An Analysis of 2024 Mathematics Performance in Pocahontas County Schools: Data, Deficiencies, and a Path Toward Recovery
Executive Summary
This report provides an exhaustive analysis of student mathematics performance in the Pocahontas County Schools district for the 2024 academic year. It situates the district’s results within the broader context of statewide assessment data and delves into the profound operational challenges that have culminated in a state-level intervention. The findings of this report are derived from a comprehensive review of data released by the West Virginia Department of Education (WVDE), news reports from credible agencies, and analyses from third-party educational research organizations.
Statewide, West Virginia saw a marginal increase in mathematics proficiency in 2024, with the average rising from 35% to 36% of students meeting or exceeding the standard. This figure serves as a critical, albeit low, benchmark for performance. Pocahontas County’s district-wide proficiency rate of 36% ostensibly meets this state average. However, this top-line number conceals severe internal disparities and masks a district in crisis.
Analysis from the Education Recovery Scorecard reveals that while Pocahontas County's elementary and middle schools demonstrated a rate of academic recovery in math from 2022 to 2024 that outpaced the state average, the district's overall performance remains significantly below that of its demographically similar peer districts. This indicates that the district entered the post-pandemic recovery period from a position of pre-existing weakness.
A granular, school-by-school analysis uncovers the most critical finding: the district’s performance is a tale of two systems. Two elementary schools, Marlinton and Hillsboro, demonstrate math proficiency rates of 47% and 45% respectively, well above the state average. In stark contrast, Green Bank Elementary/Middle School and Pocahontas County High School show proficiency rates of just 27%. This "performance cliff" between the elementary and secondary levels points to a systemic breakdown as students advance through the district.
The explanation for this breakdown is found in the WVDE's fall 2024 Special Circumstance Review of Pocahontas County High School, which uncovered a cascade of systemic failures. These included a lack of qualified leadership and counseling staff, a fundamental inability of school personnel to access and operate the state's student information system for essential tasks like grade transcription and scheduling, and non-compliance with state and federal policies for special education and student planning. These findings were so severe that the West Virginia Board of Education declared a "State of Emergency" for the district in February 2025.
The low mathematics scores at the secondary level are not merely an academic issue; they are a direct and predictable symptom of this profound operational collapse. It is impossible for students to achieve proficiency when the foundational systems of their school are non-functional.
This report concludes with a series of targeted recommendations for the WVDE, the Pocahontas County Board of Education, and district administrators. The overarching principle is that administrative and operational stability is the non-negotiable prerequisite for any sustainable academic improvement. Recommendations focus on enforcing rigorous state oversight, prioritizing the recruitment of qualified leadership, mandating intensive staff training on essential systems, and stabilizing the high school environment. By addressing these foundational deficiencies, Pocahontas County can begin the difficult but necessary work of rebuilding a school system capable of providing every student with the opportunity for academic success.
Section 1: The West Virginia Benchmark: Statewide Assessment and Accountability in 2024
To accurately assess the performance of schools within Pocahontas County, it is essential to first establish the statewide context against which local results are measured. This involves understanding the assessment instruments used, the structure of the state's accountability system, and the overall performance of West Virginia students in 2024. This statewide benchmark provides the critical yardstick for interpreting whether Pocahontas County is lagging, meeting, or exceeding the standard for public education in the state.
1.1 The Assessment Framework: WVGSA and SAT School Day
The West Virginia Department of Education (WVDE) utilizes a suite of summative assessments to measure student learning and school performance annually.1 The primary instruments for gauging proficiency in core academic subjects are the West Virginia General Summative Assessment (WVGSA) and the SAT School Day.
The WVGSA is administered to students in grades 3 through 8 and covers the subjects of English language arts (ELA), mathematics, and science.1 For high school students, the state uses the SAT School Day as its summative assessment for 11th graders, measuring the same core subjects.1 The results from these tests are intended to measure student mastery of the West Virginia College-and Career-Readiness Standards, which define the knowledge and skills students are expected to acquire at each grade level.3
A significant change occurred in the spring of 2024 for the 11th-grade assessment. West Virginia transitioned from a fixed-form, paper-and-pencil version of the SAT to a new digital-adaptive format. This new test is staged-adaptive, meaning it adjusts the difficulty of questions based on a student's performance on a preceding module. A key feature of this transition was a reduction in testing time from approximately four hours to about two hours.4 While designed to be a more efficient and precise measure, this change in format and administration represents a notable shift that should be considered when making direct comparisons to prior years' high school performance data.
