6 Surprising Realities of Mountain Warfare in Pocahontas County That History Books Left Out
When modern popular histories recount the American Civil War, their focus usually drifts toward grand strategic chess moves in Eastern Theater capitals or massive troop maneuvers across open fields. Yet along the rugged, high-altitude borderlands of Pocahontas County and the surrounding Allegheny Mountains, the war assumed an entirely different character. Here, extreme elevation, isolation, and deep local fractures transformed conventional military doctrine into a harsh, erratic struggle for basic survival.
Distilling the complex archival record of this mountain theater reveals a series of surprising, counter-intuitive truths. From military operations launched to capture law books to tactical evolutions born from brutal failure, these six realities offer an unvarnished look into how the Civil War was actually fought and endured in the high country.
1. The "Tin Cup Campaign": How Bluster and Lack of Gear Led to the "Philippi Races"
On May 18, 1861, fifty-seven men gathered at the courthouse in Huntersville, Virginia (now West Virginia)—five days before voters formally ratified the state's Ordinance of Secession. Raising a company called the Pocahontas Rescuers (which quickly grew to sixty-four men), they rallied around Captain "Count" Daniel A. Stofer. A forty-year-old local attorney, Mexican-American War veteran, and notoriously boisterous orator, Stofer embodied the theatrical overconfidence of early 1861. Before his men ever encountered a Union soldier, Stofer publicly boasted of how easily he would handle the opposition.
"chase Mr. Lincoln's invaders off the soil of Virginia with the limb of a peach tree"
However, romanticized rhetoric met an immediate logistical wall. In late May 1861, the Confederate quartermaster system in Richmond barely extended across the Allegheny crest. The state had virtually no regulation equipment to issue the company. The men marched north toward Philippi clad in civilian homespun coats, carrying homemade haversacks, shouldering personal hunting rifles and shotguns, and dangling humble tin cups from their belts—the single piece of standard gear issued to them. Decades later, veterans retained no romantic notions about their send-off, dryly dubbing their initial mobilization the "Tin Cup Campaign."
That logistical unreadiness was compounded by a total breakdown in leadership. On the rain-soaked night of June 2 at Philippi, Stofer served as Officer of the Day for Colonel George A. Porterfield's green force. Heavily intoxicated on duty, Stofer failed to maintain picket posts despite warnings from two local civilians that Federal troops were closing in. At dawn on June 3, Union artillery opened fire, sending the unprepared Confederate force into a panicked retreat dubbed the "Philippi Races." Stofer fled well ahead of his command; when another officer halted the captain on the road to inquire about his company's whereabouts, Stofer offered a classic defense.
"coming up behind me"
This opening misadventure highlights how quickly pre-war bravado dissolved when confronted by logistical reality and real artillery. Captured two months later during Robert S. Garnett's retreat to Corrick's Ford alongside roughly seven of his men, Stofer was severed from field command. His company was eventually reorganized into 2nd Company I of the 25th Virginia Infantry, their early peach-tree speeches replaced by the grim realities of high-country combat.
2. The Human Shield Ordeal: The "Immortal Six Hundred" at Fort Pulaski and Morris Island
As the conflict ground into 1864, the high mountain borderlands sent local officers into some of the war's most brutal retaliatory standoffs. Captain Jacob Warwick Mathews, a Pocahontas County native who rose from private to command Company I of the 25th Virginia Infantry, was captured at the Battle of the Wilderness on May 5, 1864. One week later, Captain Alfred Mallory Edgar of the 27th Virginia Infantry (Stonewall Brigade), a native of neighboring Greenbrier County who later settled in Hillsboro, was wounded and captured at Spotsylvania's "Mule Shoe."
Both officers were shipped to Fort Delaware, where they were selected for a group of 600 Confederate officer prisoners chosen by the U.S. War Department for a direct retaliatory action. In response to Confederate authorities placing 50 Union officer prisoners in Charleston, South Carolina, to deter Federal bombardment, these 600 officers were transported south in late summer 1864 and placed in an open stockade on Morris Island. For forty-five days, they sat directly in the line of friendly fire from Confederate siege guns guarding Charleston Harbor.
When winter set in, the ordeal shifted from violent shelling to deliberate systemic neglect. Transferred to the unheated brick casemates of Fort Pulaski, Georgia, the officers endured freezing temperatures and a punitive "retaliation ration" consisting solely of spoiled cornmeal and pickles. Writing from Fort Pulaski on February 11, 1865, Captain Mathews documented the devastating toll of this confinement in a letter to a Baltimore benefactor.
"We have had nothing in God's world to eat for the last forty-one days but corn meal & pickles. Our prison is nothing more than a hospital. There is not ten sound well men in our prison."
Condition reports by Union medical inspectors eventually spurred the survivors' return to Fort Delaware in March 1865. The ordeal of these officers—later revered as the "Immortal Six Hundred"—demonstrates how military captives were reduced to political pawns in high-level retaliatory policies, experiencing prolonged physical and psychological deprivation far removed from traditional battlefield encounters.
3. The "Battle of the Law Books": Fighting a Two-Day War for a Legal Library
Military campaigns are typically launched to secure strategic rivers, rail junctions, or territory. However, the August 1863 raid led by Union Brigadier General William W. Averell into Greenbrier and Pocahontas counties had an additional, highly unusual objective. Department of West Virginia commander Brigadier General Benjamin F. Kelley explicitly instructed Averell to drive toward Lewisburg for a legal asset: confiscating the Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals law library for the newly created state of West Virginia.
