Before the advent of the free public school system after the Civil War, education along the Greenbrier and across the Allegheny border was strictly a private affair. As regional historians observed of colonial and early Virginia, the prevailing view was that schooling was not a public obligation, but a commodity to be “purchased like clothing or groceries”.
Pioneer communities organized what were variously known as "subscription," "select," or "pay" schools, followed later by chartered classical academies [56–57, 60, 76]:
1. The Mechanics of Subscription & "Boarding Round"
- The Per-Capita Basis: Neighborhood families banded together to draw up a subscription list, agreeing to pay the master on a per-capita basis for each child sent to the school. Terms rarely lasted more than two to four winter months—the only season when boys and girls could be spared from farm labor [75–76, 113].
- Tuition Rates & Bear Skin Currency:
- At early subscription schools, cash tuition was tiny. In Edray, tuition was $1.00 per month for each pupil. On Rush Run and Stony Creek, William Young's tuition for two months under John McNulty was nine shillings (75 cents per month) [54–55].
- When hard cash was absent, masters took payment in backcountry commodities; at the old brick academy at Greenbank, student Robert J. Brown paid his tuition for studying Davies' algebra with a bear skin.
- "Warming So Many Beds": To keep monetary costs low, masters were granted free table board and lodging, which was provided by "boarding round" from cabin to cabin.
- A master stayed with each family for a duration calculated by dividing the term's days by the number of enrolled scholars. If a few days remained at the end of the term, the master changed cabins every single night to come out even.
- When neighbors met along the trail, a standing joke was asking where the teacher was staying and teasing the master about having to "warm so many beds".
2. The Frontier Schoolhouses: Mother Earth & Greased Paper
Before formal framed schoolhouses were built, classes were conducted in crude round-pole cabins or abandoned outbuildings:
- The 1798 Levelton School: The earliest recorded school in the Little Levels was taught in 1798 by Thomas Green in a round-pole cabin on lands later owned by W. H. McNeel. The roof was made of rough clapboards held down by weight poles, and the floor was "mother earth".
- Greased-Paper Windows: Glass was unattainable over the mountains, so pioneers chopped a log out of one side of the cabin wall and pasted greased paper over the opening as a substitute for window glass.
- Furniture & Slates: Benches were made by splitting small logs in half and boring auger holes into the bark side to insert wooden pins for legs. Because there were no lead pencils, children used slate pencils on rough stone slates or dipped goose-quill pens into home-made ink.
- The Textbooks: Early instruction relied almost exclusively on Dilworth’s Speller and the Bible. In Edray, several pioneer parents accompanied their children to school each day to sit on the split logs and learn to read alongside them.
3. The "Loud School" Tradition vs. The 1846 Reform
Until the mid-19th century, mountain classrooms sounded like a continuous roar:
- The Vocal Plan: All pioneer subscription schools were taught on the "open or vocal plan," where every single scholar studied, spelled, and recited aloud at the top of their lungs simultaneously. A master judged whether his pupils were actually working by the continuous din; if a child went quiet, the switch came down.
- Isaac Moore’s "Silent School" (1846): This bedlam continued until 1846, when Isaac Moore, addressing a community educational meeting, proposed the revolutionary concept of the "silent school". Despite fierce skepticism from old-timers who insisted children could not learn without shouting their lessons, the silent system gradually prevailed.
4. Stern Discipline and Portentous Switches
- The Haw Switch: While teaching a subscription school in a cabin near Mrs. George Baxter’s on Stony Creek, young master Moore kept order by placing a haw switch of portentous length prominently above the hearth. One afternoon, while the master stooped over to arrange a heavy back-log on the fire, a rebellious scholar snatched down the switch, dealt the teacher a stinging blow across the neck and head, and bolted out the door into the woods, sparking a half-mile foot chase through the brush before the student was overtaken.
- Dr. Blain's First Week: In the Little Levels, Rev. John S. Blain—a towering, lean Presbyterian minister, teacher, and physician—arrived with a reputation for kindly piety. Facing an unruly school, he whipped thirteen boys on his second day, twenty-one on the third day, and five or six daily for a week until absolute obedience was established.
5. The Classical Academies: Little Levels and Greenbank
As wealth accumulated in the limestone basins, leading citizens incorporated chartered academies:
- The Little Levels Academy (1842): Chartered by the Virginia General Assembly under the sponsorship of Josiah Beard, Samuel L. Mathews, and the Poages, a two-story brick academy with a central hall and two wings was erected at Hillsboro.
- The academy wielded such profound influence across western Virginia that the village abandoned the name of Hillsboro and formally renamed itself "Academy".
- Principals like Rev. Joseph Brown (7 years) and Rev. Mitchell D. Dunlap (10 years) taught up to eighty pupils, drawing students from Kanawha, Monroe, Greenbrier, and Bath counties [27–28, 57].
- Notable instructors included Rev. Emerson, a New England scholar and relative of Ralph Waldo Emerson, who boarded with Colonel Paul McNeel and surveyed an exact compass line from McNeel's gate to the academy doors.
- The Greenbank Academy: In northern Pocahontas, the brick academy at Greenbank offered advanced instruction in surveying, Latin, Greek, and higher mathematics. It served as the intellectual center of the district until the Civil War halted classes and soldiers turned the academy into a military camp.
📜 We could explore the old County Teachers' Institutes held in the 1880s at Marlinton and Huntersville, where licensing was decided by oral examinations and one memorable session caused a community scandal when the hostess "pulled a dance" in the Presbyterian church.
In the late 19th century, the County Teachers’ Institute was not merely a professional training seminar—it was the premier cultural and social event of the year in Pocahontas County, eagerly attended by educators and community members alike.
The transition from the old county seat at Huntersville to Marlinton in the 1880s brought both rigorous testing and a full-blown community crisis:
1. The Move to Marlinton & The 1886 Institute
For years, the institute had been traditionally convened at Huntersville. However, in 1886, a young county superintendent named Horace M. Lockridge was persuaded to change the venue to Marlinton.
- The Skyles Hotel: Marlinton was chosen largely because the Skyles family was maintaining the largest and finest hotel in the county, making it far more comfortable to accommodate visitors and far more convenient for teachers traveling from the Little Levels and Edray.
- The Presbyterian Church Sanctuary: Because the town lacked a dedicated public auditorium or high school building at the time, both the day and night sessions of the institute were held inside the Marlinton Presbyterian Church.
- A Community Gathering: The sessions drew crowds far beyond the teaching corps; citizens from across the ridges packed the pews for the lectures, debates, and musical numbers.
2. The Scandal: Mrs. Skyles "Pulls a Dance" in the Sanctuary
During the 1886 institute, one evening program was designated for community fellowship and "sociability".
- The Dance in the Church: To entertain the gathered teachers and guests, hotel hostess Mrs. Skyles pulled an impromptu dance right inside the Presbyterian church.
- "The Fearfulest Crisis": In a staunch Scotch-Irish Presbyterian community with long memories of church sessions censuring secular dancing, holding a fiddle dance inside the sanctuary caused an explosive scandal [35–36, 74]. Chroniclers later remarked that it was "the first and foremost and the fearfulest crises that the public school system has had to weather".