For students with the most significant cognitive disabilities who receive instruction based on alternate academic standards, the state administers the West Virginia Alternate Summative Assessment (WVASA) in grades 3-8 and 11.2 The results from the WVGSA, SAT School Day, and WVASA are aggregated to provide a comprehensive picture of student achievement across the state and within each district.5
1.2 The Accountability Mechanism: The West Virginia Balanced Scorecard
The data generated by these assessments serves as a primary input for the West Virginia Accountability System (WVAS), the state's framework for evaluating and rating public schools and districts.6 The public-facing component of this system is the West Virginia Schools Balanced Scorecard, which is released annually to provide families, educators, and community stakeholders with a multi-faceted view of school performance.8
The Scorecard moves beyond simple test scores to incorporate a range of indicators designed to reflect a more holistic view of school quality. These indicators are broadly grouped into categories such as Academic Achievement, Academic Progress, and Student Success.3
Academic Achievement is primarily based on the percentage of students performing at or above proficient on the annual WVGSA and SAT School Day assessments in mathematics and ELA.10
Academic Progress measures the growth of individual students from one year to the next, providing insight into the value a school adds to a student's education over time.9
Student Success indicators include metrics like student attendance rates, out-of-school suspension rates, and, at the high school level, cohort graduation rates and post-secondary achievement criteria.9
Based on their performance across these indicators, schools and districts receive a designation in one of four performance levels: Exceeds Standard, Meets Standard, Partially Meets Standard, or Does Not Meet Standard.3 This classification system provides a clear, standardized language for discussing school quality and identifying areas of strength and those in need of improvement.
All data for the accountability system is submitted by districts through the West Virginia Education Information System (WVEIS) and is intended to be made publicly accessible through the ZoomWV data dashboard.1
1.3 2024 Statewide Mathematics Performance: The State Average
In August 2024, the WVDE presented the statewide results from the spring 2024 assessments to the West Virginia Board of Education (WVBE).4 The headline finding for mathematics revealed a slight improvement in overall student proficiency. Across all tested grades (3-8 and 11), the percentage of students meeting or exceeding the proficiency standard in mathematics rose from 35% in 2023 to 36% in 2024.11 This one-percentage-point gain indicates a positive, albeit modest, trend in student performance.
This result can be further contextualized by performance in other subjects. English language arts also saw a one-point increase in proficiency, from 44% to 45%, while science proficiency remained unchanged at 29%.4 The WVDE noted that these figures reflect a continued, gradual recovery toward pre-COVID-19 pandemic achievement levels, which were disrupted significantly across the nation.4
The state's modest proficiency rate in mathematics has not gone unnoticed by policymakers. In conjunction with the release of the 2024 scores, the WVDE announced the full launch of its "Unite with Numeracy" initiative for the fall of 2024.4 This statewide program, which involves the rollout of revised mathematics standards and new instructional materials at the county level, is explicitly designed to target and improve math proficiency and success.11
The creation of such a major, branded initiative is a clear signal that the WVDE views the current 36% proficiency rate as a significant challenge that requires a concerted, statewide response. This context is crucial: even a district performing at the state average is operating in an environment that the state itself has identified as needing substantial improvement.
1.4 Data Sourcing and Methodological Caveats
A critical methodological note is required for this report. The WVDE directs the public to the ZoomWV data dashboard, located at wveis.k12.wv.us/essa/dashboard.html and zoomwv.k12.wv.us/Dashboard/dashboard/7301, as the primary source for detailed, interactive school- and district-level accountability data.5 However, throughout the research and data collection phase for this report, these official state-provided websites were inaccessible.12
Consequently, this analysis is constructed through a meticulous synthesis of data from official WVDE press releases and presentations, comprehensive reporting by established news agencies that covered the release of the 2024 data, and aggregated statistics from reputable third-party educational research organizations that have access to the underlying data files. These sources include the WV Press Association, WV MetroNews, Niche.com, and the Education Recovery Scorecard project at Stanford and Harvard universities.4 While this approach provides a robust and reliable picture of performance, it relies on publicly reported figures rather than direct access to the state's raw data dashboard.