"Our judges need it very much"
To secure the law books, destroy saltpeter works, and break up Confederate forces in Pocahontas County under Colonel William L. "Mudwall" Jackson, Averell advanced with his 4th Separate Brigade. Recognizing the strategic threat, Confederate Colonel George S. Patton (grandfather of the famous World War II general) marched his First Brigade on a grueling 24-hour forced march, arriving at Rocky Gap near White Sulphur Springs at 9:00 AM on August 26, 1863—just thirty minutes before Averell's vanguard spilled out of the pass.
What followed was a fierce, nine-hour engagement across a narrow valley floor. Averell launched repeated frontal assaults against Patton's entrenched infantry. Ewing's Union artillery battery ran dry after hours of continuous firing, while hand-to-hand combat surged along the barricades. The 14th Pennsylvania Cavalry alone suffered 102 casualties in costly saber-versus-musket charges.
By the morning of August 27, running dangerously low on ammunition, Averell bluffed a final attack before ordering a complete retreat, leaving behind one disabled cannon and fifty-five severely wounded men. Patton held the field, and Confederate authorities promptly evacuated the coveted Supreme Court law library to Richmond. The engagement highlighted how the political creation of West Virginia amidst active warfare generated unconventional, high-value military targets.
4. Tactical Evolution: How Averell Inverted His Playbook to Win Droop Mountain
The bloody repulse at White Sulphur Springs in August 1863 forced General Averell to re-examine his tactical approach to mountain combat. Ten weeks later, on November 6, 1863, Averell returned to Pocahontas County to engage Confederate forces under General John Echols and Colonel "Mudwall" Jackson at the Battle of Droop Mountain. Rather than repeating his previous mistakes, Averell inverted his operational playbook across every domain.
Instead of relying strictly on mounted infantry and carbine-armed cavalry, Averell added two dedicated foot-infantry units: the 10th West Virginia Infantry (569 men under Colonel Thomas M. Harris, armed with long-range .58-caliber Enfields) and the 28th Ohio Infantry (605 men carrying heavy .69-caliber muskets). He doubled his artillery by pairing Keeper’s Battery B with Ewing’s Battery G and integrated a 68th New York Signal Corps detachment to maintain real-time communications across rugged terrain.
On the morning of November 6, Averell avoided a costly frontal charge up the 3,100-foot summit. Masking his intentions near Mill Point and Hillsboro, he used Colonel James M. Schoonmaker's 14th Pennsylvania Cavalry to conduct a fixing feint along the turnpike. Meanwhile, he sent Colonel Augustus Moor with 1,175 men on a circuitous six-to-nine-mile flanking march through dense timber to envelop the Confederate left flank, held by Lieutenant Colonel William P. Thompson's dismounted 19th Virginia Cavalry. When Signal Corps officers flagged that the Confederate line was buckling under Moor's attack around 3:00 PM, Averell unleashed his reserves against the center, breaking organized Confederate resistance in the region.
Tactical Dimension | White Sulphur Springs (Aug. 26–27, 1863) | Droop Mountain (Nov. 6, 1863) |
Force Composition | Mounted infantry, cavalry, single artillery battery (Ewing's). | Added 2 veteran foot-infantry units (10th WV & 28th OH) + 2nd artillery battery (Keeper's). |
Battlefield Intelligence | Minimal; fought blind on Day 2 without signaling assets. | Integrated 68th NY Signal Corps detachment for real-time tactical updates. |
Primary Assault Plan | Direct frontal attrition against entrenched mountain gap defenses. | Fixing feint on turnpike paired with a 6-to-9 mile circuitous flank envelopment. |
Tactical Outcome | Union Repulse: 218 Union casualties; forced to retreat without ammo. | Union Victory: ~275 Confederate casualties; broke high-altitude defense line. |
5. "Maneuvers" for Shoes and Wilderness Patrols: The Unfiltered Daily Grind of Mountain Soldiers
While official dispatches emphasize unit positions and strategic objectives, soldier letters and personal memoirs reveal that daily life was largely defined by physical discomfort, terrain navigation, and basic logistics.
Prior to the Battle of Antietam in September 1862, Captain Alfred M. Edgar of the 27th Virginia Infantry found himself facing long marches over rough roads without functional footwear. Strict anti-straggling orders prohibited officers from leaving the column, yet practical necessity forced his hand.
"Now I cannot march barefooted when there are shoe stores in reach, so I must 'maneuver' some."
Edgar and a fellow barefoot officer used "fast walking and flanking" to slip past guards into Frederick City, Maryland, purchased new boots, and rejoined the regiment without facing formal discipline—a maneuver that enabled him to endure the forced marches that followed.
For Union soldiers stationed in mountain garrisons, daily operations involved relentless sweeps through uncharted wilderness. Writing home to his wife on December 10, 1863, Private Sheldon C. Morrison of Company F, 10th West Virginia Infantry, described a five-day winter scout into the high country dividing the Cheat and Greenbrier rivers.
"We killed no bear but killed plenty of deer and done fine. We went a way that no man ever was in the world."
Morrison’s patrol camped in dense pine thickets, subsisted on wild game, and navigated trackless terrain before ambushing a Confederate party along the Cheat River. These accounts illustrate that long-distance wilderness scouting, extreme weather, and securing basic clothing occupied far more of a soldier's daily focus than abstract political debates.
6. From Courtroom Perjury to Assassination Trials: The Bizarre Post-War Second Acts
The end of hostilities at Appomattox did not mark the end of public life for key figures from the Pocahontas County theater. Instead, several prominent veterans navigated extraordinary post-war careers that left lasting imprints on state jurisprudence and national history.
Captain Daniel A. Stofer, whose field command of the Pocahontas Rescuers ended following his capture in July 1861, returned home to resume his legal practice. Under an 1866 West Virginia Reconstruction statute, attorneys were required to take a stringent "test oath" disavowing any past Confederate allegiance before practicing in state courts. Despite his record as a Confederate officer, Stofer took the oath in the Circuit Court of Pocahontas County and was subsequently indicted for perjury.
