Search This Blog

 🌿 We could explore the old mineral spring spas across the mountain divide in Bath County, looking at how 18th-century travelers journeyed on packhorses to take the "vapor sulfur baths" and drink the warm limestone waters.

Across the mountain divide in Bath County, Virginia, the mineral springs of the Warm Springs Valley and the Cowpasture River formed the earliest and most celebrated spa corridor in the southern Alleghenies.

Long before elaborate hotels and rail lines were constructed, this canoe-shaped valley drew travelers, invalids, and land speculators across rugged trails.


1. The Frontier Journey: Wagons to Bath Alum, Packhorses Over the Mountain

  • The Packhorse Frontier: In the 18th century, travelers heading to the springs faced a grueling journey through deep water-gaps and over steep mountain crests. For decades, the wagon road from the east terminated at Bath Alum, situated at the eastern foot of Warm Springs Mountain.
  • Switching to Horseback: Local histories note that Bath Alum marked the end of wagon travel; from that point on, "it was pack-horses" over the mountain into the Warm Springs basin. Heavy freight wagons unloaded their merchandise at Brinkley’s tavern at the mountain’s foot, while travelers and baggage made the crossing on horses, returning laden with venison, cured hams, and pelts.
  • The "Jolting" Stagecoach Era: Even after turnpikes crossed the mountain, journeys remained arduous. Invalids traveling from Philadelphia faced four days of connections, enduring 16 hours a day jolting in coaches, while planters from the Deep South made weeks-long overland trips to reach the cool mountain air.

2. Early Discoveries: Walker’s Invalids and Andrew Lewis (1750–1764)

  • Dr. Thomas Walker's 1750 Diary: When explorer Dr. Thomas Walker passed through the valley on July 9, 1750, the springs were already a recognized refuge for the sick:

    "We went to the hot Springs and found Six Invalides there. The Spring Water is very Clear & Warmer than new Milk, an there is a Spring of cold Water within 20 feet of the Warm one".

  • The Soldier-Speculators: Pioneer soldier General Andrew Lewis reportedly stumbled upon the Hot Springs while evading hostile Indians, though early accounts note he was initially more impressed by the rich limestone grazing soils than the water's medicinal properties.
  • The First Hotel (1764): In 1764, Thomas Bullitt, along with Andrew and Thomas Lewis, patented 300 acres covering the Hot Springs. They agreed to erect a hotel and stock it with fermented and distilled liquors (deemed by travelers of the day to be "superior to the beverage prepared by Dame Nature"), building a hostelry that stood in part until destroyed by fire in 1901.

3. The Thermal Waters: "Light Water" and Underground Fires

Geologically, the Warm Springs Valley forms an elevated limestone canoe whose fault lines force rainfall deep into the earth’s interior heat, returning it under high pressure free from organic impurities:

  • The Hot Springs (106°): A group of six flowing fountains discharged warm water containing 43 grains of mineral salts per gallon (chiefly calcium, magnesium, sodium, and potassium), widely sought for rheumatism, nervous complaints, and dyspepsia.
  • The Warm Springs (98°): Five miles northeast, the Warm Springs discharged an astonishing 1,200 gallons a minute of 98-degree water. Early chroniclers marveled at its clarity and light effervescence:

    "The water flowed into great bathing pools and it maintained in these pools a temperature of ninety-eight degrees. The water is clear as clear can be and is thoroughly well charged with gas. At these springs in Bath County, bathing has reached its highest state of perfection".

    • Local observers noted that travelers could drink large quantities of this "light water" because of the dissolved subterranean gases, remarking playfully that drinking a gallon of Warm Springs water furnished several cubic inches of gas, leaving the bather to "float away on the wings of the morning feeling fine".
  • Healing Springs (84°): Located three miles south of Hot Springs, these waters were celebrated as an alterative for skin affections and bronchial complaints.

4. "Vapor Sulphur Baths" & Frontier Bathing Rituals

  • The 1772 Poplar Trough: When severe illness struck, pioneers improvised their own baths. In 1772, an invalid woman was carried across the mountains on a litter; settlers felled a giant poplar tree, hollowed out an enormous bathing trough with an adz and axe, filled it with sulfur water, and heated the pool by dropping red-hot river stones directly into the trough until she was bathed and cured.
  • The "Vapor Sulphur" Cure: By the early 19th century, prominent regional physicians capitalized on the springs' fame. In Staunton, Napoleonic veteran Dr. Alexis Martin established an extensive private sanitarium for wealthy visitors traveling to and from the springs, treating prominent patients (including Miss Myra Clark Gaines) with "vapor sulphur baths" and his secret restorative compound, "Le Roy".

5. The Two Baths: High Society vs. The Mountain Solitude

By the 1830s and 1840s, the valley had become the premier seasonal retreat for American high society:

  • The Summer Throng: Wealthy planters, politicians, and foreign dignitaries—including the Baltimore Bonapartes arriving with outriders, carriages drawn by four horses, and liveried servants—thronged the road through Staunton toward Bath.
  • "Two Bath Counties": As local historians remarked, there grew to be "two Bath Counties in Virginia": one was the quiet, rural world of pioneer stockmen farming the Cowpasture bottoms; the other was the glamorous "tourist Bath" of Warm Springs Valley, where visitors escaped the summer heat to bathe in the crystal caldrons of the Alleghenies [59, 126–127].

🌊 We could explore the stories of other nearby mineral waters across the mountain ridges, like the alum waters of Bath Alum, the salt-sulfur springs of Webster, or the old resort at Minnehaha Springs along Knapps Creek.

 

Beyond the thermal caldrons of the Warm Springs Valley, the surrounding ridges and river gaps of the Allegheny divide harbored a remarkable variety of mineral springs. From the alum waters of the Cowpasture to the bubbling fountain pools of Knapps Creek and the historic salt-sulfur licks of the Elk River, each watering place developed its own distinct history and culture:


1. Minnehaha Springs on Knapps Creek: "Laughing Water" & Allegheny Lodge

Nine miles east of Marlinton along Knapps Creek, the community originally known as Driscol was renamed Minnehaha Springs—taking its name from an Indian word signifying "Laughing Water".

  • The 72-Degree Fountain Pool: Emerging from the base of the mountains, the spring discharges more than one million gallons of crystal-clear water a day at an unvarying year-round temperature of 72 degrees. Compressed subterranean gases force the water upward in thousands of tiny sprays that ripple across a pool six feet deep and over an eighth of an acre wide, filled with aquatic mosses and "mineral flowers".
  • Purity & Medicinal Renown: Analyzed by Professor J. W. Mallet of the University of Virginia and chemists of the State Board of Health, the water was rated of extraordinary purity—comparable to the Bethesda Springs of Waukesha, Wisconsin—and was sought after for digestive ailments, kidney complaints, and eczema, with barrels and bottles shipped across the country.
  • The Modern Bathhouse: The Minnehaha Springs Development Company encased the main fountain in a heavy concrete barrier wall to exclude surface runoff, feeding a concrete bathing reservoir and a covered bathhouse equipped with dressing rooms for ladies and gentlemen.
  • Allegheny Lodge & The Rocky Mountain Elk: In 1912, state game warden J. A. Viquesney and investors acquired the property to erect the grand Allegheny Club House (later Allegheny Lodge) overlooking Knapps Valley.
    • Viquesney established the first game preserve in West Virginia, hiring Western cowboys in 1912 to round up several dozen Rocky Mountain elk and ship them by rail to Minnehaha Springs to restore the species, which had been considered extinct in the state since 1875.
    • Luminaries including author Pearl S. Buck, Olympic gold medalist Jean-Claude Killy, and West Virginia governors William Glasscock and William MacCorkle stayed at the lodge to hunt, play golf, and take the waters. (The historic wooden lodge stood until destroyed by fire in 1983).

2. Bath Alum & The Chalybeate Waters of the Cowpasture

Five miles east of Warm Springs, at the eastern base of Warm Springs Mountain, sat Bath Alum.

