Search This Blog

The Tin Cup Campaign: The Pocahontas Rescuers on the Road to War, 1861

 

The Tin Cup Campaign: The Pocahontas Rescuers on the Road to War, 1861

When the old soldiers of Pocahontas County gathered on courthouse steps decades after Appomattox, they did not remember their first march to war in the grand, bronze-statue language of the 1861 newspapers. They called it the "Tin Cup Campaign"—a dry piece of mountain shorthand for a mobilization so hastily thrown together that a tin cup was just about the only piece of regulation gear a man could count on carrying out of the county.

The story began on May 18, 1861, at Huntersville, the county seat tucked east of the Greenbrier River. Five days before Virginia voters formally ratified the Ordinance of Secession, fifty-seven local men stepped forward to muster for a one-year term—a roster that soon swelled to sixty-four. They called themselves the Pocahontas Rescuers (rendered in William T. Price's Historical Sketches of Pocahontas County and several period rosters as the Pocahontas Rescues). At their head stood a figure straight out of antebellum frontier theater: "Count" Daniel A. Stofer, a forty-year-old attorney, Mexican War veteran, and booming orator with a heavy frame, a fondness for liquor, and a taste for theatrical bravado. Before the company ever saw a Yankee picket, Stofer had declared to anyone within earshot that he could "chase Mr. Lincoln's invaders off the soil of Virginia with the limb of a peach tree".

Huntersville sent them off with the customary farewell address and high expectations, yet the logistical reality on the turnpike north told a far starker story. In late May 1861, Richmond's quartermaster system barely reached across the Alleghenies. The Rescuers marched out not as a uniformed battalion, but as a column of mountain farmers and woodsmen in homespun civilian coats, carrying homemade haversacks, whatever hunting rifles or fowling pieces they had taken down from their own mantels, and the humble tin cups dangling from their belts that gave the expedition its enduring nickname.

Their destination was Philippi, where Colonel George A. Porterfield was struggling to cobble together a Confederate defense line in northwestern Virginia out of raw, under-armed companies. The gap between Stofer's peach-tree oratory and real soldiering closed abruptly on the rain-drenched night of June 2, 1861. Brigadier General Thomas A. Morris was marching roughly 3,000 Federal troops down the muddy roads toward Philippi, and Stofer happened to be Officer of the Day. Even after two local civilians slipped into town with warning of the approaching columns, the camp remained fatally slack—Stofer was reportedly drunk on duty and failed to hold his pickets to their posts.

At dawn on June 3, Union artillery boomed from the heights overlooking the covered bridge. Caught half-asleep and virtually unequipped, Porterfield's makeshift force abandoned what little camp gear it possessed and broke south in a chaotic stampede the Northern press gleefully christened the "Philippi Races". The Rescuers were swept up in the general rout, with their own captain reportedly riding well ahead of the pack; when an officer halted Stofer to ask where his company was, the attorney answered that they were "coming up behind me".

For the men from Pocahontas County, the humiliation at Philippi was only the opening chapter of a punishing first year in the mountains. Rather than joining the 25th Virginia Infantry immediately—that consolidation would not come until 1862, when the unit was folded into the regiment as its 2nd Company I—the Rescuers spent the rest of 1861 as Company D of Hansbrough's 9th Battalion, Virginia Infantry, in the Army of the Northwest. Stationed at Leedsville during the July fighting at Laurel Hill and Rich Mountain, they were swept into Brigadier General Robert S. Garnett's grueling, rain-soaked retreat to Corrick's Ford, where roughly seven men from the company, including Captain Stofer himself, fell into Federal hands.

What remained of the company stayed in the high country through the autumn, fighting in the cold fog of Cheat Mountain on September 12 and behind the earthworks at Camp Bartow on October 3. By the time the survivors finally took their place as Company I of the 25th Virginia Infantry the following year, the peach-tree speeches of Huntersville were a distant memory. What lasted in the county's fireside lore was the unvarnished truth of that first wet spring—sixty-four neighbors marching north out of the Greenbrier Valley with little more than grit, homespun, and a tin cup.
----------------------------------------------------------------
First, a quick regimental correction to the prompt: only one of these two companies ended up in the 25th Virginia Infantry. The Pocahontas Rescuers became 2nd Company I, 25th Virginia Infantry, whereas the Pocahontas Riflemen (also recorded on some rolls as the Pocahontas Reserves) remained Company G, 31st Virginia Infantry for the entire war. The confusion is easy to see—a company did transfer from the 31st Virginia into the 25th Virginia in 1862, but it was Pendleton County's Pendleton Minute Men (becoming 2nd Company K), while the 25th's Company G was originally the Bath Grays/Bath Rifles and later William H. Mollohan's company.

Even in separate regiments, the Rescuers and the Riflemen were twin pillars of Pocahontas County's early 1861 mobilization, raised eleven days apart and fighting across many of the same Allegheny and Shenandoah battlefields.

FeaturePocahontas Rescuers (Rescues)Pocahontas Riflemen (Reserves)
Muster Date & SiteMay 18, 1861, at HuntersvilleMay 29, 1861, at Green Bank
Original CaptainDaniel A. Stofer (attorney, Mexican War veteran)James C. Arbogast (promoted to Major, 31st VA, June 9, 1862)
1861 AssignmentIndependent at Philippi, then Co. D, 9th Battalion VA Infantry (Hansbrough's)Co. G, 31st Virginia Infantry (mustered into CSA service July 1861)
1862–1865 AssignmentMerged into 25th Virginia Infantry as 2nd Company I (spring 1862)Remained Company G, 31st Virginia Infantry throughout the war
1861 Mountain ActionsPhilippi, Corrick's Ford retreat, Cheat Mountain, Camp Bartow (Greenbrier River), Camp AlleghenyRich Mountain, Cheat Mountain, Camp Bartow (Greenbrier River), Camp Allegheny
Major Eastern Theater CampaignsValley Campaign (1862), Seven Days, Cedar Mountain, 2nd Manassas, Antietam, Fredericksburg, Gettysburg, Wilderness–Cold Harbor, Early's 1864 Valley CampaignValley Campaign (Cross Keys/Port Republic), Gaines' Mill, Cedar Mountain, 2nd Manassas, Fredericksburg, Chancellorsville, 2nd Winchester, Gettysburg (Culp's Hill), Wilderness, Spotsylvania, Early's 1864 Valley Campaign & Fort Stevens
Regiment at Appomattox25th VA surrendered 15 men (1 officer, 14 enlisted)31st VA surrendered 56 men (7 officers, 49 enlisted)

Leadership and Early Discipline

The sharpest contrast between the two companies in 1861 was at the top.

  • Stofer and the Rescuers: "Count" Daniel A. Stofer brought courtroom bluster and a notorious taste for liquor to Huntersville's company. His reported drunkenness as Officer of the Day on the night of June 2, 1861, contributed to the Confederate surprise at Philippi, and his capture during Garnett's retreat to Corrick's Ford removed him from field command barely two months after muster.

  • Arbogast and the Riflemen: James C. Arbogast proved a far steadier regimental officer. After leading Company G through the 1861 Allegheny campaigns and Jackson's 1862 Valley Campaign, he was promoted to Major of the 31st Virginia on June 9, 1862—the day Major Joseph H. Chenoweth was killed at Port Republic—serving in field command until his resignation on December 20, 1862.

County Geography and Recruitment

The two musters split along Pocahontas County's natural north-south geography:

  • Huntersville (Central/Southern County): The Rescuers drew heavily around the county seat and the central Greenbrier corridor, organizing five days before Virginia voters ratified secession.

  • Green Bank (Northern County): The Riflemen pulled from the upper Greenbrier and Deer Creek communities—families like the Arbogasts, Warwicks, and Wooddells—mustering eleven days later.

Parallel Paths in the Same Theater

Even though they wore different regimental numbers, men from both companies repeatedly found themselves holding the same ridges and marching the same turnpikes. In the autumn and winter of 1861, Hansbrough's 9th Battalion (with the Rescuers) and the 31st Virginia (with the Riflemen) both served in the Army of the Northwest, defending Pocahontas County's own doorstep at Cheat Mountain, Camp Bartow, and Camp Allegheny.

After the spring 1862 reorganization folded Hansbrough's Battalion into the battered 25th Virginia, both regiments moved east with Stonewall Jackson into the Second Corps, Army of Northern Virginia. By Gettysburg and the 1864 Shenandoah Valley campaign, neighbors who had mustered separately at Huntersville and Green Bank were fighting in the same corps—and both regiments' remnants stayed in the field all the way to Appomattox Court House in April 1865.
 
---------------------------------------------------
 
Company G of the 31st Virginia Infantry—the Pocahontas Riflemen (also carried on rolls as the Pocahontas Reserves)—fought in some of the hardest, most lopsided terrain engagements of the Eastern Theater, moving from defending their own county line at 4,400 feet to enduring a crossfire in the Shenandoah Valley and holding the stone wall at Spangler's Meadow.

BattleDateRegimental CommanderBrigade / Higher Command31st VA Regimental Losses
Camp AlleghenyDec. 13, 1861Maj. Francis M. BoykinCol. Edward Johnson, Army of the Northwest37 total casualties
Port RepublicJune 9, 1862Col. John S. HoffmanElzey's / Walker's Brigade, Ewell's Division97 (Cross Keys & Port Republic combined); some accounts cite 34 killed, 83 wounded at Port Republic alone
Gettysburg (Culp's Hill)July 1–3, 1863Col. John S. HoffmanBrig. Gen. William "Extra Billy" Smith's Brigade, Early's Division27 (1 killed, 19 wounded, 7 missing of 267 engaged)

Camp Allegheny (December 13, 1861)

For the men of Company G, Camp Allegheny was literal home-ground defense. Perched at 4,400 feet on the summit of Allegheny Mountain in Pocahontas County—the highest Civil War fortification in the East—Colonel Edward Johnson's 1,200-man garrison guarded the Staunton-Parkersburg Turnpike against Union Brigadier General Robert H. Milroy's 2,000-man attacking column. Privates William and Henry Yeager of Company G were fighting practically on their own family farmland nearby.

  • Into the Northeast Brush: When Milroy's pickets opened fire around 8:00 AM in freezing winter wind, Johnson ordered the 31st Virginia—led by Major Francis M. Boykin—to occupy the ground near the old Staunton-Parkersburg Turnpike northeast of the winter camp.

  • Side-by-Side with the Rescuers: Hansbrough's 9th Virginia Battalion (which included Pocahontas County's other company, the Pocahontas Rescuers) was deployed immediately, fell back under pressure, and rallied directly on the 31st Virginia. Together, the two commands charged back through the felled timber and brush, pouring a heavy close-range fire into Milroy's advancing column.

  • Four Hours of "Indian Fighting": Because Colonel Gideon Moody's flanking Federal column arrived late on the opposite side of the camp, Johnson was able to fight off the two Union wings in turn. On the 31st's front, the battle devolved into a brutal, four-hour close-quarters firefight behind logs and trees—close enough that a Union soldier of the 2nd Virginia (U.S.) recalled that exposing an inch of skin meant taking a bullet.

  • Cost and Aftermath: John Robson of the 52nd Virginia noted that the 31st fought with particular ferocity because "Milroy stood between them and home". The 31st suffered 37 casualties in holding the pass, and the survivors endured a brutal winter at Camp Allegheny where exposure and disease ultimately claimed more lives than Milroy's rifles.

Port Republic (June 9, 1862)

Six months later, Company G—still led by Captain James C. Arbogast—walked into the bloodiest single day of the regiment's war. At Port Republic, Stonewall Jackson's attack stalled in the open wheatfield below the Coaling, a commanding knoll bristling with Union artillery that swept the Confederate line with oblique fire.

  • Into the Wheatfield Crossfire: After the Stonewall Brigade was driven back, Colonel John S. Hoffman (newly elected regimental commander in the May 1 reorganization) led the 31st Virginia—advancing alongside the 25th Virginia, which now contained the Pocahontas Rescuers—onto General Charles Winder's right to steady the crumbling line.

  • Pinned Under Enfilade Fire: As soon as the 31st came on line, it absorbed the same blistering infantry volleys from the front and flanking artillery fire from the Coaling that had shattered Winder's men. Five color bearers of the 31st Virginia were shot down in succession until a lieutenant ordered the men to leave the flag lying on the ground. Pinned down by a Federal counterattack, the men of Company G lay flat in the wheat as minie balls sheared through the stalks above them until Richard Taylor's Louisiana Brigade finally stormed and held the Coaling.

  • Company G Casualties and Promotion: The regiment absorbed devastating losses—97 casualties reported across Cross Keys and Port Republic combined in official summaries, with battle accounts putting the Port Republic toll at 34 killed and 83 wounded, more killed than any other Confederate regiment on the field. Among the wounded from Company G was Green Bank enlistee Private Peter Hull Warwick (who survived to surrender at Appomattox). When Major Joseph H. Chenoweth was killed in the fighting, Captain James C. Arbogast of Company G was promoted on the spot—effective June 9, 1862—to Major of the 31st Virginia.

Gettysburg (July 1–3, 1863)

By the Pennsylvania campaign, the 31st Virginia was a lean veteran regiment of 267 men under Colonel John S. Hoffman, serving in Brigadier General William "Extra Billy" Smith's Brigade (31st, 49th, and 52nd Virginia—the 13th and 58th having been left behind to garrison Winchester) in Jubal Early's Division of Ewell's Second Corps.
  • July 1–2 (The York Pike Delay): Company G missed the opening rout of the Union XI Corps on July 1 and Early's twilight assault on East Cemetery Hill on July 2. Smith—a 65-year-old former Virginia governor widely distrusted by his superiors—had reported a phantom threat of Union cavalry approaching from the east, resulting in his entire brigade being detached for two full days to guard the York Pike and eastern approaches.