Stofer appealed his indictment all the way to the Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia. On January 15, 1869, the court issued its ruling in Daniel A. Stofer v. The State of West Virginia (3 W. Va. 689). Stofer won his appeal on technical grounds regarding indictment clarity, establishing a foundational legal precedent cited in West Virginia jurisprudence well into the 20th century regarding an accused person's right to clear, unambiguous notice of charges.
Meanwhile, Colonel Thomas Maley Harris—the physician-turned-commander of the 10th West Virginia Infantry whose flanking attack broke the Confederate line at Droop Mountain—rose to national prominence in the summer of 1865. Promoted to brigadier general, Harris was appointed to serve on the nine-member Military Commission that tried the conspirators involved in the assassination of President Abraham Lincoln, playing a direct role in one of the most significant trials in American history.
Conclusion: The Unvarnished Echoes of the Mountain War
The Civil War in Pocahontas County stands as a vivid study in contrast. The conflict began in May 1861 when sixty-four neighbors marched out of Huntersville carrying homemade haversacks and tin cups; four years later, only fifteen men remained in the 25th Virginia Infantry to surrender at Appomattox. In the intervening years, the region witnessed everything from low-level wilderness ambushes and strategic skirmishes over law libraries to complex multi-column tactical envelopments and severe prisoner-of-war standoffs.
Looking back at these archival realities reveals how profoundly war shatters early idealizations, testing individuals and rural communities through raw physical hardship, rapid operational adaptation, and long-lasting legal aftermaths.
Consider this final question: When we strip away the romanticized narratives of Civil War history, how fully can modern audiences appreciate the sheer structural shock absorbed by small mountain communities whose roads, fields, and citizens became the testing ground for a nation's violent transformation?
-----------
Comprehensive Briefing Document: Military Mobilization, Campaigns, and Key Figures of Pocahontas County in the Civil War
Executive Summary
This briefing document synthesizes the historical records, regimental histories, battle reports, and personal correspondence detailing the Civil War experience of Pocahontas County, Virginia (later West Virginia), and its surrounding Allegheny borderlands.
Key findings and critical takeaways include:
- The 1861 Mobilization and Logistical Reality: Pocahontas County’s initial Confederate mobilization began in May 1861 with two local infantry companies: the Pocahontas Rescuers (mustered May 18 at Huntersville under Captain "Count" Daniel A. Stofer) and the Pocahontas Riflemen (mustered May 29 at Green Bank under Captain James C. Arbogast). Severe logistical deficiencies left the Rescuers equipped with little more than civilian coats, hunting arms, and tin cups—coining the veteran moniker "Tin Cup Campaign."
- Tactical Failures and Command Shifts: Early command of the Rescuers was severely compromised by Captain Stofer’s drunkenness on duty as Officer of the Day at Philippi on June 2–3, 1861, contributing to the surprise Federal artillery strike and the humiliating "Philippi Races." Stofer’s subsequent capture in July 1861 during Garnett's retreat to Corrick's Ford transferred field leadership to junior officers, eventually culminating in Captain Jacob Warwick Mathews.
- Regimental Divergence and Attrition: The Rescuers became 2nd Company I of the 25th Virginia Infantry, while the Riflemen became Company G of the 31st Virginia Infantry. Both companies endured devastating attrition across major Eastern Theater campaigns (including Camp Allegheny, Port Republic, Gettysburg, the Wilderness, and Spotsylvania). By the surrender at Appomattox Court House on April 9, 1865, the 25th Virginia Infantry was reduced to just 15 men (1 officer, 14 enlisted), while the 31st Virginia Infantry surrendered 56 men (7 officers, 49 enlisted).
- The "Immortal Six Hundred" POW Ordeal: Capt. Jacob W. Mathews (25th Virginia) and Capt. Alfred M. Edgar (27th Virginia), alongside other regional officers, survived being placed under friendly artillery fire on Morris Island and subjected to a winter starvation diet of moldy cornmeal and pickles in the casemates of Fort Pulaski as part of the retaliatory "Immortal Six Hundred" detachment.
- Local Mounted Defense and Civic Leadership: The McNeel family of the Little Levels provided political representation (Col. Paul McNeel signed the Ordinance of Secession) and mounted defense. Capt. William L. McNeel’s Company F, 19th Virginia Cavalry, served as the eyes and ears of local defense, with Lt. George W. Siple’s November 3, 1863 clash near Green Bank alerting Confederate forces to Union Brig. Gen. William W. Averell’s approach prior to the Battle of Droop Mountain.
- Tactical Evolution of Union Operations: Union Brig. Gen. William W. Averell transformed his operational approach between his August 1863 repulse at White Sulphur Springs (Rocky Gap) and his November 1863 victory at Droop Mountain. By integrating foot infantry (Col. Thomas M. Harris’s 10th West Virginia Infantry), doubling artillery, utilizing Signal Corps battlefield intelligence, and launching a 6-to-9-mile flanking envelopment, Averell overcame fortified mountain terrain.
- Counter-Guerrilla Warfare: Following Droop Mountain, Col. Thomas M. Harris’s 10th West Virginia Infantry conducted extensive winter patrols and counter-guerrilla sweeps out of Beverly, culminating in a May 15–30, 1864 expedition across Pocahontas, Webster, and Braxton counties that captured 36 prisoners (including partisan leader Major Marshall Triplett), 85 horses, and 40 head of cattle.