- The Anti-Free School Outcry: In those post-Reconstruction years, a powerful, vocal minority remained fiercely hostile to the very concept of tax-funded "free schools". They seized upon Mrs. Skyles's dance as proof of scandalous frivolity among the very people entrusted with public funds to train the rising generation.
- Opponents organized public protests, declaring to their own satisfaction that "the county was destined to disaster unless the levy for schools was voted down". Despite the backlash, the school levy survived, and the County Institute continued meeting annually at Marlinton until the county unit plan was adopted decades later.
3. The Oral Examination Gauntlet & The 125 Questions
Before a teacher could secure a schoolroom, they had to face the County Board of Examiners (which included local educational leaders such as J. W. Warwick, Jr., W. F. Arbogast, and John J. Moore):
- The Oral Grilling: Examinations were conducted strictly orally, continuing over two full days. If an applicant could not make it to town, members of the examining board would sometimes travel on horseback directly to the candidate's home cabin to examine them on the spot.
- Fees and Pay: Teachers paid an examination fee of $1.00 to $2.00, which funded the examiners' statutory compensation of $3.00 per day for preparing questions and hearing recitations.
- The Strict Grading Scale: Applicants were asked a standard battery of 125 questions spanning spelling, mental arithmetic, English grammar, and geography. Certificates were granted on an unforgiving mathematical tier:
- Grade No. 1 Certificate: Missing no more than 5 questions.
- Grade No. 2 Certificate: Missing no more than 10 questions.
- Grade No. 3 Certificate: Missing no more than 20 questions.
- Grade No. 4 Certificate: Missing no more than 35 questions.
- Grade No. 5 Certificate: Missing no more than 55 questions.
- Annual Renewal: Certificates were valid for only one single year; veteran masters and young girls alike had to stand the 125-question oral ordeal all over again every autumn to determine their certificate grade and salary tier for the coming winter term.
4. Cracking Down on End-of-Term "Jollifications"
The dance scandal at Marlinton was not an isolated clash between mountain merrymaking and school board solemnity:
- In Green Bank District, a long-standing tradition had grown up where pupils, parents, and teachers held wild exhibitions and parties on the final day of classes.
- In the 1890s, the Green Bank Board of Education stepped in with an authoritarian order:
"Whereas, The custom that has prevailed of having an exhibition or jollification on the last day of the term... is detrimental, in the extreme, to the advancement of the pupils, and is bringing the schools into disrepute... [we] forbid the teachers... to have, or allow to be held any exhibition, jollification, or gathering of the people".
- Teachers were commanded to conduct the last day of school with regular recitations exactly like every other day, with trustees instructed to report any master who permitted an end-of-year celebration.
🎒 We could look into the 1890s county school reports, where superintendents complained about teachers abandoning the profession because third-grade certificates only paid $18 a month, while truancy ran rampant during chestnut season.
The official reports submitted by Pocahontas County superintendents to the State Superintendent in Charleston—preserved in WPA historical transcriptions—capture the exact frustrations of managing rural mountain classrooms at the close of the 19th century:
1. Salaries and the Exodus: "Our Best Teachers Are Driven from the Profession"
In his Third Annual Report for the year ending June 30, 1896, County Superintendent Davis L. Barlow issued a scathing assessment of district pay scales and teacher retention:
- The Flight from the Classroom: Barlow tracked the teaching corps over nine years, discovering a catastrophic attrition rate:
*“Of the fifty-nine teachers in Pocahontas County in the year 1887, **only eighteen taught in our schools this year. Forty-one have left the profession within nineThe official reports filed by Pocahontas County superintendents during the late 1890s and 1900 reveal a constant struggle with low wages, teacher turnover, and irregular mountain school attendance [71, 75–77, 86, 92, 94]:
1. Low Pay and Teacher Flight: The 1896 Report
In his 1896 annual report, County Superintendent Davis L. Barlow raised an urgent alarm regarding teacher retention across the county's four magisterial districts:
- The Mass Resignations: Barlow analyzed the county rolls over a nine-year period, discovering that out of 59 educators teaching in Pocahontas in 1887, 41 had completely abandoned the profession by 1896, leaving only 18 veterans in the classroom.
- No Premium for Experience: Barlow complained that local boards of education offered experienced, well-qualified teachers the exact same baseline wages as inexperienced novices. A beginner with no high school training received identical pay to a teacher with years of study and classroom practice [93–94].
- The $18 Salary Floor: Across districts like Huntersville, Greenbank, and Edray, pay was strictly dictated by the grade of certificate earned on the annual oral exam [61, 70, 76, 80, 83–84]:
- Grade No. 1: $25.00 to $27.50 per month [61, 70, 76, 80, 83–84].
- Grade No. 2: $22.00 to $22.50 per month [61, 70, 76, 80, 83–84].
- Grade No. 3: $18.00 per month [61, 70, 76, 80, 83–84].
- With terms running only four to five months a year, a third-grade teacher often took home under $90 for an entire year's labor, forcing talented educators into farming, lumbering, or other trades [75, 80, 83–84, 94]. Barlow urged the creation of a professional certificate paying at least $35 to $40 per month to stem the exodus.
2. Truancy, Tardiness, and Seasonal Chores: The 1900 Report
By the 1899–1900 school year, County Superintendent James W. Warwick, Jr. submitted detailed countywide statistics to the State Department in Charleston, exposing the difficulties of keeping children in class:
- The Attendance Drop: While 1,858 pupils were enrolled across the county's 83 schoolhouses (mostly wood-frame buildings with eight remaining pioneer log cabins), average daily attendance hovered at only 1,144.
- Tardiness & Only 51 Perfect Pupils: The records documented 970 cases of tardiness and 20 formal cases of truancy. Out of nearly 1,900 students, only 51 children in the entire county managed to complete the five-month term without being absent or tardy.
- Harvesting and Epidemics: Beyond seasonal autumn disruptions—such as farm harvests and foraging in the mountain woods—Warwick reported that winter attendance was frequently decimated by outbreaks of mumps and measles.
- The Superintendent's Interrupted Circuit: Visiting remote one-room schools on horseback over mountain trails was so difficult that Warwick was only able to inspect 42 schools that year; after being called home by his wife's sudden illness, he found that the five-month term had already expired before he could finish his circuit [71, 76–77].
3. The Discipline Record
Managing crowded, multi-age one-room schools with young staff led to frequent use of the rod. Warwick’s 1900 summary recorded 301 total cases of corporal punishment administered across the county during that single term.
🎒 We could explore the history of the early African American schools established in the county during the late 19th century, such as the ones on Stamping Creek and Browns Mountain.
Under the post-Civil War West Virginia free school system, township and district boards of education were required by law to establish separate schools for African American children whenever local enumerations warranted. Because the Black population in mountainous Pocahontas County was relatively small and clustered in specific farming and mountain settlements, colored schools were concentrated in the Little Levels, Huntersville, and Edray districts, while the northern Greenbank District reported no Black youth and no colored schools prior to 1900 [41–44, 78].
The minute books of local boards of education and county superintendent reports preserve the founding, struggles, and teachers of these early schools [41–44, 70–71]:
1. The Stamping Creek School ("Irish Town" – Little Levels District)
The earliest documented African American school in Pocahontas County was established in the Little Levels basin:
- The 1866 Order: On July 17, 1866, the Board of Education of Union Township (later Little Levels District)—composed of John T. Kinnison, James Morrison, and their colleagues—met and formally ordered that a school for colored children be established according to law, after an official census showed over thirty colored children living in the district.