  • July 3 (Culp's Hill and Spangler's Meadow): On the final morning of the battle, Smith's Brigade was finally pulled off the York Pike and rushed south to Culp's Hill to reinforce Edward "Allegheny" Johnson's Division—reuniting Company G with their old commander from Allegheny Mountain. The brigade took position behind the stone wall on the north edge of Spangler's Meadow, facing south with its left flank anchored on Rock Creek.

  • Action Across Rock Creek and the Meadow: During the morning's heavy fighting around lower Culp's Hill, Smith's men helped break the ill-fated Federal charge across Spangler's Meadow; following the repulse of the 27th Indiana, elements of Smith's Brigade pushed forward into the meadow to pour flanking and rear fire into the 2nd Massachusetts. In the shifting tactical fight along the creek, while the 49th Virginia stayed on the west side of Rock Creek, Hoffman reported that the 31st and 52nd Virginia recrossed the creek and moved southeastwardly to check Federal pressure on the flank.

  • Losses and Retreat: Compared to Port Republic, the stone wall and the late commitment spared the regiment from annihilation: the 31st Virginia lost 1 man killed, 19 wounded, and 7 missing (27 total, roughly 10% of the 267 engaged) out of 142 casualties in Smith's Brigade. After moving farther up Rock Creek, the regiment marched to Seminary Ridge during the night of July 3–4 to rejoin Early's Division, held that line through July 4, and began the retreat toward Hagerstown after midnight.

-------------------------------
James Crawford Arbogast (1837–July 25, 1913) was a Green Bank native who, at roughly twenty-four years old, raised and led Pocahontas County's Company G, 31st Virginia Infantry—the Pocahontas Riflemen (also carried on rolls as the Pocahontas Reserves)—rising to the field rank of Major before resigning after the Battle of Fredericksburg.

Biographical DetailRecord
Full NameJames Crawford Arbogast (often styled J. C. Arbogast)
Born1837, Virginia
DiedJuly 25, 1913 (aged ~76)
Home CommunityGreen Bank / upper Greenbrier Valley, Pocahontas County
SpouseSarah Jane ("Sally J.") Beard (m. March 4, 1863, Pocahontas County)
Confederate RanksCaptain, Co. G, 31st Virginia Infantry (1861–1862); Major, 31st Virginia Infantry (June 9 – Dec. 20, 1862)

Family Roots in the Upper Greenbrier

Arbogast belonged to one of the foundational pioneer families of northern Pocahontas County. As William T. Price recorded in Historical Sketches of Pocahontas County, the local Arbogast line descended from Michael Arbogast—a pre-1758 settler in what became Highland County, Virginia—and his son Adam Arbogast, who married Margaret "Peggy" Hull and settled near Travellers Repose at the head of the Greenbrier River in 1796. By the eve of the Civil War, the Arbogasts were deeply woven into the farming and civic fabric around Green Bank and Deer Creek.

Captain of the Pocahontas Riflemen (1861–1862)

When Virginia moved toward secession in the spring of 1861, Arbogast stepped forward to organize an infantry company at Green Bank. Period accounts vary slightly on the exact muster milestone—Confederate Military History dates the company's initial organization at Green Bank to April 1861 with 106 men ordered west along the Staunton-Parkersburg Turnpike, while individual enlistment records (such as Private Peter Hull Warwick's) mark May 29, 1861 at Green Bank.

In July 1861, Arbogast's men were formally mustered into Confederate service as Company G, 31st Virginia Infantry. Unlike Huntersville's Daniel A. Stofer—whose brief command of the Pocahontas Rescuers ended in controversy at Philippi and capture on Garnett's retreat—Arbogast held his company together through the grueling first year of mountain warfare:

  • 1861 Allegheny Campaigns: Arbogast led Company G through Rich Mountain (July 11), Lee's Cheat Mountain campaign, Camp Bartow / Greenbrier River (October 3), and the bitter winter defense of Camp Allegheny (December 13).

  • 1862 Valley Campaign: Moving east under Edward "Allegheny" Johnson and Stonewall Jackson in the spring of 1862, he commanded the company at McDowell (May 8) and into the climactic Valley battles of Cross Keys and Port Republic (June 8–9).

Promotion to Major and the 1862 Campaigns

Arbogast's field promotion came in the smoke of the 31st Virginia's costliest engagement. During the Battle of Port Republic on June 9, 1862, 31st Virginia Major Joseph H. Chenoweth was killed in action. Effective that same day, Captain James C. Arbogast was promoted out of Company G to Major of the 31st Virginia Infantry, joining Colonel John S. Hoffman and Lieutenant Colonel Alfred H. Jackson on the regimental field staff.

Over the next six months, Major Arbogast served with the regiment in Ewell's Division (Jackson's Command, Army of Northern Virginia) through the most intense campaign stretch of the war in Virginia:

  • Seven Days Battles (including Gaines' Mill, June 27, 1862)

  • Cedar Mountain (August 9, 1862—where Lt. Col. Alfred H. Jackson was mortally wounded, increasing the leadership load on Hoffman and Arbogast)

  • Second Manassas (August 28–30, 1862) and Antietam (September 1862)

  • Fredericksburg (December 13, 1862)

One week after Fredericksburg, on December 20, 1862, Major Arbogast resigned his commission. Captain James S. K. McCutchen of Company D (Gilmer Rifles) was promoted to Major in his place.

Marriage, Later Life, and Archival Leads

Arbogast returned home to Pocahontas County immediately after leaving the army. Barely ten weeks after his resignation, on March 4, 1863, he married Sarah Jane ("Sally J.") Beard in Pocahontas County.

He remained rooted in the county for the next half-century, appearing in the 1880 federal census and turning up in local public notices—such as a January 19, 1893 Pocahontas Times listing alongside fellow county residents. Major James Crawford Arbogast died on July 25, 1913, having outlived the war by nearly fifty years.

Note for primary-source verification: Published regimental summaries record the December 20, 1862 date of Arbogast's resignation but do not quote the text of his resignation letter (whether prompted by health, family obligations, or the grueling 1862 campaign season). The best places to pull that exact paperwork and any post-war veterans' notes are his Compiled Service Record (NARA M324, 31st Virginia Infantry) and the Roy Bird Cook Collection (31st Virginia Infantry Notebooks, Vol. 1) at West Virginia University's West Virginia & Regional History Center.
 
-------------------------
"Count" Daniel A. Stofer (1821–1891/1892) was one of the most theatrical figures to emerge from Pocahontas County's 1861 mobilization—a Mexican-American War veteran, former printer, and hard-drinking Huntersville attorney whose brief field career as captain of the Pocahontas Rescuers ended in Federal hands during Robert S. Garnett's retreat, yet whose post-war clash with West Virginia's loyalty oath landed his name in the state's Supreme Court casebooks.

Biographical DetailRecord
Full NameDaniel A. Stofer (nicknamed "Count" Stofer)
Lifespan1821–1891 (some Virginia printing records cite 1892)
Pre-War ProfessionsPrinter (Martinsburg Gazette, 1848); attorney in Randolph and Pocahontas counties
Prior Military ServiceMexican-American War veteran
Civil War CommandCaptain, Pocahontas Rescuers (Rescues) — later Co. D, 9th Battalion VA Infantry and 2nd Co. I, 25th VA Infantry
CaptureJuly 1861, during Brig. Gen. Robert S. Garnett's retreat toward Corrick's Ford
Post-War MilestoneAppellant in Stofer v. State, 3 W. Va. 689 (1869) over West Virginia's 1866 Lawyer's Test Oath

Pre-War Life: Printer, Veteran, and Mountain Orator

Born in 1821, Stofer had roots in Greenbrier County—listed in Virginia printing lineages as being "of Lewisburg"—before settling into the Allegheny counties to the north.

  • Mexican-American War and the Press: After serving in the Mexican-American War, Stofer worked as a printer. In April 1848, he joined the Martinsburg Gazette alongside a fellow Mexican War veteran.

  • Admission to the Bar: Within a few years he pivoted from the print shop to the courtroom. He was admitted to the Randolph County bar in 1852 and established himself as a prominent—and conspicuously loud—attorney in Pocahontas County.

  • The "Count" Persona: Heavyset, fond of liquor, and addicted to courtroom bombast, Stofer earned the ironic local sobriquet "Count". During the secession fever of spring 1861, he captured the overconfidence of the hour by boasting that he could "chase Mr. Lincoln's invaders off the soil of Virginia with the limb of a peach tree".

Philippi and Capture During Garnett's Retreat (May–July 1861)

On May 18, 1861, Stofer mustered 57 men into the Pocahontas Rescuers (Rescues) at Huntersville for a one-year term, expanding the roster to 64—including recruits he personally enlisted at Valley Head in Randolph County three days later on May 21.

  • The Philippi Disaster (June 2–3): Marched north to join Colonel George A. Porterfield's makeshift force at Philippi, Stofer drew duty as Officer of the Day on the rain-drenched night of June 2 as Brigadier General Thomas A. Morris's 3,000 Federal troops closed in. Even after two local civilians slipped into town with warning of the advance, Stofer was reportedly drunk on duty and failed to maintain military discipline. When Union cannon opened fire at dawn on June 3, sparking the chaotic "Philippi Races," Stofer fled well ahead of his command; asked where his company was, he famously replied that they were "coming up behind me".

  • Capture on Garnett's Retreat (July 1861): Following the rout, the Rescuers were folded into Major George W. Hansbrough's 9th Battalion, Virginia Infantry as Company D in the Army of the Northwest. Stationed at Leedsville during the mid-July engagements at Laurel Hill and Rich Mountain, the company was swept into Brigadier General Robert S. Garnett's punishing, rain-soaked retreat toward Corrick's Ford. During that retreat, approximately seven men of the company—Captain Stofer among them—were overtaken and captured by pursuing Federal forces.

Stofer's capture effectively severed him from field command barely two months after the Huntersville send-off. Without him, the Rescuers fought on at Cheat Mountain and Camp Bartow before being consolidated into the 25th Virginia Infantry as 2nd Company I in 1862.

Post-War Years and Stofer v. State (1869)

After the war, Stofer returned to Pocahontas County to resume his legal practice—and immediately collided with West Virginia's Reconstruction-era loyalty laws.

  • The 1866 Test Oath Clash: An 1866 West Virginia statute required attorneys to swear a "test oath" disavowing past Confederate allegiance or aid as a condition of practicing law in state courts. When Stofer—whose service as a Confederate captain was hardly a secret in Huntersville—applied to the Circuit Court of Pocahontas County to practice and took the oath, he was indicted for perjury.

  • Supreme Court Precedent: Stofer fought the indictment all the way to the Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia in Daniel A. Stofer v. The State of West Virginia, 3 W. Va. 689, decided January 15, 1869. Challenging technical defects in how the indictment alleged the court's authority and the offense, Stofer's appeal became a lasting West Virginia legal precedent (cited well into the 20th century, including State v. Lake in 1932) for the rule that an indictment must describe the charged offense clearly enough for the accused to know what he is required to answer and prepare his defense.

  • Final Years: Stofer lived on for more than two decades after his Supreme Court case, dying in 1891 or 1892 at roughly seventy years of age (military histories generally give 1891, while the Library of Virginia's printing index lists 1892, the same year a January 8 Shenandoah Herald notice referenced the dissolution of a business or legal partnership involving him).

Note for primary-source verification: Published summaries of the 1861 campaign confirm Stofer's capture during Garnett's retreat, but do not specify his exact Federal prison camp or parole/exchange dates. Those exact movements—and his formal separation from the 9th Battalion / 25th Virginia rolls—can be nailed down in his Compiled Service Record (NARA M324), Richard L. Armstrong's 25th Virginia Infantry and 9th Battalion Virginia Infantry (H.E. Howard, 1989), and the full published opinion of Stofer v. State, 3 W. Va. 689 (1869).

------------------
After Captain Daniel A. Stofer was captured during Brigadier General Robert S. Garnett's July 1861 retreat to Corrick's Ford, command of the Pocahontas Rescuers passed down through the company's lieutenant ranks—most notably culminating in Captain Jacob Warwick ("J. W.") Mathews, who rose from private to lead the company through its hardest Army of Northern Virginia campaigns before being captured in the Wilderness and surviving the "Immortal Six Hundred".

Leadership After Stofer's Capture

  • Immediate Succession (1861–1862): On the company's original Huntersville muster roll preserved in William T. Price's Historical Sketches of Pocahontas County, 1st Lieutenant J. H. McLaughlin stood directly beneath Captain Stofer as the senior subordinate officer. With Stofer in Federal hands barely two months after muster, day-to-day field leadership fell to the company's lieutenants as the unit fought as Company D, 9th Battalion Virginia Infantry (Hansbrough's) at Cheat Mountain and Camp Bartow, and then entered the 25th Virginia Infantry as 2nd Company I in the spring of 1862.

  • Attrition Among Junior Officers: Officer turnover in Company I was steep once the regiment moved east. Lieutenant Sylvester Mitchell, serving in Company I during the 1862 Northern Virginia campaign, was severely wounded in the thigh on August 28, 1862, at Second Manassas and reported killed the following day.

  • Captain Jacob Warwick Mathews (1863–1864): The company's best-documented commander in the 25th Virginia was Jacob Warwick Mathews (1839–1930), a merchant and farmer from Alvon in neighboring Greenbrier County. Mathews enlisted as a private on May 18, 1861—the company's opening muster day—earned a lieutenant's commission in early 1862 for meritorious service, and received his captain's commission for gallantry at Gettysburg in July 1863. He commanded Company I until his capture at the Battle of the Wilderness on May 5, 1864.

(Note for primary-source verification: Published county and online rosters confirm McLaughlin as original 1st Lieutenant and Mathews's 1863–1864 captaincy, but do not spell out the exact interim captaincy dates across the spring 1862 Conscription Act reorganization. Those exact muster-roll transitions can be checked in Richard L. Armstrong's 25th Virginia Infantry and 9th Battalion Virginia Infantry and NARA Compiled Service Records, M324.)