  • The End of the Wagon Road: In the late 18th and early 19th centuries, when the mountain turnpike from Staunton served as the sole eastern gateway into Bath, heavy freight wagons terminated at Bath Alum; from Brinkley's Tavern at the foot of the ridge, all travel over the mountain had to be continued on packhorses.
  • The Slates of the Cowpasture: Geologically, while the thermal springs of Warm Springs Valley rise through deep limestone fault fractures, the waters of the Cowpasture basin flow through slate beds loaded with iron pyrites ("fool's gold"). The decomposition of these pyrites produced cold, astringent alum, sulfur, and chalybeate (iron) waters.
  • "Heaviest and Most Powerful": Regional chroniclers noted that alum water was the heaviest and most powerful of all mountain iron tonics—often so sour and acidic that it was disagreeable to swallow, yet prized as an appetite stimulant and tonic.
  • The Solitary Brick Hotel: In the 1850s, Bath Alum flourished as a major resort, paying $87.09 in annual resort license fees in 1856 (close behind Warm Springs' $114.59 and Hot Springs' $100.84). Because no surrounding village ever developed, the brick hotel eventually closed when an owner grew indifferent to tourism, leaving the historic structure to stand in quiet isolation among fields and mountain woods.
  • Cowpasture Sister Springs: Other noted mineral waters along the river included the sulfur baths at Millboro Springs (opened by John U. Dickenson near the railroad before 1861), the private sanitarium at Wallawhatoola, and the sulfur pool at All Healing Springs at the southern tip of Shenandoah Mountain.

3. Webster Salt Sulphur Springs: From Buffalo Lick to Courthouse Well

West across the divide on the upper forks of the Elk River lay the famous Webster Salt Sulphur Springs (at Addison, now Webster Springs):

  • The Great Buffalo Lick: Long before white settlement, massive herds of woodland bison cut deep trails across the mountains to congregate at the mineral lick at the forks of the Elk. Early border chronicles record frontiersman John Hacker pursuing wounded buffalo straight into the lick, while early captive lore told of fleeing settlers stumbling into the salty spring water that made their feet smart.
  • The Healing Salt Sulphur: The waters were heavily impregnated with sulfur and sodium chloride. As one traveler noted, when visitors stopped on the Webster County Courthouse lawn to draw a cup from the famous natural salt-sulfur well, the mineral brew carried the unmistakable odor and flavor that "some say tastes like rotten eggs".
  • The Resort Boom & The "Salt Sulphur Special": During the late 19th and early 20th centuries, grand hotels like the multi-story Webster Springs Hotel accommodated thousands of visitors seeking relief from dyspepsia and rheumatism. In later years, rail enthusiasts celebrated the town's mineral heritage by running the "Salt Sulphur Special" excursion train over the rugged mountain grades connecting Slaty Fork, Cheat Junction, and Cass.

🚂 We could explore the old stagecoach and turnpike routes that connected these springs across the Alleghenies, like the Kanawha Turnpike or the Narrows road through Huntersville.

Across the Allegheny divide, the mountain turnpikes and stagecoach roads served as the vital arteries connecting the tidewater cities of Virginia and the mineral springs of Bath with the Ohio Valley and the trans-Allegheny frontier. Long before railways crossed the ridges, these routes were crowded with four-horse stagecoaches, lumbering freight wagons, livestock droves, and pioneer caravans [49, 98–100, 165].


1. The James River & Kanawha Turnpike (The Midland Trail)

The most famous southern thoroughfare across the mountains was the James River & Kanawha Turnpike (later designated State Route 3 and the Midland Trail), spanning roughly 180 miles across West Virginia from the crest of the Alleghenies near White Sulphur Springs to the Ohio River at Guyandotte and Huntington [43–44, 59, 63]:

  • Evolution of the Trace: The highway originated as an ancient buffalo path that found a passage where the New-Kanawha River cut through the mountain barriers. It was used as an Indian warpath, then followed by General Andrew Lewis’s army marching to Point Pleasant in 1774 [42–43, 58].
  • The Stagecoach Era: By the early 19th century, it was engineered as a regular turnpike. Stagecoaches made regular runs over the mountain summits, though travel was notoriously dramatic; chroniclers noted that crossing Gauley Mountain—climbing 10 or 11 miles from Kanawha Falls to Hawk’s Nest in four hours—was the kind of driving where "it is better to hug the bank than it is to hug your companion".
  • The "Northern Route" to Kentucky: Following the Revolutionary War, emigrants from Philadelphia, Baltimore, and New York converged at Staunton and had to choose between taking the longer Wilderness Road through Cumberland Gap or turning west over the Northern Route [49–51]. Taking the Northern Route through Buffalo Gap, Warm Springs, Lewisburg, and over the Midland Trail allowed pioneers to reach the mouth of Kellys Creek (then called "Boatyard"), where they could purchase dugout canoes and float down the Kanawha and Ohio rivers [51–52].
  • The Great Mail Line: A primary line of public stagecoaches ran between Staunton and Guyandotte on the Ohio River, providing the chief passenger and mail transport between eastern Virginia and the Mississippi Valley.

2. The Warm Springs & Huntersville Turnpike Through "The Narrows"

Connecting the springs of Bath County with the county seat of Pocahontas County was the Warm Springs and Huntersville Turnpike (and its extension, the Warm Springs and Marlins Bottom Turnpike) [30, 61–62]:

  • "The Narrows" or Northwest Passage: Just east of Huntersville, where Knapps Creek cuts through the mountain barrier, the road passed through a dramatic watergap known as The Narrows (referred to by General Andrew Lewis as the "Northwest Passage"). It was considered one of only two low mountain gateways into the upper Greenbrier Valley (the other being Frost Gap).
  • The Spur Road on Knapps Creek: Before turnpike construction, the earliest pioneer track into the valley was known from old land grants as Knapp’s Spur, or the Spur Road, which crossed the Allegheny Mountains opposite the old Harper Mill. In later decades, travel through Knapps Creek gorge was shifted from the shady, ice-prone Allegheny side to the opposite bank by local builders Jacob Kernel and Andrew Daugherty to make it passable in winter.
  • Stage Stops & Civil War Defenses: The turnpike was dotted with taverns and inns. At the foot of the Allegheny Mountain, Camp Northwest was constructed on the White farm along this pike in 1861 as an elaborate Confederate camp with log barracks, stores, and blacksmith shops to guard the passage, until General Averell’s Union cavalry swept through the Narrows and burned the post in August 1863 [61–62, 72].
  • Late 19th-Century Turnpike Commerce: Ads in local newspapers like The Pocahontas Times continuously oriented travelers by their position along this route—such as the Hotel Pocahontas kept by G. W. Wagner in Huntersville, or the Mountain Grove stores advertising themselves as situated "at the foot of the Alleghany Mountain on the Warm Springs and Huntersville Turnpike" [79–83, 177–181].

3. The Staunton and Parkersburg Turnpike & Travellers Repose

Further north, the great stage highway crossing northern Pocahontas was the Staunton and Parkersburg Turnpike, engineered in the late 1830s and early 1840s under the direction of Colonel Claudius Crozet, former engineer in Napoleon’s armies:

  • The Imperial Highway: Connecting the Valley of Virginia directly with the Ohio River at Parkersburg, the pike was constructed at state expense and was widely considered one of the finest thoroughfares in the nation. It became the favored stage route for Midwestern congressmen and travelers going to Washington and Richmond who preferred an alternative to the National Pike through Pennsylvania.
  • Travellers Repose (Bartow): Where the turnpike crossed the East Fork of the Greenbrier River at the foot of Top Allegheny stood Travellers Repose [30, 33, 78–79]. Settled originally by pioneer John Yeager and operated as a tavern by Andrew Yeager, it became a legendary stagecoach stop where lines changed horses, emigrants rested their wagon teams, and famous travelers were entertained [30, 33, 76, 78–79].
  • The Turnpike as a Battlefield: Because it commanded the only graded passage across the high spruce wilderness of Cheat Mountain, the turnpike became the main axis of the western Virginia campaign in 1861. Travelers Repose became the fortified Confederate base Camp Bartow, while the Federal army entrenched 4,000 feet up at Camp Cheat Mountain Summit, fighting back and forth along the turnpike ditches throughout the war's first winter.