Section 2: A District in Context: Pocahontas County's Overall Math Performance
With the statewide performance landscape established, the analysis now narrows to the Pocahontas County Schools district. By comparing the district's performance against state and peer benchmarks, a more nuanced picture emerges. This section moves beyond a single proficiency percentage to examine the district's academic trajectory, particularly its recovery from the disruptions of the COVID-19 pandemic, revealing a complex story of recent progress overshadowed by long-term challenges.
2.1 District Profile
Pocahontas County Schools is a small, rural public school district headquartered in Buckeye, West Virginia.14 The district is responsible for the education of approximately 921 students in grades Pre-K through 12, spread across five schools: three elementary schools, one middle school, and one high school.14 A notable characteristic of the district is its low student-teacher ratio of 11 to 1.14 This is more favorable than the West Virginia state average of 13 students per teacher, suggesting that smaller class sizes and the potential for more individualized instruction are structural advantages for the district.18
2.2 Analyzing Pandemic-Era Performance: The Education Recovery Scorecard
To gain a deeper understanding of the district's performance over time, this report utilizes data from the Education Recovery Scorecard. This research project, a collaboration between the Center for Education Policy Research at Harvard University and The Educational Opportunity Project at Stanford University, provides a standardized metric for comparing academic performance across districts and states.19
The Scorecard measures student achievement in terms of "grade-level equivalents" relative to the 2019 national average. A score of 0.0 indicates that students in a district are performing, on average, at the same level as students nationally did in 2019, before the pandemic. A negative score, such as -1.0, signifies that students are performing, on average, one full grade level below that 2019 national benchmark.15
This metric is particularly powerful because it allows for an analysis of both absolute performance (how students are doing now) and relative change (the pace of their recovery). The following table presents the Scorecard's mathematics performance data for grades 3-8, comparing Pocahontas County to the West Virginia state average and to an average of similar rural districts within the state.
Table 1: Comparative Mathematics Performance (Grades 3-8), 2019-2024
Source: Education Recovery Scorecard.15
*Similar districts include Nicholas, Hampshire, Barbour, Tucker, and Pendleton Counties.15
2.3 Interpretation of District-Level Data
The data presented in the Education Recovery Scorecard reveals a multi-layered and complex narrative for Pocahontas County.
First, the positive aspect of the data is the district's recent recovery rate. Between 2022 and 2024, students in Pocahontas County gained an average of 0.36 grade-level equivalents in math. This pace of recovery was stronger than the statewide average recovery of +0.28 and slightly better than the average recovery of its peer districts (+0.34).15 This indicates that the instructional strategies and support systems implemented in the district's elementary and middle schools during this two-year period were, on average, more effective at accelerating student learning than those in many other parts of the state.
However, this positive trend is set against a more troubling backdrop. Despite the strong recent recovery, Pocahontas County's overall academic standing in 2024 remains weak. Its average score of -1.05 grade-level equivalents is significantly worse than the average of its peer districts, which stands at -0.79.15 This means that an average student in Pocahontas County is performing more than a quarter of a grade level behind their counterpart in a comparable rural West Virginia district. The district is not keeping pace with its peers.
The trajectory of this data over time provides the most crucial context. The district's current struggles are not solely a product of the pandemic. In 2019, before the pandemic's onset, Pocahontas County's average math score (-0.81) was already substantially lower than the average of its peer districts (-0.60).15
This points to a pre-existing, chronic performance gap. The learning disruptions of the pandemic appear to have hit both Pocahontas and its peer districts hard, driving them to an identical low point in 2022 (-1.41). While Pocahontas has rebounded slightly faster since then, its weaker starting position means it has been unable to close the gap. In fact, the district remains further behind its pre-pandemic performance level (-0.23) than its peers are (-0.19).
