting was purely improvisational, stage dancers performed repeatable, named routines. Teaching those steps in lumber camps and rural towns created a shared vocabulary of rhythmic footwork that later fed into the competitive clogging movement of the 1920s and 1930s.

    Challenging the Myth of Isolation

    When British folklorist Cecil Sharp toured Appalachia between 1916 and 1918 collecting centuries-old English and Scottish ballads, he famously overlooked—or deliberately excluded—the ragtime, blues, and vaudeville numbers the exact same mountain families were singing and playing. In reality, Appalachian musicians in 1907 were omnivorous: they preserved ancient unaccompanied ballads right alongside the latest clog steps and comedy songs brought into camp by traveling entertainers.

    These archival recordings and demonstrations illustrate how vaudeville showmanship and medicine-show rhythms blended directly into Appalachian old-time music and dance.
     
    While western North Carolina's dance scene in the late 1920s and 1930s became increasingly stage-oriented, competitive, and fused—blending percussive footwork directly into square dance teams—West Virginia's traditions remained participatory, community-centered, and structurally separate.

    In West Virginia, you flatfooted solo (or in informal face-offs) and glided smoothly through square dances as a community social event; in western North Carolina, festival competitions merged the two into an athletic team showcase.

    FeatureWest Virginia TraditionsWestern North Carolina Clogging Movement
    Primary SettingHome frolics, community halls, logging/coal camps, and local street dancesFestival stages, civic competitions (Asheville), and touring exhibitions
    Squares vs. Step DanceKept largely distinct: smooth-stepping squares for groups, flatfooting for soloistsFused together: entire square dance teams continuously clogged through called figures
    Square Dance FormatBoth four-couple square sets (visiting-couple style) and big circle sets, paired with waltzes and two-stepsPredominantly big circle ("running set") formations adapted for stage visibility
    Footwork StyleLow, grounded, improvisational flatfooting with no standardized steps; often moving backwardHigher knee lifts, louder accents, standardized shuffle patterns, and eventually choreographed team routines
    Cultural GoalSocial inclusion—everyone from children to elders could step onto the floor and dance togetherRegional preservation paired with competition, showmanship, and public tourism

    Solo Flatfooting Stayed Grounded and Improvisational

    In West Virginia, percussive step dancing resisted the pull toward team choreography and standardized "basic steps." As West Virginia fiddler, square dance caller, and folklorist Mack Samples noted in The West Virginia Encyclopedia, flatfooting remained a strictly solo, improvisational expression driven by the hard drive of a fiddle.

    • Economy of motion: Unlike North Carolina cloggers—who developed a distinct, bouncy shuffle step and higher leg lifts to project to festival audiences—old-time West Virginia flatfooters kept both feet close to the floorboards with minimal upper-body movement.

    • Distinct movement patterns: Samples documented that traditional West Virginia flatfooters had no universally accepted steps and frequently danced backward across the floor, focusing entirely on rhythmic sound rather than visual spectacle. As one elderly West Virginia dancer summed it up: "The music just goes in your ear, down through your soul, and comes out through your feet".

    Square Dancing Remained a Smooth Social Gathering

    Whereas Sam Queen's Soco Gap Dancers in Maggie Valley turned the square dance into a high-energy percussive team sport, West Virginia callers and dancers preserved square dancing as an accessible social pastime where the caller's rhyming patter guided the whole room.

    • Two durable formats: Depending on the county and the size of the room, West Virginians danced either four-couple square sets (using a visiting-couple structure where one couple worked its way around the set) or mountain "big circle" dances, where any number of couples formed a large ring and broke into two-couple figures. Both formats remained staples across the West Virginia highlands, including long-running community dances in Pocahontas County communities like Marlinton, Dunmore, and Cass.

    • Early recorded proof: West Virginia's traditional calling style was captured right at the moment North Carolina's clogging movement was beginning—most notably on the 1928 78-rpm recordings of the Kessinger Brothers featuring Kanawha Valley caller Ernest Legg, whose brisk, rhythmic calls ("Ladies do and the gents you know...") reflected everyday community dance floors rather than staged competitions.

    • Mixed dance evenings: Traditional West Virginia dances routinely alternated squares with "round dances"—waltzes and two-steps—keeping the emphasis on social partnering rather than percussive athleticism.

    Different Cultural Catalysts

    The divergence came down to institutional momentum. Western North Carolina had Bascom Lamar Lunsford's Mountain Dance and Folk Festival (founded 1928) and the 1939 White House performance for the British royals, which gave team clogging a name, a competitive circuit, and national press.

    West Virginia had no equivalent competitive dance stage in the 1920s and 1930s. Its dance traditions stayed anchored in rural kitchens, schoolhouses, and timber or coal communities well into the mid-20th century—a pattern that aligns directly with the 1907 Cranberry logging camp dispatch, where Rastus McCoy's lessons in "foot shaking" treated percussive step dancing as an individual showcase skill practiced alongside, rather than fused into, community social dances.

    Watching traditional West Virginia flatfooting and community square dancing highlights that low-to-the-floor economy of motion and relaxed, participatory pace.

     

     
     
     

No comments:

Post a Comment

1972

  Unfiltered, Raw, and Upside Down: 5 Mind-Blowing Takeaways from a 1972 High School Yearbook Have you ever wondered what teenage life was r...

Shaker Posts