4. Stagecoach Travel and the "Springs Season" at Staunton

Staunton served as the great eastern terminus and staging hub for all the trans-Allegheny stage routes [49, 99–100, 127–128]:

  • The "Springs Season" Rush: During the summer rush, Staunton was described as "alive with stage coaches, besides the private carriages in which many wealthy people traveled", with vehicles drawn by four horses and staffed by liveried servants.
  • The Baltimore Bonapartes: Local chroniclers recalled that the annual return of the Baltimore Bonapartes from the mountain springs brought entire crowds of boys running into the streets to watch the procession: a two-horse lead buggy carrying gentlemen, followed by a family carriage drawn by four horses carrying the ladies and children, and a two-horse baggage wagon bringing up the rear—a display of ten horses and numerous servants.
  • Tavern Bells and Knoxville Teams: Stage travelers lodged at Staunton's famous ordinaries—the Bell, the Eagle, the Wayne, and the Washington taverns—where large bells suspended in the yards were rung twice before each meal to summon guests to the tables. Outside, the turnpikes echoed with the clatter of the "Knoxville teams"—freight wagons carrying goods to East Tennessee, their heavy draft horses decorated with chiming bells.

🛎️ We could look into the old tavern regulations and travelers' diaries along these turnpikes, like the 1775 court rates for a "warm diet with good meat" or travelers having to share beds on bearskin rugs.

 

The court order books and travelers' journals of the 18th and early 19th centuries preserve an unfiltered look into the legal regulations, prices, and rough accommodations of frontier ordinaries across the Allegheny passes:


1. The County Court Rates: Fixing the Ordinary Prices

In early Virginia, ordinaries were strictly regulated public utilities. County courts met annually to establish maximum prices that tavern-keepers were legally forbidden to exceed, and these rate sheets had to be posted openly in the public room:

  • Botetourt County Court (1775): When Botetourt’s jurisdiction spanned the Greenbrier Valley and the mountain passes to the west, the court established standard legal rates:
    • "Warm diet with good meat": 1 shilling (16⅔ cents).
    • Cold diet: 10½ cents.
    • Lodging (sleeping alone): ½ shilling (8⅓ cents).
    • Lodging (two or more sharing a bed): ⅓ shilling (5½ cents) each.
    • Pasturage or hay for 24 hours: 10½ cents.
    • Liquors: Rum, whiskey, or peach brandy was fixed at $1.00 a gallon; three pints of toddy made with half a pint of rum and "single refined sugar" cost 21 cents.
  • Augusta County Court (March 1746): Decades earlier, when Augusta County first established its court at Staunton, the justices fixed the frontier’s baseline prices:
    • Hot diet: 12½ cents.
    • Cold diet: 8⅓ cents.
    • Lodging with clean sheets: 4⅙ cents.
    • Stabling and fodder at night: 8⅓ cents.
    • Liquors: Rum at $1.50 per gallon; whiskey at $1.00 per gallon; claret at 83⅓ cents per quart.
  • Testing the Beer (1750): At the March 1750 term of the Augusta court, commissioners were officially appointed to inspect all beer sold on the courthouse grounds, ordering that "if it appear that the same is not at least one month old and well hop'd then they presume not to ask more than one penny a quart".

2. Travelers’ Realities: Sharing Beds on Bearskins and Puncheon Floors

While court records envisioned "clean sheets," travelers entering the mountains quickly discovered the reality of pioneer accommodation:

  • Sleeping on Bearskins with Hercules Wilson (1749): When two Moravian missionaries traveled on foot across Bath toward the New River in November 1749, they put up at an "English Cabin" (probably Hercules Wilson's). Finding no beds or bread in the cabin, they warmed themselves by the open hearth fire and slept side-by-side on bearskins spread directly on the floor, sharing a bit of bread and cheese they had carried with them in exchange for the family's bear meat.
  • Stepping Over Sleeping Men: During court terms, elections, or muster days, taverns and private homes along the turnpikes overflowed. At the home of Dr. Williams, which served as a campaign headquarters, the housewife was compelled for three days and nights "to step over the bodies of sleeping men, with scarce room to set her foot" as woodsmen slept crowded across the hearth and floorboards.
  • Hacker’s Packhorse "Bed": When caught in a freezing mountain storm on the Alleghenies without a fire, pioneer John Hacker improvised the ultimate shared bed: he lashed his two packhorses tightly side by side, wrapped his blankets around himself, and slept stretched across the horses' backs to absorb their body heat.

3. The Marquis de Chastellux at Mrs. Teaze’s Ordinary (1782)

When the Marquis de Chastellux traveled through western Virginia following the victory at Yorktown, Thomas Jefferson personally recommended he stop at an inn kept by Mrs. Teaze (Teas) along the South River:

  • "The Worst in All America": The Marquis recorded in his journal that Mrs. Teaze’s tavern was "one of the worst in all America".
  • The Solitary Wash-Bowl: The entire establishment—family, servants, and travelers—had to share a solitary tin vessel as the only wash-bowl.
  • Cakes on the Cinders: Hurrying down the road to find a better inn near Greenville, the party was turned away because the landlord had neither food for the men nor grain for the horses. Pushing on to a disabled soldier's mill at Midway, the guests found no spirits at all, eating a meager supper of milk, butter, and cakes baked directly upon the hot hearth cinders.

4. "Can You Pay For It? And In What?"

  • The Landlord’s Eye on Continental Money: During the Revolution, hyperinflation wrecked tavern hospitality. When young soldier William McCutchen was discharged from the army in New Jersey and walked home across Virginia with his pockets full of depreciated paper money, landlords along the road repeatedly met him at the door demanding: "Can you pay for it? And in what can you pay for it?". One suspicious landlord refused to serve him a meal for less than five dollars paper currency, while another demanded two and a half.
  • Mrs. Breckinridge’s $15 Beer: Marching toward Guilford Courthouse in 1781, young militiaman Houston recorded in his diary that after encamping at Purgatory near Buchanan, he "paid fifteen dollars for beer to Mrs. Breckinridge" (the widow of Col. Robert Breckinridge)—an expense reflecting the practically worthless state of wartime paper cash.

5. The Great Tavern Bells of the Turnpike

  • Summoning the Guests: In turnpike towns like Staunton, Warm Springs, and Lewisburg, taverns were not yet called "hotels". One indispensable fixture of every establishment was a large bell suspended in the yard or porch.
  • The Double Clatter: The bells were rung twice before every meal: first, an alert twenty to thirty minutes ahead to notify travelers and boarders to wash and get ready; and second, a final clatter summoning everyone to charge the tables. Before town clocks were installed in church steeples, these tavern bells effectively served as the community's public clock three times a day.

🎲 We could explore the colorful story of Bob Bailey, the charming gambler and ordinary-keeper in Staunton who married the Widow Bosang and operated illegal "Pharaoh Bank" tables at the Wayne Tavern.

 

The story of Robert "Bob" Bailey—and the scandal surrounding his illegal Pharaoh (Faro) Bank tables in Staunton—is one of the most entertaining chapters in the early annals of Augusta County and the Virginia turnpikes [83–87, 133–137].


1. The Making of a "Sportsman"

According to his own accounts, Bob Bailey was born in Culpeper County in 1773. His father was killed at the Revolutionary War battle of Cowpens, leaving his mother poor and throwing young Bob onto his own resources.

  • The Young Overseer: By 1791, at age eighteen, he was employed as an overseer by Major John Hays on Hays' Creek in Rockbridge County. Sent to Staunton to fetch Dr. Alexander Humphreys, Bailey was so captivated by the physician's conversation on the ride back that he resolved to move to Staunton to study medicine.
  • Dancing with the Widow Bosang: Arriving in town, Bailey attended a Washington’s Birthday ball on February 22. There, the handsome nineteen-year-old was paired in the dance with the Widow Bosang (whose late husband, John Bosang, had kept an ordinary at Main and Lewis streets). Captivated by the charming youth, the widow—then twenty-eight or thirty—agreed after a whirlwind courtship to marry him.
  • From Ordinary-Keeper to Faro Dealer: For a time, Bailey successfully ran the Bosang tavern. Seeking to expand into merchandise, he took a drove of horses to Philadelphia to barter for dry goods. In Philadelphia, he was introduced to the gaming table; utterly enchanted, he abandoned legitimate trade and spent the next twenty years running high-stakes games. He always rejected the label "gambler," insisting he was an honorable "sportsman" because “a gambler cheats and he always played fair”.