How Company I Fared in the 25th Virginia Infantry (1862–1865)

Once folded into the 25th Virginia Infantry in spring 1862 to rebuild a regiment shattered at Rich Mountain, the Pocahontas Rescuers shared the fate of one of the hardest-hit Virginia regiments in the Eastern Theater.

Campaign / MilestoneDateImpact on the 25th Virginia & Company I
Valley & 1862 CampaignsMay–Dec. 1862Fought at Cross Keys, Port Republic, Seven Days, Cedar Mountain, 2nd Manassas (Lt. Sylvester Mitchell mortally wounded), Sharpsburg, and Fredericksburg.
Gettysburg (Culp's Hill)July 2–3, 1863Regiment lost roughly 25% of 280 engaged (~72 casualties); J. W. Mathews promoted to Captain for gallantry; Pvt. Michael H. Willihan lost his right arm.
Battle of the WildernessMay 5, 1864Regiment lost nearly half its men and its third flag; Capt. J. W. Mathews captured (later one of the "Immortal Six Hundred").
Spotsylvania ("Mule Shoe")May 12, 1864Nearly the entire remaining regiment overrun and captured; 17 men of Company I captured and sent to Point Lookout and Elmira (6 died in prison).
Appomattox Court HouseApril 9, 1865Only 15 men (1 officer, 14 enlisted) remained in the entire 25th Virginia at the surrender.

1862–1863: Valley Campaign to Culp's Hill

Moving east under Stonewall Jackson and into the Army of Northern Virginia's Second Corps, the 25th Virginia absorbed steady battle and camp losses across 1862: Cross Keys (6 killed, 5 wounded), Port Republic (4 killed, 5 wounded), Cedar Mountain (1 killed, 24 wounded), Second Manassas (5 killed, 15 wounded, including Lt. Mitchell), Sharpsburg (3 killed, 20 wounded), and Fredericksburg (1 killed, 13 wounded). Disease took an equally quiet toll—19-year-old 1st Sergeant George R. Ware, whom Stofer had enlisted at Valley Head on May 21, 1861, died of fever at Winchester Hospital on November 12, 1862.

At Gettysburg (July 2–3, 1863), the 25th Virginia assaulted Culp's Hill with Edward Johnson's Division, losing about 72 of 280 men engaged. Company I's conduct there produced two enduring stories: Mathews earned his captaincy on the field, while Private Michael H. Willihan—sent to an ambulance at sick call on July 2—left the ambulance to join his messmates in the evening assault, taking a gunshot fracture that cost him his right arm at the shoulder.

May 1864: The Twin Disasters at the Wilderness and Spotsylvania

Company I was effectively destroyed as a fighting unit during one catastrophic week in May 1864:

  • The Wilderness (May 5, 1864): Advancing in Brigadier General John M. Jones's Brigade (where Jones was killed in action), the 25th Virginia lost nearly half its remaining strength and its third regimental battle flag. Captain Jacob W. Mathews was captured in the fighting and eventually selected as one of the "Immortal Six Hundred"—the 600 Confederate officers placed under friendly artillery fire on Morris Island, South Carolina, and confined through the winter of 1864–65 at Fort Pulaski, Georgia. In a February 11, 1865 prison letter, Mathews wrote that they had survived "for the last forty-one days" on nothing "but corn meal & pickles" and that "not ten sound well men" remained in the prison; he survived to return to Fort Delaware and live until 1930.

  • Spotsylvania's "Mule Shoe" (May 12, 1864): Holding the apex of the Mule Shoe salient—just after their 21-year-old commander, Colonel John C. Higginbotham, was killed—nearly the entire remainder of the 25th Virginia was enveloped and captured in Hancock's dawn breakthrough. According to Price's Historical Sketches, 17 men of Company I were captured in that collapse and marched off to Point Lookout, Maryland, and then to the notorious Union prison camp at Elmira, New York, where 6 of the 17 died in captivity and 11 survived the war.

The Final Year (1864–1865)

What was left of the 25th Virginia—a handful of returning convalescents, detailed men, and stragglers—was consolidated with other shattered regiments for Jubal Early's 1864 Shenandoah Valley Campaign and the final retreat from Petersburg. By the surrender at Appomattox Court House on April 9, 1865, the entire 25th Virginia Infantry numbered just 15 men (1 officer and 14 enlisted men)—a stark closing chapter for the sixty-four Pocahontas County neighbors who had marched north out of Huntersville four springs earlier.

--------------
Captain Jacob Warwick Mathews (1839–1930) was a Pocahontas County native who enlisted as a private on the Pocahontas Rescuers' opening muster day, rose through the ranks to command Company I, 25th Virginia Infantry, and survived one of the most notorious prisoner-of-war ordeals of the Civil War as a member of the "Immortal Six Hundred".

Biographical DetailRecord
Full NameJacob Warwick Mathews (also spelled Worwick / Warrick)
BornNovember 9, 1839, Pocahontas County, Virginia
DiedJanuary 7, 1930, Alvon, Greenbrier County, West Virginia (aged 90)
ParentsSamuel G. Mathews and Naomi S. (Hudson) Mathews
SpouseMary Elizabeth Hoylman (m. May 7, 1868, Anthony's Creek, Greenbrier County)
Civil War ServicePvt. to Capt., Co. I, 25th Virginia Infantry; captured May 5, 1864 (Wilderness); "Immortal Six Hundred"
Post-War OccupationMerchant (firm of Hoylman and Matthews) and farmer at Alvon

Pocahontas Roots and Capture in the Wilderness

Born in Pocahontas County on November 9, 1839, Mathews showed an early bent for military leadership: at just seventeen years old, he was elected second lieutenant of the Randolph County militia. When the Pocahontas Rescuers mustered at Huntersville on May 18, 1861, he joined as a private, steadily climbing through the company's officer ranks—earning a lieutenant's commission in 1862 and his captaincy for gallantry at Gettysburg in July 1863.

His field career ended on May 5, 1864, the opening day of the Battle of the Wilderness. Fighting in Brigadier General John M. Jones's Brigade (Edward Johnson's Division) along the Orange Turnpike, the 25th Virginia was hit by a furious Federal counterattack that killed Jones and cost the regiment nearly half its men and its battle flag. Mathews was taken prisoner in the fighting and shipped north to the officer prison at Fort Delaware on Pea Patch Island, where captives from the Wilderness and Spotsylvania arrived in mid-May.

The Immortal Six Hundred (August 1864 – March 1865)

Mathews's capture placed him at Fort Delaware at the exact moment a bitter retaliatory standoff erupted over Charleston, South Carolina. On June 13, 1864, Confederate Major General Samuel Jones notified Federal authorities that he was placing 50 Union prisoners inside Charleston to deter the ongoing Union bombardment of the city. In direct retaliation, the U.S. War Department selected 600 Confederate officer prisoners from Fort Delaware—Captain Mathews among them—to be placed under Confederate artillery fire on Morris Island.

Captured in the Wilderness
May 5, 1864
Captured with elements of the 25th Virginia Infantry on the first day of the Battle of the Wilderness and transferred to Fort Delaware.

18 Days Aboard the Crescent City
Aug. 20 – Sept. 7, 1864
Crammed into the hold of the coastal transport Crescent City with 599 fellow Confederate officers under the impression they were bound for exchange. Only upon nearing Charleston Harbor on September 7 were they told they would be used as human shields.

Under Fire on Morris Island
Sept. 8 – Oct. 1864
Landed on Morris Island, South Carolina, and held for 45 days in an open stockade (four men per tent) directly in the line of Confederate artillery fire from Charleston's defenses.

Winter and Starvation at Fort Pulaski
Late Oct. 1864 – March 1865
Transferred to the damp brick casemates of Fort Pulaski on Cockspur Island, Georgia, where the prisoners endured a freezing winter—including four inches of snow on Christmas Day—and a punitive starvation diet of moldy cornmeal and pickles.

Returned to Fort Delaware
March 1865
Following Union medical inspections that documented the prisoners' deteriorating condition, the survivors—minus 13 officers who died at Fort Pulaski—were loaded back aboard ship and returned to Fort Delaware.

Inside Fort Pulaski: Mathews's February 11, 1865 Letter

While Morris Island brought the constant dread of friendly shells, it was the winter inside Fort Pulaski's unheated brick casemates that broke the men's health. Prisoners shared crowded bunks without mattresses or adequate winter clothing, subsisting on a deliberate "retaliation ration" of spoiled cornmeal and onion pickles.

A surviving letter written by Mathews from Fort Pulaski on February 11, 1865, to Mrs. Jane Eliza (Brown) Bestor—a Baltimore Southern sympathizer with two sons in Confederate service who sent stamps, clothing, and money to imprisoned officers—preserves his firsthand testimony:

"Your very kind & long looked for letter was rec'd this morning it. It found me enjoying tolerable health. I might say very good health when I tell you we have had nothing in God's world to eat for the last forty-one days but corn meal & pickles. Our prison is nothing more than a hospital. There is not ten sound well men in our prison. There is some hope of it getting better now & God grant that it may for there is great room for an improvement."

Mathews's cautious optimism had a real basis he likely only sensed from camp rumors: just four days earlier, on February 7, 1865, Brevet Major General Cuvier Grover—commanding the District of Savannah after Sherman's arrival—had submitted a formal report shocked by the condition of the Fort Pulaski prisoners. In the rest of his letter, Mathews thanked Mrs. Bestor for news of his father and brother and for postage stamps, asked about a delayed money letter, noted that prospects for exchange looked brighter than ever, and added a postscript appealing to Baltimore friends for clothing because "we are very needy for clothing".

Later Life at Alvon and Primary Archival Sources

Mathews survived both Fort Pulaski and the return to Fort Delaware, coming home to the mountains after the war. In 1868, he settled permanently at Alvon in the Anthony's Creek district of Greenbrier County, marrying Mary Elizabeth Hoylman on May 7, 1868. Together they raised a son, Charles Forest Mathews (born 1873), while Jacob farmed and operated a mercantile partnership under the firm name Hoylman and Matthews.

He remained a fixture in regional Confederate veterans' circles for decades, appearing in the 1910 Minutes of the Immortal Six Hundred Society as one of three surviving members residing in Greenbrier County. Captain Jacob Warwick Mathews died at Alvon on January 7, 1930, at ninety years old.

For direct primary-source material beyond his February 1865 letter, three repositories hold the core documentation on Mathews:
  • West Virginia & Regional History Center (WVU), Collection A&M 1203 (Richard Orr Curry Papers): Contains original Jacob W. Mathews papers, including correspondence specifically relating to the Immortal Six Hundred, Confederate veterans' affairs, and business records of Hoylman and Matthews.

  • J. R. Cole, History of Greenbrier County (1917): Features a contemporary biographical sketch of Mathews written while he was still living at Alvon.

  • J. Ogden Murray, The Immortal Six Hundred (1905 / 1911): A fellow prisoner's published account that includes General Grover's February 7, 1865 inspection report on Fort Pulaski.

------------
Alongside Captain Jacob Warwick Mathews, a June 11, 1896 letter to the Richmond Dispatch—later preserved in the Minutes of the Immortal Six Hundred Society (1910)—identified three other surviving "Immortals" residing in Greenbrier and Pocahontas counties: Captain Alfred Mallory Edgar of Hillsboro, James William Andrew Ford of Lewisburg, and Adjutant (Rev.) David M. Layton of Frankford.

OfficerLocal TieConfederate UnitCapturePost-War Life
Capt. Jacob Warwick Mathews (1839–1930)Born in Pocahontas Co.; lived at Alvon, Greenbrier Co.Co. I, 25th Virginia InfantryWilderness (May 5, 1864)Alvon merchant/farmer; First Vice-President of the Immortal Six Hundred Society
Capt. Alfred Mallory Edgar (1837–1913)Born near Lewisburg; settled at Hillsboro, Pocahontas Co.Co. E (Greenbrier Rifles), 27th Virginia InfantrySpotsylvania C.H. (May 12, 1864)Hillsboro farmer; married Lydia Ann McNeel; author of a published Civil War memoir
James W. A. Ford (1843–1900)Born and lived in Lewisburg, Greenbrier Co.20th Virginia Cavalry (and earlier service)July 1864Prominent Lewisburg merchant; kept a Fort Pulaski roll of the 600
Adjt. (Rev.) David M. LaytonPastor at Frankford, Greenbrier Co. (native of Mt. Meridian, VA)Field & Staff (Adjutant), 25th Virginia InfantrySpotsylvania C.H. (May 12, 1864)Presbyterian minister at Frankford before returning to Mount Meridian in 1898

Captain Alfred Mallory Edgar (Hillsboro, Pocahontas County)

If Mathews was Pocahontas County's native son who settled in Greenbrier, Alfred Mallory Edgar (1837–1913) made the exact reverse journey. Born near Lewisburg on July 10, 1837, Edgar worked on his father Archer's farm and flour mill before enlisting at Lewisburg on May 9, 1861, as 4th Corporal in the Greenbrier Rifles—Company E, 27th Virginia Infantry of the Stonewall Brigade.

  • Rise and Capture: Promoted through the ranks to 2nd Lieutenant (March 1862), 1st Lieutenant (June 1863), and Captain (September 1863), Edgar fought at Antietam and Gettysburg before being wounded in the left shoulder and captured in the collapse of the Mule Shoe at Spotsylvania Court House on May 12, 1864.

  • Morris Island, Fort Pulaski, and Hilton Head: Sent south from Fort Delaware with the 600, Edgar endured the Morris Island stockade and arrived at Fort Pulaski on October 20, 1864. Unlike Mathews, who wintered at Fort Pulaski, Edgar was among the roughly 200 officers transferred in November 1864 to Hilton Head Island, South Carolina, where he remained until March 12, 1865, before returning to Fort Delaware and taking the oath of allegiance on June 16, 1865.