Thematic & Chapter-Complete Analysis
1. 1861 Mobilization & The "Tin Cup Campaign"
Decades after Appomattox, when the Confederate veterans of Pocahontas County gathered on courthouse steps, they eschewed grand newspaper rhetoric and referred to their first march to war as the "Tin Cup Campaign." This mountain shorthand described a hasty mobilization where Richmond's quartermaster system failed to cross the Alleghenies, leaving recruits with virtually no standard military issue beyond the humble tin cup attached to their belts.
- Muster at Huntersville: On May 18, 1861—five days before Virginia voters formally ratified the Ordinance of Secession—57 local men gathered at Huntersville, the county seat east of the Greenbrier River, to enlist for a one-year term. The roster quickly grew to 64 men calling themselves the Pocahontas Rescuers (also recorded as the Pocahontas Rescues).
- The Command of "Count" Daniel A. Stofer: At the head of the company was 40-year-old attorney, Mexican-American War veteran, and booming orator "Count" Daniel A. Stofer. Known for his heavy frame, fond preference for liquor, and theatrical bravado, Stofer boasted before seeing action that he could "chase Mr. Lincoln's invaders off the soil of Virginia with the limb of a peach tree."
- Logistical Deficiencies: The company marched north toward Philippi in civilian homespun coats, carrying homemade haversacks, mantel-hung hunting rifles or shotguns, and tin cups dangling from their belts.
- The Surprise at Philippi (June 2–3, 1861): Sent to reinforce Col. George A. Porterfield’s makeshift Confederate line, the Rescuers reached Philippi. On the rain-soaked night of June 2, Union Brig. Gen. Thomas A. Morris marched ~3,000 Federal troops toward the town. Stofer was Officer of the Day. Despite warnings delivered by two local civilians, Stofer was reportedly drunk on duty and failed to keep his pickets posted. At dawn on June 3, Federal artillery opened fire from the heights, initiating the chaotic rout known as the "Philippi Races." Stofer fled ahead of his company; when asked by another officer where his men were, he famously replied that they were "coming up behind me."
- Garnett's Retreat and Early Engagements: Reorganized as Company D of Major George W. Hansbrough's 9th Battalion, Virginia Infantry (Army of the Northwest), the Rescuers served at Leedsville during the July engagements at Laurel Hill and Rich Mountain. During Brig. Gen. Robert S. Garnett's retreat to Corrick's Ford, roughly seven men from the company, including Captain Stofer, were captured. The remaining survivors fought at Cheat Mountain (Sept. 12) and Camp Bartow (Oct. 3) before being consolidated into the 25th Virginia Infantry in 1862.
2. Comparative Analysis: Pocahontas Rescuers vs. Pocahontas Riflemen
Pocahontas County’s early 1861 mobilization rested on two twin infantry companies raised eleven days apart. Although historical accounts occasionally conflate their designations, regimental records clarify their distinct assignments and operational trajectories:
Feature | Pocahontas Rescuers (Rescues) | Pocahontas Riflemen (Reserves) |
Muster Date & Site | May 18, 1861, at Huntersville | May 29, 1861, at Green Bank |
Original Captain | Daniel A. Stofer (attorney, Mexican War vet) | James C. Arbogast (promoted to Major June 1862) |
1861 Assignment | Philippi; then Co. D, 9th Bn. VA Infantry | Co. G, 31st Virginia Infantry (mustered July 1861) |
1862–1865 Assignment | Merged into 25th VA Infantry as 2nd Co. I (1862) | Remained Co. G, 31st Virginia Infantry throughout war |
1861 Mountain Actions | Philippi, Corrick's Ford retreat, Cheat Mountain, Camp Bartow, Camp Allegheny | Rich Mountain, Cheat Mountain, Camp Bartow, Camp Allegheny |
Major Eastern Campaigns | 1862 Valley, Seven Days, Cedar Mountain, 2nd Manassas, Antietam, Fredericksburg, Gettysburg, Wilderness–Cold Harbor, 1864 Valley | Cross Keys/Port Republic, Gaines' Mill, Cedar Mountain, 2nd Manassas, Fredericksburg, Chancellorsville, 2nd Winchester, Gettysburg, Wilderness, Spotsylvania, 1864 Valley & Fort Stevens |
Surrender at Appomattox | 25th VA surrendered 15 men (1 officer, 14 enlisted) | 31st VA surrendered 56 men (7 officers, 49 enlisted) |
Recruitment and Geographic Division
- Huntersville (Central/Southern County): The Rescuers recruited around the county seat along the central Greenbrier River corridor, organizing prior to the secession vote.
- Green Bank (Northern County): The Riflemen drew from the upper Greenbrier and Deer Creek communities—including prominent local families like the Arbogasts, Warwicks, and Wooddells—mustering at Green Bank.
Parallel Operational Service
Though assigned to different regiments after spring 1862, both commands served in the Army of the Northwest defending local passes at Cheat Mountain, Camp Bartow, and Camp Allegheny in late 1861. Both were subsequently assigned to Stonewall Jackson’s Second Corps, Army of Northern Virginia, fighting in the same operational theater through Appomattox.
3. Combat History of Company G, 31st Virginia Infantry (Pocahontas Riflemen)
Company G of the 31st Virginia Infantry engaged in several key battles across extreme topographies:
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| MAJOR ENGAGEMENTS: COMPANY G, 31ST VIRGINIA INFANTRY |
+-------------------+---------------+-----------------------+-----------------------+
| Battle | Date | Commander | Casualty Summary |
+-------------------+---------------+-----------------------+-----------------------+
| Camp Allegheny | Dec. 13, 1861 | Maj. Francis M. Boykin| 37 regimental casualties|
| Port Republic | June 9, 1862 | Col. John S. Hoffman | 97 combined casualties|
| Gettysburg | July 1–3, 1863| Col. John S. Hoffman | 27 regimental casualties|
+-------------------+---------------+-----------------------+-----------------------+
Camp Allegheny (December 13, 1861)
Positioned at 4,400 feet on Allegheny Mountain—the highest Civil War fortification in the East—Col. Edward Johnson’s 1,200-man garrison held the Staunton-Parkersburg Turnpike against Union Brig. Gen. Robert H. Milroy’s 2,000-man attacking column. Privates William and Henry Yeager of Company G fought on land adjacent to their family farm.