2. The Pharaoh Bank Presentment at the Wayne Tavern (1802–1803)

In September 1802, the District Court convened in Staunton with Judges St. George Tucker and Joseph Jones presiding. The Grand Jury returned a presentment charging:

“Robert Bailey, at the house of William Chambers, in Staunton, (the Wayne Tavern), was the keeper and exhibitor of a certain unlawful gaming table called Pharaoh, or Pharaoh Bank”.

  • The Trial & The Sentence: The case was tried a year later in September 1803. General Blackburn represented Bailey, while John Poage served as foreman of the petit jury that brought in a verdict of guilty.
  • The "Vagrant" Verdict: The court handed down a sentence specifically designed to humiliate the dapper high-roller:
    • Bailey was formally adjudged and treated as a vagrant.
    • He was ordered into the custody of the sheriff to be delivered to the overseers of the poor, “to be by them hired out for three months for the best wages that could be procured, for the use of the poor”.
    • He was required to post a $500 good-behavior bond lasting three years.

3. Outrage, Exile, and The 100-Guinea Bribery Charge

Hearing the verdict while hiding across the mountain in Bath County, Bailey was outraged:

  • "What a Punishment for a Gentleman!": Bailey later wrote that the thought of a gentleman of his style being hired out as a common pauper's laborer drove him “almost into a lunatic”. Unsurprisingly, he declined to turn himself in, and the authorities showed little genuine appetite to track him down and keep him around.
  • Accusing the Judge: Determined to appeal, Bailey tried to retain Philip Grymes, writing him a letter alleging that Judge St. George Tucker had offered to drop the prosecution in exchange for a bribe of one hundred guineas [84–85, 134–135]. Grymes promptly showed the letter to Judge Tucker, who laid the matter before the Virginia Legislature to demand an official inquiry to clear his name.

4. A Divided Community & The "Light Infantry Blues"

The bribery accusation split Staunton society into hostile camps [85–86, 135–136]:

  • The Establishment vs. The Sportsman: Eminent figures like General Blackburn, Judge Archibald Stuart, Alexander St. Clair, and Jacob Swoope signed testimonials defending Judge Tucker’s integrity [85–86, 135–136].
  • Bailey’s Popularity: Despite his gaming habit, Bailey was genuinely well-liked by common citizens. He was generous with his winnings, quick to help people in need, and served as Captain of the Staunton Light Infantry Blues—lauded as “the finest uniformed company west of the Blue Ridge”.
  • Running for Office: In April 1803, Bailey had actually run for the Virginia House of Delegates, winning 259 out of 564 votes. Between two and three hundred respectable citizens signed counter-petitions vouching for his fairness in business and his personal kindness.
  • The Legislative Retort: The Legislature's committee exonerated Judge Tucker. In response, Bailey published a blistering pamphlet mocking his accusers—taunting prominent men who had gladly accepted his hospitality and eaten his dinners when he was flush, while dismissing opponent Daniel Sheffey as "a little cobbler".

5. High Life at the Springs & The Escape at Rockfish Gap

  • Rolling in Splendor: Bailey took his tables on the seasonal resort circuit, establishing headquarters at the Sweet Springs and operating across Richmond, Washington, Baltimore, Philadelphia, Charleston, and New Orleans. When flush, he traveled with liveried outriders and coaches, scattering gold to all who asked; when busted, he relied on fellow gamblers to grubstake him for another run. He even ran for Congress in the Botetourt district, claiming he came within three votes of winning.
  • The 1818 Ambush in Court: Fifteen years later, around 1818, Bailey slipped back into Staunton to sell subscriptions for his published memoirs. Boldly strolling into the courthouse, he was spotted from the bench by Judge Archibald Stuart, who immediately recognized the old offender and ordered the sheriff to arrest him on the 1803 warrant.
  • The Widow Mitchell’s Getaway: Bailey bolted from the room and sprinted out of town to the country tavern of the Widow Mitchell on the Winchester road. While the sheriff was scouring the lower Valley, the widow helped Bailey slip over Rockfish Gap, allowing the old sportsman to vanish once more into the Blue Ridge.

🐎 We could look into the old horse racing tracks and betting grounds around early Staunton and the Greenbrier Valley, where planters and tavern-keepers matched their thoroughbreds for heavy purses.

 

In the late 18th and early 19th centuries, horse racing was deeply ingrained in the sporting culture of western Virginia, spanning the Valley of Virginia at Staunton and the limestone grazing pastures of Greenbrier County:


1. The Racing Culture of Early Staunton (1797)

When the French traveler and philanthropist François Alexandre Frédéric, Duke de La Rochefoucauld-Liancourt, visited Staunton in 1797, he observed that the population was passionately devoted to turf sports:

  • A Passion for Wagers: Rochefoucault recorded that the inhabitants, “like the generality of Virginians, were fond of gambling and betting”.
  • "Two Miserable Horse Races": During his stay at a local inn, the Frenchman personally witnessed two horse races held near town, though coming from European aristocratic circuits, he somewhat dismissively described them as “two miserable horse races”.
  • The Sporting Terminus: At the time, Staunton’s inns were filled with travelers, land speculators, and wealthy planters passing back and forth between Richmond, Baltimore, and the healing mineral springs of Bath and Greenbrier, creating an eager audience of bettors and horse traders.
  • The Fairgrounds Track on Lewis’ Creek (1868): Organized agricultural and turf exhibitions were later formalized when the Augusta County Fair was incorporated in 1867 and opened its grounds in October 1868 along Lewis' Creek, one mile east of Staunton, featuring public exhibition tracks and livestock rings.

2. The Greenbrier Valley: Thoroughbred Pastures & Traveler

While the rougher mountainous hollows relied on draft teams, the open limestone savannas of the Greenbrier Valley—specifically the Big Levels of Greenbrier and the Little Levels of Pocahontas—were renowned throughout Virginia for producing world-class saddle and race stock:

  • The Nursery of Famed Horses: Chroniclers noted that no finer horse country existed west of the Blue Ridge. It was here that Traveler, General Robert E. Lee’s famed grey war horse, was foaled in the Little Levels of Pocahontas and developed into maturity in the Big Levels of Greenbrier, leading local writers to boast that “this region has produced its thousands like unto the far famed Traveler”.
  • The Main Street "Horse Race" of 1862: During the Civil War, the sporting reputation of Lewisburg took an involuntary turn. In May 1862, when Federal troops under Captain Powell charged into town and pursued retreating Confederate cavalry down the turnpike, regional historian Andrew Price noted with dry humor that “about daylight on that morning the people of Lewisburg were treated to a horse race on Main Street, the Confederate cavalry fleeing before the Federal horsemen... kept up to within a mile of White Sulphur Springs”.
  • The Little Levels Horse Show: By the early 20th century, the traditional matching of bloodstock evolved into celebrated community exhibitions like the Annual Pocahontas County Horse Show held at Hillsboro in the Little Levels, where farmers and horsemen showed off driving horses, saddle stock, and thoroughbred studs.

3. Betting the Long Shots: The Story of "Trifle" and "Black Maria"

In early Virginia sporting memoirs preserved in the chronicles (such as Philip Pendleton Kennedy’s Blackwater Chronicle), mountain travelers and tavern guests recounted the high-stakes wagers placed on the great regional intersectional races of the era [153–155]:

  • The Upset at the Central Club: Old-timers recalled the heyday of the Central Club, when Stevens’s celebrated mare Black Maria had decisively defeated her Southern rivals in the premier contest of the season.
  • Colonel Johnson’s Long Shot: The following day, Colonel Johnson entered an unheralded, young, and largely unknown Virginia mare named Trifle against the Northern champion.
  • "Heads and Tails" Philosophy: Amid heavy wagering and roaring hotel crowds, a legendary bettor named Davy backed Trifle and cleaned up, lecturing the crestfallen losers at the tavern bar on his ironclad betting philosophy:

    “Whenever you want to bet your money upon a race, or cock-fight at faro, or 'sweat,' or 'double O,' or anything at all at which gentlemen pleasure themselves, find out the general opinion, and put up your money against it, as I did on the Virginia mare on principle, and you'll double your pile!”.


🃏 We could explore how early county courts cracked down on other illicit tavern sports that flourished alongside race betting, like cockfighting and dice rolling at militia muster camps.