- Location at "Irish Town": The board ordered a suitable building procured on Stamping Creek, in the neighborhood known as "Irish Town".
- John B. Beard and the School Funds (1873): On September 18, 1873, the board appointed John B. Beard to take charge of all public school funds belonging to the colored population of the district. Because accumulated tax receipts had built up a surplus that exceeded the amount necessary to pay teacher salaries for three or more years, Beard was officially authorized to draw on this fund to rent or construct permanent school buildings.
- Teacher Salary Disparities: The county records reflect that colored teachers were paid noticeably lower salaries than their white counterparts. In 1876, when the board instructed Beard to employ a teacher for the colored school on the mountain, it set a strict maximum salary cap not to exceed fifteen dollars per month.
- Enrollment Growth: By 1875, the youth enumeration for Little Levels listed 57 colored scholars (alongside 464 white youth). Around the turn of the century, the district reported 56 colored pupils [42–43].
2. The Browns Mountain School (Huntersville District)
On Browns Mountain, an early African American settlement grew up in the high country above Huntersville:
- The Abandoned Log Schoolhouse (1879): The community’s educational and religious life was intertwined. When the Mt. Zion Baptist Church (the oldest African American congregation in the county) was organized in 1879 by traveling evangelist Rev. Coleman Booze, its earliest services were conducted inside an old abandoned log building that had been erected and used as a schoolhouse.
- Board of Education Records (1884): District records officially noted one colored school operating in Huntersville District in June 1884, serving an enumeration of 22 colored youth between the ages of six and twenty-one (which dropped to 17 by 1887).
- Repairs and Teachers: In 1888, the district board ordered the trustees of the Browns Mountain colored school to repair the building at an expenditure of no more than fifteen dollars. In 1898, the school was taught by Rev. I. H. Goodwin, who had settled on Browns Mountain to preach and teach before later leading the congregation's move down into Marlinton.
- The Sunset Sub-District: In 1889, the board hired James J. Jones to teach the colored school in the Sunset sub-district for a four-month winter term starting on December 11, 1889. In 1909, the board further ordered a colored school built in or near Frost.
3. Brownsburg and the "Brush Country" (Edray District)
In Edray District, early colored schools served the rural hollows and the farming settlement of Brownsburg [13, 17, 42–43]:
- The McDowell School: The earliest colored school in Edray District was known as the McDowell School, situated in the "brush country". While early records were lost, county historians estimated it began around 1880.
- The 1878 Brownsburg Schoolhouse: Soon after the African American community was founded at Brownsburg around 1870, the residents petitioned the school board for a schoolhouse. A building was completed around 1878. Reflecting the dual civic role of frontier schoolhouses, it doubled as the meeting house for both Baptist and Methodist church services for over two decades until separate church buildings were dedicated in 1902 and 1905.
- The "Lower Brush Country" Committee (1907): In 1907, Edray District formed a new colored sub-district in the lower brush country. The board appointed a local patron committee—consisting of Fannie Hill, William A. Wilson, Lewis Wheeler, J. A. Peters, and A. A. Mocheeny—to secure a suitable classroom for the 1907–1908 term.
- Moving into Town (Marlinton): As families moved into Marlinton, the Edray Board of Education ordered a colored school established in the town in 1901 if a room could be found. In 1917, the board awarded a contract to P. F. King for $1,495 to build a modern two-room school for Black children in Marlinton, followed in 1928 by a new one-room state-approved schoolhouse at Brownsburg.
4. Countywide Statistics and Licensing (1896–1900)
Official superintendents' reports reveal the overall status of African American schooling in Pocahontas County at the end of the century:
- The 1896 Census: Superintendent Davis L. Barlow recorded a total county enumeration of 139 colored youth (42 in Edray, 21 in Huntersville, and 76 in Little Levels). Of these, 68 pupils were actively enrolled across three district schools (34 in Edray and 34 in Little Levels).
- The 1900 Warwick Report: Superintendent James W. Warwick, Jr. reported 62 colored children enrolled out of a total county enrollment of 1,858 pupils.
- Teacher Certification: While none of the county's Black teachers held a Grade No. 1 certificate or normal school diploma at that date, two held Grade No. 2 certificates and one held a Grade No. 3 certificate.
- Discipline: Out of 301 total cases of corporal punishment recorded across all schools in the county during the 1899–1900 school year, only two cases involved colored boys and zero involved colored girls.
⛪ We could examine the founding of Mt. Zion Baptist Church on Browns Mountain in 1879 and the annual barefoot mountain treks of Rev. Coleman Booze from Virginia.
The founding and journey of Mt. Zion Baptist Church represents one of the most resilient community histories in Pocahontas County.
While county lore records that Rev. Coleman Booze walked through the mountains on foot from Virginia once each year, the church records do not state that he made these treks barefoot (that particular detail in county church chronicles belonged to Sister Jane Beverage, who famously shouted barefoot through a meeting at Union Chapel).
The historical record preserves the story of Mt. Zion from its mountain beginnings to its permanent sanctuary in Marlinton:
1. Organization on Browns Mountain (1879)
- The Oldest African American Church: Organized in 1879, Mt. Zion Baptist Church holds the distinction of being the oldest Negro church in Pocahontas County.
- The Abandoned Log Schoolhouse: Before constructing a sanctuary, the small congregation gathered for worship inside an old abandoned log building that had previously been used as a schoolhouse high on Browns Mountain.
- The Annual Visit of Rev. Coleman Booze: During these early years, the congregation had no resident pastor. Instead, Rev. Coleman Booze walked on foot through the mountains all the way from Virginia once every year to conduct revival services, administer ordinances, and minister to the mountain settlement.
- The First Charter Members: The original roll preserved in the church records consisted of:
- Samuel Freeman
- Mary and John Cunningham
- James and Julia Harris
- Titus and Violet Carter
- Dave and Julia Brooks
- Clay Massey
- Agnes and William Massey
- Jenny Massie
- Susan and Ben Graves
- Tamar Stewart
- William Miller
2. The 1899 Reorganization & Rev. I. H. Goodwin’s Warning
In 1899, twenty years after its founding, the congregation formally reorganized and proposed erecting a permanent church building on Browns Mountain.
- The Arrival of Rev. Goodwin: They were advised against building on the mountain by Rev. I. H. Goodwin, who had recently arrived, settled on Browns Mountain, and was both teaching school and preaching to the community.
- Foreseeing the Economic Shift: Rev. Goodwin recognized that Browns Mountain offered no long-term industrial or agricultural future for their families, warning the congregation that they would soon have to move off the mountain in search of work [50–51].
- Following the Families to Marlinton: His prediction proved accurate; within a short time, families began relocating down to Marlinton to work in the expanding timber mills and rail yards, and the church body followed them down into the valley.
3. The Temporary Sanctuaries in Marlinton
Before securing a permanent home in town, the congregation met in several temporary structures:
- The Price Hollow Schoolhouse: White residents of Marlinton gave the congregation permission to worship in the public schoolhouse in Price Hollow, which they used as their meeting house for several years.
- The Depot Hill Building: From Price Hollow, they moved into an old frame building situated against the hill directly opposite where the freight depot stood.