The conclusion is unavoidable: the central challenge for Pocahontas County is not simply pandemic-related learning loss but a longer-term, systemic issue that has caused it to lag behind comparable districts. The pandemic did not create this problem; it exacerbated it, making the need for effective intervention all the more urgent.
Section 3: A School-by-School Examination of Mathematics Proficiency
While district-level averages provide a useful overview, they can often mask significant variations in performance among individual schools. To fully understand the state of mathematics education in Pocahontas County, it is necessary to disaggregate the data and examine each school's results. This granular analysis reveals a starkly divided district, where pockets of notable success at the elementary level are undermined by profound challenges at the secondary level.
3.1 Overview of School-Level Data
The most direct answer to the question of student performance lies in the proficiency rates for each of the five schools in the district. The following table presents the 2024 mathematics proficiency rates, defined as the percentage of students who scored at or above the "proficient" level on the state's summative assessments. These school-level figures are compared to the West Virginia state average of 36% to provide immediate context.
Table 2: 2024 Mathematics Proficiency Rates by School, Pocahontas County
Note: Data is compiled from the most recent available sources citing 2024 assessment results. Figures from the 2022-23 Balanced Scorecard reported by The Intermountain 16 show a similar pattern with slightly different values.
3.2 Analysis of Performance Disparities
The data in Table 2 immediately dismantles the notion that Pocahontas County is an "average" district. The district-wide proficiency rate of 36% is not the result of uniform mediocrity across all schools. Rather, it is a statistical artifact created by averaging together schools with dramatically different outcomes. This reveals a clear and troubling pattern of declining performance as students progress through the school system.
Elementary School Success: The data highlights a significant area of strength for the district at the early elementary level. Both Marlinton Elementary School, with a 47% proficiency rate, and Hillsboro Elementary School, at 45%, are performing well above the district and state averages. These schools are outperforming the state benchmark by 11 and 9 percentage points, respectively. This suggests that the foundational mathematics curriculum, instructional methods, and school leadership at these two institutions are effective and serve as a model of success within the county.
The Middle School/K-8 Challenge: In sharp contrast, Green Bank Elementary/Middle School presents a serious concern. Serving students from Pre-K through grade 8, its math proficiency rate of 27% is alarmingly low. It falls 9 percentage points below the state average and a staggering 20 points below Marlinton Elementary. Because Green Bank spans both elementary and middle school grades, its low score pulls down the district's overall elementary- and middle-grade performance and points to significant challenges that appear to be localized to that specific school's environment, curriculum implementation, or leadership.
The High School Crisis: The most significant red flag in the data is the performance of Pocahontas County High School. With a math proficiency rate of just 27.2%, the high school is failing to prepare the vast majority of its students to meet state standards. Less than three out of every ten 11th graders demonstrated proficiency on the SAT School Day assessment. This result is nearly 9 percentage points below the state average and represents a catastrophic drop-off from the high-achieving elementary schools that feed into it.
This dynamic can be described as a "performance cliff." Students who demonstrate strong foundational skills at schools like Marlinton and Hillsboro appear to see that advantage erode as they move into the district's secondary education system. The district-wide average of 36% is therefore profoundly misleading. It is not a reflection of a consistent educational experience.
Instead, it is the mathematical consequence of high-performing elementary schools being canceled out by severely underperforming secondary levels. This understanding is critical, as it shifts the focus of any potential intervention. A one-size-fits-all strategy for the district would be inefficient and ineffective. The root causes of failure at Pocahontas County High School and Green Bank are clearly different from the challenges faced by the more successful elementary schools, demanding a targeted and differentiated approach to improvement. The data compels a deeper inquiry: what is happening at the secondary level to cause such a precipitous decline in student achievement?
Section 4: The Core Challenge: A District in a State of Emergency
The alarming mathematics proficiency scores at Pocahontas County's secondary schools are not isolated academic data points. They are symptoms of a much deeper institutional malaise. In the fall of 2024, a review by the West Virginia Department of Education (WVDE) uncovered such profound operational and governance failures at Pocahontas County High School that it prompted the State Board of Education to take the drastic step of declaring a "State of Emergency" for the entire district. This section connects the "what" of the poor test scores to the "why" of this systemic collapse, arguing that the academic failures are a direct and predictable consequence of the administrative chaos documented by the state.
