| Feature | Pocahontas Rescuers (Rescues) | Pocahontas Riflemen (Reserves) |
| Muster Date & Site | May 18, 1861, at Huntersville | May 29, 1861, at Green Bank |
| Original Captain | Daniel A. Stofer (attorney, Mexican War veteran) | James C. Arbogast (promoted to Major, 31st VA, June 9, 1862) |
| 1861 Assignment | Independent at Philippi, then Co. D, 9th Battalion VA Infantry (Hansbrough's) | Co. G, 31st Virginia Infantry (mustered into CSA service July 1861) |
| 1862–1865 Assignment | Merged into 25th Virginia Infantry as 2nd Company I (spring 1862) | Remained Company G, 31st Virginia Infantry throughout the war |
| 1861 Mountain Actions | Philippi, Corrick's Ford retreat, Cheat Mountain, Camp Bartow (Greenbrier River), Camp Allegheny | Rich Mountain, Cheat Mountain, Camp Bartow (Greenbrier River), Camp Allegheny |
| Major Eastern Theater Campaigns | Valley Campaign (1862), Seven Days, Cedar Mountain, 2nd Manassas, Antietam, Fredericksburg, Gettysburg, Wilderness–Cold Harbor, Early's 1864 Valley Campaign | Valley Campaign (Cross Keys/Port Republic), Gaines' Mill, Cedar Mountain, 2nd Manassas, Fredericksburg, Chancellorsville, 2nd Winchester, Gettysburg (Culp's Hill), Wilderness, Spotsylvania, Early's 1864 Valley Campaign & Fort Stevens |
| Regiment at Appomattox | 25th VA surrendered 15 men (1 officer, 14 enlisted) | 31st VA surrendered 56 men (7 officers, 49 enlisted) |
Leadership and Early Discipline
Stofer and the Rescuers: "Count" Daniel A. Stofer brought courtroom bluster and a notorious taste for liquor to Huntersville's company. His reported drunkenness as Officer of the Day on the night of June 2, 1861, contributed to the Confederate surprise at Philippi, and his capture during Garnett's retreat to Corrick's Ford removed him from field command barely two months after muster.
Arbogast and the Riflemen: James C. Arbogast proved a far steadier regimental officer. After leading Company G through the 1861 Allegheny campaigns and Jackson's 1862 Valley Campaign, he was promoted to Major of the 31st Virginia on June 9, 1862—the day Major Joseph H. Chenoweth was killed at Port Republic—serving in field command until his resignation on December 20, 1862.
County Geography and Recruitment
Huntersville (Central/Southern County): The Rescuers drew heavily around the county seat and the central Greenbrier corridor, organizing five days before Virginia voters ratified secession.
Green Bank (Northern County): The Riflemen pulled from the upper Greenbrier and Deer Creek communities—families like the Arbogasts, Warwicks, and Wooddells—mustering eleven days later.
Parallel Paths in the Same Theater
| Battle | Date | Regimental Commander | Brigade / Higher Command | 31st VA Regimental Losses |
| Camp Allegheny | Dec. 13, 1861 | Maj. Francis M. Boykin | Col. Edward Johnson, Army of the Northwest | 37 total casualties |
| Port Republic | June 9, 1862 | Col. John S. Hoffman | Elzey's / Walker's Brigade, Ewell's Division | 97 (Cross Keys & Port Republic combined); some accounts cite 34 killed, 83 wounded at Port Republic alone |
| Gettysburg (Culp's Hill) | July 1–3, 1863 | Col. John S. Hoffman | Brig. Gen. William "Extra Billy" Smith's Brigade, Early's Division | 27 (1 killed, 19 wounded, 7 missing of 267 engaged) |
Camp Allegheny (December 13, 1861)
Into the Northeast Brush: When Milroy's pickets opened fire around 8:00 AM in freezing winter wind, Johnson ordered the 31st Virginia—led by Major Francis M. Boykin—to occupy the ground near the old Staunton-Parkersburg Turnpike northeast of the winter camp.
Side-by-Side with the Rescuers: Hansbrough's 9th Virginia Battalion (which included Pocahontas County's other company, the Pocahontas Rescuers) was deployed immediately, fell back under pressure, and rallied directly on the 31st Virginia. Together, the two commands charged back through the felled timber and brush, pouring a heavy close-range fire into Milroy's advancing column.
Four Hours of "Indian Fighting": Because Colonel Gideon Moody's flanking Federal column arrived late on the opposite side of the camp, Johnson was able to fight off the two Union wings in turn. On the 31st's front, the battle devolved into a brutal, four-hour close-quarters firefight behind logs and trees—close enough that a Union soldier of the 2nd Virginia (U.S.) recalled that exposing an inch of skin meant taking a bullet.