Frontier courts, military tribunals, and church sessions across the Virginia border took a stern—and occasionally ironic—hand in punishing unlawful sports, gaming, and public disorder [80–82, 85–87, 230–231, 236]:


1. The Ducking Stool: An "Irish Blunder" in Staunton

  • The 1751 Court Order: On August 29, 1751, the Augusta County Court entered a solemn order:

    "Ordered that the sheriff employ a workman to make a ducking stool for the use of the county according to law, and bring in his charge at laying the next county levy". Under an act of Assembly passed in 1705, ducking was the prescribed statutory punishment for women convicted as "common scolds".

  • The Scold and the Justice: Soon after the stool was constructed, a local woman named Anne Brown marched directly into open court and verbally assaulted Justice William Wilson, calling him a "rogue" and declaring that "on his coming off the bench she would give it to him with the devil" [85–86, 230–231]. Mrs. Brown was hauled into custody, but historians searching the order books found that she was never ducked [85–86, 230–231].
  • No Deep Water: As county historian Joseph Waddell noted, the court certainly lacked no stomach for physical punishment—they regularly whipped offenders and even cited eminent attorney Gabriel Jones for swearing. The failure to use the machine was simply an "Irish blunder":

    "Having provided a jail, stocks, whipping post, shackles, etc.—all the means and appliances necessary in a well-ordered community—they ordered a ducking stool without reflecting that there was no water deep enough for its use within reach of the court-house".

  • Frontier Military Ducking: Where deep water was available, officers used the punishment without hesitation. In October 1755, while marching from Fort Dinwiddie on Jackson’s River toward Fort Cumberland, Major Andrew Lewis ordered two women ducked after catching them in the act of plundering abandoned settler cabins along the frontier.

2. The Public Whipping Post and Gallows

Behind the Augusta County courthouse, at the rear of the open town market shed on Augusta Street, stood the whipping post and pillory:

  • Lashes on the Bare Back: Sentences to the whipping post were standard for minor felonies, petty thefts, and moral offenses. In February 1751, the court presented Catherine Cole for having a child out of wedlock; upon her refusal to pay the required fine or post security, the justices ordered that she "receive on her bare back at the public whipping post of this county twenty lashes well laid on", commanding the sheriff to execute the flogging immediately.
  • The Devoted Husband (1776): In December 1776, Mary Wolfinger was convicted of felony and agreed to corporal punishment rather than be sent eastward to Williamsburg for trial [92–93, 240]. When the court sentenced her to receive twenty lashes on her bare back, her husband stepped forward and declared himself "the capital on the offence whereof she is convicted," begging the justices that the lashes be laid upon him instead. The court granted his request, and he took the flogging.
  • "Gallowstown" & Horse Theft: Capital punishment was enforced for property crimes like horse stealing [148, 245–247, 283]. In October 1793, John Bullitt was convicted of stealing a gray horse and goods worth $116.66 from John Nichols. The court ordered the sheriff to erect a gallows at the northern fork of Augusta and New streets. Bullitt was hanged on October 18, giving that entire quarter of Staunton the enduring name "Gallowstown" [246–247, 274–275].

3. Suppressing Dice, Cards, and "Disguised" Soldiers at Musters

Taverns and muster fields were notorious hotspots for illicit gaming, brawling, and drunken wagers:

  • Governor Dinwiddie's Directives (1755): When authorizing Captain Peter Hogg’s ranger company under Major Lewis, Governor Dinwiddie explicitly commanded:

    "Recommend morality and sobriety to all the people, with a due submission and regard to Providence. Let swearing, private quarrels, drunkenness and gaming be strictly forbidden".

  • Cutting off the Rum Rations (1779): During the Revolutionary War, officers had to take severe measures when soldiers drew liquor allowances before muster parades. In October 1779, Captain Gamble noted in his order book that soldiers caught "disguised with liquor either on or off duty" would have their daily rum ration cut off for two weeks, with repeat offenders remanded to court-martial. Soldiers convicted of roll-call absence, fighting, and petty theft were routinely sentenced to between 50 and 100 lashes.
  • Gaming at Encampments: When surveyors, chain-bearers, and axemen ran the boundary lines in 1746, card and dice bets were common around the tavern tents; at Lockhart’s encampment, an argument over a game led one camper to wager a Spanish silver dollar ("piece of eight") to fight another man, landing the dispute before an Orange County magistrate.
  • Sleeping Through the Cards: Even judges found themselves powerless against late-night dice and cards. When Judge Archibald Stuart presided over the Bath County court, he was kept awake in his tavern room all night by the clicking of cards and chips from attorneys playing in the adjacent bedchamber. When the grand jury dutifully filed in the next morning reporting "no presentments," the exasperated judge gave them a blistering public scolding for ignoring the illegal games.

4. Profanity and Contempt in the Courtroom

Colonial courts guarded their dignity with stocks and heavy fines:

  • The Stocks for "Damning the Court": In 1746, the Augusta court ordered that Edward Boyle, "for damning the court and swearing four oaths in their presence, be put in the stocks for two hours, and be fined twelve shillings" ($2.00).
  • Cursing the Royal Governor (1756): In 1756, frontiersman Francis Farguson was arrested under warrant "for damning Robert Dinwiddie, Esq., for a Scotch peddling son of a b—", escaping severe punishment only after offering a full public apology and posting a good-behavior peace bond.
  • Silencing Lawyers: The Augusta justices took order so seriously that at their very first session in February 1746, they ordered that "any attorney interrupting another at the bar, or speaking when he is not employed, forfeit five shillings".

5. Church Sessions: Cracking Down on Fiddling, Dancing, and Sunday Horse Trading

Where the civil magistrates stopped, the Presbyterian church sessions stepped in, haling members before church tribunals for secular amusements:

  • Ellen Hanes and the Bradshaw Dance (1837): At Hillsboro, the Session of the Oak Grove Church summoned young Ellen Hanes, who appeared before pastor Joseph Brown to make "satisfactory acknowledgments of regret for having engaged in a dance at Thomas Bradshaw's".
  • Thomas Bradshaw’s Second Offense (1839): Host Thomas Bradshaw was censured for tolerating the dance and for "selling a horse in Huntersville on the Sabbath day". Two years later, when Bradshaw permitted another dance at his home on the Fourth of July for his daughter's wedding—arguing that dancing was the "least of two evils" that might happen—the Session refused his excuse and formally suspended him from church communion.
  • The Huntersville Knife Affray (1836): When prominent surveyor Sampson L. Mathews got into an affray on the street in Huntersville with John Graham—where the two men called each other liars, shook fists, and drew hunting knives—the Oak Grove Session summoned Mathews for unchristian conduct and excommunicated him from church fellowship until he formally repented [39–40, 64–65, 212–213].

⚖️ We could examine the unusual 1775 trial in Staunton over the slaying of Chief Cornstalk's son and the frontier proclamation where "no witness volunteered" to testify against the rangers.

The historical episode surrounding the murder of Shawnee sachem Cornstalk and his son Ellinipsico took place not in 1775, but in November 1777, with the subsequent examination held in April and May 1778.

Furthermore, while Staunton was the mother courthouse of the frontier, the proceedings were conducted before the newly created Rockbridge County Court (which had just been formed from Augusta and Botetourt), because the accused rifle company hailed from the Kerr’s Creek settlements.

The records preserve a stark portrait of frontier vengeance, military defiance, and an examination that border historians frankly described as a "farce of justice".


1. Hostages at Fort Randolph (1777)

In late 1777, Cornstalk—who had commanded the Indian confederacy at Point Pleasant in 1774 and scrupulously maintained his treaty with Virginia—arrived at Fort Randolph (Point Pleasant) accompanied by the Delaware chief Red Hawk [54, 66, 103, 171–172].

He came to deliver an honest warning to the garrison commander, Captain Matthew Arbuckle: British agents at Detroit were distributing arms and inciting the tribes, and Cornstalk warned that unless Virginia acted to protect the peace, the Shawnee would be compelled to "go with the stream".

Rather than allowing him to return, Arbuckle detained Cornstalk, Red Hawk, and another companion as hostages. During their confinement, officers held long, cordial conversations with the chief. One afternoon, while Cornstalk was sketching a map of the territory between the Mississippi and Missouri rivers on the cabin floor, a voice shouted from across the Ohio River. It was his son, Ellinipsico, who, anxious over his father’s long absence, had traveled hundreds of miles through the wilderness to seek him out.


