Search This Blog

Following the six-year abandonment of the Greenbrier country after the massacres of 1763, the permanent resettlement of the valley began in 1769. A small band of ambitious young frontiersmen from Augusta County crossed the Alleghenies to clear land and erect the first permanent cabins:


1. The Young Pioneers of 1769

The party that reopened the Greenbrier wilderness consisted of John Stuart, Dr. Robert McClanahan, Thomas Renick, and William Hamilton:

  • Youthful Leaders: John Stuart was just twenty years old (born March 27, 1749, the son of Augusta County Lieutenant David Stuart). His close companion, Robert McClanahan (baptized April 19, 1747, the son of Staunton founder Robert McClanahan), was only twenty-two and a practicing physician.
  • Thomas Renick: Renick was a surviving son of Robert Renick, who had been killed by Cornstalk’s Shawnees on Purgatory Creek in 1761; Thomas was among the children redeemed from the Ohio towns following Bouquet’s treaty in 1764.
  • William Hamilton: Hamilton became an active settler and later served as an orderly to General Andrew Lewis during the Point Pleasant campaign.

2. The Settlement at Frankfort (Frankford)

  • Locating in the Big Levels: The four young men chose rich bluegrass bottomlands in the northern Big Levels, establishing their community around what became the town of Frankfort (modern Frankford).
  • Fort Before Ford: Regional historian Andrew Price observed that while modern maps spell the town "Frankford," it was one of the few valley towns lacking a stream or wading ford to justify the name. In frontier times, the settlement was a true "Frank-Fort"—a community of pioneering families centered around a stockade enclosure.
  • Second Only to Pittsburgh: When trans-Allegheny frontiersmen petitioned for the creation of a fourteenth colony (Westsylvania) in 1776, they estimated that, outside of Pittsburgh (which had only about thirty houses), Frankfort in Greenbrier was probably the largest settlement in the entire mountain district.
  • Fort Spring & Fort Union: Stuart established a stockade at Frankford locally called Fort Spring. Near the Big Savannah (Lewisburg), Stuart also raised a substantial two-and-a-half-story dwelling of hewn logs that served double duty as a family residence and a fortified blockhouse, widely known along the border as Fort Union.

3. Frontier Cabin Architecture

Pioneer records describe the precise method by which the first cabins were raised during the initial seasons of resettlement:

  • Axe and Augur: Cabins were built entirely from timber cut while clearing fields for corn, potatoes, and buckwheat, fashioned using only an axe and an augur, with no iron nails.
  • Walls and Mud Daubing: Wall logs were notched and fitted, and the open crevices were chinked and sealed with a heavy mortar of clay dug from the second layer of earth beneath the topsoil.
  • Clapboards and Weight Poles: Roofs were covered with split oak clapboards, which were held tightly in place without nails by long straight poles weighed down with heavy river stones. Where fasteners were required, wooden pins were driven into augur holes.
  • Puncheons and Port-Holes: Floors were either packed earth or made of puncheons (broad logs split and hewn smooth on the upper surface). Heavy puncheon doors were swung on wooden hinges, while the outer walls were pierced with port-holes for rifle defense. Early chimneys were built of short timber cribbing daubed with mud, until fieldstones could be quarried to lay permanent stone masonry.

4. The Flood of Immigrants (1769–1774)

Once Stuart, McClanahan, Renick, and Hamilton proved that settlements could be maintained without immediate Indian interference, settlers flooded across the divide:

  • Reaching Pocahontas: Settlers pushed north up the river into the Little Levels and mountain bottoms; John McNeel and the Kinnison brothers established homesteads in the Little Levels, followed closely by Joshua Buckley at Buckeye.
  • Rapid Growth: Between 1769 and 1774, the population multiplied so rapidly that the Greenbrier Valley—transferred into Botetourt County in 1769—was able to recruit and field three full companies of riflemen for the 1774 Point Pleasant campaign: Captain John Stuart’s company, Captain Robert McClanahan’s company, and Captain Matthew Arbuckle’s company.

The settlement of the Little Levels of Pocahontas County and the establishment of frontier land claims combine personal drama with the unique customary laws of the Allegheny border.


