Across both the 18th-century border wars and the Civil War raids, surviving in the Allegheny wilderness often depended on knowing every hollow tree, ravine, swamp, and farm outbuilding [84–85, 113–116, 623]. Local sketches preserve several remarkable accounts of how settlers, scouts, and families concealed themselves, their livestock, and their possessions:
1. Hollow Trees, Logs, and Caves
The primeval forests of the Greenbrier Valley featured massive timber with cavities large enough to shelter men and families [113–116, 221–222]:
- The Sycamore Cone and Sewell’s Cave: When pioneer Stephen Sewall disagreed over religion with Jacob Marlin at Marlin’s Bottom in 1750–1751, he relocated across the slough into a giant hollow sycamore tree whose base resembled an Indian tepee and could comfortably shelter five or six people [113–115]. Seeking still greater seclusion from theological debate, Sewall subsequently retreated eight miles up the mountain to a limestone cave at the head of Sewell Run near Marvin.
- The Hollow Tree on Keeney’s Knob: Following the 1763 massacre at the Clendennin homestead in the Greenbrier Valley, Mrs. Clendennin was marched away with other captives [173–176]. As the party began climbing Keeney's Knob, she slipped unnoticed into a dense laurel thicket and crawled inside a hollow tree, evading detection even when a warrior murdered her crying infant to lure her out. She remained in the tree until after dark, then made her ten-mile trek back through the woods to her ruined home [176–177].
- The Buckeye "Boy's Log": When pioneer Joshua Buckley settled at the mouth of Swago Creek, frequent Indian alarms forced the family to split up [219–222]. While the women and young children were sent south to the stockade fort at Millpoint, the older boys were left behind to guard the cattle and crops, given strict instructions to refugee inside a designated hollow log whenever raiding parties passed along the trail [221–222].
2. Hemp Patches, Swamps, and Ravine Feints
When open flight was impossible, fleeing scouts and settlers relied on natural cover to throw pursuers off the scent [263–264, 623, 659–660]:
- Greenbrier Ben in the Burning Hemp Patch: When Indians raided and ransacked Major Jacob Warwick’s row of cabins at Clover Lick, an older servant named Sam fled deep into the woods, but young Greenbrier Ben dove into a nearby hemp patch. The hemp stood so close to the cabins that when the warriors torched the buildings, Ben had to lie motionless while the radiant heat made his buckskin breeches scorchingly hot [263–264]. From this hiding spot, he watched the warriors pluck live roosters and shove the farm's pioneer wagon into the flames [263–264].
- "Mad Ann" Bailey’s Swamp Refuge: The eccentric scout and express courier Ann Bailey (who frequently rode her pony "Liverpool" through the mountains carrying ammunition to Point Pleasant) outwitted pursuing warriors by submerging herself in a deep swamp overnight, lying in the water until morning so dogs and scouts lost her scent entirely [620–623].
- Swago Bill's Ravine Dodge: While carrying his plow through the woods near Buckeye, William "Swago Bill" Ewing stumbled upon three Indians ambushed behind a log [658–659]. When their damp powder caused their rifles to misfire, Ewing dropped the plow and sprinted over a hill into a gully [659–660]. Instead of continuing straight, he abruptly darted up a side ravine and crouched down, watching with relief as his pursuers trotted blindly past down the main draw.
3. Domestic Hiding Places during Civil War Raids
During the Civil War, when regular troops and irregular bushwhackers swept through the county, domestic ingenuity was required to save food and records [340–342, 636–637]:
- The Hoop-Skirt Sugar Stash: When General Averell’s freezing, starving troops straggled across the Little Levels during their December 1863 retreat, foraging soldiers ransacked farmhouses for any scrap of bacon or grease [636–638]. In one raided home, a prized store of maple sugar was tucked beneath a parlor lounge; the lady of the house and three visiting neighbor girls sat in a row on the couch, spreading their wide skirts over the edge to completely shield the stash from the searching soldiers.