4. Building the Permanent Sanctuary (1911)
- The Lot in Birds Addition: In 1911, the church acquired Lot 1 in Birds Addition to the town of Marlinton from Uriah and Susan Bird. The deed was officially conveyed to trustees George Gilmer, Jacob Robinson, and Cunningham, noting that the church structure was already erected upon the parcel.
- The Builders: Rev. I. H. Goodwin and James Harris performed the lion's share of the physical construction, cutting timber and raising the frame.
- A Community-Wide Effort: Funding came from both Black and white citizens across the county. To pay the carpenters and materials suppliers, Rev. Goodwin traveled on preaching missions throughout Tucker and Randolph counties, raising money from outlying congregations.
- The First Bank Account & Debt-Free Dedication: Rev. Goodwin opened the very first bank account in the church’s name, depositing every cent raised and taking nothing for his personal travel expenses. When he eventually concluded his pastorate, the church was left entirely free of debt.
5. Rev. Goodwin’s 40-Year Ministry
Rev. Goodwin became one of the most prominent religious figures in the county:
- He preached across Pocahontas County for over forty years.
- In 1917, he helped organize and later pastored the First Baptist Church of Cass (which maintained a Sunday School of 35 members), traveling to preach there once a month while also serving as janitor of the First National Bank building in Marlinton.
- By the 1930s, Mt. Zion in Marlinton had grown under the leadership of Rev. C. C. Logan to fifty active members and a Sunday School class of thirty-five.
⛪ We could explore the history of the Macedonian Baptist Church and the Brownsburg Methodist Church, which shared congregations and held joint Ladies' Aid meetings across the ridge [39, 53, 56–57].
In the mountain farming community of Brownsburg (established as an African American settlement around 1870 in Edray District), religious life developed into one of the most remarkable examples of interdenominational cooperation in the county.
For over two decades following the construction of their first public schoolhouse in 1878, the settlement’s families held all community gatherings and shared Sunday worship under that single schoolhouse roof. At the turn of the century, this shared foundation gave rise to two neighboring sister sanctuaries:
1. Macedonian Baptist Church (Built 1902)
- The First Sanctuary in the Settlement: Macedonian Baptist was the first dedicated church building erected in Brownsburg.
- The Site: The church was constructed on 0.25 acres of land formally deeded on March 2, 1907, by B. W. Vaughn and his wife, Maud E. Vaughn, to trustees Andy Wheeler, J. A. Peters, William Walker, and B. W. Vaughn.
- Community Fundraising: Funds to erect the frame building were raised through church suppers, rallies, and broad community subscriptions. Notably, white neighbors from surrounding farms and business owners in Marlinton contributed funds to assist with the building costs.
- Architecture & Services: The chapel featured a raised gallery across the rear. Regular preaching services were held once a month, drawing from charter families including the Walkers, Wheelers, Peters, Jacksons, McDowells, Tibbs, Boggs, and Rev. I. H. Goodwin.
2. Brownsburg Methodist Church (Built 1905)
- The Need for a Second Sanctuary: When Macedonian Baptist was initially planned, the community hoped it would remain open to all denominations. However, after its completion in 1902, the Methodist families felt the need for their own dedicated altar and began raising building funds through donation suppers and rallies.
- The One-Dollar Land Deed (1903): On October 2, 1903, Joseph Wilson conveyed a one-acre parcel to trustees William Wilson, Price Graves, Amos Jackson, Amos Crawford, and C. W. Wilson for the nominal sum of $1.00. The deed carried a strict reversionary clause: the church had to be erected within five years from January 1, 1904, or the land reverted back to the grantor.
- Sponsors and Dedication: The building project was actively sponsored by Joseph Wilson, Billie Wilson, Liza Wilson, and Melissa Wilson, with the chapel completed and opened for worship in 1905. Other active members included Charlott Wheeler, Belle Wheeler, Roy Wheeler, Moody Wilson, Louisa Wilson, and William and Mabel Boggs.
- Furnishings: The interior was fitted out with handmade wooden bench seats, a central coal heating stove, an organ, and electric lights.
3. The Shared Congregation & The Joint Ladies' Aid
Although two separate buildings stood along the country road, sectarian division never took root in Brownsburg:
- Morning and Afternoon Pews: Because Brownsburg’s population was small and closely knit by marriage and kinship, the families treated the two churches as one unified parish:
"For many years the people have attended both churches, going to one in the morning and to the other in the afternoon".
- A Single Ladies' Aid Society: Rather than maintaining rival church circles, the women of both congregations united into a single, joint Ladies' Aid organization. Working side-by-side, they sponsored suppers, quilted comforts, and pooled their bazaar proceeds to buy coal, paint, and repairs for both church properties.
- Later Years: As the timber industry modernized and families relocated to Marlinton or regional rail centers, both congregations dwindled to small classes, yet the surviving elders preserved their alternating Sunday schedule, keeping both pulpits open well into the 20th century [19–20, 27].
⛪ Down the valley near Seebert, another early African American congregation built the Pleasant Green Methodist Episcopal Church in 1888 on land deeded by W. L. McNeel, where the cornerstone and thirty-dollar subscription list tell a similar story of community devotion. We could explore how that congregation was organized.
The history of Pleasant Green Methodist Episcopal Church (Colored)—located about two miles from Seebert in the Little Levels—is documented in the county church surveys compiled by Juanita S. Dilley and local historians.
1. The Cornerstone, The Land Deed, and the $30 Agreement (1888)
- The Inscribed Cornerstone: The date cut directly into the church's cornerstone marks 1888 as the year construction began.
- The McNeel Deed: On September 22, 1888, W. L. McNeel and M. L. McNeel, his wife, officially executed the deed conveying the church lot to trustees George Lee, C. W. Lee, E. N. Grant, W. D. McCoy, and Henry Anderson (all colored), acting for the Methodist Episcopal Church.
- The Parcel: The property consisted of one acre situated in the Little Levels along the public road leading from the colored schoolhouse, at the upper end of the T. C. Wooddell field.
- The "Thirty-Dollar" Consideration: The deed established an agreed valuation of $30.00, arranged through a partnership between the grantors and the congregation:
- One-half ($15.00) was subscribed and donated directly by W. L. and M. L. McNeel.
- The remaining one-half ($15.00) was paid in cash by the congregation.
2. Construction, Opening, and the 20-Year Debt (1889–1909)
- Rev. Ben Perkins: The frame chapel was erected under the pastorate of Rev. Ben Perkins.
- Opening for Worship (1889): Construction was completed and the doors were opened for regular divine services in 1889.
- The 1909 Dedication: Like many mountain churches built on modest subscriptions, clearing the final construction debt took time. Pleasant Green was not fully paid for and formally dedicated until 1909—twenty years after services first commenced.
3. The Original Charter Roll
The original charter roll preserves twenty-nine foundational members, representing prominent pioneer African American families across the Little Levels basin:
- The Lees: George Lee, James Lee, Sarah Lee, Biddie Lee, Charles Lee, Herbert Lee, Silas Lee, Susie Lee, Julia Lee.
- The Pryors: George Pryor, Charles Pryor, Henry Pryor.
- The Andersons: Leann Anderson (along with trustee Henry Anderson).
- The Thompsons: Tom Thompson, Irene Thompson.
- The Stewarts: Lacy Stewart, Charles Stewart.