2. The Gilmore Ambush and the Kerr's Creek Cry

The following morning, two young riflemen belonging to Captain James Hall’s company of Rockbridge volunteers—named Robert Gilmore and Hamilton—crossed the Kanawha River in a canoe on a hunting excursion.

As they returned to the riverbank, Indians concealed in the brush fired upon them, killing and scalping Gilmore. Hamilton was rescued, and soldiers paddled across to haul Gilmore’s mutilated body back to the garrison.

The sight of Gilmore's scalp ignited a frenzy:

  • Gilmore's family had been among the victims of the infamous Kerr’s Creek massacres in Rockbridge, which settlers believed Cornstalk had personally led years before.
  • The cry instantly rang through the cantonment: "Let us kill the Indians in the fort!".
  • Captain James Hall placed himself at the head of his infuriated men and marched on the council house.
  • When Captain Arbuckle and Captain John Stuart of Greenbrier stepped between the mob and the door to forbid the act, Hall’s men cocked their rifles and threatened instant death to any officer who stood in their way [67, 104, 176–177].

3. The Death of the Chiefs

Inside the cabin, the interpreter’s wife ran to warn the captives. Ellinipsico was accused of bringing the hostile raiders with him, an allegation he vehemently denied.

Seeing his son tremble, Cornstalk encouraged him with remarkable composure:

"My son, the Great Spirit has seen fit that we should die together, and has sent you here to that end. It is His will and let us submit; it is all for the best." [138, 177–178].

Cornstalk rose, walked toward the doorway to face the mob, and was struck by seven rifle balls, falling lifeless without a groan. Ellinipsico met his death sitting calmly in his chair. Red Hawk attempted to climb up the fireplace chimney but was pulled down and shot, while their fourth companion was slaughtered by the enraged soldiers.


4. The 1778 Courtroom Farce: "No Witness Volunteered"

When word of the murder reached Williamsburg, Governor Patrick Henry and the Virginia Executive were appalled, fearful that the slaughter of peaceful envoys would unleash a devastating war along the entire border. The Executive ordered criminal proceedings against the ringleaders.

The trial was convened before the Rockbridge County Court on April 18 and May 5, 1778:

  • The Arraignment: Captain James Hall and his subaltern Hugh Galbraith were brought before the magistrates "upon a charge of suspicion of being guilty of the killing of Cornstalk and two other Indians in November, 1777".
  • The Plea: Both men entered pleas denying their guilt.
  • The Proclamation at the Door: Under the strict rules of the court, the commonwealth required sworn eyewitness testimony to hold the accused for the General Court in Richmond.

    "On both occasions the sheriff made proclamation at the door of the courthouse for all persons who could give evidence in behalf of the commonwealth against the accused to come forward and testify" [69, 106, 155–156].

  • The Silence of the Frontier: The sheriff shouted the summons into the courthouse yard, but not a single soul stepped forward.

Every soldier in the garrison knew exactly what had happened, and dozens had watched Hall lead the charge. Yet amidst the ongoing Revolutionary War and deep border hostility, no frontiersman would turn state’s evidence against a neighboring militia captain for killing Indians.

With no witnesses answering the proclamation, the magistrates entered an immediate verdict of acquittal, and Hall and Galbraith walked out of court free men [69, 106, 139, 155–156].


🏹 The murder directly provoked the Shawnee invasion of 1778, when warriors marched across the mountains to avenge Cornstalk by laying siege to Fort Donnally in the Greenbrier Valley. We could explore how Dick Pointer and Philip Hammond saved the settlement during that dawn attack.

 

The siege of Fort Donnally in May 1778 was the direct sequel to the murder of Cornstalk at Point Pleasant [29–31]. Seeking revenge, a large Shawnee force marched eastward to wipe out the Greenbrier settlements, leading to one of the most celebrated defensive stands on the Virginia frontier [29–31, 182–187].


1. The Warning: Pryor and Hammond’s Desperate Race

In May 1778, an Indian army numbering over two hundred warriors appeared before Fort Randolph (Point Pleasant) [30–32, 182, 187]. Failing to draw the garrison into an ambuscade, they besieged the stockade for a week, then slaughtered cattle and marched eastward up the Kanawha toward the unsuspecting settlements of the Greenbrier Valley.

  • The Volunteers: Garrison commander Captain William McKee knew the Greenbrier country was doomed unless warned. Two initial couriers turned back in despair when they saw how thick the warriors were in the woods. McKee then asked the garrison who would risk his life to carry the alarm. Philip Hammond and John Pryor stepped forward.
  • Disguised by the Grenadier Squaw: To give them a chance of passing through the warrior lines, Nonhelema (the sister of Cornstalk, known to settlers as the Grenadier Squaw, who remained friendly to the Americans) painted their faces in warrior colors and dressed them in Indian fashion.
  • Overtaking the War Party: Traveling day and night at top speed, Hammond and Pryor pushed through the wilderness, overtook and slipped past the dispersed Indian vanguard around Meadow River (near Rainelle), and reached Fort Donnally (the frontier post situated about eight or ten miles north of modern Lewisburg) at sunset [30–31, 74, 182].

2. Preparing the Stronghold & The Water Hogshead

Upon their arrival, Colonel Andrew Donnelly sent messengers to assemble the scattered farm families of the neighborhood and dispatched a courier to warn Captain John Stuart at Fort Savannah (now Lewisburg).

Knowing from Point Pleasant how quickly a garrison could be brought to surrender by thirst, Pryor and Hammond warned Donnelly to secure water immediately. A heavy hogshead was filled with water and rolled behind the door of the log kitchen, which adjoined the main two-story dwelling house.

Twenty-one men—along with women and children—were gathered inside the fort that night [31–32, 187].


3. The Dawn Assault: The Woodpile Ambush

At daybreak the following morning, John Pritchet, a servant or hand working for Donnelly, stepped outside into the yard to fetch firewood from the woodpile.

  • Warriors concealed nearby fired upon Pritchet, fatally wounding him.
  • As Pritchet ran toward the building, the Indians charged into the yard in force and rushed the kitchen door, attempting to batter it down with their tomahawks.

4. Philip Hammond and Dick Pointer at the Kitchen Door

Inside the kitchen room were only two men: Philip Hammond and Dick Pointer, an enslaved Black man belonging to Colonel Donnelly.

  • The Battle at the Door: The Indians began chopping through the heavy door planks with hatchets. Seeing that the wood would quickly give way, Hammond realized that barricading alone would fail. With Dick Pointer's assistance, Hammond rolled the heavy water hogshead slightly back and threw the door wide open.
  • The Musket Loaded with Swan Shot:
    • Hammond leveled his rifle and shot dead the lead warrior standing on the threshold.
    • Hammond had handed Dick Pointer a heavy musket loaded to the muzzle with "swan shot" (coarse buckshot). Pointer stepped to the opening and fired point-blank into the crowd of warriors pressing into the yard.
    • The blast tore into the attackers, checking their advance and sending them scrambling behind outbuildings and fences. (A war club with one of Pointer's swan shot embedded in it was later recovered in the yard).
  • Waking the Garrison: The roar of Hammond’s rifle and Pointer’s musket inside the kitchen alerted the sleeping men in the main house. Settlers scrambled to the upstairs rifle portholes and opened a steady, plunging fire into the yard, leaving seventeen warriors dead before the assault was broken.

5. The Rye Field Relief: Stuart and Lewis

Hearing the distant crack of musketry, Captain John Stuart and Colonel Samuel Lewis (son of Gen. Andrew Lewis) assembled a relief company of sixty-six men at Fort Savannah.

  • Avoiding the main road—where they correctly suspected the Indians had set an ambush—Stuart’s men cut through the woods and approached Fort Donnally through an adjoining field of tall rye around 2:00 in the afternoon [31, 185–186].
  • Spotting the Indians watching the fort, Stuart and Charles Gatliff fired into them, and the relief force charged across the yard into the stockade under a heavy volley, entering without losing a man.

Around dusk, a warrior hailed the fort in broken English calling out, "We want peace," but when invited to step inside, he declined, and the war party withdrew into the forest, dragging away their wounded.


