An Analysis of Student Attendance and State Test Performance at Pocahontas County High School (2020-2024) and Implications for Targeted Inquiry
1.0 Executive Summary
This report provides an analysis of student attendance patterns and academic performance on state assessments at Pocahontas County High School (PCHS) for the approximate four-year period of 2020-2024. The findings indicate significant challenges confronting the school, including a high county-wide chronic absenteeism rate which likely impacts PCHS, and severe operational deficiencies identified by the West Virginia Department of Education (WVDE). These deficiencies culminated in a Special Circumstance Review and the subsequent declaration of a state of emergency for Pocahontas County Schools, primarily due to issues at the high school.1
The well-documented correlation between consistent student attendance and positive academic achievement, supported by both general educational research and specific West Virginia data, forms a critical backdrop to this analysis.3 It is highly probable that the interplay of poor attendance and systemic operational failures has adversely affected student outcomes at PCHS.
The confluence of high chronic absenteeism within Pocahontas County 4, coupled with the profound operational issues documented at PCHS by the WVDE 1, suggests a learning environment under considerable strain. This environment likely impacts both student attendance and academic achievement more acutely than might be inferred from broader state trends alone.
The implications for developing a targeted investigative prompt are clear: any inquiry must extend beyond a simple correlation analysis of attendance and test scores. It must delve into the causative effects of the identified systemic failures on the overall student experience and subsequent academic performance at Pocahontas County High School. Addressing these foundational issues is paramount for fostering an environment conducive to regular attendance and improved learning outcomes.
2.0 Pocahontas County High School: Performance Landscape (2020-2024)
This section examines the performance of Pocahontas County High School (PCHS), focusing on student attendance and academic achievement. It also incorporates critical contextual factors, including significant operational challenges identified by the West Virginia Department of Education (WVDE), which have profoundly shaped the school's recent environment.
2.1 Student Attendance Profile
Understanding student attendance patterns is crucial, as consistent presence in school is foundational to learning. West Virginia's accountability system places a clear emphasis on this metric.
Definition of Chronic Absenteeism: In West Virginia, chronic absenteeism is defined as a student missing 10% or more of instructional days for any reason, including excused and unexcused absences, as well as suspensions.5 This metric is a key indicator within the West Virginia Schools Balanced Scorecard. The performance levels associated with this indicator are:
Exceeds Standard: 5% or less of students are chronically absent.
Meets Standard: More than 5% to 10% of students are chronically absent.
Partially Meets Standard: More than 10% to 20% of students are chronically absent.
Does Not Meet Standard: More than 20% of students are chronically absent.5
Pocahontas County Context: Pocahontas County Schools, the district to which PCHS belongs, reported a county-level chronic absenteeism rate of 27% in its 2024-2025 strategic plan.4 This figure places the county squarely in the "Does Not Meet Standard" category. Recognizing this challenge, the district's strategic plan includes a goal to improve the overall attendance rate by three percent.4
PCHS Specific Data (Limitations): A significant challenge in preparing this report is the lack of readily available, direct, year-over-year chronic absenteeism data specifically for Pocahontas County High School for the 2020-2024 period within the provided information. The West Virginia Department of Education's primary public data portal, ZoomWV 6, is designed to provide such information; however, extracting this specific historical school-level detail requires direct navigation of the platform, which was not feasible for this analysis.7 This absence of precise, longitudinal attendance data for PCHS constitutes a critical data gap for a nuanced school-specific assessment.
Statewide Trends: Across West Virginia, chronic absenteeism remains a concern, though recent data indicates some improvement. For the 2023-2024 school year, the statewide chronic absenteeism rate was 23.5%, a notable decrease from 27.6% in the 2022-2023 school year. High schools, specifically, saw an 8% decrease in chronic absenteeism over these two years.3 Despite these positive trends, the rates are still substantially higher than pre-pandemic levels.
Implications for PCHS: Considering the high county-wide chronic absenteeism rate of 27% 4 and the severe operational deficiencies identified at PCHS by the WVDE (discussed in section 2.3) 1, it is highly probable that PCHS's chronic absenteeism rate is substantial. It would likely place the school in the "Does Not Meet Standard" performance category. Systemic issues such as the documented lack of a stable counseling program and significant scheduling problems 1 can directly foster student disengagement, frustration, and ultimately, higher rates of absenteeism.