- The Grants: Elijah Grant, Lizzie Grant (along with trustee E. N. Grant).
- The Lacys: Ben Lacy, Sally Lacy.
- The Taylors: Odas Taylor, Mrs. Odas Taylor, Sinah Taylor.
- The Boldens: John Bolden, Harriet Bolden.
- The Jacksons: Andrew Jackson, Vandalia Jackson.
4. Community Life & The Four-Point Circuit
- Active Leaders and Sunday School: By the late 1930s and 1940, the congregation maintained an active roll of about twenty-five members. Florence Tibbs served as Sunday School superintendent, assisted by John Henry, with Vernie Bolden and Mattie Tibbs recognized as leading church workers [25, 52–53].
- Preserving the Chapel: While the chapel lacked auxiliary societies, the members took pride in maintaining the structure, replacing the original wooden shingle roof with a metal roof and erecting a new chimney flue.
- The County Circuit: Pleasant Green formed one of four regular appointments comprising the countywide African American Methodist Episcopal circuit, which united the congregations at Pleasant Green (Seebert), Marlinton, Brownsburg, and Durbin (where members met in private homes and a converted meeting hall) under the pastoral care of Rev. Graham, serving roughly eighty members across the four communities.
🚂 We could explore the Fourth Appointment of that circuit up in Durbin and Cass, where Black rail and mill families met in temporary shanties before organizing the First Baptist Church of Cass in 1917.
The records compiled by the West Virginia Writers' Project in "Chapter 6: Religion" document the northern branch of that circuit across Durbin and the booming lumber town of Cass:
1. The Fourth Appointment at Durbin (M. E. Circuit, Colored)
As documented in the county church surveys, the African American Methodist Episcopal Church in Pocahontas County maintained four regular appointments served by a single traveling minister, Rev. Graham:
- The Four Stations: Pleasant Green (near Seebert), Marlinton, Brownsburg, and Durbin.
- Together on the Circuit: Across all four appointments, the circuit comprised about 80 members.
- The Meeting Place at Durbin: Unlike Pleasant Green, Brownsburg, and Marlinton—which had dedicated church buildings—the small Black Methodist class at Durbin had no church edifice of their own.
- Private Homes and Converted Halls: The records note that at Durbin, the congregation:
"have no church building at Durbin, but have an old building of some kind fixed up to use for services," while also "meeting regularly in private homes".
2. The Industrial Boom at Cass & The Early Mill Shanties
At the turn of the century, the founding of the massive West Virginia Pulp & Paper Company (Westvaco) double-band sawmill and rail hub at Cass drew hundreds of laborers into the upper Greenbrier Valley. Among them were African American workers who operated the booming rail yards, log trains, and drying kilns.
Before any church was organized, their spiritual life was completely itinerant:
- The Mill Shanties: In the winter months, workers gathered for prayer and preaching inside temporary company shanties scattered along the riverbanks and rail spurs.
- Summer Services in the Groves: During the warm months, the congregation held their meetings outdoors "in the groves" beneath the mountain timber.
- The Schoolhouse Meeting Place: As the community grew, their regular services moved into the colored schoolhouse in Cass.
3. Organizing the First Baptist Church of Cass (1917)
- The Founding by Rev. Goodwin: In 1917, Rev. I. H. Goodwin—the veteran pioneer pastor of Mt. Zion in Marlinton who had lived on Browns Mountain—came up the rail line to formally organize the First Baptist Church of Cass (Colored).
- The Original Charter Members: The original roll preserved in the church records consisted of:
- John Parks
- Joe Tyson
- Tom Hunter
- Carrie Hunter
- John Crews
- George Gilbert
- Mattie Scott
- Flora Davis
- Charlie Davis
- Ollie Davis
- Minnie Gilbert
- Manuel Tyson
4. Ministry, Westvaco Support, and Rev. Goodwin’s Return
- The Successive Pastors: Following its organization, the church was led by several pastors, including Rev. I. H. Goodwin, followed by Rev. White (from Ronceverte) and Rev. Burner (from Davis).
- Rev. Goodwin's Dedicated Care: By 1940, Rev. I. H. Goodwin had returned as pastor, serving the congregation steadily for nine consecutive years. Even while working as janitor of the First National Bank building in Marlinton, he traveled up the Greenbrier line once every month to preach to his flock at Cass.
- Sunday School and Building Drive: Under his guidance, the church maintained an active Sunday School of about 35 members.
- Westvaco Backing: The church records explicitly noted that "the West Virginia Pulp and Paper Company helps and encourages this church" [59–60].
- The Goal for a Permanent Altar: By 1940, the congregation had launched an active fundraising campaign, saving their money with the hope of purchasing or constructing a dedicated church building of their own in the near future.
🚂 We could follow the rail line further up the mountain to the logging settlement of Spruce or Cheat Bridge, where the Westvaco company and itinerant preachers held outpost services in rail cars and camp boarding houses.
Following the logging rails up and over the high shoulder of Cheat Mountain brings into view one of the most rugged chapters of Appalachian industrial and social history.
To harvest the massive red spruce stands of the upper Shavers Fork watershed, the West Virginia Pulp & Paper Company (Westvaco) constructed a standard-gauge railroad climbing out of Cass, using two steep switchbacks to conquer 1,600 feet of elevation before dropping into the Cheat River gorge.
1. Spruce: The "Coldest and Highest" Town in the East (3,853 Feet)
Perched along Shavers Fork of the Cheat River, the boomtown of Spruce became the operational nerve center of the high-country logging empire:
- The High Metropolis: At an elevation of 3,853 feet, Spruce was celebrated as the highest and coldest town in the eastern United States. In 1909, 36 million board feet of lumber poured through its large band sawmill, while 40 railcars of peeled spruce pulpwood left daily for the paper mills in Covington, Virginia, and Luke, Maryland.
- A Thriving Mountain Settlement: By 1914, Spruce boasted a population of 500 residents, complete with its own school, post office, company hotel and boarding houses, and a resident physician, Dr. Coffer, who traveled the rail lines with his pill bag aboard a track motor car [30–31, 34–35].
- The Italian and Austrian Rail Gangs: Construction and maintenance of the Greenbrier, Cheat & Elk Railroad (G. C. & E.) between Spruce and Bemis was largely carried out by Italian and Austrian stone and track crews, who lived along the right-of-way in separate mountain enclaves known in company reports as "the bohunk camps".
2. Boarding House Life & Second-Story Snowdrifts
Life in the high spruce camps was dominated by extreme isolation, treacherous switchbacks, and alpine winters [30–37]:
- Riding the Log Cars: Veteran railroad engineer Walter Good, who ran the Spruce line from 1927 until 1960, recalled that trains over the switchbacks were strictly capped at thirteen cars, requiring a brakeman stationed for every two cars [30–37]. In summer, log cars were crowded with berry pickers, while in autumn they hauled swarms of deer and bear hunters into the wilderness.
- Mrs. Good's Boarding House (1941–1946): Walter Good’s wife ran the very last boarding house at Spruce (Cheat Junction). During one epic winter storm, snow drifted completely to the second-story windows.
- Shoveling Snow Out of the Cabs: The railroad had to couple two and three steam locomotives together to plow the cuts. As Walter Good ran the lead engine, snow blew into the cab windows so furiously that the crew had to repeatedly stop the train simply to shovel snow off the engine deck.