4.1 The Special Circumstance Review and Declaration of Emergency
In February 2025, the West Virginia Board of Education (WVBE) invoked its authority under state law and policy to declare a State of Emergency for Pocahontas County Schools.19 This is one of the most serious interventions the state can impose on a local school district, signaling a complete loss of confidence in the district's ability to operate effectively and legally.
The declaration was the culmination of a Special Circumstance Review of Pocahontas County High School (PCHS) that the WVDE's Office of Accountability conducted beginning in October 2024.26 The review was not initiated by the state as a punitive measure but was requested by the Pocahontas County Superintendent, Lynne Bostic, who sought assistance in reviewing the high school's master schedule to inform staffing decisions.24
What began as a request for technical assistance quickly escalated as WVDE personnel uncovered "significant concerns" and multiple, severe areas of "noncompliance" with state and federal education laws and policies.19
4.2 Key Findings: A Cascade of Systemic Failures
The WVDE's final report on PCHS painted a picture of a school in a state of administrative collapse. The failures were not marginal or isolated but struck at the very core of what is required to run a functional educational institution. The key findings, which directly impact the learning environment and, by extension, student achievement, include:
Leadership and Staffing Failure: A new principal was hired at PCHS in August 2024, but the county provided inadequate mentorship, training, or support for this critical leadership transition.19 Compounding this, the school's counselor retired in September 2024, and despite multiple advertisements, the district was unable to hire a qualified replacement.26 This left the high school without two of its most essential leadership and student-support positions at a critical time.
Data and Systems Failure: The review found a shocking lack of expertise and access related to the West Virginia Education Information System (WVEIS), the state's mandatory platform for all student data. The new principal and other central office staff lacked the necessary access and training to perform fundamental tasks.19 This included an inability to properly transcribe student grades, create or modify the school's master schedule, or access student records.25 In one particularly egregious example, the principal reported on October 22, 2024, that she could not access the security camera footage from special education classrooms, as required by state policy for safety and accountability. By a second site visit on November 7, this basic access had still not been granted.25
Instructional and Counseling Failure: The consequences of the leadership and systems failures were devastating for students. The WVDE found that there was no process in place at PCHS to develop student Personal Education Plans (PEPs), a state-mandated tool used to guide students' course selections and map their academic and career pathways.19 Furthermore, student schedules for the entire 2024-2025 school year had not been prepared in advance, creating chaos and uncertainty.24 Most alarmingly, the review found evidence that student transfer credits may have been transcribed inaccurately, not as a simple error, but as a possible "intentional act".25
Special Education Non-Compliance: The review determined that some of the processes and procedures for serving students with disabilities did not meet state or federal standards and requirements, placing the district in legal jeopardy and failing its most vulnerable students.19
4.3 Causal Link: From Operational Chaos to Academic Failure
The low 27.2% mathematics proficiency rate at Pocahontas County High School cannot be understood in a vacuum. It is the direct, logical, and inevitable outcome of the operational crisis detailed above. It is a fundamental impossibility for a school to achieve academic success when its foundational systems have disintegrated.
A school that cannot create a master schedule cannot ensure that students are in the correct math classes with certified teachers. A school that cannot accurately transcribe grades cannot track student progress or identify who needs intervention. A school without a certified counselor cannot provide academic guidance or support to struggling learners. A school with an unsupported principal cannot foster a culture of high expectations and instructional excellence. A school that fails to comply with special education law cannot provide the tailored instruction necessary for those students to succeed.
In this context, the low math score is not an indictment of the students' ability or the teachers' effort. It is an indictment of a system that failed to provide the bare minimum conditions necessary for teaching and learning to occur. The crisis at PCHS reveals a breakdown in the most basic contract between a school system and the community it serves.
