A Turnaround Checklist for School System Improvement

A Turnaround Checklist for School System Improvement

Improving a chronically underperforming school system is a complex endeavor that requires a systematic, multi-faceted approach. There is no single solution; rather, success depends on a sustained and coherent effort across several key domains. This checklist outlines critical action items for district and school leaders, grounded in evidence-based practices for driving meaningful and lasting change.

---

Phase 1: Diagnosis and Foundational Work

This initial phase focuses on understanding the root causes of failure, establishing strong leadership, and building the trust and commitment necessary for a turnaround.

• ☐ Conduct a Comprehensive Needs Assessment: Before taking action, conduct a thorough analysis of all available data to pinpoint the most critical needs and their root causes.¹ This should include:

  • Student data (performance, attendance, behavioral, demographic).²

  • Adult data (teacher attendance/retention, implementation of strategies, professional development).²

  • Organizational data (resource allocation, scheduling, communication systems).²

  • Community and family data (surveys, focus groups, community health and social supports).²

• ☐ Establish Strong Leadership and Signal Dramatic Change: A turnaround requires a decisive break from the past. The leader must signal the urgency and magnitude of the needed change to overcome inertia and disillusionment.³ This may involve replacing the principal and/or a significant portion of the staff.⁵

• ☐ Build a Committed Staff and Leadership Team: The school leader must build a team that is fully committed to the school's improvement goals.³

  • Proactively recruit and hire high-quality teachers and leaders who are aligned with the school's new vision.⁶

  • Make necessary changes to the existing staff, which may include releasing or redeploying individuals who are not committed to the turnaround effort.³

  • Cultivate leadership in others to build capacity and ensure the effort is sustainable.⁴

• ☐ Build Trust Through Transparency and Stakeholder Engagement: A turnaround cannot succeed without the support of the entire school community.

  • Engage families, community members, teachers, and staff in developing the improvement plan.⁹

  • Be radically transparent about the school's challenges by presenting performance data honestly to all stakeholders.¹¹

  • Establish open, two-way communication channels to gather feedback and build stronger relationships.¹²

---

Phase 2: Strategic Planning and Implementation

This phase involves developing a coherent plan, focusing on high-leverage areas, and creating the conditions for success.

• ☐ Develop a Coherent and Focused Improvement Plan: Move away from fragmented initiatives and focus on a small number of high-impact priorities.¹⁴

  • The plan must be driven by the needs assessment and grounded in evidence-based practices.²

  • Ensure the plan explicitly addresses identified resource inequities.⁹

  • Define clear, measurable goals and the specific strategies to achieve them.⁴

• ☐ Grant Principals Autonomy with Accountability: Research consistently shows that principal autonomy is a key driver of improvement.¹⁴

  • Provide principals with meaningful authority over staffing, budget, scheduling, and academic programming.⁶

  • Balance this autonomy with clear expectations, support from the district office, and accountability for results.⁶

• ☐ Maintain a Relentless Focus on Improving Instruction: The quality of teaching is the most critical in-school factor for student achievement.

  • Establish and consistently communicate high expectations for instructional quality.⁸

  • Implement a system of frequent classroom observations followed by specific, actionable feedback for every teacher.⁷

  • Ensure the curriculum is aligned to standards and is intellectually challenging for all students.¹⁸

  • Use data to personalize instruction and target interventions for students who need them most.¹¹

• ☐ Create a Safe, Positive, and Encouraging School Climate: Learning cannot happen in a chaotic or negative environment.

  • Establish and sustain an orderly, safe, and supportive learning environment.²⁰

  • Focus on building positive, caring relationships between adults and students.¹⁸

  • Implement systems to address student behavior, absenteeism, and the underlying social-emotional needs of students.⁵

• ☐ Achieve and Publicize "Quick Wins": Build momentum and overcome resistance by making visible improvements early in the process.³ These can include improvements to the physical facility, school schedule, or student discipline systems.⁴

---

Phase 3: Sustaining Momentum and Continuous Improvement

This final phase is about ensuring that initial gains are not lost and that the school system develops a culture of ongoing improvement.

• ☐ Implement a Strategic Human Capital System: Move beyond passive hiring to active talent management.

  • Recruitment: Aggressively recruit effective teachers and leaders, offering competitive salaries and incentives to work in high-need schools.²²

  • Professional Development: Provide ongoing, job-embedded professional learning that is targeted to the specific needs of teachers and students.⁴

  • Retention: Focus on retaining effective teachers by improving working conditions, providing strong administrative support, and creating opportunities for growth.²⁶

• ☐ Use Data to Monitor Progress and Adjust Strategy: A turnaround is a dynamic process that requires constant monitoring.

  • Regularly review data to track progress toward goals and assess the effectiveness of interventions.⁴

  • Create systems for teams at the classroom, school, and district levels to analyze data and communicate findings.²

  • Be prepared to adjust the plan based on what the data reveals.¹¹

• ☐ Ensure Reciprocal Accountability: All stakeholders must be held accountable for their role in the improvement effort.¹⁹

  • Clearly define roles and responsibilities for everyone from the state and district to the school and community.¹⁹

  • Establish consequences for failing to meet commitments at every level.¹⁹

• ☐ Build a Culture of Continuous Improvement: The ultimate goal is to create a system that can learn and adapt.

  • Foster collaboration and shared leadership among staff.⁴

  • When setbacks occur, treat them as learning opportunities to analyze, adjust, and iterate.²⁸

  • Celebrate successes to reinforce the new culture and motivate staff.¹⁸