- Scratching the Bottom of the Barrel: Mrs. Good, who had bed space for fourteen people, found herself snowbound for an entire week with twenty men and two women. Running out of rations, she baked fresh biscuits three times a day from the dregs of the flour barrel until the rails were finally cleared.
3. Outpost Services & Preachers in the Camps
Sustaining community and church life at nearly 4,000 feet required mobile, adaptive ministry:
- Outposts of the Cass Presbyterian Church: The church records of Cass Presbyterian Church document that pastors maintained formal outpost mission work in the lumber settlements, notably at Spruce and Raywood, holding regular prayer meetings and Sunday School classes for timber families until the mills cut out and the populations moved away.
- The Preacher’s Lament: Circuit-riding pastors often found lumber camps a daunting spiritual frontier. Minister John W. McNeil reported to his quarterly conference that the opening of the railroads had created serious challenges for mountain morality:
“I fear building the railroad will not help our people spiritually, for they have open saloons along the road and we fear they do not regard the Sabbath in their sales... And then many of our men work in the lumber camps and are away from home and religious influence for 6 or 8 months and we believe they must have unwavering faith or they would come back with more money and less religion than when they left”.
- Worship in Dining Halls and Rail Shanties: Where no formal chapels existed, itinerant ministers, colporteurs, and Methodist circuit riders held services directly inside camp boarding house dining halls, one-room schoolhouses, and trackside work cars, preaching to crews between shifts.
4. Cheat Bridge and Big Cut (4,066 Feet)
Northwest of Spruce, the rails crossed Shavers Fork at Cheat Bridge, pushing past five river bridges toward Big Cut:
- At 4,066 feet elevation, Big Cut stood as the highest mainline railroad point in the eastern United States, where rail travelers and lumber crews were reminded that even in the heat of August, a heavy winter jacket was essential against the biting mountain wind.
🌲 We could look into the logging town of Wildell or Winterburn along the upper forks, where whole families lived in portable boxcar shanties that were hoisted onto flatcars and hauled down the mountain when a tract was cleared.
Along the upper forks of the Greenbrier River and the high mountain corridor stretching north from Durbin to the Randolph County divide, the timber boom of 1900–1920 gave rise to a dense constellation of boomtowns and temporary rail camps.
1. The Boomtowns of the Upper Forks (1900–1920)
When a historic boundary dispute was resolved in favor of Pocahontas County, thousands of acres of virgin timber and roughly ten miles of the Western Maryland Railroad (originally the Coal and Iron Railway) fell into the Greenbank District. Almost overnight, the sixteen-mile stretch of river and tracks between Durbin and the mountain divide filled with newly built sawmill settlements:
- The "Lost Towns": Between 1900 and 1915, towns sprang up along the rails in rapid succession: Wildell, May, Gertrude, Burner, Braucher, Madeline, Olive, Nida, and Oxley on the West Fork, alongside Winterburn on the East Fork.
- Town Infrastructure: During their peak, these settlements averaged populations of about three hundred people and operated large band sawmills. Despite their remote mountain locations, they were equipped with churches, schools, company stores, and modern conveniences to provide comfortable living for the mill men and their families while the timber held.
- The "Drummers" on the Track: Andrew Price recalled in The Pocahontas Times the intense commercial energy along the line: "What a vision of wealth and prosperity that name once conjured... drummers [traveling salesmen] walked the railroad from one town to the next when the trains did not run to suit them".
2. Winterburn on the East Fork
While Wildell sat on the Western Maryland's West Fork line, Winterburn anchored the logging operations on the East Fork of the Greenbrier:
- The C&O Railhead (1905): The Chesapeake & Ohio Railway’s Greenbrier Division—which completed track to Cass in 1900 and Durbin in 1902—pushed up the East Fork to reach its northern terminus at Winterburn in 1905, bringing the total length of the Greenbrier branch to 100.96 miles.
- George Craig & Sons: The large mill operation at Winterburn was headed by George Craig & Sons, who employed timber jobbers like Robert Cochran and dozens of woodmen to fell the surrounding virgin stands.
- The 1933 Abandonment: Once the timber was exhausted and the Great Depression struck, through freight dried up; the entire rail section from Bartow to Winterburn was formally abandoned in 1933.
3. Mobile Woods Camps & Camp Shanties on Rails
While the mill towns themselves featured stationary frame dwellings, schools, and boarding houses, the woods crews who followed the cutting spurs deep into the hollows lived in portable structures:
- Camp Shanties on Sidings: In the high logging woods, companies maintained mobile trackside camps—such as Camp No. 5 and Camp No. 29—where log cars and flatcars fitted with portable camp shanties were set on sidings.
- "Jenny Lynn" Construction: Woods shacks were commonly erected in the "Jenny Lynn" style (vertical board-and-batten construction), stripped with creosote to preserve the wood and deter bedbugs, with simple six-to-twelve roof slopes and steel stovepipes thrust through the roof.
- Moving with the Cut: When a mountain watershed or hollow was completely timbered out, these temporary camp cars and skidder outfits were coupled to the geared Shay engines, hoisted down the spurs, and relocated to the next boundary of virgin forest.
4. "Wild and Naked": The Sudden Collapse
The lifespan of these high-altitude settlements was entirely tethered to the timber:
- The 10,000-Person Exodus: County records note that at the peak of the lumber boom around 1915, the population of Pocahontas County reached approximately 22,000 residents; as the mills cut out and closed down, the population plummeted by ten thousand people.
- Andrew Price’s 1918 Epitaph: Describing the sixteen-mile corridor north of Durbin in 1918, Andrew Price wrote:
"This is now a part of the cold and barren which lies in Pocahontas. Where as it used to look stern and wild, it now looks wild and naked".
🏭 We could look into the Pocahontas Tanning Company down at Frank near Durbin, which became the second-largest sole-leather tannery in the United States by consuming mountain oak and hemlock bark.
The Pocahontas Tanning Company plant at Frank (just across "The Narrows" from Durbin) was one of the most remarkable industrial installations in the Allegheny highlands.
A detailed portrait of the plant’s operations survives in an official questionnaire and letter preserved by the West Virginia Writers' Project, written on September 8, 1937, by company superintendent H. M. Widney [52–53]:
1. Scale & Standing: Second-Largest in the Nation
- Sole Leather Monopoly: Widney confirmed that the Durbin Tannery at Frank was "probably the second largest tannery in the U.S.A., both in floor space and production, devoted entirely to the production of sole leather".
- Corporate Structure: Although operating deep in the mountains along the upper Greenbrier River, the company was a West Virginia corporation headquartered in the northern panhandle, with its main offices located at Main and 24th Streets in Wheeling.
- The Plant Atmosphere: Visitors were generally discouraged from touring the facility because the tanning process required vast batteries of wet vats and continually soaked floors, though partial visits and product exhibits were occasionally permitted. The company’s letterhead bore the firm motto: "Nothing Takes the Place of Leather".
2. The Appetite for Mountain Tanbark
- Why Locate at Frank: The tannery was established at Frank specifically to take advantage of "the close-up supply of large quantities of hemlock and oak bark" from the surrounding virgin timber tracts.