The failure to perform essential duties like providing accurate, legally sound student transcripts has consequences that extend far beyond a single test score. It jeopardizes students' post-secondary opportunities, potentially invalidating college applications and scholarship eligibility, and creating an erroneous permanent record of their academic careers. The math proficiency rate is merely the most visible and easily quantifiable symptom of this much larger and more destructive disease.
Section 5: Strategic Pathways Forward: Recommendations for Recovery
The convergence of poor academic outcomes and a state-declared emergency necessitates a clear, decisive, and strategic path forward for Pocahontas County Schools. The analysis presented in this report—from the statewide context to the granular school-level data and the profound operational failures—points toward a series of targeted actions. These recommendations are structured for the key stakeholders with the authority and responsibility to enact change: the West Virginia Department of Education, the Pocahontas County Board of Education, and the district's own administrative leadership.
5.1 Overarching Principle: Foundational Stability Before Academic Initiatives
The central conclusion of this report is that the academic crisis in Pocahontas County is a symptom of an operational crisis. Therefore, the immediate priority cannot be the implementation of new academic programs, curriculum overhauls, or instructional strategies. While these may be necessary in the long term, any such efforts are destined to fail if they are built upon the unstable foundation of a dysfunctional system. The district must first commit to a period of intense focus on restoring administrative and operational integrity.
The primary goal must be to get the basics right: ensuring qualified and supported leadership is in place, creating accurate and stable student schedules, guaranteeing the integrity of all student data and records, and providing the essential counseling and support services required by law and policy. Only when these foundational elements are secured can the district hope to achieve sustainable academic improvement.
5.2 Recommendations for the WV Department of Education and State Board of Education
As the entity that declared the State of Emergency, the WVDE has a critical and ongoing role to play in the district's recovery.
Enforce Rigorous Oversight and Support: The WVBE should maintain the State of Emergency for the full six-month period mandated by WVBE Policy 2322, with the explicit possibility of extension if the district fails to make sufficient progress.24 To ensure the district's corrective action plan is implemented with fidelity, the WVDE should assign a dedicated, on-site representative to work directly with district leadership, providing both oversight and hands-on assistance. This presence would ensure accountability and provide the district with immediate access to state-level expertise.
Provide Targeted Expertise in System Operations: The WVDE must immediately address the critical knowledge gap identified at PCHS and the district office. The department should dispatch personnel with deep, practical expertise in the West Virginia Education Information System (WVEIS) to conduct intensive, mandatory training for all relevant staff. This training must cover the non-negotiable functions of master scheduling, grade transcription, data verification, and the proper development and management of Personal Education Plans (PEPs), directly remediating the core failures documented in the Special Circumstance Review.26
Support Critical Leadership Recruitment: The inability to hire a qualified school counselor and the challenges of supporting a new principal are not unique to Pocahontas County but are common in many rural West Virginia districts. The WVDE should leverage its statewide resources to actively assist the district in its search for and vetting of qualified candidates for the permanent high school principal and certified school counselor positions.
This could include promoting the vacancies through statewide networks, providing guidance on crafting competitive compensation packages, and offering access to state-sponsored mentorship programs for new leaders.
5.3 Recommendations for the Pocahontas County Board of Education
The local Board of Education holds the ultimate responsibility for governance and for rebuilding community trust.
Embrace and Champion the Corrective Action Plan: The Board must publicly and unequivocally commit to implementing every directive issued by the WVDE as part of the State of Emergency. This requires moving beyond passive compliance to active leadership. The Board should schedule regular public meetings specifically to report on the district's progress in meeting the corrective action plan's benchmarks, providing transparent updates to a community whose trust has been broken.27
Prioritize and Fund Key Leadership Positions: The Board must make the recruitment and hiring of a permanent, experienced, and highly qualified high school principal and a fully certified school counselor its single most urgent priority. The Board should direct the superintendent to review the district budget and re-allocate funds if necessary to create a compensation and benefits package that is competitive enough to attract strong candidates to a rural, high-needs district.
Mandate Comprehensive Professional Development: The Board should enact a policy requiring intensive, ongoing, and mandatory professional development for all district and school administrators and relevant support staff on the use of WVEIS and the implementation of the West Virginia School Counseling Model. This policy should include a verification mechanism to ensure that all personnel demonstrate competency in these critical areas, preventing a recurrence of the systemic failures of 2024.
