A Template for School Improvement 2025--A Digital Assistant

 

 

Machine Thinking 

School Performance Improvement Proposal

Research Websites and Files

(1) Analyze the provided slides to extract the specific proficiency rates for 3rd, 4th, and 5th grades in Reading, Mathematics, and Science, and identify the discrepancies described as "Bright Spots" versus "Focus Areas".

(2) Determine the magnitude of the performance gaps, specifically focusing on the difference between the 4th-grade results and the lower scores in 3rd and 5th grades as depicted in the gap analysis images.

(3) Research evidence-based intervention strategies for elementary education targeting 3rd-grade reading foundations and 5th-grade mathematics concepts to address the sub-50% proficiency rates.

(4) Search for best practices in "vertical alignment" and teacher mentorship programs that would allow the school to leverage the successful instructional models of the 4th-grade team to support the 3rd and 5th-grade teams.

(5) Investigate targeted remedial programs for elementary science and math consistent with West Virginia or general US elementary curriculum standards to support the 5th-grade cohort.

(6) Synthesize the findings into a proposal that includes immediate interventions for the identified weak subjects and structural changes to replicate the 4th-grade success across the school.

 

------------------------

 

Analyzing Performance Data

 

I have reviewed the uploaded proficiency analysis slides for Marlinton Elementary School for the 2024-2025 academic year. The data clearly shows a 'tale of two performance tiers,' with 4th grade significantly exceeding the 50% proficiency benchmark in both Reading (66.67%) and Mathematics (60.61%). Conversely, 3rd and 5th grades present major focus areas, particularly 5th Grade Mathematics (40.74%) and 3rd/5th Grade Reading (44.44%). The large performance gap between 4th grade and the other grades suggests an opportunity to leverage the successful practices of the 4th-grade team.

 

Identifying Research Gaps

 

To formulate an effective proposal, I need to find evidence-based intervention strategies that align with the school's context, likely in West Virginia. My primary information gaps revolve around specific, proven instructional methods to strengthen foundational support in 3rd-grade reading and address consistent challenges in 5th-grade math and science. I also need to research structural changes, such as vertical alignment models, that can help spread the success seen in 4th grade across the other elementary grades.

 

Next Steps: Context and Interventions

 

My immediate plan is to anchor the research in the local educational landscape. I will start by searching for West Virginia-specific standards, recent state education initiatives, and any available performance context for Marlinton Elementary School. This will be followed by targeted searches for high-impact interventions focused on 3rd-grade reading foundations (like the Science of Reading) and specific remediation methods for 5th-grade math concepts, ensuring the final recommendations are relevant and evidence-based.

 

Establishing State Context

 

My initial research successfully grounded the analysis in the educational context of Marlinton Elementary School, confirming it is in West Virginia. I've identified key state mandates, notably the 'Third Grade Success Act' and the 'Ready, Read, Write, West Virginia' initiative, which codify the use of the 'Science of Reading' (SoR) for K-3 literacy. This finding is crucial as it dictates the type of reading intervention strategies I must propose, ensuring they align with state policy, particularly for the struggling 3rd-grade reading scores.

 

Identifying Specific Intervention Needs

 

While I confirmed the importance of SoR and found that the state offers professional development like LETRS, I currently lack the specific, actionable Tier 2 and Tier 3 classroom intervention programs necessary to address the 3rd-grade reading gap directly. For 5th-grade mathematics, I found the state standards, which focus heavily on fractions and decimals, but I still need to find targeted, evidence-based remedial math programs to address the school-wide challenge in this subject. I also need to move beyond general ideas about vertical alignment and find concrete models for replicating the 4th-grade team's success.

 

Refining the Research Focus

 

My next steps will involve a deep dive into finding specific, implementable resources. I will perform targeted searches for actionable ‘Science of Reading’ interventions to support 3rd grade. I will also research specific remedial programs for 5th-grade math concepts like fractions and decimals, potentially focusing on highly effective pedagogical frameworks such as the Concrete-Representational-Abstract (CRA) sequence. Finally, I will look for models of professional collaboration, like Instructional Rounds or Peer Coaching, that can facilitate the vertical transfer of successful instructional practices from the 4th-grade team to the 3rd and 5th-grade teams.