6. Dick Pointer's Legacy

The defense of the kitchen door made Dick Pointer a frontier legend:

  • Frontier Retellings: Decades later, schoolchildren in Lewisburg would gather around to hear "Old Dick" and "Old Pool" (Col. John Stuart's servant at Point Pleasant) trade stories, with Pointer boasting with mountain exaggeration that he had "killed Indians as high as the court house" [155–156].
  • Freedom and Pension: Recognizing that his courage had saved the lives of every family in the fort, the Virginia General Assembly granted Dick Pointer his freedom and awarded him an annual state pension.

🏡 The year following Fort Donnally, a raiding party struck the upper Greenbrier at Marlins Bottom, where scout John Pryor met a tragic fate while traveling with his family near Mill Point [31–32]. We could explore that raid and the early defenses around Jacob Marlin’s old settlement.

The raid of 1779—striking the upper Greenbrier Valley around Marlins Bottom and Mill Point—marked one of the most tragic chapters in the border warfare of what is now Pocahontas County [20, 161–164]. Occurring the year following the attack on Fort Donnally, it was the last major hostile incursion into the Greenbrier settlements.


1. Jacob Marlin and the Beginnings at Marlins Bottom (1749–1751)

The earliest English settlement on the Western Waters began around 1749, when Jacob Marlin and Stephen Sewell crossed the mountains from Frederick County and built a cabin where Knapps Creek empties into the Greenbrier River.

  • The Cabin and the Sycamore: Finding that they could not agree—particularly over theological arguments—they separated: Marlin lived in the log cabin, while Sewell took up residence a short distance away inside the hollow of a giant sycamore tree.
  • Andrew Lewis’s 1751 Arrival: In April 1751, General Andrew Lewis, surveying for the Greenbrier Company, found them living amicably apart. Lewis surveyed a prime boundary of 480 acres around Marlins Bottom (the site of modern Marlinton).
  • Sewell’s Fate & Marlin’s Survival: Sewell moved forty miles west to Sewell Mountain, where he was eventually killed by Indians. Marlin remained, surviving the French and Indian War, and died on the Greenbrier, leaving descendants in the county.

2. Early Strongholds: Fort Greenbrier & The Narrows Route

  • Fort Greenbrier (1755): Following Braddock’s defeat in 1755, Andrew Lewis garrisoned a frontier post known as Fort Greenbrier at Marlins Bottom to protect pioneer cabins, though settlers regularly had to fall back across the Alleghenies to Fort Dinwiddie on Jackson's River.
  • The 1755 & 1756 Raids: On August 12, 1755, raiders struck Marlins Bottom, killing and capturing eighteen people. In September 1756, another party retreated through the Narrows of Knapps Creek past Marlin's Ford, where pursuing militia discovered the body of a murdered infant buried near the present courthouse hill and rescued young Joseph Mayse when a grapevine pulled him from his horse [30–31].

3. The 1779 Incursion: The 22 Warriors

In 1779, anticipating widespread operations across the western border, a war party of twenty-two warriors was dispatched into the upper Greenbrier Valley to scout its defenses and plunder the frontier [161–162].

  • The Slaying of Baker and the Prized Fence: The party struck first near the home of Lawrence Drinnon, a few miles above the Little Levels. Early in the morning, Henry Baker and Richard Hill went to the river to wash. The warriors fired, killing Baker, while Hill scrambled back into the house. Because Baker fell close to a fence within rifle range of Drinnon’s cabin, the warriors were afraid to climb over; instead, they prized up the bottom rail with a pole, slipped a noose over Baker's neck, dragged his body down the riverbank, and scalped him.
  • Hugh McIver Killed: Moving down the valley, the party attacked the home of Hugh McIver, killing him and taking his wife captive.
  • Thirteen Victims in the Neighborhood: Regional histories note that across this upper Greenbrier raid, thirteen persons were killed in the neighborhood, among them John and James Bridger.

4. The Tragic Fate of John Pryor near Mill Point

Shortly after leaving McIver’s, the war party crossed the trail of John Pryor, who, along with Philip Hammond, had become famous the year before for volunteering to run from Point Pleasant to save Fort Donnally [19–20, 163].

  • Traveling with His Family: Pryor was moving along the trail near Mill Point toward the south side of the Kanawha River, accompanied by his wife and infant child.
  • Shot Through the Breast: The warriors fired from ambush, shooting Pryor directly through the chest.
  • The Hand-to-Hand Struggle: Despite being mortally wounded, Pryor stood his ground, desperate to protect his wife and child. When an Indian closed in and seized him, Pryor summoned his remaining strength and grappled with his attacker, overpowering him and breaking free while the other warriors looked on without interfering.
  • The Trap: Seeing that the Indians were not immediately harming his wife or baby, Pryor turned and walked away unmolested. Chroniclers noted that the war party deliberately allowed him to leave, expecting he would seek help from the nearest settlement and give them a chance to ambush any rescue party.
  • Death in the Settlements: Pryor staggered into the nearest cabins and gasped out what had occurred before dying that same night.
  • The Lost Captives: A rescue party never overtook the raiders. Mrs. Pryor and the infant were never heard of again, presumed murdered along the trail when they could no longer keep pace with the warriors' retreat.

5. The End of the Incursions

Before leaving the valley, the warriors captured Mrs. Thomas Drinnon, Mrs. Smith, and a child, and murdered an elderly settler named Monday and his wife.

This bloodshed marked the final hostile Indian raid into the Greenbrier settlements. Although fighting continued along the Ohio and Monongahela rivers for over a decade, the Greenbrier Valley remained free from further invasion, allowing settlements like Marlins Bottom and Mill Point to develop into permanent communities.


🌲 We could look into the later story of Marlins Bottom during the Civil War, when Confederate winter cabins were burned and the covered bridge became a contested crossing during Averell's raid.

During the Civil War, Marlins Bottom (modern Marlinton) became a strategic gateway and fortified military depot on the Greenbrier River [25–26, 41, 74]. The intersection of the Huttonsville Turnpike, the Huntersville Road, and the covered bridge built across the Greenbrier in 1851 made the settlement a natural choke point and target during cavalry campaigns [41, 69, 73–74, 80].

The chronicles preserve two major episodes concerning the covered bridge, the burning of Confederate quarters, and the marches of General William W. Averell:


1. Fortified Camps & The "Battle of Minie Balls" (January 3, 1862)

  • The Bridgehead Fortifications: Marlins Bottom was heavily fortified to protect the approaches against Federal invasion from the north. An earthwork embankment crowned with a cannon stood atop the rise dropping down to the bridgehead, while on the eastern bank, rifle trenches stretched along the river bank, flanked by another cannon near the Marlin ford.
  • The Winter Camps: By the winter of 1861–1862, Confederate companies were established in winter quarters. One unit camped on the "Ingen Patch" (later the tannery site), while a Louisiana company set up on the west bank of the river on the Price plantation, where soldiers felled almost every tree on the farm except a walnut and a hickory that the children begged the colonel to spare.
  • Major Webster’s Surprise Attack: On January 2–3, 1862, Major George Webster led 738 Federal troops (including the 25th Ohio, 2nd West Virginia, and Bracken’s cavalry) across Elk Mountain [26, 76–78]. Reaching Stony Creek, Webster sent his cavalry galloping down the east bank of the Greenbrier.
  • Retreat Across the Bridge: The charging cavalry cut off the Confederate defenders from behind. The Confederates stampeded across the covered bridge to the west side and scattered into the hills, while Webster advanced and captured Huntersville [26, 80–82]. Local historian Andrew Price noted with dry humor that while the bottom was "sowed with minie balls" and the racket was terrible, the engagement produced no casualties on either side—"at Marlins Bottom all that they lost was their wind".

2. Averell’s 1863 Campaign: Burning the Winter Cabins

By late autumn of 1863, Marlins Bottom was once again selected as a major winter cantonment for Confederate forces:

  • Colonel Arnett’s Log Quarters: Colonel W. W. Arnett established his regiment at Marlins Bottom, constructing comfortable log cabins across the bottoms in preparation for spending the winter.
  • Averell’s Pincer & The Price Hill Barricade: On Wednesday, November 4, 1863, General Averell swept south from Huntersville to cut off Arnett [25, 27, 60–62].
    • Arnett evacuated Marlins Bottom at sunset "by the skin of his teeth", sending a courier to Captain Marshall at Edray to take the back mountain road.
    • To slow the Union pursuit, Arnett’s men cut trees across the pike on Price Hill and dug out portions of the roadbed on the sliding mountain slope.
  • Occupying and Torching the Cabins: At dusk that same Wednesday, Federal cavalry under Colonel Ohley rode into Marlins Bottom and occupied the deserted Confederate log cabins. On Thursday, before advancing south toward Mill Point and the decisive engagement at Droop Mountain, the Federal troops burned the Confederate winter cabins to the ground.
  • The Preserved Fire Wall: Decades later, local historian Andrew Price recorded that the stone fire wall of one of those burned Confederate winter cabins stood preserved in his own front yard, guarded by his family along with a large military machete excavated from the site.