1. The Flight and Return of John McNeel

  • The Fatal Boxing Match: The first permanent English settlement of Pocahontas County had its origin in an athletic bout in Frederick County, Virginia. John McNeel, a native of Frederick County with a passion for athletics, engaged in a boxing match in which his opponent was badly knocked unconscious and believed to be fatally injured. Fearing arrest and trial for murder, McNeel fled west into the uncharted Allegheny mountains.
  • The Little Levels Camp: Striking the rich, gently rolling plains of the Little Levels (near present-day Hillsboro), McNeel found the landscape so reminiscent of his old home that he resolved to stop, build a solitary cabin, and remain in hiding. For months, he lived completely alone, subsisting almost entirely on wild venison and forest game.
  • The Kinnisons Bring Deliverance: While hunting in the forest one day, McNeel crossed paths with Charles and Jacob Kinnison, two brothers from his home neighborhood in Frederick County who had journeyed west looking for lands to settle. They brought the astonishing news that his boxing opponent had not died after all.
  • The 1765 Return with Martha Davis: Relieved of the fear of prosecution, McNeel returned to Frederick County, married Martha Davis, and journeyed back to the Little Levels around 1765 to establish a permanent homestead. Martha carried in her dowry a Welsh-dialect Bible—the first recorded Bible brought to the Greenbrier waters.

2. The Kinnison Brothers & The First Bluegrass Crops

  • Frontier Woodworkers: Charles and Jacob Kinnison returned to the Levels alongside McNeel to build their own homes. The brothers were renowned as exceptionally skilled woodworkers with the broadaxe and whipsaw, performing some of the very first carpenter work ever executed in the county. Charles Kinnison personally hewed the logs for John McNeel’s permanent house, as well as the dwelling occupied near Buckeye by Claiborne McNeill.
  • Preparing Ground for Grain: Early settlers initially lived out of rough "hunter's camps" while clearing the soil. When pioneer Joshua Buckley arrived at Buckeye, he noted that McNeel and the Kinnison brothers were the only residents in the Little Levels. Buckley stayed in a hunter's camp while a cabin was erected and ground was prepared for the staple mountain crop rotation: corn, potatoes, and buckwheat. The proceeds of a single autumn's hunt were used to meet the survey and title expenses for his lands.
  • Mutual Protection and Woodcraft: When Dunmore’s War broke out in 1774, McNeel and the Kinnisons rallied at Camp Union (Lewisburg) and marched in the expedition to fight at the Battle of Point Pleasant. In later border alarms, the Kinnisons' expertise with broadaxe and timber joinery made their services indispensable in planning and erecting neighborhood stockades and forts.

3. "Tomahawk Rights" on the Frontier

Before formal colonial land offices could operate west of the mountains—and during periods when royal proclamations strictly prohibited settlement—frontier hunters created their own customary tenure known as "tomahawk rights":

  • Deadening Trees at the Spring: A tomahawk improvement was established by walking into a desirable bottomland, finding the head of a freshwater spring, and deadening a few trees with a tomahawk or belt axe. The claimant would then peel or blaze the bark of one or more surrounding trees and carve the initials of his name into the wood.
  • Customary Currency: While lacking formal statutory authority in colonial courts, tomahawk rights were recognized and respected by the border community. Settlers routinely bought and sold these claims. If an incoming settler desired to clear a bottom that bore another man's marked spring, he generally paid the claimant a nominal consideration (such as a rifle, a horse, or dressed skins) to avoid a feud. If an overlapping dispute arose, the tomahawk claimant usually yielded and simply went looking for another unmarked spring.
  • The "Laced Jacket": If a contentious settler forcibly dispossessed a claimant without compensation, frontier justice took over. Chroniclers noted that if an aggrieved claimant was too persistent, he risked receiving a "laced jacket"—a backwoods flogging with hickory switches administered by a more pugnacious rival.

4. "Corn Rights" & The 1779 Land Act

Alongside tomahawk marks, Virginia developed legal settlement customs that tied land ownership directly to agricultural improvements:

  • The Corn Right: To incentivize food production and self-sustaining outposts, early regulations granted one hundred acres of land for every single acre cleared and planted in corn.
  • Cabin & Settlement Rights: Under standard Virginia frontier statutes, a settler who erected a habitable log cabin and raised a grain crop was granted four hundred acres as a settlement right, which carried with it the legal privilege to preempt an additional one thousand acres adjoining the tract at a modest statutory fee (forty cents an acre).
  • The Land Act of 1779: When Virginia declared independence and severed ties with the British Crown, the Virginia Assembly officially ignored royal restrictions, validated unpatented border claims, and formally opened the land office in 1779. The Assembly recognized actual settlement rights without requiring prior paperwork from royal governors, allowing thousands of pioneers who had staked their claims with axe marks and cornfields to finally patent their holdings under the Commonwealth.


No comments:

Post a Comment

Following the six-year abandonment of the Greenbrier country after the massacres of 1763, the permanent resettlement of the valley began in ...

Shaker Posts