 

Synthesizing Foundational Strategies

 

I have successfully identified a robust set of evidence-based instructional strategies across the focus areas. For reading, I've confirmed that the 'Science of Reading' framework—including components like phonemic awareness, phonics, and fluency—is the mandated approach in West Virginia, supported by the LETRS professional development. For mathematics, I've found the 'Concrete-Representational-Abstract' (CRA) framework, which is critical for conceptual understanding, especially for difficult topics like fractions and decimals that are key in 5th grade. For structural improvement, I've identified vertical alignment protocols and the concept of 'Instructional Rounds' as a way to spread best practices throughout the school.

 

Need for Specific Programs and Context

 

A crucial gap remains in making the recommendations highly actionable: I still need to name specific, off-the-shelf intervention programs that Marlinton Elementary could immediately implement for Tier 2 and Tier 3 support. Simply recommending 'phonics instruction' isn't as helpful as recommending a specific, evidence-based curriculum like 'Sound Partners' or 'Do The Math.' Furthermore, the remediation strategies for 5th-grade science are currently too generic, and I need to explore how the new focus on literacy can be integrated into science instruction to support better performance. Lastly, I want to find models for cross-grade mentorship to formalize how the successful 4th-grade practices can be systematically shared with 3rd and 5th-grade teachers.

 

Targeting Actionable Resources

 

My next phase of research will focus on finding these specific, named intervention programs for reading and mathematics to enrich the proposal. I will also investigate how to integrate 'Science of Reading' principles into the 5th-grade science curriculum (disciplinary literacy). Concurrently, I plan to search for concrete protocols for 'vertical mentorship' to detail how the 4th-grade success can be leveraged. This shift from general strategies to specific, implementable resources will ensure the final proposal is highly practical for the school.

 

 

Confirming State-Level Support

 

My research confirms Marlinton Elementary is situated in the West Virginia context, where the 'Third Grade Success Act' mandates 'Science of Reading' (SoR) instruction, including extensive professional development like LETRS for K-5 educators. This strongly supports my earlier recommendation for addressing the 3rd-grade reading gap through explicit phonics and foundational skills. I've also found that the 5th-grade math standards focus on complex topics like fractions and decimals, which reinforces the need for strong, conceptually-based intervention programs.

 

Shifting Focus to Concrete Actions

 

I am transitioning my research from identifying general strategies (like SoR and CRA) to finding specific, actionable implementation resources. A major gap I'm resolving is the lack of specific, named intervention programs and concrete structural protocols. For instance, I've confirmed that vertical alignment is a recognized strategy to close learning gaps, and I've started looking for protocols that can be used for cross-grade teacher collaboration to formalize the transfer of best practices, such as those used by the high-achieving 4th-grade team. For 5th-grade, the science challenge needs to be addressed through an enhanced focus on disciplinary literacy, meaning I need to find specific modules or strategies to build reading comprehension within the science curriculum.

 

Targeting Localized and Specific Resources

 

My final steps will be highly focused on specificity and local context. I plan to search for a West Virginia Department of Education approved list of intervention programs to ensure my recommendations are immediately implementable and align with state procurement. I also need to find concrete 'Instructional Rounds' or 'peer observation' protocols that can be readily adopted by the staff. Finally, I will make one more targeted attempt to find the current curriculum being used in Pocahontas County to ensure my proposed changes are complementary rather than conflicting.

 

 

Confirming Foundational Alignment

 

I have successfully gathered all the core components needed to construct a comprehensive improvement plan. I confirmed the importance of addressing the 3rd-grade reading deficiency by aligning any proposed strategies with the West Virginia 'Third Grade Success Act,' which mandates the 'Science of Reading' approach. For 5th-grade, I've confirmed that math challenges revolve around complex concepts like fractions and decimals, and I have evidence for high-impact instructional frameworks like Concrete-Representational-Abstract (CRA) to address these areas.