  • Pocahontas County Roots & Memoir: In June 1875, Edgar married Lydia Ann McNeel and settled on a farm at Hillsboro in Pocahontas County, where he died on October 8, 1913, and is buried in McNeel Cemetery north of town. He attended the 1907 Immortal Six Hundred Society reunion in Richmond alongside Mathews, and his written recollections were published in 2011 as My Reminiscences of the Civil War: With the Stonewall Brigade and the Immortal 600.

James William Andrew Ford (Lewisburg, Greenbrier County)

Listed in the 1896 Richmond Dispatch letter (with a printing error in the initial) as "Col. D. W. A. Ford, Lewisburg," James William Andrew Ford (1843–1900) was a native of Lewisburg who served in multiple Confederate commands, raising a cavalry company in 1863 and serving in the 20th Virginia Cavalry.

  • Captivity and Roll: Captured in July 1864, Ford was shipped from Fort Delaware to Morris Island and Fort Pulaski. According to the 1896 letter preserved in the society minutes, Ford brought home his own manuscript roster of the 600 compiled at Fort Pulaski.

  • Post-War Lewisburg: After returning home, Ford became a prominent Lewisburg merchant. Although his name was reprinted in the 1910 society minutes via the 1896 letter, Ford had already passed away in 1900 and is buried in Old Stone Presbyterian Church Cemetery in Lewisburg.

Adjutant (Rev.) David M. Layton (Frankford, Greenbrier County)

David M. Layton had the closest wartime link to Mathews of anyone in Greenbrier County: he was the regimental Adjutant of the 25th Virginia Infantry. Originally from Mount Meridian in Augusta County, Virginia, Layton was swept up at Spotsylvania Court House on May 12, 1864—just seven days after Mathews was captured in the Wilderness—and joined the same Fort Delaware detachment sent to Morris Island and Fort Pulaski.

After the war, Layton entered the ministry and served for years as pastor of the Presbyterian church at Frankford in Greenbrier County before returning to Mount Meridian in 1898. He remained connected to Mathews and the survivors' organization, being formally added to the Society of the Immortal Six Hundred roll at its 1907 Richmond reunion.

Additional Regional & Regimental Leads

Because the 1896 letter only tallied survivors still living in Greenbrier and Pocahontas counties thirty-one years after the war, it does not capture officers who died earlier or moved out of the region. Two additional groups overlap closely with Mathews's circle:

  • Lewisburg & 26th Battalion Officers from Cold Harbor: The Battle of Cold Harbor on June 3, 1864—where Edgar's 26th Battalion Virginia Infantry (heavily drawn from Greenbrier and Monroe counties) took heavy losses—sent additional Greenbrier-area officers to Fort Delaware and onto the Morris Island roster, including at least two officers listed with Lewisburg/Greenbrier residences captured at Cold Harbor on that date.

  • Fellow 25th Virginia Infantry Officers: Mathews and Layton were far from the only 25th Virginia officers on Morris Island; the regiment's contingent also included Captain Edwin Duncan Camden (Company C, of Sutton, West Virginia), Captain John J. Dunkle (Company K, of Pendleton County), and Captain C. D. McCoy (captured at Spotsylvania on May 12, 1864).

For a complete cross-check of early-deceased or relocated Greenbrier and Pocahontas officers, the definitive primary lists are Captain John L. Cantwell's official Morris Island/Fort Pulaski roll (reproduced in the appendix of J. Ogden Murray's The Immortal Six Hundred, 1911) and the biographical sketches in J. R. Cole's History of Greenbrier County (1917).

 
 
 
 
 

 ---------------------------------

The "Tin Cup Campaign" is a fitting bit of veteran shorthand for the chaotic, ad-hoc mobilization of Company I, 25th Virginia Infantry—the "Pocahontas Rescuers"—in the late spring of 1861.

Historical Context

  • The Unit: Organized in Pocahontas County under Captain Daniel A. Stofer, the Pocahontas Rescuers were mustered into the 25th Virginia Infantry—one of the earliest Confederate regiments formed in what was then northwestern Virginia, placed under Colonel George Porterfield.

  • Why "Tin Cup": In May and June 1861, Richmond's quartermaster system barely existed in the Allegheny counties. When the Rescuers marched out toward the northern front (ahead of the clashes at Philippi and Rich Mountain), the state had almost nothing to issue them—no standard uniforms, no tents, and few regulation accoutrements. Old soldiers later joked that a tin cup was about the only piece of government-issued gear they received, leaving them to march in homespun civilian clothes, carry homemade haversacks, and shoulder whatever hunting rifles or shotguns they brought from home.

  • The Early Ordeal: That lack of basic supply compounded the misery of the 1861 mountain campaigns—relentless rain, muddy turnpikes, and the hasty retreats and surrenders that cost the 25th Virginia roughly half its strength at Rich Mountain.

If you are folding this into a historical sketch or a Salt Shaker Press piece, the "Tin Cup Campaign" label works well as a narrative anchor to contrast the romantic local send-offs of spring 1861 with the stark logistical reality the Pocahontas County recruits actually faced on the road.

--------
Captain Alfred Mallory Edgar (1837–1913) bridged the Greenbrier Valley and Pocahontas County across a remarkable life: raised at the mill that became Ronceverte, seasoned in the ranks of the Stonewall Brigade's 27th Virginia Infantry, tested among the Immortal Six Hundred, and settled for nearly forty years as a farmer, stockman, and memoirist in Hillsboro.

Biographical DetailRecord
Full NameAlfred Mallory Edgar
BornJuly 10, 1837, Greenbrier County, Virginia
DiedOctober 8, 1913, Pocahontas County, West Virginia (aged 76)
ParentsArcher Edgar and Nancy Howe Pearis
Spouse & FamilyLydia Ann McNeel (1849–1919), daughter of Col. Paul McNeel; married June 1875; 5 children
Confederate Service4th Cpl. to Capt., Co. E (Greenbrier Rifles), 27th Virginia Infantry
BurialMcNeel Cemetery, Hillsboro, Pocahontas County, West Virginia

From Edgar's Mill to the Stonewall Brigade (1837–1865)

Born on July 10, 1837, Edgar grew up working on his father Archer's large farm and flour mill near Lewisburg—Edgar's Mill, which stood on the site of present-day Ronceverte. As a young man he attended the old Lewisburg Academy, where he first met Lydia Ann McNeel of Pocahontas County, whom he would eventually marry a decade after the war.

When Virginia mobilized in the spring of 1861, the 23-year-old Edgar enlisted at Lewisburg on May 9, 1861, as 4th Corporal in the Greenbrier Rifles—soon designated Company E, 27th Virginia Infantry in the Stonewall Brigade. Over the next three years he climbed steadily through the company's officer corps:

  • Promotions: Commissioned 2nd Lieutenant on March 23, 1862; promoted to 1st Lieutenant by June 1863; and promoted to Captain on September 28, 1863.

  • Wounded and Captured: After fighting through the major Eastern Theater campaigns—including Sharpsburg (Antietam) in September 1862—Edgar was wounded in the left shoulder and captured during the collapse of the Mule Shoe at Spotsylvania Court House on May 12, 1864.

  • The Immortal Six Hundred: Sent to Fort Delaware, Edgar was selected in late summer 1864 for the retaliatory detachment of 600 Confederate officers placed under friendly artillery fire on Morris Island, South Carolina. He was transferred to Fort Pulaski, Georgia, on October 20, 1864, and then moved in November to Hilton Head Island, South Carolina, where he was held until March 12, 1865. Returned to Fort Delaware, he was finally released on June 16, 1865, after taking the oath of allegiance.

His Wartime Memoir: My Reminiscences of the Civil War

Later in life—drawing on wartime notes he began keeping as a 23-year-old soldier—Edgar wrote a candid, personal account of his service. Nearly a century after his death, the manuscript was published in August 2011 by 35th Star Publishing (Charleston, West Virginia) under the title My Reminiscences of the Civil War: With the Stonewall Brigade and the Immortal 600, edited by Allan N. Clower and Steve Cunningham.

Presented with minimal editorial alteration across roughly 170–180 pages, the book stands out among regional Confederate memoirs for its plainspoken focus on the daily grind of infantry life rather than grand battlefield rhetoric. One of its most frequently cited passages comes from September 6, 1862, during the Stonewall Brigade's march into Maryland ahead of Antietam:

"We have the most stringent orders against straggling or depredations on private property, but as I am almost without shoes, I ask permission of Col. Grisby [Andrew J. Grigsby] to be allowed to go ahead of the army and do some shopping, but he says it will be directly against orders for him to give me permission and that he is obligated to refuse. Now I cannot march barefooted when there are shoe stores in reach, so I must 'maneuver' some."

Edgar recruited a friend, Lieutenant Yarnall of Wheeling—who also needed clothing—and the two officers used "fast walking and flanking" to slip ahead of the column into Frederick City, Maryland, buy footwear, and rejoin the regiment without drawing formal discipline. His new shoes paid off days later during the grueling forced marches to Sharpsburg, where Edgar observed how quickly barefoot marching hollowed out the brigade: "The physical effort required is greater than most of the men are equal to. So many of them are without shoes and are foot sore…. Night comes on and we have made as much as twenty miles or more".

Post-War Life in Hillsboro, Pocahontas County (1875–1913)

Ten years after his release from Fort Delaware, Edgar reconnected with his old Lewisburg Academy acquaintance, Lydia Ann McNeel (1849–1919), daughter of Colonel Paul McNeel. The couple married in June 1875 and made their permanent home at Hillsboro in the Little Levels of Pocahontas County.
  • Farmer and Stockman: By the 1880 federal census, Edgar was well established farming his own place in Pocahontas County, working as a farmer and stockman while he and Lydia raised five children.

  • Veterans' Ties: Despite his quiet life in Hillsboro, Edgar remained active in preserving the memory of his prison comrades, maintaining ties with the Immortal Six Hundred Society alongside fellow regional survivors like Captain Jacob Warwick Mathews of Alvon.

  • Death and Burial: Captain Alfred Mallory Edgar died in Pocahontas County on October 8, 1913, at the age of 76. He is buried in McNeel Cemetery in Hillsboro, where Lydia joined him following her death in 1919.

-----------
Colonel Paul McNeel (1803–1872) and the extended Hillsboro McNeel family—settled in the Little Levels since the 1760s—formed the political, military, and logistical backbone of Confederate Pocahontas County. From casting Pocahontas County's vote at the 1861 Virginia Secession Convention to fielding local cavalry companies and hosting Union General William W. Averell's army on their doorstep the night before Droop Mountain, the family stood at the center of the county's war.

Family MemberCivil War RoleLocal Connection
Col. Paul McNeel (1803–1872)Pocahontas County delegate to the 1861 Virginia Secession ConventionOwned the large brick home overlooking the Little Levels between Mill Point and Hillsboro; father-in-law of Capt. Alfred M. Edgar
Capt. Andrew G. McNeelCommander of the Levels Cavalry (1861)Raised early local cavalry; after disbanding, many members joined the Bath Squadron (11th Virginia Cavalry)
Capt. William L. McNeel (1825–1899)Commander of Company F, 19th Virginia CavalryLed Pocahontas County's mounted company in Col. William L. "Mudwall" Jackson's brigade
2nd Lt. Matthew John McNeelOfficer in Company F, 19th Virginia CavalryLater owned part of the Little Levels fields where Averell's Federal army camped before Droop Mountain
Isaac McNeelMill Point landowner and builder of McNeel MillBegan building the new mill at Mill Point in 1860; the war halted completion until 1865–1868

Colonel Paul McNeel and the 1861 Secession Convention

As one of the wealthiest landowners and most influential civic figures in the Little Levels, Colonel Paul McNeel was elected to represent Pocahontas County at the Virginia State Convention of 1861 in Richmond. His voting record mirrors the cautious shift of many western Virginia conservatives during that spring:

  • April 4, 1861 (Against): Before the firing on Fort Sumter, McNeel voted against immediate secession.

  • April 17, 1861 (Absent, Later For): Following Fort Sumter and President Lincoln's call for 75,000 troops, McNeel was absent during the final roll call on the Ordinance of Secession, but later announced himself in favor and signed the ordinance.

McNeel survived the war and died on December 8, 1872, at the age of 69, with burial in McNeel Cemetery north of Hillsboro. Three years after his death, his daughter Lydia Ann McNeel married Captain Alfred Mallory Edgar of the 27th Virginia Infantry, cementing the family's post-war Confederate veterans' ties in the Little Levels.

The McNeels in the Saddle: Pocahontas Cavalry

While Huntersville and Green Bank sent their earliest infantry companies into the 25th and 31st Virginia regiments, the Hillsboro and Little Levels McNeels were heavily represented in the Confederate cavalry:

  • The Levels Cavalry (1861): Early in 1861, Captain Andrew G. McNeel organized the Levels Cavalry. When that company was disbanded, a large portion of its troopers rolled into Captain Archie Richards's Bath Cavalry, which reorganized in April 1862 into Companies F and G—the Bath Squadron—of the 11th Virginia Cavalry.

  • Company F, 19th Virginia Cavalry (1863–1865): Later in the war, Captain William L. McNeel led Pocahontas County's Company F in Colonel William L. "Mudwall" Jackson's 19th Virginia Cavalry, with 2nd Lieutenant Matthew John McNeel serving among his officers. Operating across the Allegheny borderlands—including the Jones–Imboden Raid, Bulltown, Marling's Bottom, and the 1864 Valley Campaign—Company F served as the eyes and ears of Confederate defenses in Pocahontas County. On November 3, 1863, it was a dispatch from Lieutenant George W. Siple of Captain William L. McNeel's company that alerted Mudwall Jackson (then camped near Mill Point) to Averell's advance near Green Bank, setting in motion the Confederate concentration toward Droop Mountain.