3. The Covered Bridge: The Loopholes & Grandma Price’s Fire Bucket

The 1851 covered wooden bridge survived repeated crossings by both armies [41, 73–74]:

  • The Sharpshooters' Loopholes: Confederate soldiers cut firing loopholes directly through the wooden walls of the bridge to command the river crossing. Years after the war, Andrew Price encountered Confederate veteran James Schisler of Greenbrier County walking the bridge, carefully inspecting the wooden planks to find the specific loophole he had manned during the war.
  • The Attempted Burning: Armies routinely crossed the bridge during low water without incident, but during one raid in high water, soldiers kindled a fire directly on the bridge timbers to cut the crossing behind them. The historic span was saved when Andrew Price’s grandmother, Mrs. Margaret Poage Price, rushed out with water, successfully scattering and putting out the flames before the bridge could ignite.
  • Averell’s Tense Retreat (December 1863): Following the Salem Raid in mid-December 1863, Averell retreated through Pocahontas in freezing winter weather, closely pursued by Confederate divisions [19–20, 23]. Fearing a Confederate ambush at Marlins Bottom where the turnpike from the east came in, Union troops approached the bridge in absolute silence and extreme tension. Prisoners noted that "when the bridge at that place had been safely passed their spirits rose and they seemed to be freed from all fear of being captured".

🪖 We could explore the Battle of Duncan’s Lane on Stony Creek in 1864, where Union State Guards and Confederate scouts clashed in an apple orchard over a commandeered bee gum.

The Battle of Duncan’s Lane (fought on Wednesday, November 6, 1864—the first anniversary of the Battle of Droop Mountain) is one of the most remarkable, grassroots Civil War engagements in West Virginia history [15, 21, 84–85].

Ignored by official military compilations, it was chronicled by local historian Andrew Price from interviews with surviving participants on both sides, including Union soldier Peter McCarty and Confederate scout Godfrey Geiger [58–59, 73, 81].


1. The Lincoln Presidential Election Mission

In the autumn of 1864, the preservation of the Union hung on the re-election of Abraham Lincoln, and state authorities felt that every single vote across the border counties mattered.

  • While most of Pocahontas County was ardently Confederate, the mountain community of Edray remained steadfastly loyal to the Union.
  • The West Virginia state authorities determined to conduct a legal presidential election in Pocahontas County. To protect the ballot, a company of the West Virginia State Guards (a regiment formed at Buckhannon and headquartered at Beverly) was ordered to march across the mountains.
  • Under the command of Captain Samuel Young (a minister) and Captain Isaac Walton Allen, the guard company marched on foot 54 miles from Beverly to Edray by way of the headwaters of Elk River.
  • On Monday, November 4, the troops reached Edray (where a soldier named Washington Neff had been captured and killed while attempting to escape), and on Tuesday, November 5, they successfully held the presidential election.

2. Buck’s Mountain and the Commandeered Bee Gum

Fearing that regular Confederate forces or local bushwhackers would ambush them if they retreated down the main road, the Union company withdrew under cover of darkness:

  • Climbing Buck’s Mountain: They slipped up Price Run, scaled the grasslands of Buck’s Mountain, and lay down in the brush near the timbered crest to sleep in the freezing cold without lighting a campfire.
  • Breakfast on Dry Run: Before daybreak on Wednesday, November 6, they marched down to the head of Dry Run and stopped at the home of Peter Beverage, a known Union man, who fed them.
  • The Confederate Brother’s Honey: They next proceeded across to the farm of William Beverage, who was Peter Beverage's brother but a strong Confederate sympathizer and non-combatant. Feeling safe from pursuit, the hungry soldiers decided to help themselves to an early midday meal:
    • Finding William Beverage's bee yard heavy with autumn honey, the soldiers forced Beverage to hand over buckets and proceeded to commandeer a bee gum (hive).
    • They gathered in the yard and open ground, filling their pails with sweet comb for their lunch.

3. The Confederate Muster at the Mouth of Stony Creek

News of the Union election expedition had quickly alerted the local Southern defenders:

  • Captain J. C. Gay’s Call: Captain J. C. Gay, holding a Confederate commission to guard the border, made his headquarters at his farm at the mouth of Stony Creek. He issued an immediate call for all regular Confederate soldiers home on furlough and local scouts to assemble.
  • The Furlough Soldiers: Among those answering the summons were brothers Godfrey and Adam Geiger of Stony Bottom, who arrived at Gay’s late on election evening. Gay assembled roughly seventeen men (including James Shannon, Jacob Simmons, Michael Willerton—a one-armed veteran—Charles Jackson, and several McLaughlins).
  • Tracking by the Honey Trail: Moving out before daybreak, Gay's men followed the tracks of the State Guards up Buck’s Mountain. They were attempting to get bread at William Kinnison’s when they heard distant shooting at Peter Beverage’s. Pressing through the autumn woods, they broke into the clearing around William Beverage’s farm and spotted the Union bluecoats roughly 300 yards away in the very act of robbing the bee gum [16, 78–79].

4. The Ambush in Duncan’s Lane

Captain Gay gave the order to fire, letting off a crashing volley at 300 yards:

  • Scattering for Cover: The blast shattered the honey feast, sending the bluecoats scrambling down the hollow. Some took to the steep hillsides, others took cover behind the knoll where the West Union schoolhouse stood, and a large party sprinted down Duncan's Lane—a passway fenced on both sides leading between William Beverage's and the double log house of Henry Duncan on the headwaters of Stony Creek [15–16, 74, 79].
  • The Shootout at the Double Log House: Captain Young took cover in the open passage between the two sections of Henry Duncan’s log house. Confederate rifleman Godfrey Geiger, armed with an army musketoon firing paper cartridges, drew a bead on Young and fired. The bullet tore the coat clean across Captain Young’s chest without breaking the skin.
  • Aaron Moore and the Election Returns: Private Aaron Moore, carrying the precious packet of presidential election returns, bolted up the open hillside. Godfrey Geiger later admitted he had Moore dead in his sights and could have killed him easily, but held his fire because Moore was dressed in civilian clothes, and the mountain code forbade shooting any man not in uniform.
  • Mortally Wounding Bernard Sharp: During the firefight, Bernard Sharp (son of William Sharp of Elk) stood behind an apple tree returning fire with a mountain rifle. A Confederate ball struck him through both hips.

5. Stalemate, Cave Refuge, and The Replaced Bee Gum

For about an hour and a half, the two small forces kept up a steady duel from behind fences, trees, and log corners. Because neither side dared to mount an open charge across the lane, the engagement settled into a standoff:

  • The Union Withdrawal: Captain Young’s guards gradually withdrew in small squads through the woods, carrying their wounded and safely spiriting the Lincoln election returns all the way back to Beverly.
  • Concealed in Red Knob Cave: The wounded Union men—including Moffett Walton, John E. Adkison, William Kennison, James L. Rodgers, John Armstrong, and Moffett Sharp (who was shot in the mouth)—were carried to a secluded limestone cave under the shadow of Red Knob near James McClure’s, where the sympathetic McClure family hid and nursed them in secret.
  • Caring for Bernard Sharp: The Confederates carried the dying Bernard Sharp into Henry Duncan’s home and sent for a doctor, but the young soldier expired a few hours later. Not a single Confederate soldier was hit during the entire battle.
  • Mountain Justice for the Bees: Before leaving the field, the Confederates marched down Duncan's Lane to Henry Duncan's farm. Because Duncan was a Union man and William Beverage was for the Confederacy, Captain Gay’s men took a bee gum and bees from Duncan's yard and carried it up the lane to William Beverage to replace the hive the Union soldiers had eaten.


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

No comments:

Post a Comment

Camps Life

  Before the advent of the free public school system after the Civil War, education along the Greenbrier and across the Allegheny border was...

Shaker Posts