- Tactical Action: Maj. Francis M. Boykin led the 31st Virginia into the brush northeast of camp. Hansbrough’s 9th Battalion (including the Pocahontas Rescuers) fell back under fire and rallied directly on the 31st Virginia. Together, they launched a countercharge through felled timber.
- Outcome: The battle devolved into four hours of brutal close-quarters fire behind logs and trees. Veteran John Robson of the 52nd Virginia observed that the 31st fought with ferocity because "Milroy stood between them and home." The 31st sustained 37 casualties in holding the pass.
Port Republic (June 9, 1862)
Under Col. John S. Hoffman, the 31st Virginia advanced alongside the 25th Virginia onto Gen. Charles Winder's right below "the Coaling."
- Enfilade Fire: Subjected to infantry volleys and artillery crossfire from the heights, five successive color bearers of the 31st Virginia were shot down, forcing officers to order the flag left on the ground. Company G lay flat in the wheatfield under severe fire until Gen. Richard Taylor’s Louisiana Brigade carried the battery.
- Losses: The 31st Virginia reported 97 casualties across Cross Keys and Port Republic (with battle accounts placing Port Republic losses alone at 34 killed and 83 wounded—the highest regiment mortality on that field). Private Peter Hull Warwick of Company G was wounded. Following the death of Maj. Joseph H. Chenoweth in the engagement, Company G Captain James C. Arbogast was promoted to Major on the field.
Gettysburg (July 1–3, 1863)
Serving in Brig. Gen. William "Extra Billy" Smith's Brigade (Early's Division, Ewell's Second Corps), the 31st Virginia entered the campaign with 267 men.
- York Pike Delay: On July 1–2, the brigade was detached to guard the York Pike against a reported (and nonexistent) threat of Union cavalry, missing Early’s assault on East Cemetery Hill.
- Culp's Hill & Spangler's Meadow: Rushed to Culp’s Hill on July 3 to reinforce Edward "Allegheny" Johnson's Division, the regiment took position behind a stone wall on the northern edge of Spangler's Meadow along Rock Creek. They helped repulse the 27th Indiana and engaged the 2nd Massachusetts. The 31st and 52nd Virginia recrossed Rock Creek to check Federal pressure on the flank.
- Losses: The 31st Virginia lost 1 killed, 19 wounded, and 7 missing (27 total casualties, roughly 10% of engaged strength).
4. Leadership Profiles: Early Company Commanders
Major James Crawford Arbogast (1837–1913)
- Background: Born in 1837 in Virginia, Arbogast descended from Michael Arbogast (a pre-1758 pioneer in Highland County) and Adam Arbogast (who settled near Travellers Repose in 1796).
- Wartime Career: Raised the Pocahontas Riflemen at Green Bank (organized April/May 1861; mustered as Co. G, 31st Virginia in July 1861). Commanded the company through Rich Mountain, Cheat Mountain, Camp Bartow, Camp Allegheny, McDowell, Cross Keys, and Port Republic.
- Field Staff Promotion: Promoted to Major of the 31st Virginia on June 9, 1862, following Maj. Chenoweth’s death. Served on the regimental staff through the Seven Days Battles (Gaines' Mill), Cedar Mountain, Second Manassas, Antietam, and Fredericksburg.
- Resignation & Later Life: Resigned his commission on December 20, 1862 (replaced by Capt. James S. K. McCutchen). Married Sarah Jane ("Sally J.") Beard on March 4, 1863, in Pocahontas County. Died July 25, 1913. (Primary records located in NARA M324, CSR, and the Roy Bird Cook Collection, WVU).
Captain "Count" Daniel A. Stofer (1821–1891/1892)
- Background: Born in 1821 in Lewisburg, Greenbrier County. Served in the Mexican-American War, worked as a printer for the Martinsburg Gazette (1848), admitted to the Randolph County bar in 1852, and established a legal practice in Pocahontas County. Known for courtroom bombast, heavy drinking, and his ironic title "Count."
- Military Career: Raised the Pocahontas Rescuers (mustered May 18, 1861 at Huntersville). Discredited during the "Philippi Races" on June 3, 1861, for drunkenness on duty and abandoning his post. Captured in July 1861 during Garnett's retreat to Corrick's Ford, ending his field command.
- Post-War Legal Precedent: Returned to Pocahontas County after the war. In 1866, he took West Virginia's Reconstruction-era Lawyer's Test Oath disavowing Confederate service and was subsequently indicted for perjury in the Pocahontas Circuit Court. Stofer appealed to the Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia in Daniel A. Stofer v. The State of West Virginia, 3 W. Va. 689 (decided Jan. 15, 1869). The court ruled in his favor, establishing a long-standing legal precedent that an indictment must describe a charged offense with sufficient clarity for the accused to prepare a defense. Died in 1891 or 1892.
5. Pocahontas Rescuers in 25th Virginia Infantry (1862–1865)
Following Stofer's capture, command of the Rescuers passed through the lieutenant ranks. 1st Lieutenant J. H. McLaughlin assumed initial day-to-day leadership. Severe officer turnover followed: Lieutenant Sylvester Mitchell was mortally wounded at Second Manassas (Aug. 28, 1862), and 1st Sergeant George R. Ware died of fever at Winchester Hospital (Nov. 12, 1862).