- Bark Peeling in the Woods: During the spring and summer sap run, woods crews across Pocahontas peeled mountain chestnut oak and hemlock bark by the thousands of cords. Loggers were paid $2.50 per cord for peeling tanbark, which was bundled and hauled directly to the vats at Frank or shipped over the C&O and Western Maryland tracks.
- Exhausting the Forests: The plant’s enormous industrial consumption outpaced even the Alleghenies; by 1937, Superintendent Widney reported that local supplies of native bark were "now largely exhausted".
3. Global Supply Lines: Hides and Exotic Extracts
To sustain its daily vat runs, the tannery operated an international supply web:
- Worldwide Raw Hides: Raw cattle hides were shipped in from the major packing centers of the United States, as well as imported from South America, Mexico, Australia, and Europe.
- Worldwide Tanning Materials: In addition to local hemlock and oak extracts, the company imported specialized tanning agents from South America, Africa, the Philippine Islands, Turkey, and India.
4. Products and By-Products
- Primary Product: Heavy-duty sole leather manufactured specifically for the production of new shoes.
- By-Products:
- Washed Cattle Hair: Cleaned and baled for use in commercial floor coverings, insulation felts, and furniture padding.
- Glue Stock and Greases: Scrap tissue and trimmings saved and barrelled for the manufacture of industrial glues and heavy lubricating greases.
5. The Company Village of Frank
Separated from Durbin by the natural mountain breach known as The Narrows (traditionally remembered as an ancient deer stand where Henry Clay once had a hunting cabin), Frank grew up as a classic industrial community:
- The Town: Located along U.S. Route 250, Frank was an unincorporated village made up of company-owned houses alongside many privately owned residences, which company officials noted were well-maintained and marked by strong civic pride.
- Schools and Churches: The community supported its own Tannery School (which operated alongside the Durbin Graded School). The Pocahontas Tanning Company also donated the land upon which the local Church of the Nazarene and parsonage were erected in the 1930s under Rev. J. Roger Morris.
6. The Industrial Aftermath
Long after the tannery ceased operations, its footprint remained a prominent part of local affairs. In June 2000, the Pocahontas County Commission advertised bids for an extensive environmental clean-up of the old tannery site at Frank, funding the removal and stabilization of remaining sludge from the historic tanning ponds and installing heavy liners for a final drying bed [20–21].
🚂 We could look into the Greenbrier Division of the C&O Railroad, which brought the trainloads of hides and hemlock bark up the river into Frank and Durbin.
The story of the Greenbrier Division of the Chesapeake & Ohio Railway (originally chartered in part as the Greenbrier Railway) is the foundational transportation saga that transformed Pocahontas County from a remote mountain pocket into an industrial timber and leather giant [11, 16–18, 76].
1. Why It Was Built: Timber Over Coal
Unlike almost every other C&O branch line across West Virginia—which were driven into mountain hollows to tap rich seams of bituminous coal—the Greenbrier Division was constructed specifically to develop the vast, untouched timber resources of the Greenbrier Valley [17–18].
- The St. Lawrence River Drives: Prior to the tracks, the only timber harvested was white pine, floated down the spring freshets of the Greenbrier River to the great St. Lawrence Boom and Manufacturing Company sawmills at Ronceverte [17–18, 63, 68, 71, 73]. Hardwoods like oak, cherry, and chestnut, along with dense red spruce, could not be successfully rafted down river currents and required rail transport [17–18, 63].
- The Westvaco Catalyst: Although railroad charters had languished since the Civil War, the decisive catalyst came in the late 1890s when the West Virginia Pulp & Paper Company built its pulp mill at Covington, Virginia, and acquired enormous spruce tracts on Cheat Mountain [17–18]. Westvaco guaranteed the C&O sufficient sustained tonnage to justify financing the water-level line up the valley [17–18].
2. Construction Milestones (1899–1905)
Spanning 100.96 miles, the Greenbrier line hugged the banks of the river from Whitcomb (near Ronceverte) in Greenbrier County north to the headwaters [17–18]:
- July 1899: Ground broken and construction begun [17–18].
- October 26, 1900 (Marlinton Celebration): The arrival of the first train in Marlinton was celebrated with "a wild celebration which included a barbecue, polo, tournaments, a football game and welcoming speeches".
- December 1900: Rails reached the brand-new company town of Cass, with pulpwood shipments rolling eastward in January 1901 and the Cass double-band mill roaring to life a year later [17–18].
- 1902: The line was completed through the narrows to Durbin [17–18].
- 1903 (The Western Maryland Junction): At Durbin, the C&O linked with the Coal and Iron Railway (later the Western Maryland Railway), forging a crucial through-connection north toward Elkins, Cumberland, and Baltimore [11, 15, 17–18].
- 1905: The line reached its final northern terminus on the East Fork of the Greenbrier at Winterburn [17–18].
3. Local Sandstone Quarries for the Right-of-Way
To carry heavy trains across mountain tributaries, C&O civil engineers relied on Pocahontas County's native stone:
- Dimension Stone: Sandstone for masonry construction was quarried directly along the western bluffs of the Greenbrier River.
- The Bridge Abutments: The massive stone abutments for the Knapps Creek Bridge, the Watoga Bridge, and numerous crossing spans were cut from the famous Broad Ford Sandstone formation, known for its extreme abrasive resistance and durability against river floods.
4. Traffic: Freight, Tannery Vats, and "Two Trains Daily"
During its golden era from 1900 through the 1920s, the Greenbrier Division became one of the busiest lines on the C&O system [17–18]:
- Feeding the Mills and Tanneries: The road hauled continuous cuts from dozens of sawmills and served two major sole-leather tanneries—the Pocahontas Tanning Company at Frank (near Durbin) and the tannery at Marlinton—hauling hundreds of boxcars of salt-cured hides and thousands of cords of peeled hemlock and chestnut oak tanbark [17–19, 52–53, 97].
- Through Freight in the 1920s: When local timber stands began thinning in the early 1920s, the C&O repurposed the branch as a vital through-route for freight shipments between eastern ports and western cities via the Durbin junction [17–18].
- Passenger Service: Passenger traffic was accommodated by two scheduled passenger trains daily each way, connecting rural whistle-stops like Beard, Denmar, Seebert, Buckeye, Clover Lick, and Boyer with the outside world [17–18, 62, 65, 67].
5. Decline and the Greenbrier River Trail
- The Depression Cutback (1933): The Great Depression collapsed through-freight and closed mills; passenger runs were cut to one train daily in 1930, and the northern branch between Bartow and Winterburn was formally abandoned and torn up in 1933 [17–18].
- Postwar Fading: Passenger service ended on January 8, 1958. Following the closure of the Cass mill in 1960 and the Marlinton tannery in 1970, freight dropped from daily to a single train per week by 1974.
- Final Runs (December 1978): In 1975, the C&O formally applied to the Interstate Commerce Commission to abandon the remaining 92-mile line [15, 19–20]. The final trains ran on December 27 and 28, 1978.
- The Legacy: The C&O donated the abandoned right-of-way to the State of West Virginia, transforming the river-grade roadbed between North Caldwell and Cass into the Greenbrier River Trail, while the Durbin end was later revived by tourist lines like the Durbin & Greenbrier Valley Railroad [19, 52–53, 55, 60].