- The Mountain Cabin Refuge: After hiding the county records in a buckwheat rick for three weeks during Averell’s Covington raid, Clerk William Curry and a farm hand named Andy Daugherty loaded the archives and hauled them four miles deeper into the mountains to an isolated cabin occupied only by the wife and young daughter of an absent Confederate soldier [340–341]. There the public records lay hidden and undisturbed for nearly two full years [341–342].
4. The High Ridge Strategy
Beyond specific hiding spots, the early pioneers adopted a universal geographic rule for evading ambuscades: they abandoned stream bottoms in favor of high mountain crests [84–85]. The original settler paths to Clover Lick, Droop Mountain, and Huntersville avoided hollows, laurels, and creek beds—where a traveler could easily be hemmed in—and blazed their trails along narrow, windswept ridge-tops, where it was possible to spot an ambush from afar or break out down either slope if attacked [84–85, 249–250].
🧗 We could investigate the early pioneer stockades and blockhouses where these scattered families gathered during major alarms, like the fort at Millpoint or the Warwick fort on Deer Creek.
To defend against Indian raids in the mountain valleys, pioneer settlers relied on a coordinated system of community fortifications, roving rangers, scouting networks, terrain tactics, and emergency concealment:
1. Community Stockades and Blockhouses
Because families lived scattered across isolated clearings, neighborhood forts served as their primary defense:
- A Tradition of Fortification: Following General Braddock’s defeat in 1754, pioneer Presbyterian minister Dr. John Craig opposed retreating east of the mountains and insisted on fortifying the frontier, spending one-third of his estate to build community defenses—a practice his parishioners brought directly into the Greenbrier Valley.
- Refuge Stockades: Settlers established central fortified strongholds throughout the valleys, such as the fort at Millpoint on the knoll near Stamping Creek, John Warwick’s Fort on Deer Creek, and James Warwick’s Fort in Tygart’s Valley. Specialists like Jacob Kinnison were specifically sought after for their skill in planning and constructing these forts.
- Evacuation Protocols: Whenever an alarm sounded, women and young children were immediately evacuated to the nearest stockade. For example, when alarms reached Buckeye, Joshua Buckley sent his wife and small children down to the fort at Millpoint while the older boys stayed behind to protect crops and livestock.
2. Roving Rangers and Scout Networks
Remote from colonial garrisons, the settlers defended the frontier through volunteer patrols and vigilant scouting:
- Armed Companies of Rangers: Local companies of "Rangers," "Independents," or "Volunteers"—led by frontier captains like the Lewises, McClenachans, Prestons, Dickinsons, Dunlaps, and Moffetts—armed and equipped themselves at their own expense to patrol the wilderness and disperse hostile parties.
- Tracking Indian Signs: Experienced hunters like Moses Moore, Richard Hill, and Jacob Warwick constantly monitored the woods for enemy trails. Moore closely watched narrow river crossings along the upper Greenbrier where warriors vaulted across on poles, noting which bank the vaulting pole had been left on to anticipate their movements.
- Express Messengers: When raiding parties struck, couriers ran through the mountains to warn neighboring homesteads. During the Drinnon raid near Stony Creek, an enslaved servant named Nathan slipped out under cover of darkness, crossing Marlin Mountain and Buckley Mountain to alert the garrison at Millpoint.
3. Ridge-Top Travel and Ambush Tactics
The physical terrain heavily shaped defensive and offensive strategies:
- Abandoning the Valleys: Settlers quickly learned that travelling along stream bottoms and valley floors was dangerous because a party could be easily trapped against hillsides or caught in an ambuscade. Consequently, pioneers blazed their trails along the crests of leading ridges and summits, where they had a commanding view of the surrounding country and could break out down either slope if attacked.