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| 25TH VIRGINIA INFANTRY (COMPANY I) CAMPAIGN MILESTONES |
+-------------------+---------------+-----------------------+-----------------------+
| Campaign | Date | Operational Impact | Key Losses/Notes |
+-------------------+---------------+-----------------------+-----------------------+
| Gettysburg | July 2–3, 1863| Culp's Hill Assault | Capt. Mathews promoted|
| | | ~25% regimental loss | Pvt. Willihan arm loss|
| Wilderness | May 5, 1864 | Jones's Brigade hit | Regimental flag lost |
| | | Over half regiment lost| Capt. Mathews captured|
| Spotsylvania | May 12, 1864 | Mule Shoe Overrun | 17 of Co. I captured |
| | | Col. Higginbotham KIA | 6 died at Elmira POW |
| Appomattox | April 9, 1865 | Final Surrender | 15 total survivors |
+-------------------+---------------+-----------------------+-----------------------+
Captain Jacob Warwick Mathews (1839–1930)
Enlisting as a private on May 18, 1861, Mathews earned a lieutenant’s commission in early 1862 and was promoted to Captain for gallantry on the field at Gettysburg in July 1863 (where Private Michael H. Willihan left an ambulance on sick call to join the assault, receiving a wound that necessitated the amputation of his right arm). Mathews led Company I until his capture on May 5, 1864, at the Wilderness.
Destruction of the Unit (May 1864)
- The Wilderness (May 5, 1864): Fighting in Brig. Gen. John M. Jones's Brigade along the Orange Turnpike, the 25th Virginia lost nearly half its strength, Gen. Jones was killed, its third regimental battle flag was lost, and Captain Mathews was captured.
- Spotsylvania Mule Shoe (May 12, 1864): Holding the apex of the Mule Shoe salient, the regiment was overrun following the death of 21-year-old Col. John C. Higginbotham. Seventeen men of Company I were captured and sent to Point Lookout, Maryland, and Elmira, New York; six of these seventeen died in captivity at Elmira.
- Appomattox (April 9, 1865): The consolidated remnants of the 25th Virginia Infantry surrendered just 15 men (1 officer, 14 enlisted).
6. The "Immortal Six Hundred" & Regional Officers
Capt. Jacob W. Mathews and the Retaliatory Detachment
Following his capture at the Wilderness, Captain Jacob W. Mathews was transferred to Fort Delaware. On June 13, 1864, Confederate Maj. Gen. Samuel Jones placed 50 Union officer prisoners in Charleston, South Carolina, to deter Union bombardment. In retaliation, the U.S. War Department selected 600 Confederate officer prisoners from Fort Delaware—including Mathews—to be placed under friendly fire on Morris Island.
- Transport & Morris Island (Aug.–Oct. 1864): After 18 days confined in the hold of the transport Crescent City, the officers were placed in an open stockade on Morris Island for 45 days under fire from Confederate batteries guarding Charleston.
- Fort Pulaski & Starvation Diet (Oct. 1864–March 1865): Transferred to the unheated brick casemates of Fort Pulaski on Cockspur Island, Georgia, the prisoners endured a harsh winter (including four inches of snow on Christmas Day) and a punitive starvation diet consisting exclusively of moldy cornmeal and onion pickles.
- Inspection and Return: On February 7, 1865, Union Brevet Maj. Gen. Cuvier Grover inspected Fort Pulaski and formally reported the horrific condition of the prisoners. Thirteen officers died at Fort Pulaski before the survivors were returned to Fort Delaware in March 1865.
Other Regional "Immortal Six Hundred" Officers
A June 11, 1896 letter published in the Richmond Dispatch (reprinted in the 1910 Minutes of the Immortal Six Hundred Society) details four officers from Greenbrier and Pocahontas counties who survived the ordeal:
Officer | Local Residence | Confederate Unit | Capture Detail | Post-War Career |
Capt. Jacob W. Mathews | Pocahontas Co. / Alvon, Greenbrier Co. | Co. I, 25th Virginia Infantry | Wilderness (May 5, 1864) | Merchant/farmer (Hoylman & Matthews); 1st Vice-President Immortal 600 Society |
Capt. Alfred M. Edgar | Ronceverte / Hillsboro, Pocahontas Co. | Co. E, 27th Virginia Infantry | Spotsylvania C.H. (May 12, 1864) | Hillsboro farmer; married Lydia Ann McNeel; author of wartime memoir |
James W. A. Ford | Lewisburg, Greenbrier Co. | 20th Virginia Cavalry | July 1864 | Lewisburg merchant; compiled Fort Pulaski manuscript roll |
Adjt. (Rev.) David M. Layton | Frankford, Greenbrier Co. | Field & Staff (Adjutant), 25th VA | Spotsylvania C.H. (May 12, 1864) | Presbyterian minister at Frankford; returned to Mt. Meridian, VA (1898) |
Additional Regional Officers Included on Rolls
Other 25th Virginia Infantry officers subjected to the retaliatory draft included Capt. Edwin Duncan Camden (Co. C, Sutton), Capt. John J. Dunkle (Co. K, Pendleton County), and Capt. C. D. McCoy. Officers from the 26th Battalion Virginia Infantry captured at Cold Harbor (June 3, 1864) were also included.
7. Civic, Political, and Mounted Mobilization: The McNeel Family
The McNeel family of the Little Levels formed a cornerstone of Pocahontas County’s political, logistical, and military structure.
- Col. Paul McNeel (1803–1872): Represented Pocahontas County at the 1861 Virginia Secession Convention in Richmond. On April 4, he voted against secession. On April 17, following Fort Sumter, he was absent for the main roll call but subsequently signed the Ordinance of Secession. Owned a large brick homestead located between Mill Point and Hillsboro.