🚴 We could explore the conversion of the old roadbed into the 78-mile Greenbrier River Trail, or look into the scenic excursions pulled by the historic locomotive "Little LeRoi" along the preserved tracks out of Durbin [55–60].
The preservation of the old C&O Greenbrier Division and the Western Maryland line around Durbin created two of the region's most celebrated rail-heritage transformations: the Greenbrier River Trail and the heritage excursions of the Durbin & Greenbrier Valley Railroad.
1. Conversion to the Greenbrier River Trail
- The Abandonment (1978): Following the closure of the Cass sawmill in 1960 and the Marlinton tannery in 1970, freight traffic dwindled to a single train per week by 1974. In 1975, the C&O formally applied to the Interstate Commerce Commission to abandon its 92-mile branch, with final authority granted in 1978; the last trains completed their runs down the river on December 27 and 28, 1978 [9–10].
- The Donation to the State: Rather than seeing the right-of-way broken up or lost, the C&O donated the entire river-grade roadbed to the State of West Virginia.
- The River-Grade Trail: The corridor stretching between North Caldwell in Greenbrier County and Cass in Pocahontas County was developed into the Greenbrier River Trail. Because the original line followed water-level contours, it created a gentle, nearly level grade passing through remote river gorges, historic cuts, and across restored stone bridge abutments [7–9].
2. Preserving the Rails at Durbin: Volunteer Restoration
- The Durbin Rail Abandonment (1984): While the lower line became a trail, the Western Maryland connection into Durbin continued operating for a brief period before it was officially abandoned in 1984.
- Saving the Track: Rail enthusiasts and community leaders organized to keep the steel in place. Part of the original C&O Greenbrier Division track at Durbin was painstakingly restored through the hard work of devoted volunteers, laying the groundwork for the Durbin & Greenbrier Valley Railroad.
3. "Little LeRoi on the Greenbrier"
Operating out of the historic 1920s rail yard at Durbin, the railroad introduced a heritage run pulled by the beloved locomotive "Little LeRoi":
- The Locomotive: Little LeRoi is an antique industrial yard engine celebrated as "the type of antique engine featured in the children's classic The Little Engine That Could".
- The Consist: The little engine pulls passengers in an open observation car coupled to a faithfully restored 1920s caboose.
- The 90-Minute River Wilderness Ride: Departing from Durbin, Little LeRoi hauls passengers on a leisurely 90-minute excursion meandering along the unspoiled upper Greenbrier River.
- Wilderness Wildlife: Because the route runs through quiet, roadless river bends, passengers routinely spot mountain wildlife along the banks, including beaver, basking river turtles, and nesting golden eagles.
- The Rail & Trail Store: Excursion headquarters were established right across the street from the depot at the Rail & Trail Store, which became a local gathering spot famed for its "Big Scoop" ice cream cones, railroad collectibles, and local Appalachian handicrafts.
4. The High-Country Companion: The "Cheat Mountain Salamander"
Connecting with the Durbin operation, the affiliated West Virginia Central Railroad launched a companion wilderness excursion climbing into the high Alleghenies [98–101]:
- The Leyland Railbus: Operating a unique Leyland National R3 Railbus, the "Cheat Mountain Salamander" carried passengers on a 34- to 35-mile mountain wilderness trek departing from Cheat Bridge.
- Crossing the Torrent: The railbus traversed five bridges over Shavers Fork of the Cheat River, rolling past the overgrown ruins of the abandoned logging town of Spruce.
- Summiting Big Cut (4,066 Feet): The excursion climbed to Big Cut—the highest mainline rail point in the East—where summer visitors were advised to bring winter jackets against the alpine wind while taking in panoramic vistas of the surrounding mountain peaks.
🔭 Just down the road from the Shay switchbacks sits the National Radio Astronomy Observatory at Green Bank, where astronomers in the early 1960s feared the clattering steam trains and visiting tourists might drown out signals from deep space [44–45, 55]. We could explore how the observatory and the railroad negotiated their quiet coexistenc
When the state moved to transform the abandoned logging line at Cass into a major tourist attraction, it collided directly with the National Radio Astronomy Observatory (NRAO) at nearby Green Bank, sparking an intense standoff between 19th-century steam locomotion and 20th-century space exploration.
1. The Clash: "Quiet as a Moon Crater" vs. The Steam Boom
- The Silent Valley: The federal government had established the observatory in Deer Creek Valley because the high Allegheny mountain ridges shielded the basin from man-made electrical noise, leaving the area "as quiet as a moon crater at midnight" to detect faint radio signals from distant galaxies.
- The $576,000 ARA Grant: Around 1963–1964, the state sought a $576,000 federal grant from the Area Redevelopment Administration (ARA) to rebuild the Cass machine shops, overhaul additional Shay locomotives, and extend the tourist track four miles past Whittaker Station all the way to the 4,852-foot summit of Bald Knob.
- The Astronomers' Protest: The grant was abruptly stalled when observatory officials lodged formal protests. The scientists warned:
“No indeed... we don’t want noisy trains and noisy people with their noisy automobiles. It’ll ruin our reception”.
- While the steam trains produced clatter and smoke, the far greater threat to the giant dish antennas was the electrical ignition noise generated by thousands of tourist automobiles flooding into the valley.
2. The Man in the Middle: Ted Riffe
The dispute featured a unique local irony:
- The chairman of the Cass Planning Committee—the grassroots group of local citizens who conceived the idea of saving the railroad and fought for state acquisition—was Theodore "Ted" Riffe.
- Riffe lived in Cass, but his day job was chief accountant for the National Radio Astronomy Observatory at Green Bank.
- At the same time, following the collapse of the Mower lumber mill, many younger Pocahontas County residents had crossed the ridge to take jobs at the observatory, creating strong familial and economic ties between the two institutions.
3. The Highway Deadlock: "It Would Cost Millions!"
Observatory officials conceded that the scenic railroad itself could operate, but insisted that the influx of tourist vehicles had to be kept away from the radio dishes:
- The Route 28 Demand: The observatory initially demanded that the primary approach—State Route 28—be relocated completely away from the observatory grounds.
- The State Road Commission Pushes Back: West Virginia State Road Commissioner Burl Sawyers rejected the demand outright, protesting:
“Can’t do it!... It would cost millions!”.
4. The Compromise on Route 7
The impasse was resolved when Commissioner Sawyers proposed a compromise that satisfied federal radio quiet requirements without having to rebuild the main highway:
- Moving the Secondary Road: Instead of touching Route 28, the state agreed to relocate State Route 7 (the secondary road connecting Route 28 to Cass, about six miles away).
- A Mile to the South: The intersection of Route 7 and Route 28 was shifted about one mile south of its original location.
- The 1.3-Mile Bypass: The state constructed one and three-tenths miles of new highway, routing tourist traffic to Cass further south and away from the direct line of sight of the Green Bank telescopes.
5. Coexistence and Expansion
With the road relocation plan accepted by federal authorities, the observatory withdrew its objections and approved the agreement:
- The $576,000 ARA grant was released, funding the track construction to the spruce forests of Bald Knob, the renovation of the historic rail shops, and the acquisition of a 40-acre scenic plateau on the mountain.
- The compromise allowed the Green Bank telescopes to continue listening to deep space in peace while the geared Shays carried tens of thousands of visitors up Cheat Mountain just six miles to the west.
No comments:
Post a Comment