What If Covid Would Have Been Around in 1861--Cyber Fiction
Lee's Western Virginia Campaign: The Plague of '61
The Situation
In August 1861, Robert E. Lee arrived in Western Virginia to salvage a faltering Confederate campaign. The rugged Allegheny Mountains, incessant rains, and rampant camp diseases like measles and typhoid already challenged his command. Historically, this campaign was a frustrating failure, marked by logistical nightmares and poor morale. Now, imagine a far more insidious enemy arriving with the supply wagons: a novel coronavirus, 'COVID-19'. Unleashed into the dense, unsanitary camps of Huntersville, where germ theory was unknown and close quarters were unavoidable, this invisible killer would not only amplify existing suffering but fundamentally alter the course of the campaign, and perhaps, the early war itself.
Military Impact
The introduction of COVID-19 would have been catastrophic for Lee's already beleaguered Western Virginia campaign. His force, approximately 9,000 effective troops, was already grappling with high rates of dysentery, typhoid, and measles, which had reduced combat effectiveness by 10-15%. A rapidly spreading respiratory pathogen would have exponentially worsened this situation. Within weeks, 30-40% of his force could be incapacitated by severe fever, respiratory distress, and profound fatigue, rendering any offensive action impossible. Troop movements would halt, supply lines would become choked with the sick, and the logistical burden on an already strained commissary would become insurmountable. Morale, already low due to the harsh conditions and lack of decisive action, would plummet into despair as soldiers watched their comrades succumb to a mysterious, highly contagious 'camp fever' that baffled doctors.
Key officers, including Lee himself, though perhaps less exposed than the common soldier, would be at severe risk of debilitating illness, disrupting the chain of command at a critical juncture. The Battle of Cheat Mountain, historically a Confederate failure in early September, would likely never have occurred as an offensive. Instead, Lee would have been forced into a desperate defensive posture, or more probable, a chaotic and disease-ridden retreat, abandoning much of the strategic territory and resources of Western Virginia to the Union much earlier. The campaign would unequivocally have ended in an even more ignominious failure, potentially damaging Lee's nascent reputation more severely and sooner.
Medical Reality (1861)
Nineteenth-century medicine, operating without the benefit of germ theory, would have been utterly helpless against COVID-19. Camp surgeons, accustomed to treating familiar fevers, would have initially categorized the new affliction as another variant of 'camp fever,' 'influenza,' or an unusually virulent form of pneumonia or bronchitis, possibly linked to the damp, cold conditions.
Standard treatments would have included:
1. **Bleeding and Purging:** The prevailing humoral theory of disease often led to bloodletting, cupping, and the administration of purgatives (like calomel, a mercury compound) to 'rebalance' the body's humors. These would have severely weakened already compromised patients, exacerbating dehydration and contributing to circulatory collapse.
2. **Quinine and Whiskey:** Quinine, effective against malaria, was often used as a general anti-fever agent. While it might have provided some symptomatic relief for fevers, it would have no antiviral effect. Whiskey, used as a stimulant, analgesic, and antiseptic, would be prescribed liberally, offering false comfort but no cure, and potentially complicating dehydration.
3. **Opium:** Opium derivatives would be used to suppress coughs, ease pain, and induce sleep, providing temporary relief but masking severe respiratory distress and potentially contributing to respiratory depression. 4. **Nutritive Support:** 'Nourishing' broths or easily digestible foods might be offered, but proper rehydration and caloric intake would be difficult to manage for large numbers of severely ill men.
Critically, the absence of any understanding of airborne viral transmission meant no effective isolation protocols could be implemented beyond basic hospital tents, which themselves would become infection vectors. The close-quarter conditions of military encampments, shared blankets, communal cooking, and lack of personal hygiene would serve as ideal conduits for rapid, uncontrolled spread. The lack of oxygen therapy, intravenous fluids, and antibiotics for secondary bacterial infections (which would invariably complicate severe COVID-19 cases) would lead to an extremely high case fatality rate, far exceeding modern estimates. The camp hospitals would quickly be overwhelmed, turning into hospices rather than places of healing.
Chronology of the Outbreak
Lee Arrives in Huntersville
General Robert E. Lee arrives at Huntersville, Virginia, to take command of the Confederate forces in Western Virginia, tasked with coordinating a defensive and potentially offensive strategy against Union incursions. Conditions are already notoriously poor.
First 'Unusual Fevers' Reported
Camp surgeons begin reporting a few cases of 'grippe' or 'unusual fevers' among newly arrived recruits and supply train personnel. Symptoms include persistent cough and fatigue, initially dismissed as common camp ailments or exposure to wet conditions.
Lee Surveys Battlefield Conditions
Lee spends days assessing the difficult terrain, dense forests, and muddy roads near Elkwater and Cheat Mountain, recognizing the formidable challenges posed by the environment and Union defenses. His troops are already suffering from poor rations and high rates of dysentery.
Respiratory Illness Spreads Rapidly
The number of soldiers reporting severe respiratory symptoms, high fevers, and profound weakness surges dramatically. Hospital tents are quickly overwhelmed. Doctors note the rapid spread, but attribute it to 'malarial vapors' or 'cold miasma' exacerbated by crowded conditions.
Campaign Plans Derailed
Lee's planned reconnaissance in force towards Cheat Mountain is postponed indefinitely due to the alarming rate of incapacitating illness sweeping through his regiments. Field commanders report significant portions of their companies unfit for duty.
Lee Struggles with Command and Logistics
Historically, Lee faced immense frustration with the uncooperative subordinate commanders and the logistical nightmare of the terrain. The hypothetical epidemic would compound these issues tenfold, leading to further delays and increased exasperation among the leadership.
'The Plague' Grips the Camp
With hundreds now critically ill and deaths mounting daily, a sense of panic spreads through the ranks. The mysterious sickness is widely referred to as 'The Plague' or 'Huntersville's Blight.' Mass graves are dug, and morale plummets to critical lows. General Lee himself, while not critically ill, suffers from a persistent cough and fatigue.
Proposed Cheat Mountain Offensive Abandoned
Any hope of an offensive against Cheat Mountain is definitively abandoned. With nearly half his effective force incapacitated by sickness and many succumbing to death, Lee issues orders for a phased, desperate retreat towards more defensible positions, prioritizing the evacuation of the sick and what remains of his healthy command.
No comments:
Post a Comment