- Capt. Andrew G. McNeel: Raised the Levels Cavalry in early 1861. Upon its disbandment, many troopers joined the Bath Squadron (Companies F and G, 11th Virginia Cavalry).
- Capt. William L. McNeel (1825–1899): Commanded Company F, 19th Virginia Cavalry (Col. William L. "Mudwall" Jackson’s brigade), operating as local cavalry scouts.
- 2nd Lt. Matthew John McNeel: Officer in Company F, 19th Virginia Cavalry; owned portion of the Little Levels acreage where Union forces bivouacked prior to Droop Mountain.
- Isaac McNeel: Commenced construction of the McNeel Mill at Mill Point in 1860. The passage of troops halted work until 1865–1868, when it was completed with 1,500-pound French millstones.
8. The Droop Mountain Campaign & Border Operations
Company F, 19th Virginia Cavalry Operational Sequence (Nov. 3–8, 1863)
[Nov. 3, 1863] Lt. Siple's 350-man detachment clashes with 8th WV Mounted Inf at Green Bank.
|
v (Dispatches courier to Col. "Mudwall" Jackson at Mill Point; 350 troopers cut off)
[Nov. 5, 1863] Skirmish at Mill Point. Lt. Col. Thompson screens dismounted retreat up mountain.
|
v (Jackson & Echols establish defense on 3,100-ft summit of Droop Mountain)
[Nov. 6, 1863] Battle of Droop Mountain. 19th VA Cav anchors left flank; overrun by Moor's column.
|
v (Confederate line breaks; remnants retreat south through Lewisburg)
[Nov. 8, 1863] 100–200 survivors of Jackson's command rally with Gen. Imboden at Covington.
November 3 Green Bank Clash
Lt. George W. Siple (Co. F, 19th Virginia Cavalry) led 350 troopers in a skirmish against a squadron of the 8th West Virginia Mounted Infantry near Green Bank. Siple sent a courier to alert Col. William L. "Mudwall" Jackson at Mill Point, initiating regional Confederate defense preparations. However, Siple's detachment was cut off by Federal movements, stripping Jackson of one-third of his strength and leaving him with only ~750 men for the initial defense.
Battle of Droop Mountain (November 6, 1863)
Reinforced by Brig. Gen. John Echols (bringing total force to ~1,700), Confederate troops faced Averell's ~3,855-man column. Lt. Col. William P. Thompson’s 19th Virginia Cavalry anchored the Confederate left flank. When Col. Augustus Moor’s 1,175-man Union flanking column struck the left, 175 dismounted troopers of the 19th Virginia and the 23rd Virginia Infantry Battalion attempted a countercharge, but were overrun. The 19th Virginia Cavalry and 22nd Virginia Infantry suffered the highest Confederate casualties of the battle (out of 276 total Confederate losses).
Marling's Bottom Operations: Skirmish vs. Affair
Documentary sources distinguish between two separate actions at Marling's Bottom (present-day Marlinton):
Operational Feature | Skirmish at Marling's Bottom Bridge | Affair at Marling's Bottom |
Date | December 11, 1863 | April 19, 1864 |
Campaign Context | Opening feint of Averell's Salem Raid | Spring borderland security operations |
Forces Involved | 14th PA Cavalry & Col. Moor vs. Col. W. L. Jackson's 19th VA Cav | 19th VA Cavalry vs. Union scouting party |
Official Records Status | Reports filed by Union and Confederate officers (OR Vol. 29) | No Union report filed; Confederate report only (OR Vol. 33, p. 307) |
Strategic Result | Screened main column feinting toward Salem; led to Gatewood's skirmish (Dec. 12) | Minor localized border skirmish preceding 1864 Valley Campaign |
9. Averell's Raids & Tactical Evolution: Rocky Gap vs. Droop Mountain
Between August and November 1863, Brig. Gen. William W. Averell fundamentally altered his tactical methodology to overcome Confederate mountain defensive positions:
Tactical Dimension | White Sulphur Springs / Rocky Gap (Aug. 26–27, 1863) | Droop Mountain (Nov. 6, 1863) |
Force Composition & Size | ~1,300 engaged: 2nd, 3rd, 8th WV Mounted Inf; 14th PA Cav; Gibson's Bn.; 1 battery (Ewing's Battery G) | ~5,000 total column: Added 2 foot-infantry regiments (10th WV, 28th OH); Co. C 16th IL Cav; 68th NY Signal Corps; 2 batteries (Ewing & Keeper) |
Operational Design | Single isolated raid column relying on uncoordinated hope of Kanawha Valley relief | Coordinated two-column pincer: Averell from Beverly; Brig. Gen. Alfred N. DuffiƩ marching east from Charleston |
Opening Reconnaissance | Reactive meeting engagement; vanguard ran into Capt. Read's ambush at Henry Miller's house | Deliberate morning reconnaissance; Averell immediately ruled out a direct frontal assault as suicidal |
Primary Attack Plan | Head-on attrition in narrow valley—repeated frontal charges against Patton's entrenched flanks | Three-sided dismounted attack: fixing feint on right, 6-to-9-mile flanking march on left, timed frontal push |
Use of Cavalry | 14th PA Cavalry thrown into costly saber-vs.-musket frontal charges (102 casualties) | 14th PA Cavalry paired with artillery on left to pin Confederate right; reserves held for pursuit |
Command & Logistics | Ran out of small-arms & artillery ammo Day 1; Day 2 reduced to a failed bluff | Sustained supply for single-day push; Signal Corps relayed real-time gaps in Confederate line |
Tactical Outcome | Union Repulse: 218 Union vs. 162 Confederate casualties; abandoned 1 gun and 55 wounded | Union Victory: 119 Union vs. ~275 Confederate casualties; broke organized Confederate control in region |
10. Counter-Guerrilla Operations of the 10th West Virginia Infantry
Led by Col. Thomas Maley Harris (a physician from Glenville, Gilmer County), the 10th West Virginia Infantry provided the decisive flanking blow at Droop Mountain. Armed with long-range .58-caliber Enfield rifled muskets, 569 men of the 10th West Virginia extended Col. Augustus Moor’s line beyond the Confederate left, forcing Gen. Echols to strip his center and causing the collapse of the Confederate defense.