Cost and Aftermath: John Robson of the 52nd Virginia noted that the 31st fought with particular ferocity because "Milroy stood between them and home". The 31st suffered 37 casualties in holding the pass, and the survivors endured a brutal winter at Camp Allegheny where exposure and disease ultimately claimed more lives than Milroy's rifles.
Port Republic (June 9, 1862)
Into the Wheatfield Crossfire: After the Stonewall Brigade was driven back, Colonel John S. Hoffman (newly elected regimental commander in the May 1 reorganization) led the 31st Virginia—advancing alongside the 25th Virginia, which now contained the Pocahontas Rescuers—onto General Charles Winder's right to steady the crumbling line.
Pinned Under Enfilade Fire: As soon as the 31st came on line, it absorbed the same blistering infantry volleys from the front and flanking artillery fire from the Coaling that had shattered Winder's men. Five color bearers of the 31st Virginia were shot down in succession until a lieutenant ordered the men to leave the flag lying on the ground. Pinned down by a Federal counterattack, the men of Company G lay flat in the wheat as minie balls sheared through the stalks above them until Richard Taylor's Louisiana Brigade finally stormed and held the Coaling.
Company G Casualties and Promotion: The regiment absorbed devastating losses—97 casualties reported across Cross Keys and Port Republic combined in official summaries, with battle accounts putting the Port Republic toll at 34 killed and 83 wounded, more killed than any other Confederate regiment on the field. Among the wounded from Company G was Green Bank enlistee Private Peter Hull Warwick (who survived to surrender at Appomattox). When Major Joseph H. Chenoweth was killed in the fighting, Captain James C. Arbogast of Company G was promoted on the spot—effective June 9, 1862—to Major of the 31st Virginia.
Gettysburg (July 1–3, 1863)
July 1–2 (The York Pike Delay): Company G missed the opening rout of the Union XI Corps on July 1 and Early's twilight assault on East Cemetery Hill on July 2. Smith—a 65-year-old former Virginia governor widely distrusted by his superiors—had reported a phantom threat of Union cavalry approaching from the east, resulting in his entire brigade being detached for two full days to guard the York Pike and eastern approaches.
July 3 (Culp's Hill and Spangler's Meadow): On the final morning of the battle, Smith's Brigade was finally pulled off the York Pike and rushed south to Culp's Hill to reinforce Edward "Allegheny" Johnson's Division—reuniting Company G with their old commander from Allegheny Mountain. The brigade took position behind the stone wall on the north edge of Spangler's Meadow, facing south with its left flank anchored on Rock Creek.
Action Across Rock Creek and the Meadow: During the morning's heavy fighting around lower Culp's Hill, Smith's men helped break the ill-fated Federal charge across Spangler's Meadow; following the repulse of the 27th Indiana, elements of Smith's Brigade pushed forward into the meadow to pour flanking and rear fire into the 2nd Massachusetts. In the shifting tactical fight along the creek, while the 49th Virginia stayed on the west side of Rock Creek, Hoffman reported that the 31st and 52nd Virginia recrossed the creek and moved southeastwardly to check Federal pressure on the flank.
Losses and Retreat: Compared to Port Republic, the stone wall and the late commitment spared the regiment from annihilation: the 31st Virginia lost 1 man killed, 19 wounded, and 7 missing (27 total, roughly 10% of the 267 engaged) out of 142 casualties in Smith's Brigade. After moving farther up Rock Creek, the regiment marched to Seminary Ridge during the night of July 3–4 to rejoin Early's Division, held that line through July 4, and began the retreat toward Hagerstown after midnight.
---------------------------------
Historical Context
The Unit: Organized in Pocahontas County under Captain Daniel A. Stofer, the Pocahontas Rescuers were mustered into the 25th Virginia Infantry—one of the earliest Confederate regiments formed in what was then northwestern Virginia, placed under Colonel George Porterfield.
Why "Tin Cup": In May and June 1861, Richmond's quartermaster system barely existed in the Allegheny counties. When the Rescuers marched out toward the northern front (ahead of the clashes at Philippi and Rich Mountain), the state had almost nothing to issue them—no standard uniforms, no tents, and few regulation accoutrements. Old soldiers later joked that a tin cup was about the only piece of government-issued gear they received, leaving them to march in homespun civilian clothes, carry homemade haversacks, and shoulder whatever hunting rifles or shotguns they brought from home.
The Early Ordeal: That lack of basic supply compounded the misery of the 1861 mountain campaigns—relentless rain, muddy turnpikes, and the hasty retreats and surrenders that cost the 25th Virginia roughly half its strength at Rich Mountain.

No comments:
Post a Comment