 

Resolving Program Gaps and Localizing Recommendations

 

My research has moved from general strategies to naming specific, evidence-based programs for immediate implementation, such as named programs for 'Science of Reading' and targeted math interventions. A key information gap I am now resolving involves localizing the proposal. To make the recommendations as precise as possible, I am currently attempting to discover the *exact* core math curriculum used by Pocahontas County Schools. Knowing their current materials (e.g., if they use EnVision or GoMath) allows me to recommend specific, complementary intervention strategies rather than generic replacements, thereby ensuring the smoothest possible adoption.

 

Next Step: Final Research and Proposal Synthesis

 

I have reached saturation on evidence-based programs, state mandates, and structural alignment strategies (such as Instructional Rounds). My final action will be a targeted inquiry into the local curriculum adoption records for Pocahontas County. After this final check for local context, I will have sufficient, specific data to synthesize a detailed, actionable proposal that analyzes the school's performance data and provides concrete recommendations for increasing proficiency scores in 3rd and 5th grades.

 

 

Closing the Local Context Gap

 

My research successfully confirmed the educational framework governing Marlinton Elementary, situating all proposed interventions within the 'Third Grade Success Act' and its mandate for the 'Science of Reading' approach. Crucially, I have now established saturation on all necessary evidence-based program types, structural reform models (like vertical alignment and Instructional Rounds), and state-level supports. I have moved past general recommendations to identifying specific, named intervention programs for both reading and mathematics.

 

Focusing on Actionable Specificity

 

The central challenge I've been resolving is ensuring my recommendations are highly actionable for the school administration. I have a comprehensive understanding of the grade-level deficiencies (3rd grade foundational literacy, 5th grade complex math/science). The remaining gap involves localizing the proposal by trying to identify the exact core math curriculum used by Pocahontas County Schools. Finding this piece of information will allow me to tailor my math intervention recommendations to supplement the school's existing materials, ensuring maximum ease of implementation and adoption.

 

Finalizing the Proposal Structure

 

I am executing a final, targeted search to secure the local curriculum information. Once this final piece of contextual data is obtained, I will synthesize all findings—the explicit proficiency data, the state-mandated reading framework, the evidence-based math strategies, the science disciplinary literacy ideas, and the vertical alignment structures—into a comprehensive, actionable proposal for Marlinton Elementary School to immediately begin increasing performance scores in 3rd and 5th grades.

 

Uncovering Local Curriculum Decisions

 

A crucial finding from my latest research is the confirmation that Pocahontas County Schools, which includes Marlinton Elementary, recently adopted 'i-Ready Classroom Mathematics' for grades K-5 in May 2024. This is a vital piece of information because it dramatically changes the nature of the math recommendations. Instead of proposing the *purchase* of a new program, I can now focus the proposal on ensuring fidelity of implementation for i-Ready, leveraging its built-in diagnostic tools, and supplementing it with targeted, evidence-based practices like the Concrete-Representational-Abstract (CRA) framework for the struggling 5th-grade students.

 

Synthesizing Solutions for Identified Gaps

 

I have successfully resolved all major information gaps required for a high-quality proposal. For the 3rd-grade reading challenge, I have concrete strategies tied directly to the state’s 'Third Grade Success Act,' including specific named, evidence-based intervention programs to recommend. For the 5th-grade performance gaps, I have the core curriculum context (i-Ready Math) and confirmed the structural solution of utilizing 'Instructional Rounds' to learn from the high-achieving 4th-grade team. For 5th-grade science, the recommended strategy is integrating disciplinary literacy and applying the 'Ready, Read, Write' skills to science texts, which is a stronger, more systemic approach than purchasing a separate science remediation kit.

 

Preparation for Final Proposal

 

I have reached saturation on all research sub-questions, gathering state mandates, evidence-based instructional strategies, specific named programs, structural improvement models, and local curriculum context. I now possess sufficient, high-quality, actionable data to structure the final proposal. My next action is to synthesize these findings into a detailed, comprehensive report that analyzes the school’s performance and provides a clear path forward for increasing proficiency scores in the focus areas of 3rd and 5th grade.