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| 10TH WEST VIRGINIA INFANTRY: POST-DROOP MOUNTAIN OPERATIONS |
+-------------------+---------------+-----------------------------------------------+
| Date | Location | Operational Details & Results |
+-------------------+---------------+-----------------------------------------------+
| Nov. 10, 1863 | Hillsboro | Rear-guard action escorting wounded north |
| Dec. 6, 1863 | Cheat River | 5-day wilderness scout; 1 KIA, 1 WIA, 7 POWs |
| May 15–30, 1864 | Multi-County | 15-day sweep of Pocahontas, Webster, Braxton; |
| | Expedition | captured 36 POWs, 85 horses, 40 cattle |
+-------------------+---------------+-----------------------------------------------+
Cheat River Wilderness Scout (December 6, 1863)
Private Sheldon C. Morrison (Company F) documented a five-day patrol into the trackless headwaters of the Cheat and Greenbrier rivers. Carrying six days' rations into unsettled wilderness, the detachment intercepted a Confederate party along the prongs of the Cheat River. Lieutenant Henry Bender and Sergeant Norman B. Squires ambushed the group, killing 1, wounding 1, and capturing 7 prisoners (Sgt. Squires was wounded twice in the leg).
May 15–30, 1864 Multi-County Scout
The 10th West Virginia conducted a 15-day counter-guerrilla sweep out of Beverly through Pocahontas, Webster, and Braxton counties. Operating simultaneously with the Battle of New Market, the sweep secured the Union rear, netting 36 prisoners, 85 horses, and 40 head of cattle. Telegraph wire dispatches from June 4, 1864, reported that Webster/Braxton partisan leader Major Marshall Triplett was among the captured.
Key Insights & Notable Quotes
1. The Reality of the "Tin Cup Campaign"
Before seeing action, Captain "Count" Daniel A. Stofer expressed the ungrounded romanticism of early 1861 mobilization, boasting to Huntersville citizens that he could:
"chase Mr. Lincoln's invaders off the soil of Virginia with the limb of a peach tree."
This statement directly contrasted with the reality of June 3, 1861, at Philippi. When halted during the retreat and asked where his company was, Stofer admitted:
"coming up behind me."
2. Local Ferocity at Camp Allegheny
During the freezing four-hour battle at Camp Allegheny on December 13, 1861, Private John Robson of the 52nd Virginia recorded why Company G of the 31st Virginia Infantry fought with such intensity on the mountain ridge:
"Milroy stood between them and home."
3. The Ordeal of the "Immortal Six Hundred"
Writing from the cold brick casemates of Fort Pulaski, Georgia, on February 11, 1865, Captain Jacob Warwick Mathews (Company I, 25th Virginia Infantry) described the severe suffering of the officer prisoners to Baltimore sympathizer Mrs. Jane Eliza Bestor:
"Your very kind & long looked for letter was rec'd this morning it. It found me enjoying tolerable health. I might say very good health when I tell you we have had nothing in God's world to eat for the last forty-one days but corn meal & pickles. Our prison is nothing more than a hospital. There is not ten sound well men in our prison. There is some hope of it getting better now & God grant that it may for there is great room for an improvement."
4. Pragmatism on the March to Antietam
In his published memoir (My Reminiscences of the Civil War), Captain Alfred Mallory Edgar (Company E, 27th Virginia Infantry) captured the unvarnished daily existence of the Confederate infantryman during the September 6, 1862 march into Maryland:
"We have the most stringent orders against straggling or depredations on private property, but as I am almost without shoes, I ask permission of Col. Grisby [Andrew J. Grigsby] to be allowed to go ahead of the army and do some shopping, but he says it will be directly against orders for him to give me permission and that he is obligated to refuse. Now I cannot march barefooted when there are shoe stores in reach, so I must 'maneuver' some."
Edgar expanded on the physical toll of continuous barefoot movement prior to Sharpsburg:
"The physical effort required is greater than most of the men are equal to. So many of them are without shoes and are foot sore…. Night comes on and we have made as much as twenty miles or more."
5. Homefront Impact in the Little Levels
Describing the bivouac of Brig. Gen. William W. Averell’s Federal army on November 5, 1863—the night preceding the Battle of Droop Mountain—Private John D. Sutton of the 10th West Virginia Infantry recorded:
"the army went into camp in the levels between Mill Point and Hillsboro"
This positioning placed thousands of Union soldiers directly on the farmland of 2nd Lt. Matthew John McNeel and Capt. Alfred M. Edgar, in full view of Col. Paul McNeel's brick estate.
6. The Hardships of Mountain Scouting
Writing to his wife from Camp Beverly on December 10, 1863, Private Sheldon C. Morrison (Company F, 10th West Virginia Infantry) described the wilderness terrain along the headwaters of the Cheat and Greenbrier rivers:
"The second day we started bright and early. We traveled all day and yet saw no farm yet nor nary one the day before and the like of dear [deer] and bear you never heard of in your life. We killed no bear but killed plenty of deer and done fine. We went a way that no man ever was in the world."
No comments:
Post a Comment