(Note for primary-source verification: The former West Virginia Civil War Trails "Yankee Army Camp" marker in Hillsboro stated that Col. Paul McNeel had a son who served as a Confederate captain in McNeill's Rangers. Because regional lore occasionally conflates Pocahontas County's McNeel cavalry officers with Hardy County's famous McNeill's Rangers, checking NARA Compiled Service Records for Paul McNeel's sons is the surest way to confirm whether one rode with Captain John Hanson McNeill or if the marker conflated him with Captain William L. McNeel's company.)

The Little Levels Homefront and the Eve of Droop Mountain

The war reached the McNeels' front porch in November 1863. Marching south down the county to break Confederate resistance in the Greenbrier Valley, Union Brigadier General William W. Averell brought his combined infantry and cavalry force into the Little Levels on November 5, 1863—the night before the Battle of Droop Mountain.
  • Averell's Camp and Col. McNeel's Brick House: Private John D. Sutton of the 10th West Virginia Infantry recorded that "the army went into camp in the levels between Mill Point and Hillsboro"—on fields later owned by 2nd Lt. Matthew John McNeel and the Capt. Edgar estate. Standing in plain view of the Federal encampment was Colonel Paul McNeel's large brick home, and local tradition holds that General Averell spent the night of November 5 either inside Col. McNeel's house or at the nearby Presbyterian Manse before assaulting Droop Mountain the next morning.

  • McNeel Mill at Mill Point: Just north of the encampment at Mill Point, Isaac McNeel had started building a new gristmill in 1860 to replace the old Cackley Mill. The outbreak of war and the repeated passage of armies through the Levels forced him to suspend construction; the mill—equipped with 1,500-pound French millstones—was not completed until after the war ended (between 1865 and 1868).

-----------------
During Brigadier General William W. Averell's November 1863 raid, **Captain William L. McNeel's Company F, 19th Virginia Cavalry**—Pocahontas County's own mounted company—played a decisive opening role in spotting Averell's column near Green Bank, fell back through its own Little Levels home ground at Mill Point, and fought on the embattled Confederate left flank atop **Droop Mountain**, where the 19th Virginia absorbed some of the heaviest losses of the battle.

* Nov. 3, 1863: First Contact Near Green Bank
A 350-man detachment of the 19th Virginia Cavalry led by **Lt. George W. Siple** (Company F) clashes with a squadron of the 8th West Virginia Mounted Infantry near Green Bank and dispatches the warning that alerts Col. William L. "Mudwall" Jackson at Mill Point. Siple's detachment is cut off from the main body for days.


* Nov. 5, 1863: Skirmish at Mill Point & Withdrawal
Averell's columns converge on Mill Point. **Lt. Col. William P. Thompson** holds the 19th Virginia's mounted troopers in the rear to cover Col. William W. Arnett's dismounted men as Jackson's brigade withdraws up to the 3,100-foot crest of Droop Mountain.


* Nov. 6, 1863: Battle of Droop Mountain
Thompson's 19th Virginia Cavalry anchors the Confederate **left flank**. Hit by Col. Augustus Moor's 1,175-man flanking column, the 19th—reinforced by the 23rd Virginia Battalion—fights stubbornly before the line collapses, leaving the 19th Virginia and 22nd Virginia Infantry with the highest Confederate casualties on the field.


* Nov. 8, 1863: Reorganizing at Covington
Escaping south through Lewisburg hours ahead of Union Brig. Gen. Alfred N. Duffié, between 100 and 200 scattered survivors of Jackson's command rally with Gen. John D. Imboden at Covington, Virginia.


---

## November 3: Lt. George W. Siple's Clash Near Green Bank

Company F's most clearly documented individual action of the campaign happened three days before the main battle, carried out by **Lieutenant George W. Siple**—a Pocahontas County native in Captain William L. McNeel's company who had already served as Jackson's rear-guard commander with 30 men during Averell's earlier August 23, 1863 skirmish at Gatewoods.

* **Spotting the Raid:** After Averell's expedition crossed Cheat Mountain on November 2 and entered the Greenbrier Valley, a detached squadron of the **8th West Virginia Mounted Infantry** moved south along a separate route. On **November 3**, Siple—commanding a detachment of roughly **350 men** from the 19th Virginia Cavalry—discovered and skirmished with that Union squadron near **Green Bank**, about 20 miles north of Huntersville.
* **Triggering the Confederate Alarm:** While the 8th West Virginia broke off and rejoined Averell's main body near Green Bank and Arbovale, Siple immediately sent a courier south to **Colonel William L. "Mudwall" Jackson**, who was encamped with the main body of the 19th Virginia Cavalry near **Mill Point**. That dispatch set the entire regional defense in motion: Jackson warned **Colonel William W. Arnett** (holding Marling's Bottom eight miles north with the 20th Virginia Cavalry) and sent urgent word to **Brigadier General John Echols** in Lewisburg.
* **A Costly Separation:** Although Siple's warning saved Jackson's brigade from being surprised in camp, the skirmish came at a steep tactical price. Siple's 350-man detachment was **cut off** by Averell's advance and could not rejoin the 19th Virginia until days later—stripping Jackson of nearly a third of his manpower and leaving him with only about **750 men** available for the fight on Droop Mountain.

---

## November 4–5: Fighting Through Home Ground at Mill Point

On November 4, Averell pushed south, burning two Confederate campsites and trying unsuccessfully to trap Arnett's 20th Virginia Cavalry at Marling's Bottom before it could link up with Jackson. By the morning of **November 5**, Averell's infantry marched out of Huntersville toward **Mill Point** while Colonel John H. Oley moved down from Marling's Bottom, bringing the fighting squarely into the Little Levels neighborhoods where Captain McNeel and his Company F troopers lived.

* **Covering the Withdrawal:** Jackson posted Arnett's dismounted men along Mill Creek with orders to hold until Federal artillery opened fire, then fall back up the mountain by the safest route. **Lieutenant Colonel William P. Thompson** kept the mounted troopers of the 19th Virginia Cavalry in the rear to screen the withdrawal, pulling back only after the dismounted men were clear.
* **Camp Below the Crest:** After sporadic fighting that ended around 2:00 PM with light losses on both sides, Jackson and Arnett withdrew to the **3,100-foot summit of Droop Mountain**, looking straight down on Averell's Federal camps spreading across the Little Levels between Mill Point and Hillsboro—fields later owned by Company F's own **2nd Lieutenant Matthew John McNeel** and the Captain Alfred M. Edgar estate.

---

## November 6: Holding the Left Flank on Droop Mountain

On the morning of November 6, Brigadier General John Echols arrived with reinforcements to assume overall command of roughly 1,700 Confederates facing Averell's ~3,855-man force. Because the 19th Virginia Cavalry had been chronically short of mounts since its April 1863 formation, many of its troopers fought dismounted alongside the infantry.

* **Initial Position:** Jackson placed his two-gun battery near the turnpike on the right, Arnett's dismounted 20th Virginia in the center, and **Lt. Col. Thompson's 19th Virginia Cavalry** on the **Confederate left**.
* **Moor's Flanking Column Strikes:** Seeing that a direct frontal assault up the slope would be costly, Averell sent Colonel James M. Schoonmaker and the 14th Pennsylvania Cavalry with artillery to fix the Confederate right and front, while **Colonel Augustus Moor** marched shortly after 9:00 AM with **1,175 men** (10th West Virginia Infantry, 28th Ohio Infantry, and Co. C, 16th Illinois Cavalry) on a six-to-nine-mile circuitous march to envelop the Confederate **left flank**.
* **Overextension and Stand on the Left:** Around 11:00 AM, Thompson rushed roughly **175 dismounted men** of the 19th and 20th Virginia Cavalry to the left to meet the developing threat, though they initially pushed too far out. As Moor's infantry drove into the left flank, Echols pulled the **23rd Virginia Infantry Battalion** all the way from the extreme right across the highway to bolster the 19th Virginia Cavalry. Together, the 23rd Battalion and the 19th Virginia launched a sharp countercharge that briefly halted the Federal advance before the sheer weight of Moor's flanking troops and Averell's frontal assault broke the Confederate line.
* **Heavy Toll:** Of the **276 Confederate casualties** at Droop Mountain (33 killed, 121 wounded, 122 captured), the **19th Virginia Cavalry and the 22nd Virginia Infantry** suffered the heaviest losses of any Confederate units engaged. Driven from their breastworks, Jackson's and Echols's battered remnants escaped south through Lewisburg just hours ahead of Duffié's approaching Union column, with 100 to 200 men from Jackson's brigade regrouping with General John D. Imboden at Covington by November 8.

*Note for primary-source verification:* While the Official Records and regional Civil War Trails documentation explicitly name **Lt. George W. Siple** of Capt. William L. McNeel's Company F for the November 3 Green Bank clash and dispatch, battlefield accounts of November 6 track the **19th Virginia Cavalry** at the regimental level rather than breaking out Company F's separate position or casualty count. To pull individual Company F casualties and any specific mention of Capt. William L. McNeel on November 6, check **Terry Lowry's *Last Sleep: The Battle of Droop Mountain***, **Richard L. Armstrong's *19th and 20th Virginia Cavalry*** (H.E. Howard), and the Company F **Compiled Service Records (NARA M324)**.
---------------------
In the Official Records, the April 19, 1864 clash at Marling's Bottom (present-day Marlinton) is classified not as a pitched battle, but as a minor borderland "affair"—a sharp, localized encounter between elements of Colonel William L. "Mudwall" Jackson's 19th Virginia Cavalry and a Union scouting party along the Greenbrier River.

What makes this engagement unusual in the historical record is its lopsided documentation: no Federal officer filed a report on the skirmish (it appears in the National Park Service's compilation of Dyer's Compendium with "No Reports" on the Union side). The entire official record rests on a single Confederate dispatch from Colonel William L. Jackson—published in The War of the Rebellion: Official Records of the Union and Confederate Armies, Series I, Volume 33, page 307.

Operational Context in Spring 1864

By April 1864, Pocahontas County sat in a contested no-man's-land between the Federal garrisons in northern West Virginia (Beverly and Buckhannon) and Confederate outposts across the Alleghenies in Bath and Highland counties.

  • Rebuilding After Droop Mountain: Following the defeat at Droop Mountain (November 1863) and General William W. Averell's Salem Raid (December 1863), the 19th and 20th Virginia Cavalry were assigned to the Department of Western Virginia and East Tennessee.

  • Borderland Picket Duty: Throughout late winter and early spring of 1864, Jackson's troopers—including Pocahontas County's own Company F (Capt. William L. McNeel) and Company I (Capt. Jacob W. Marshall, drawn from Randolph and Pocahontas counties)—patrolled the Virginia–West Virginia borderlands, screening mountain passes and sparring with Federal scouting parties.

  • The Eve of the Valley Campaign: The April 19 affair was one of the 19th Virginia Cavalry's final actions in Pocahontas County before the regiment was pulled into the wider 1864 campaigns—countering Averell's May raid, defending Lynchburg in June, and riding with Jubal Early through the Shenandoah Valley at Third Winchester, Fisher's Hill, and Cedar Creek.

Don't Confuse the Two Marling's Bottom Clashes

Because Marling's Bottom guarded the key Greenbrier River crossing at the mouth of Knapp Creek, Civil War chronologies record two separate engagements there four months apart—and secondary summaries frequently blur them together (some modern web histories even misplace Marling's Bottom at Hillsboro):

EngagementDateCampaign ContextOfficial Records Classification
Skirmish at Marling's Bottom BridgeDec. 11, 1863Opening phase of Averell's Salem Raid on the Virginia & Tennessee RailroadSkirmish (involving the 14th Pennsylvania Cavalry and Jackson's command)
Affair at Marling's BottomApril 19, 1864Spring 1864 borderland scouting operationsAffair — Confederate report only (Col. William L. Jackson, 19th VA Cav.)

Where to Pull the Exact Primary Text

Because the verbatim text of Colonel Jackson's April 19, 1864 report is not indexed in full in open web snippets, I do not want to invent casualty figures, Union unit numbers, or tactical details that are not confirmed in the text. To read Jackson's exact wording—and see whether he names specific Company F or Company I officers or gives the precise toll—go straight to:
  • Official Records, Series I, Volume 33, Chapter XLV, page 307: Indexed as "Affair at Marling's Bottom, W. Va., April 19, 1864 — Report of Col. William L. Jackson" (digitized in full on the University of North Texas Portal to Texas History under metapth146032, as well as Cornell's Making of America collection).

  • Richard L. Armstrong, 19th and 20th Virginia Cavalry (H.E. Howard, Virginia Regimental Histories Series): Cross-references Jackson's OR report with individual Company F and Company I Compiled Service Records for any April 19, 1864 wounds, captures, or horse losses.

----------
The December 11, 1863 skirmish at Marling's Bottom Bridge was the opening Pocahontas County clash of Union Brigadier General William W. Averell's Salem Raid (December 8–25, 1863)—a collision between Federal cavalry and diversionary troops pushing into the Greenbrier Valley and Colonel William L. "Mudwall" Jackson's 19th Virginia Cavalry guarding the river crossing.

Rather than an isolated outpost fight, the skirmish was a deliberate piece of a multi-column deception plan designed to blind Confederate commanders while Averell's main force raced south to cut the Virginia & Tennessee Railroad at Salem.

How Marling's Bottom Fit Into Averell's Deception Plan

After failing to reach the railroad following the Battle of Droop Mountain a month earlier, Averell set out from New Creek on December 8 with orders to destroy the Virginia & Tennessee Railroad at Salem and sever supply lines between Richmond and Lieutenant General James Longstreet's force in East Tennessee. To keep Confederate brigades from converging on his main column, Averell and Department of West Virginia commander Brigadier General Benjamin F. Kelley launched simultaneous "demonstrations" across western Virginia:

Date (Dec. 1863)LocationUnion ForceStrategic Role in the Salem Raid
Dec. 11Marling's Bottom Bridge (Pocahontas Co.)14th Pennsylvania Cavalry & Col. Augustus Moor's columnDrive into Pocahontas County, push toward Frankford, and threaten Lewisburg from the north.
Dec. 11Monterey (Highland Co., VA)Averell's main column (~3,300 men)March south along the Allegheny ridge east of Pocahontas County toward Callaghan and Salem.
Dec. 11–12Big Sewell, Meadow Bluff & LewisburgBrig. Gen. Eliakim P. Scammon (Kanawha Valley)Press Brig. Gen. John Echols from the west to tie down Confederate defenders around Lewisburg.
Dec. 12Staunton–Parkersburg TurnpikeCol. Joseph Thoburn (detached from Averell)Feint east from Monterey toward Staunton to hold Confederate attention in the Shenandoah Valley.