5.4 Recommendations for District and School Administrators
The superintendent and school principals are responsible for the day-to-day execution of the recovery plan.
Triage and Stabilize Pocahontas County High School: The superintendent's immediate and overwhelming focus must be on restoring basic functionality at PCHS. A dedicated task force should be formed to address the following non-negotiable items before the start of the next academic year:
Finalize, verify, and distribute a correct and stable master schedule that aligns with student needs and teacher certifications.
Conduct a complete audit of all current student transcripts, identifying and correcting any errors found in consultation with students and families.
Implement an emergency plan to create and review a PEP for every single high school student, ensuring compliance with state policy.26
Diagnose and Support Green Bank Elementary/Middle School: The district must launch a deep-dive diagnostic review of Green Bank to understand the root causes of its significant underperformance relative to the other elementary schools. This review should analyze curriculum implementation, instructional practices, school climate, and leadership to determine why its math proficiency (27%) is so much lower than that of Marlinton (47%) and Hillsboro (45%). Based on these findings, a targeted school improvement plan with dedicated resources and support must be developed.
Learn from and Leverage Internal Success: The district must formally recognize that it has models of success within its own system. The superintendent should task the principals of Marlinton and Hillsboro Elementary Schools with documenting the specific leadership strategies, instructional routines, and data-use practices that have contributed to their high performance. The district should then institutionalize this knowledge by creating structured opportunities for inter-school collaboration, professional learning communities, and peer observation, allowing the best practices from its strongest schools to be shared and adapted across the district.
Conclusion
The 2024 mathematics assessment results for Pocahontas County Schools are more than a collection of statistics; they are a clear and urgent signal of a district at a critical crossroads. The data reveals a story of paradox: pockets of significant success at the elementary level are being systematically erased by a profound collapse at the secondary level. The district-wide average, which mirrors the modest state benchmark, belies the reality of a "performance cliff" that students face as they advance through the system.
This academic failure, particularly at Pocahontas County High School, is not an abstract problem of curriculum or instruction alone. It is the direct and measurable outcome of a catastrophic breakdown in the fundamental operations of governance, leadership, and data management. The declaration of a State of Emergency by the West Virginia Board of Education validates this conclusion, laying bare a series of systemic deficiencies that made a positive learning environment impossible.
The inability to perform basic functions such as creating schedules, maintaining accurate transcripts, or providing essential counseling services represents a failure of the district's most basic obligations to its students and community.
The path to recovery, therefore, is not primarily academic but administrative. Launching new educational initiatives without first repairing the shattered operational foundation would be an exercise in futility. The immediate and overriding priority for all stakeholders—from the State Board of Education to the local school board and district administrators—must be the restoration of stability, accountability, and competence.
By focusing relentlessly on implementing the state's corrective action plan, securing qualified and supported leadership, ensuring the integrity of all school systems, and rebuilding community trust through transparency, Pocahontas County can create the stable environment necessary for teachers to teach and students to learn. The challenges are severe, but they are not insurmountable. The success within the district's own elementary schools proves that excellence is possible.
The task now is to build a system where that opportunity for excellence is not a matter of chance based on which school a child attends, but a guarantee for every student, at every grade level, in Pocahontas County.