- Mountain Ambushes: When warned of approaching raiding parties, settlers organized counter-ambushes on high ground. Warned by a scout from Millboro that 40 to 50 Shawnee warriors were returning by way of Clover Lick, Major Jacob Warwick and about twenty riflemen waited in ambush on the crest of the mountain south of the lick, delivering a devastating volley that turned the raiding party back toward Elkwater.
4. Barricades, Bluffs, and Natural Hideaways
When cut off from the main forts, settlers relied on home barricades or quick-thinking concealment:
- Barricaded Cabins: Families barred heavy cabin doors and defended their homes from within. When John Wilson’s home on Jackson’s River was attacked, the women took refuge inside, heavily barricaded the doors, and repulsed the warriors.
- Fort Bluffs: At James Warwick's fort in Tygart's Valley, when the men rushed out to relieve neighboring settlers and left only three women, an enslaved couple, and small children behind, an aunt gave loud, booming commands to imaginary squads of riflemen, bluffing the scouts outside into believing the blockhouse was heavily manned.
- Hollow Trees and Ravines: Settlers improvised natural hiding places:
- Joshua Buckley instructed his sons to dive into a specific hollow log if warriors passed their fields.
- Mrs. Clendennin slipped away from her captors and concealed herself inside a hollow tree on Keeney’s Knob.
- "Swago Bill" Ewing, ambushed by warriors with damp powder near Buckeye, dropped his plow, sprinted over a knoll into a gully, and darted up a side ravine, watching his pursuers run past down the main draw.
- Young Greenbrier Ben hid in a dense hemp patch beside the burning cabins at Clover Lick, while scout Ann Bailey submerged herself in a swamp overnight to throw pursuing trackers off her trail.
The episode of Major Jacob Warwick shooting the warrior from the tree is one of the most vividly remembered frontier traditions of upper Pocahontas County.
Local histories preserve several key details regarding the setting, the strategic stakes, and Warwick’s personal reflections on that single combat:
1. The Setting: Warwick’s Fort on Deer Creek
The encounter took place on the pioneer settlement of John Warwick, situated on Deer Creek near Greenbank (later the property of Peter H. and John R. Warwick).
- A Contentious Stronghold: Because the fort was located so close to Clover Lick—a hunting and fishing ground held in high esteem by the Shawnee and allied tribes—the construction of a fortified settlers' stockade there was viewed as a major provocation.
- Frequent Raids: The garrison and surrounding farmsteads were in a state of nearly constant vigilance, with raiding bands repeatedly attempting to scout or surprise the post.
2. The Reconnaissance and the Fatal Shot
- The Scout in the Tree: While Warwick’s Fort was on alert, an Indian scout climbed high into the branches of a lofty tree overlooking the stockade. From this vantage point, the warrior was able to look down inside the perimeter walls to observe the layout, count the defenders, and direct an impending assault.
- Interfering with the Attack: Major Jacob Warwick spotted the observer, took aim with his mountain rifle, and shot him out of the branches. Historian William T. Price notes that the death of this scout abruptly disrupted the raiding party’s intelligence and likely prevented a coordinated assault on the fort.
- A Landmark Tree: For decades afterward, the specific tree where the event took place—standing on the lands of John Warwick near Greenbank—remained a recognized landmark that older residents pointed out to younger generations.
3. Jacob Warwick’s Regret
Although Jacob Warwick was an active ranger, hunter, and veteran of numerous skirmishes (including rallying the rear-guard butchers at the Battle of Point Pleasant), this was the only Indian he was ever certain of killing in single combat:
- Despite narrow escapes throughout his frontier career, he never took pride in the kill.
- According to family tradition, it consistently grieved him in later years that he had "certainly sent one soul into eternity under such sad circumstances".
🏹 We could explore other encounters around Clover Lick and Deer Creek, such as the time Major Warwick and twenty riflemen ambushed a Shawnee raiding party returning across the mountain crest south of the lick.

No comments:
Post a Comment