The Action: Marling's Bottom Bridge (Dec. 11) and Gatewood's (Dec. 12)

  • The Clash at the Bridge (December 11): Under Averell's plan, Colonel Augustus Moor was ordered south to Marling's Bottom by December 11 with instructions to push forward toward Frankford and threaten Lewisburg. On that date, Federal troopers—recorded on the official battle honors of the 14th Pennsylvania Cavalry—skirmished at Marling's Bottom Bridge over the Greenbrier River with Colonel William L. Jackson's 19th Virginia Cavalry, who filed the Confederate official report on the engagement.

  • Pushing East to Huntersville and Gatewood's (December 12): Pressure in Pocahontas County did not stop at the river crossing. On December 12, Captain Jacob W. Marshall (Company I, 19th Virginia Cavalry) held an outpost at Huntersville with roughly 150 men (mostly dismounted), while a follow-up skirmish broke out at Gatewood's—east of Huntersville on the approach toward Back Creek and Warm Springs—again involving the 14th Pennsylvania Cavalry.

  • Confederate Confusion and Withdrawal (December 13–14): The simultaneous hits at Marling's Bottom Bridge, Big Sewell, and Meadow Bluff on December 11—followed by Gatewood's and Lewisburg on December 12—worked exactly as Averell intended. Deprived of early warning of Averell's true objective, Jackson withdrew his dismounted men, artillery, and wagon train east to Hot Springs at sundown on December 13 and Healing Springs on December 14, while Lieutenant Colonel William P. Thompson moved the mounted troopers down to Callaghan's.

Aftermath: Averell's Frozen Retreat Back Through Pocahontas County

With Jackson and Echols pulled off-balance by the December 11–12 clashes, Averell swept unopposed into Salem on December 16, burning depots, five bridges, and tearing up 16 miles of track. On the return leg—after fighting through Jackson's trap at the Jackson River bridges near Covington on December 19—Averell discovered that Kelley's supporting columns had already withdrawn.

His battered column escaped back north through the Greenbrier Valley into Pocahontas County in brutal winter weather. As Averell wrote in his official report, "On the way to Edray my rear guard experienced some trifling attacks on the 22nd. The road thence to Beverly was a glacier, which was traversed with great difficulty and peril"—forcing dismounted troopers to haul the artillery by hand on December 23–24 before reaching safety at Beverly.

Primary-Source Note

Open-web indexes confirm the units engaged (14th Pennsylvania Cavalry, Col. Augustus Moor's column, and Col. William L. Jackson's 19th Virginia Cavalry) and the operational sequence across December 11–14, but they do not reproduce the verbatim tactical text or casualty figures from Jackson's bridge report. To pull the exact blow-by-blow account of the bridge fight, look up Col. William L. Jackson's report under the Salem Raid correspondence in Official Records, Series I, Volume 29, Part 1 (Operations in North Carolina, Virginia, West Virginia, Maryland, and Pennsylvania, Dec. 8–25, 1863), alongside Richard L. Armstrong's 19th and 20th Virginia Cavalry.

----------
Brigadier General William W. Averell's August 1863 raid—the first of his three mounted expeditions into Confederate-held western Virginia that year—swept directly through Pocahontas County on August 22–23, shattering Colonel William L. "Mudwall" Jackson's "Huntersville Line," burning his headquarters at Camp Northwest, and forcing a running rear-guard skirmish at Gatewood's before Averell was halted four days later at the Battle of White Sulphur Springs (Rocky Gap).

Objectives: Saltpeter, Mudwall Jackson, and the Lewisburg Law Library

Ordered by Department of West Virginia commander Brigadier General Benjamin F. Kelley on August 12, 1863, the raid was the first major test of Averell's newly reorganized 4th Separate Brigade—the 14th Pennsylvania Cavalry, the 2nd, 3rd, and 8th West Virginia Mounted Infantry, Gibson's Cavalry Battalion, and Ewing's Battery. Kelley gave Averell three specific targets:

  1. Destroy the Confederate saltpeter works near Franklin in Pendleton County.

  2. Drive Mudwall Jackson's brigade (19th and 20th Virginia Cavalry) out of Huntersville and Pocahontas County.

  3. Capture Lewisburg and seize the Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals law library for the newly admitted state of West Virginia—"Our judges need it very much," Kelley instructed.

Saltpeter Works Destroyed at Franklin
Aug. 19, 1863
Advancing south from Winchester and Moorefield, Averell's troopers destroy the Confederate saltpeter works near Franklin and push toward Monterey, Highland County.

Skirmish at Huntersville & Evacuation of Camp Northwest
Aug. 21–22, 1863
Entering Pocahontas County from the northeast via Gibson's Store, Averell drives back Col. William W. Arnett's 20th Virginia Cavalry and forces Col. William L. Jackson to evacuate his Camp Northwest headquarters near Huntersville.

Camp Northwest Burned & Skirmish at Gatewood's
Aug. 23, 1863
Averell's troopers burn Camp Northwest's buildings, wagons, and stores. At 10:00 AM, his advance hits Jackson and Lt. George W. Siple (Company F, 19th VA Cavalry) at Gatewood's, triggering a running rear-guard fight east toward Warm Springs.

Repulsed at White Sulphur Springs (Rocky Gap)
Aug. 26–27, 1863
Turning west from Callaghan's toward Lewisburg, Averell collides with Col. George S. Patton's Confederate brigade at Rocky Gap and is forced to retreat after two days of heavy fighting.

Retreat Back Through Pocahontas County
Aug. 30–31, 1863
Harassed by Confederate cavalry and local bushwhackers, Averell withdraws north through Pocahontas County and returns safely to Huttonsville and Beverly.

August 22: Huntersville and the Fall of Camp Northwest

While Major General Samuel Jones misread Averell's August 20–21 movements around Monterey as a thrust toward Staunton, Robert E. Lee correctly guessed that Huntersville and Lewisburg were the real targets. Moving southwest from Monterey, Averell's vanguard approached Pocahontas County from the northeast and halted for the night near Gibson's Store, about five miles northeast of Huntersville.

  • Arnett Cut Off Along Knapp Creek: Colonel William W. Arnett of the 20th Virginia Cavalry sent urgent word to Jackson that Averell's column was pressing him back toward Back Creek. When Arnett's mounted troopers rode into Camp Northwest—Jackson's headquarters and supply depot three miles from Huntersville that anchored the county-wide "Huntersville Line"—they brought in Arnett's wagon train and reported that Arnett and his dismounted men had been cut off and were working their way down Knapp Creek.

  • Evacuating the Line: Outnumbered and chronically short of mounts, Jackson immediately ordered his dismounted troopers nine miles east to Gatewood's, leaving only a small mounted screen behind at Camp Northwest. During the early hours of the night, Jackson rode to Gatewood's himself, reinforced Captain Evans's picket and roadblock detachment with two companies, and positioned Lieutenant Colonel William P. Thompson with the dismounted men a mile behind Evans.

  • Skirmish and Destruction (August 22–23): Averell's troopers skirmished through Huntersville on August 22, sweeping Jackson's command out of Pocahontas County, and captured and burned Camp Northwest—destroying its buildings, wagons, supplies, and stockpiled weapons.

August 23: Lt. George W. Siple's Rear-Guard Fight at Gatewood's

The next morning found Jackson's command strung out along the mountain road between Huntersville and Warm Springs, trying to buy time to get its dismounted men and remaining gear across the Jackson River.

  • Thinning the Screen: Feeling exposed at Gatewood's on the morning of August 23, Jackson sent his dismounted men ahead to the Jackson River on the Warm Springs road and ordered Arnett to follow with the main body of cavalry.

  • Company F Holds the Rear: Staying behind with Colonel Jackson at Gatewood's to watch for the Federals was Lieutenant George W. Siple of Pocahontas County's Company F, 19th Virginia Cavalry (Capt. William L. McNeel's company) with just 30 men.

  • The 10:00 AM Clash: Around 10:00 AM, Averell's advance guard came into sight and opened a sharp skirmish with Jackson's small screen. Jackson fell back eastward with Lt. Siple's 30 troopers serving as the rear guard, trading fire with the pursuing Federals as they retired. Along the retreat route, Jackson periodically posted detachments of his dismounted men to make brief delaying stands until the brigade cleared the pass toward Warm Springs.

Aftermath: Rocky Gap and the Road to Droop Mountain

With Jackson pushed out of Pocahontas County into Bath County, Averell pushed south through Warm Springs to Callaghan's, destroying a second Confederate saltpeter works and capturing supply wagons near Covington. Turning west toward Lewisburg at 4:00 AM on August 26, his column ran headlong into Colonel George S. Patton's Confederate brigade at Rocky Gap (White Sulphur Springs / Dry Creek).

After two days of brutal, seesaw fighting (August 26–27) that cost Averell 218 casualties to Patton's 162, the Federals broke off and retreated north back through Bath and Pocahontas counties—harassed by pursuing Confederate cavalry and local guerrillas—reaching Huttonsville and Beverly on August 30–31.

Strategically, the August raid was a mixed verdict:
  • Tactical Gains: Averell destroyed two saltpeter works, wiped out Camp Northwest, and brought back prisoners, cattle, and horses.

  • Missed Prize: He failed to reach Lewisburg or seize the law books, which Confederate authorities promptly evacuated to Richmond after the battle.

  • Rehearsal for November: More importantly for Pocahontas County, the August march gave Averell's mounted infantry and the 14th Pennsylvania Cavalry firsthand knowledge of the Greenbrier Valley roads and Mudwall Jackson's defenses—experience they put to direct use ten weeks later on the road to Droop Mountain.

--------
The Battle of White Sulphur Springs—known variously as Rocky Gap, Dry Creek, Howard's Creek, and the "Battle of the Law Books"—was a hard-fought two-day Confederate victory in Greenbrier County that stopped Brigadier General William W. Averell's August 1863 raid cold. Commanding the First Brigade in Brigadier General John Echols's absence, Colonel George S. Patton (grandfather of the World War II general) won the battle before a shot was fired by winning a 24-hour footrace to the bottleneck at Rocky Gap, then outlasting Averell's repeated assaults until the Federals ran out of ammunition.

Battle DetailUnion (Averell)Confederate (Patton)
Date & LocationAugust 26–27, 1863 — 1.5 miles east of White Sulphur Springs (Rocky Gap / Dry Creek)
CommanderBrig. Gen. William W. Averell (4th Separate Brigade)Col. George S. Patton (Echols's First Brigade)
Units Engaged2nd, 3rd, and 8th WV Mounted Infantry; 14th PA Cavalry; Gibson's Cavalry Battalion; Battery G, 1st WV Light Artillery (Ewing's Battery)22nd and 45th VA Infantry; 23rd (Derrick's) and 26th (Edgar's) VA Infantry Battalions; 37th VA Cavalry Battalion (200 men); 8th VA Cavalry (5 cos., arrived evening of Aug. 26); Chapman's Battery
Strength~1,300 engaged~2,300 engaged
Casualties218 (26 killed, 125 wounded, 67 captured/missing) — 14th PA Cavalry alone lost 102162 (20 killed, 129 wounded, 13 missing) — 22nd VA Infantry lost 79

Winning the Race to Rocky Gap (August 25–26)

Averell's column departed Callaghan's at 4:00 AM on August 26, marching west over two mountain ranges toward White Sulphur Springs and Lewisburg. His objective was to seize Lewisburg and its Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals law library, then threaten the Virginia & Tennessee Railroad.

Patton recognized the danger immediately and drove his infantry brigade on a nearly nonstop 24-hour forced march, arriving about a mile and a half east of White Sulphur Springs at 9:00 AM on August 26—barely thirty minutes before Averell's advance guard spilled out of Rocky Gap.

  • First Contact (9:30 AM): Averell's vanguard—four companies of the 2nd and 8th West Virginia Mounted Infantry under Captain Paul von Koenig—ran straight into Company B, 26th Virginia Infantry Battalion (under Captain Edmund S. Read), which Lieutenant Colonel George M. Edgar had posted inside Henry Miller's house along the road. Read's men opened fire to buy time while Patton deployed his main line across the narrow valley.

Day 1: Nine Hours of Attrition (August 26)

Patton anchored his defense across the turnpike using the high ground on both flanks to negate Averell's mobility:

  • Patton's Line: He placed the 45th Virginia Infantry (Col. William H. Browne) on his right, sending 100 men to extend the line onto a small hill on the extreme flank, and deployed the 22nd Virginia Infantry on his left, backed by Chapman's Battery (two 3-inch rifles, a 12-pounder howitzer, and a 24-pounder howitzer). Around 10:00 AM, Lieutenant Colonel Clarence Derrick's 23rd Virginia Infantry Battalion and 200 men of the 37th Virginia Cavalry Battalion reinforced the line.

  • Averell's Assaults: Averell threw the 8th West Virginia (Col. John H. Oley) against Patton's right, while stacking the 2nd West Virginia, 14th Pennsylvania Cavalry, and Gibson's Battalion on the right side of the road against Patton's left.

  • Incessant Fire and Artillery Duel: For four to five hours, the valley echoed with nonstop musketry and cannon fire. Union gunners of Ewing's Battery battered Chapman's guns—hitting one piece twice and forcing three of Chapman's four guns to pull back for repairs—before Ewing himself was severely wounded and his battery began running dry.