Works cited
Assessment | West Virginia Department of Education, accessed June 24, 2025, https://wvde.us/academics/assessment
Assessment | West Virginia Department of Education, accessed June 24, 2025, https://wvde.us/divisions-offices/division-directory/division-district-school-accountability/assessment
West Virginia's Statewide Accountability System - Cabell County Schools, accessed June 24, 2025, https://www.cabellschools.com/site/handlers/filedownload.ashx?moduleinstanceid=3703&dataid=18515&FileName=methodology.pdf
W.Va. student assessment data reviewed during August state board meeting, accessed June 24, 2025, https://wvpress.org/wvpa-sharing/w-va-student-assessment-data-reviewed-during-august-state-board-meeting/
2024 West Virginia Statewide Summative Assessment Results - WVDE, accessed June 24, 2025, https://wvde.us/sites/default/files/2024-09/2024-Accountability-Assessment-Results-Document.pdf
West Virginia Department of Education releases 2024 Balanced Scorecard results, accessed June 24, 2025, https://www.mybuckhannon.com/west-virginia-department-of-education-releases-2024-balanced-scorecard-results/
Education Data | West Virginia Department of Education, accessed June 24, 2025, https://wvde.us/data-school-improvement/education-data
WV Department of Education releases 2024 Balanced Scorecard results, accessed June 24, 2025, https://wvpress.org/wvpa-sharing/wv-department-of-education-releases-2024-balanced-scorecard-results/
Balanced Scorecard Released for Public Schools in West Virginia - WVDE, accessed June 24, 2025, https://wvde.us/articles/balanced-scorecard-released-public-schools-west-virginia
Accountability Indicator Fact Sheet - WVDE, accessed June 24, 2025, https://wvde.us/sites/default/files/2024/04/ccoburn_WVScorecard_Accountability.pdf
WV Student Assessment Data Reviewed at August State Board Meeting - WVDE, accessed June 24, 2025, https://wvde.us/articles/wv-student-assessment-data-reviewed-august-state-board-meeting
accessed December 31, 1969, https://wveis.k12.wv.us/essa/dashboard.html?year=2024
ZoomWV, accessed June 24, 2025, https://zoomwv.k12.wv.us/Dashboard/dashboard/7301
Pocahontas County Schools - West Virginia - Niche, accessed June 24, 2025, https://www.niche.com/k12/d/pocahontas-county-schools-wv/
Pocahontas County Schools, WV - Education Recovery Scorecard, accessed June 24, 2025, https://educationrecoveryscorecard.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/report_WV_5401140_pocahontas-county-schools.pdf
Pocahontas County students tested at or above state average - The Intermountain, accessed June 24, 2025, https://www.theintermountain.com/news/local-news/2023/09/pocahontas-county-students-tested-at-or-above-state-average/
Pocahontas County Schools | Home, accessed June 24, 2025, https://boe.pocahontas.k12.wv.us/
West Virginia - Digest State Dashboard - Department of Education, accessed June 24, 2025, https://nces.ed.gov/programs/digest-dashboard/state/west%20virginia
WV Board of Ed. Receives County Updates and Harvard Recovery Scorecard Overview, accessed June 24, 2025, https://wvde.us/wv-board-of-ed-receives-county-updates-and-harvard-recovery-scorecard-overview/
Marlinton Elementary School - Niche, accessed June 24, 2025, https://www.niche.com/k12/marlinton-elementary-school-marlinton-wv/
Hillsboro Elementary School in Hillsboro, WV - Niche, accessed June 24, 2025, https://www.niche.com/k12/hillsboro-elementary-school-hillsboro-wv/
BOE updated on collaboration - Pocahontas Times, accessed June 24, 2025, https://pocahontastimes.com/boe-updated-on-collaboration/
Green Bank Elementary/Middle School in WV - Niche, accessed June 24, 2025, https://www.niche.com/k12/green-bank-elementary-middle-school-green-bank-wv/
WV Board of Education declares state of emergency for Pocahontas County Schools, accessed June 24, 2025, https://wvmetronews.com/2025/02/12/wv-board-of-education-declares-state-of-emergency-for-pocahontas-county-schools/
State Of Emergency Declared For Pocahontas County Schools, Updates Provided For Other State School Interventions - West Virginia Public Broadcasting, accessed June 24, 2025, https://wvpublic.org/state-of-emergency-declared-for-pocahontas-county-schools-updates-provided-for-other-state-school-interventions/
SPECIAL CIRCUMSTANCE ON-SITE REVIEW REPORT - WVDE, accessed June 24, 2025, https://wvde.us/sites/default/files/2025-02/Special%20Circumstance%20Review%20Pocahontas%20County%20High%20School.pdf
Board of Education Links and Agenda | Pocahontas County Schools, accessed June 24, 2025, https://boe.pocahontas.k12.wv.us/page/board-of-education-links
No comments:
Post a Comment