  • Bloody Repulses on the Right: Desperate to crack Patton's left, Averell ordered repeated charges:

    • The 2nd West Virginia stormed the 22nd Virginia and two companies of the 23rd Virginia Battalion, only to be cut down within 15 steps of the Confederate line. Their commander, Major Francis P. McNally, was mortally wounded and captured.

    • The 14th Pennsylvania Cavalry charged into the Confederate barricades in brutal hand-to-hand combat—sabers against muskets and bayonets. Captain John Bird was wounded and captured, and the 14th Pennsylvania absorbed 102 casualties, nearly half of Averell's entire loss for the battle.

    • Around 5:00 PM, Captain Paul von Koenig—Averell's daring chief scout—was killed on the field.

By 7:00 PM, fighting died down with both armies holding the exact ground they had occupied that morning.

Day 2: Resupply vs. Bluff (August 27)

Both sides slept in line of battle and held councils of war overnight. The logistical balance shifted decisively in the dark:

  • Patton Reinforced: Overnight, Patton received fresh ammunition and was joined by Colonel James M. Corns with five companies of the 8th Virginia Cavalry (held in reserve for the morning).

  • Averell's Bluff: Averell's men were nearly out of cartridges, and Ewing's Battery had exhausted its ammunition. Averell chose to resume fighting at dawn largely as a bluff—hoping either that Patton would pull back or that promised Union reinforcements and ammunition would arrive from the Kanawha Valley.

At daybreak on August 27, Averell launched two final probing attacks—including an assault repulsed by the 45th Virginia. When Patton's line refused to budge and no Kanawha relief appeared, Averell broke off the engagement. Forced to leave behind one disabled cannon, Captain Ewing, and 55 severely wounded soldiers in two roadside field hospitals, Averell retreated toward Warm Springs and Callaghan's (reaching Callaghan's around 5:00 PM).

Patton sent Colonel Corns's 8th Virginia Cavalry and a rifled gun in pursuit. Corns blasted through Averell's first felled-tree roadblock, but a second heavy blockade slowed the chase enough for Averell to slip north back through Pocahontas County to Beverly.

Strategic Impact

Patton's stand at Rocky Gap was a major setback for Union plans in western Virginia:
  • The Law Library Saved: Averell never reached Lewisburg; Confederate authorities immediately evacuated the Virginia Supreme Court law library to Richmond.

  • Patton's Reputation & Troop Shifts: Patton proved he could command an independent brigade under sustained pressure, and his victory allowed Department commander Major General Samuel Jones to shift troops toward East Tennessee.

  • Setting Up Droop Mountain: Though Averell's August raid failed to secure the Greenbrier Valley, the lessons he learned fighting Patton's infantry at Rocky Gap—especially the need for a larger combined-arms force and a flanking column—directly shaped his return ten weeks later at the Battle of Droop Mountain.

-----------
At White Sulphur Springs in August 1863, Brigadier General William W. Averell blundered into a meeting engagement with a light raiding force, bled his regiments in repeated frontal assaults, and ran out of ammunition. Ten weeks later at Droop Mountain, he inverted nearly every element of that playbook—bringing heavy foot infantry, doubling his artillery, using a deliberate fixing feint to mask a nine-mile flanking march, and relying on Signal Corps intelligence to time the knockout blow.

Tactical DimensionWhite Sulphur Springs (Aug. 26–27, 1863)Droop Mountain (Nov. 6, 1863)
Force Composition & Size~1,300 engaged: 2nd, 3rd, and 8th WV Mounted Infantry, 14th PA Cavalry, Gibson's Battalion, and 1 artillery battery (Ewing's Battery G)~5,000 total column: Added 2 veteran foot-infantry regiments (10th WV and 28th OH), Co. C 16th IL Cavalry, a 68th NY Signal Corps detachment, and a 2nd artillery battery (Keeper's Battery B)
Operational DesignSingle isolated raid column relying on uncoordinated hope of Kanawha Valley reliefCoordinated two-column pincer: Averell drove south from Beverly while Brig. Gen. Alfred N. Duffié marched east from Charleston to trap Echols at Lewisburg
Opening ReconnaissanceReactive meeting engagement; vanguard ran straight into Capt. Read's ambush at Henry Miller's houseDeliberate morning reconnaissance from Mill Point/Hillsboro; Averell immediately ruled out a frontal assault up the 3,100-foot ridge as suicidal
Primary Attack PlanHead-on attrition in a narrow valley—repeated frontal charges against Patton's entrenched flanksThree-sided dismounted attack: fixing demonstration on the Confederate right, deep flanking envelopment on the Confederate left, and a timed reserve/frontal push
Use of Cavalry14th PA Cavalry thrown into costly saber-vs.-musket frontal charges (102 casualties)14th PA Cavalry used to screen and pin the Confederate right with artillery; most of Gibson's Battalion held in reserve for pursuit
Command & LogisticsExhausted rifle and artillery ammo on Day 1; Day 2 reduced to a failed bluffSustained supply for a decisive single-day push; Signal Corps relayed real-time breaks in the Confederate line
Tactical OutcomeUnion repulse: 218 Union vs. 162 Confederate casualties; abandoned 1 gun and 55 woundedUnion victory: 119 Union vs. ~275 Confederate casualties; broke organized Confederate resistance in West Virginia

1. Rebuilding the Force Mix: Foot Infantry and Double Artillery

White Sulphur Springs exposed the core limitation of Averell's 4th Separate Brigade: mounted infantrymen armed with short Enfields and troopers carrying carbines did not have the sustained firepower or ammunition depth to pry entrenched Confederate infantry out of mountain gaps. When Ewing's Battery ran dry on August 26, Averell lost his only leverage against Colonel George S. Patton's line.

For the November expedition, Averell corrected both weaknesses before leaving Beverly:

  • Adding Staying Power: He incorporated Colonel Augustus Moor's veteran foot infantry—569 men of the 10th West Virginia (armed with .58-caliber Enfields) and 605 men of the 28th Ohio (armed with .69-caliber muskets)—giving him a dedicated shock force capable of grinding through wooded mountain terrain.

  • Doubling the Guns: Alongside Captain Chatham T. Ewing's Battery G, he brought Captain John V. Keeper's Battery B, 1st West Virginia Light Artillery. Even though the steep terrain at Droop Mountain forced Union gunners to fire from a hill roughly 500 feet below the Confederate batteries on the crest, having two batteries kept continuous pressure on Echols's right and center without running dry.

2. Replacing Frontal Attrition with a Fixing Feint and Deep Envelopment

At Rocky Gap, Averell had neither the room nor the patience to turn Patton's flanks; he fed the 2nd West Virginia and 14th Pennsylvania Cavalry straight into the Confederate left until they were cut to pieces at fifteen paces.

At Droop Mountain, Averell refused to repeat that mistake. After moving his skirmishers out on confusing, varied routes from Mill Point and Hillsboro shortly after sunrise to mask his intentions, he studied the ridge and built a three-part dismounted plan:

  1. The Fixing Feint (Union Left / Confederate Right): Instead of sacrificing Colonel James M. Schoonmaker's 14th Pennsylvania Cavalry in another frontal charge, Averell paired them with his artillery on the Union left to keep Jackson's and Echols's attention locked on the turnpike and the eastern approaches.

  2. The Deep Envelopment (Union Right / Confederate Left): Shortly after 9:00 AM, Averell sent Colonel Augustus Moor with 1,175 men (10th West Virginia, 28th Ohio, Company C of the 16th Illinois Cavalry, and signalmen) marching backward one mile to stay out of sight, then swinging along an obscure six-to-nine-mile circuitous route through the timber to strike Lieutenant Colonel William P. Thompson's 19th Virginia Cavalry on the Confederate left.

  3. The Reserve Hammer: Rather than committing everything at once as he had on August 26, Averell held his mounted infantry and reserve elements ready to strike the center and right once Moor's flanking blow forced Echols to strip his line.

3. Real-Time Battlefield Intelligence via the Signal Corps

One of the sharpest technical upgrades between August and November was battlefield communications. At White Sulphur Springs, Averell fought blind on the morning of August 27—launching probing attacks in the hope that Patton was weakening or that Kanawha reinforcements were nearby.

At Droop Mountain, Averell attached a Signal Corps detachment from the 68th New York Infantry (commanded by Captain Ernst A. Denicke, with Lieutenant Abraham C. Merritt accompanying Moor's flanking column). As Moor's infantry fought almost blind through the woods on the Confederate left and Patton shifted troops to shore up the center, the signalmen monitored the ridge. Around 3:00 PM, they flagged Averell that the Confederate line was beginning to buckle. Armed with that confirmation, Averell committed his final reserve at the exact tipping point, collapsing Echols's defense within an hour.

4. The Operational Pincer—and the One Habit Averell Didn't Break

At the theater level, Department commander Benjamin F. Kelley also applied the lessons of August by pairing Averell's advance with Brigadier General Alfred N. Duffié's brigade marching east from Charleston. Even though Duffié never fired a shot at Droop Mountain, word that his column was only 18 miles from lightly defended Lewisburg weighed heavily on Echols's decision to abandon the mountain rather than risk total encirclement.

Yet Averell's cautious streak still showed in the final hours of November 6. After breaking the Confederate line around 4:00 PM, he sent a battalion and two guns in pursuit but chose not to press the beaten Confederates aggressively that evening, writing afterward that he hoped Echols would loiter on the road and be caught the next day between his column and Duffié's. Echols did the opposite—driving his shattered brigade on an exhausting night march through Lewisburg before dawn on November 7, slipping out of the trap hours before Duffié rode into town.

Averell solved his tactical problem completely between August and November—turning a bloody frontal stalemate at Rocky Gap into a textbook mountain envelopment at Droop Mountain—but it would take his third raid a month later to Salem to finally solve the operational problem of reaching the Virginia & Tennessee Railroad.
------
At the Battle of Droop Mountain on November 6, 1863, Colonel Thomas Maley Harris and the 10th West Virginia Infantry provided the decisive offensive punch of Colonel Augustus Moor's flanking column. While the 28th Ohio Infantry absorbed the initial Confederate counter-thrust on the mountain's western approaches, Harris swung his 569 West Virginians into line on Moor's right, drove back the Confederate left flank with sustained Enfield rifle fire, and forced Brigadier General John Echols to strip his center—triggering the collapse of the entire Confederate position.

Regimental Profile10th West Virginia Infantry at Droop Mountain
CommanderCol. Thomas Maley Harris (physician from Glenville, Gilmer County; Ritchie County native)
Higher CommandCol. Augustus Moor's 1,175-man flanking column (Averell's 4th Separate Brigade)
Strength Engaged569 officers and men (9 companies present; Company I detached to Grant County)
Armament.58-caliber Enfield rifled muskets (longer-range precision than the 28th Ohio's .69-caliber muskets)
Tactical PositionDeployed to the front on Moor's right (extreme Union right / Confederate left flank)
Battle TollAlongside the 28th Ohio, suffered the highest casualties of any Union regiment on the field

Colonel Harris and the 10th West Virginia

Born in 1813 in what became Ritchie County and practicing medicine at Glenville in Gilmer County when the war broke out, Thomas Maley Harris had raised the 10th West Virginia Infantry in the spring of 1862 at the request of Major General William S. Rosecrans. Recruited across central and northern West Virginia (including Glenville, Sutton, Philippi, and Piedmont), the regiment was composed of mountain Unionists who knew the Allegheny terrain as intimately as the Confederates waiting on the crest above them.

By November 1863, the 10th West Virginia was a seasoned outfit—having guarded the Baltimore & Ohio Railroad, fought at Beverly and Bulltown, and endured Averell's August 1863 raid to Rocky Gap. Going into Droop Mountain, Harris fielded 569 men (with Company I detached to Grant County), equipped with .58-caliber Enfield rifles that gave Moor's column accurate long-range firepower in the timbered slopes alongside the 28th Ohio's 605 men carrying .69-caliber "big bore" muskets.

The Flanking March (9:00 AM – 1:45 PM)

Early on November 6, Brigadier General William W. Averell surveyed the 3,100-foot crest of Droop Mountain from the Little Levels and concluded that a direct frontal assault up the turnpike would be a disaster. He assigned the flanking blow to Colonel Augustus Moor (commanding the 28th Ohio), placing Harris's 10th West Virginia Infantry, Lieutenant Colonel Gottfried Becker's 28th Ohio Infantry, Company C of the 16th Illinois Cavalry, and a Signal Corps detachment from the 68th New York under Lieutenant Abraham C. Merritt under Moor's command.

  • Concealing the Movement: Departing shortly after 9:00 AM, Moor's 1,175-man column first fell back roughly one mile to drop out of sight of Confederate observers overlooking Hillsboro and Mill Point.

  • The Circuitous Approach: Screened by Colonel James M. Schoonmaker's 14th Pennsylvania Cavalry and Union artillery demonstrating on the opposite flank, Harris and Moor marched their foot infantry along an obscure, six-to-nine-mile circuitous route through rugged mountain woods. The grueling four-and-a-half-hour climb brought the column undetected onto the Confederate left flank, held by Lieutenant Colonel William P. Thompson's dismounted 19th Virginia Cavalry and elements of the 20th Virginia Cavalry.

Striking the Confederate Left (1:45 PM – 4:00 PM)

Moor's flanking force collided with the Confederate left at approximately 1:45 PM.

  • The 28th Ohio Absorbs the First Shock: Leading the advance, Lieutenant Colonel Becker and the 28th Ohio Infantry ran into the Confederate flank and were hit by a sharp counter-thrust from the defenders. Moor steadied his German-Ohioan veterans by ordering them to lie down and "fire by file," holding the ground while the rest of his column deployed.

  • Harris Brings the 10th West Virginia Forward: While the 28th Ohio pinned the Confederates in front, Colonel Harris moved the 10th West Virginia Infantry up to the front on Moor's right, extending the Union line beyond the Confederate left. Pouring steady .58-caliber Enfield fire into the timber, Harris's regiment began steadily pushing the outnumbered Confederate defenders back.

  • Creating the Fatal Angle: As the 10th West Virginia and 28th Ohio rolled up the flank, the retreating Confederate left bent backward into a dangerous, exposed angle. To prevent his line from being folded completely, Brigadier General John Echols was forced to pull troops from his center and right to shore up the crumbling flank.

  • The Collapse: Once Moor's signalmen flagged that the Confederate line was weakening, Averell unleashed his three dismounted mounted-infantry regiments (2nd, 3rd, and 8th West Virginia) obliquely up the face of the mountain against the thinned Confederate center. Caught between Harris and Moor pressing down the ridge from the left and Averell's frontal assault surging over the breastworks, Confederate soldiers began to panic over being cut off from the Lewisburg road and broke into retreat around 4:00 PM.

Casualties, Aftermath, and Later Service

The close-quarters timber fighting on the flank came at a heavy cost: out of Averell's 140 total casualties (45 killed or mortally wounded, 93 wounded, and 2 captured), the 10th West Virginia Infantry and the 28th Ohio Infantry suffered the highest losses of any Union regiments engaged.

  • Returning Through Hillsboro: After the Confederate retreat through Lewisburg, Moor's infantry column marched back north through Pocahontas County, stopping at Hillsboro to collect 55 wounded Union soldiers and one wounded Confederate in ambulances and wagons.

  • Winter Duty and Beyond: Following a November 10 skirmish at Hillsboro, the 10th West Virginia returned to Beverly, spending the winter and spring of 1863–1864 scouting across Randolph, Tucker, Pocahontas, Greenbrier, and neighboring counties before moving east to fight in the 1864 Shenandoah Valley Campaign (Third Winchester and Cedar Creek) and the 1865 Appomattox Campaign.

  • Colonel Harris's Later Career: Harris's steady battlefield leadership earned him brigade command—passing regimental command of the 10th West Virginia to Lieutenant Colonel Moses S. Hall—and eventual promotion to brigadier general (brevet major general). He later gained national prominence in 1865 as a member of the Military Commission that tried the Lincoln assassination conspirators.

Note for primary-source verification: For the exact company-by-company casualty roll of the 10th West Virginia on November 6 and Colonel Harris's verbatim after-action dispatch, consult The War of the Rebellion: Official Records, Series I, Volume 29, Part 1 (Chapter XLI) and Terry Lowry's Last Sleep: The Battle of Droop Mountain, November 6, 1863.

------
After the Battle of Droop Mountain, the 10th West Virginia Infantry spent six months anchored at Beverly conducting grueling winter and spring counter-guerrilla sweeps across the Allegheny borderlands—including an action at Hillsboro on November 10, 1863, a wilderness ambush along the Cheat River toward the headwaters of the Greenbrier on December 6, 1863, and a major final sweep through Pocahontas, Webster, and Braxton counties in May 1864.

DateOperation / EngagementKey Details & Outcome
Nov. 10, 1863Action at Hillsboro (Pocahontas Co.)Logged on the 10th WV's battle honors during the return leg of Averell's Nov. 1–17 raid.
Nov. 1863 – May 1864Winter Garrison & Mountain Scouting (HQ: Beverly)Continuous patrols across Randolph, Tucker, Pocahontas, Greenbrier, Braxton, Highland, Pendleton, and Webster counties.
Dec. 6, 1863Skirmish on Cheat River (Randolph–Pocahontas headwaters)Five-day wilderness scout toward the head of the Greenbrier River; Co. F detachment kills 1, wounds 1, and captures 7 prisoners (Sgt. Norman B. Squires wounded twice in the leg).
Jan. 3, 1864Moorefield JunctionMid-winter detachment clash outside the Pocahontas sector.
May 15–30, 1864Scout through Pocahontas, Webster, and Braxton CountiesFifteen-day sweep from Beverly capturing 36 prisoners, 85 horses, and 40 head of cattle before the regiment moved east to the Shenandoah Valley.

The November 10, 1863 Action at Hillsboro

In the National Park Service's compilation of Dyer's Compendium, Hillsboro (November 10, 1863) is entered directly on the 10th West Virginia Infantry's service record as the final Pocahontas County engagement of Averell's Raid against Lewisburg and the Virginia & Tennessee Railroad (November 1–17).

  • Tactical Context: Four days after the November 6 victory on Droop Mountain, Averell's columns were pulling back north out of the Greenbrier Valley toward Beverly. Colonel Augustus Moor's foot-infantry column—comprising the 10th West Virginia and 28th Ohio—had the slow, vulnerable task of escorting the battle's wounded back through the Little Levels at Hillsboro, while scattered elements of Colonel William L. "Mudwall" Jackson's 19th and 20th Virginia Cavalry and local irregulars hovered along the mountain flanks.

  • Record Limitations: Unlike Mill Point (Nov. 5) and Droop Mountain (Nov. 6), the November 10 Hillsboro clash does not appear with a standalone tactical narrative or separate casualty breakdown in open-web summaries of the Official Records. To pull the exact skirmish details or any individual company casualties from that date, the primary trail runs through the 10th West Virginia Infantry muster rolls in the West Virginia Adjutant General Papers (West Virginia State Archives) and the November 1863 return-march dispatches in Official Records, Series I, Volume 29, Part 1.

Winter 1863–64: Scouting Out of Beverly

Once back in winter quarters at Beverly—where the regiment transitioned from Averell's 4th Separate Brigade to the 1st Brigade, 4th Division, Department of West Virginia in December 1863—the 10th West Virginia did not sit idle behind earthworks. Across the winter of 1863–64, while Mudwall Jackson's 19th and 20th Virginia Cavalry conducted picket duty and minor raids along the Virginia–West Virginia border, the 10th West Virginia ran relentless multi-day foot patrols through Randolph, Tucker, Pocahontas, Greenbrier, Braxton, Highland, Pendleton, and Webster counties to break up guerrilla bands, intercept Confederate scouts, and deny livestock and forage to enemy raiders.

Eyewitness on the December 6, 1863 Cheat River Scout

One of the clearest surviving firsthand accounts of what those winter patrols into the Pocahontas borderlands actually looked like comes from Private Sheldon C. Morrison of Company F, 10th West Virginia Infantry (a Braxton County native), writing to his wife from Camp Beverly on December 10, 1863—just days after the December 6 Cheat River skirmish listed in the regiment's official honors:

  • Into the Trackless Headwaters: Carrying six days' rations (and staying out five days), Morrison's scouting detachment marched straight into the high country "towards the head of Greenbrier River"—the rugged, largely unsettled mountain divide between Randolph and northern Pocahontas counties. On the first night they camped in a pine thicket on the headwaters of one of the prongs of the Cheat River.

  • Living Off the Woods: Morrison marveled at how remote the route was: "The second day we started bright and early. We traveled all day and yet saw no farm yet nor nary one the day before and the like of dear [deer] and bear you never heard of in your life. We killed no bear but killed plenty of deer and done fine. We went a way that no man ever was in the world". On the second night, they finally emerged onto a mountain road with about a hundred cleared acres and three homesteads, where the patrol quartered for the night.

  • The Ambush Along the Prongs of Cheat: Splitting into separate squads to sweep down different forks of the Cheat River and converge the next morning, Morrison's group—including Lieutenant Henry Bender and Sergeant Norman B. Squires—stepped directly in front of the opposing party and halted them. Most of the Confederates surrendered as the rest of the squad closed in; four escaped, while the 10th West Virginia brought back 7 prisoners, leaving 1 killed and 1 wounded. On the Union side, Sergeant Squires was shot twice in one leg in the brief exchange, though Morrison noted he would recover.

Closing the Beverly Chapter: The May 15–30, 1864 Sweep

Before leaving the Allegheny sector permanently for the Shenandoah Valley and, ultimately, Petersburg and Appomattox, the 10th West Virginia mounted one final large-scale sweep across the central mountain counties.

From May 15 to May 30, 1864, a Federal scouting expedition out of Beverly—including elements of the 10th West Virginia—swept through Pocahontas, Webster, and Braxton counties. Over fifteen days on the mountain roads, the column cleared out local irregulars and Confederate foraging parties, returning to Beverly with 36 prisoners, 85 horses, and 40 head of cattle. Weeks later, the regiment was pulled east to Harpers Ferry and Leetown, bringing its two-year contest with Pocahontas County's mountains and cavalry to a close.

---------
The **May 15–30, 1864 scout from Beverly through Pocahontas, Webster, and Braxton counties** was the final major mountain sweep conducted by the **10th West Virginia Infantry** before the regiment left the Allegheny sector permanently for the Shenandoah Valley. Logged in Frederick H. Dyer's *Compendium* as a 15-day expedition with the 10th West Virginia as the sole credited unit, it functioned as a classic counter-guerrilla and livestock-confiscation raid across three of central West Virginia's most rugged, contested counties.

| Expedition Detail | Record |
| --- | --- |
| **Dates** | May 15–30, 1864 (15 days out of Beverly) |
| **Union Unit** | **10th West Virginia Infantry** (attached to Kelley's Command, Reserve Division, Department of West Virginia) |
| **Route / Area of Operations** | From **Beverly** (Randolph County) through **Pocahontas, Webster, and Braxton counties**, returning to Beverly on May 30 |
| **Documented Captures** | **36 prisoners**, **85 horses**, and **40 head of cattle** |
| **High-Profile Target Reported** | Wire dispatches reported the capture of **"the notorious Major Triplett"** (Marshall Triplett, Webster/Braxton Confederate partisan leader) among the 36 prisoners |

---

## Strategic Timing: A Sweep During a Theater-Wide Shakeup

The scout stepped off from Beverly on **May 15, 1864**—a pivotal day across Virginia and West Virginia:

* **Covering the Mountain Rear:** On that same day, Major General Franz Sigel was defeated at the **Battle of New Market** in the Shenandoah Valley, while Brigadier Generals William W. Averell and George Crook united their raiding columns farther south at **Union, West Virginia**. With regular Confederate cavalry pulled east and south to meet those major offensives, the 10th West Virginia's sweep was aimed at clearing out local irregulars, seizing mounts and beef cattle before Confederate foragers could collect them, and keeping the central mountain backdoor quiet.
* **Intelligence on the March:** According to Herman E. Matheny's biography *Major General Thomas Maley Harris*, while the 10th West Virginia was moving through Pocahontas, Webster, and Braxton counties, Colonel Harris's command received word that Sigel was still back at Woodstock, Virginia, while Crook had marched east.
* **End of the Beverly Garrison Era:** Four days into the scout, on **May 19, 1864**, Major General **David Hunter** was appointed to replace Sigel in command of the Department of West Virginia (assuming command on May 21). Once the 10th West Virginia returned to Beverly on May 30, its six-month mountain-scouting chapter closed; within weeks the regiment was pulled east to Harpers Ferry, fighting at **Leetown (July 3)** and **Maryland Heights (July 6–7)**.

---

## The Haul and the "Major Triplett" Wire Report

Late-19th-century West Virginia county histories—including Hu Maxwell's *History of Randolph County* and *History of Barbour County*, as well as W. B. Cutright's *History of Upshur County*—all preserve the exact same official tally for the 15-day march: **36 prisoners, 85 horses, and 40 head of cattle** brought back to Beverly on May 30.

Contemporary newspaper wire dispatches add a striking detail that the brief county chronologies omit. On **June 4, 1864**, the *Burlington Weekly Hawk Eye* carried the telegraph summary of the Beverly scout's haul—36 prisoners, 85 horses, and 40 head of cattle—and added:

> *"The notorious major Triplett is reported to be among the prisoners."*

That reference points directly to **Marshall Triplett**—variously styled "Major" or "Captain" Marshall Triplett of the Virginia Partisan Rangers—a Braxton County resident and Upperglade, Webster County guerrilla leader who was one of the most active Confederate irregulars operating across the Braxton–Webster–Pocahontas borderlands. Triplett was indeed captured by Federal forces during the war and held at **Camp Chase, Ohio** (alongside Captain John S. Spriggs, where both faced threatened execution in a retaliation dispute before being held as regular prisoners of war). Because the June 4 press wire explicitly hedged that Triplett was *"reported to be"* among the captives, checking his Camp Chase POW ledger is the surest way to confirm whether the May 15–30 scout was the exact operation that bagged him or whether the wire jumped the gun.

---

## Why the Day-by-Day Route Is Sparse—and Where to Pull Primary Records

Unlike pitched engagements such as Droop Mountain or Rocky Gap, multi-county counter-guerrilla scouts rarely generated detailed battlefield maps or full published narratives in open-web summaries. To reconstruct the exact route through Pocahontas, Webster, and Braxton counties—along with the names of the 36 prisoners and which company officers led the detachments—the primary trail runs through four sources:

* ***The War of the Rebellion: Official Records*, Series I, Volume 37, Part 1:** Covers Department of West Virginia operations in May 1864, including Colonel Thomas M. Harris's Beverly dispatches and Kelley's Reserve Division correspondence.
* **Herman E. Matheny, *Major General Thomas Maley Harris*:** Draws directly on the *Official Records* and Harris's papers for the 10th West Virginia's May 1864 transition from Beverly to the Shenandoah Valley.
* **10th West Virginia Infantry Company Muster Rolls (May–June 1864):** Filed in the **West Virginia Adjutant General Papers** (West Virginia State Archives), which often note brief "Remarks" on individual scouts, horse details, and skirmishes.
* **Camp Chase, Ohio POW Registers (June 1864):** Useful for cross-checking prisoners booked out of Beverly in early June 1864 to identify Pocahontas, Webster, and Braxton County men—and to verify Marshall Triplett's exact capture date. 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

No comments:

Post a Comment

Tin Cup Base

6 Surprising Realities of Mountain Warfare in Pocahontas County That History Books Left Out When modern popular histories recount the Americ...

Shaker Posts