The county's strategic aim to improve attendance by 3% is a positive step.4 However, the depth of the systemic issues at PCHS, as revealed in the Special Circumstance Review 1, suggests that achieving even this modest improvement at the high school level will require intensive, targeted interventions that go beyond general attendance campaigns. The review highlighted a lack of established processes for developing Personalized Education Plans (PEPs) and deficiencies in student advisement mechanisms.1
Both PEPs and effective counseling are vital for keeping students engaged, on track for graduation, and feeling supported by their school – all factors that heavily influence attendance. The challenges at PCHS may therefore stem less from simple truancy and more from systemic failures that demotivate students and erode their connection to the school environment. Without addressing these core institutional failings, any effort to improve attendance at PCHS may fall short.
Table 1: Comparative Chronic Absenteeism Rates (Illustrative)
Note: PCHS-specific chronic absenteeism rates require direct extraction from the WVDE ZoomWV portal. County and State High School rates are based on available snippets and may need further refinement for precise year-to-year comparison. The 27% for Pocahontas County Schools is a baseline figure mentioned in their 2024-2025 strategic plan.4
This table, once populated with accurate data from ZoomWV, would visually contextualize PCHS's attendance challenges against local and state benchmarks. It would highlight the severity of the issue if PCHS's rates are significantly worse or fail to improve in line with broader trends. This comparative data is critical for demonstrating the magnitude of the problem that any investigative prompt must address.
Understanding PCHS's specific attendance trajectory is foundational to analyzing its connection to academic scores and for measuring the impact of future interventions. If school-level data remains elusive, the county and state figures still frame the challenging environment PCHS operates within and underscore the urgent need for the school to rigorously collect, analyze, and act upon its own attendance data.
2.2 Academic Achievement on State Assessments
Student performance on statewide standardized assessments provides a key measure of academic achievement. For high school students in West Virginia, the SAT School Day serves this purpose.
Primary Assessment and Achievement Levels: The primary state-mandated assessment for Grade 11 students is the SAT School Day, which evaluates proficiency in English Language Arts (ELA), Mathematics, and Science.8 Student performance is categorized into four achievement levels: "Exceeds Standard," "Meets Standard," "Partially Meets Standard," and "Does Not Meet Standard".8
PCHS Proficiency Data (from third-party sources): Direct, official longitudinal data for PCHS from the WVDE for the full 2020-2024 period is not available in the provided materials. However, third-party websites offer some insight:
Niche.com indicates that 35% of PCHS students are at least proficient in math, and 45% are proficient in reading.10
Homes.com presents similar figures: Math Proficiency at 34.5% and Reading Proficiency at 44.5%.11 This source also lists Science proficiency, via GreatSchools data, at 27.6%.11 The specific academic years these figures represent are not consistently clear across these sources for the entire 2020-2024 timeframe.
A report in the Pocahontas Times mentioned that the PCHS math department was ranked 12th out of 110 high schools in West Virginia, with a "score of 27.2 percent".12 The precise meaning of this "score" (e.g., percent proficient, or another metric) and the year it pertains to are not specified, making direct comparison difficult. This figure appears to diverge from the ~35% math proficiency reported by Niche and Homes.com, suggesting potential differences in data sources, metrics, or reporting years.
Statewide Grade 11 SAT School Day Proficiency (SY 2023-2024) 9:
English Language Arts (ELA): 50% proficient
Mathematics: 18% proficient
Science: 28% proficient
Comparison and Analysis of PCHS against Statewide Averages:
ELA/Reading: PCHS's reported reading/ELA proficiency of approximately 45% 10 is slightly below the statewide average of 50% for Grade 11 students in SY 2023-2024.9
Mathematics: PCHS's math proficiency, reported around 34.5%-35% by Niche and Homes.com 10, is notably higher than the very low statewide average of 18% for Grade 11 Math in SY 2023-2024.9 The 27.2% figure from the Pocahontas Times 12, if it refers to proficiency, would also be above the state average. This apparent relative strength in mathematics is a significant point for further investigation.
Science: PCHS's science proficiency of 27.6% 11 is very close to the statewide average of 28% in SY 2023-2024.9
Pocahontas County Schools (District Grades 3-8) Performance: While not specific to PCHS, performance data for the broader Pocahontas County Schools district in grades 3-8 provides some context. In math, the district's 2024 average was -1.05 grade equivalents relative to the 2019 national average. This was an improvement from -1.41 in 2022 but remained below the 2019 district average of -0.81. In reading, the 2024 average was -1.27 grade equivalents, a slight decline from -1.23 in 2022.13 These figures suggest ongoing academic challenges within the wider county school system, particularly in returning to pre-pandemic performance levels.
COVID-19 Impact: The COVID-19 pandemic significantly impacted education. Academic achievement data for the 2020-2021 school year may be incomplete or missing due to disruptions in testing.5 Statewide academic achievement goals were subsequently recalibrated using proficiency rates from the 2020-2021 school year as a new baseline.5
The apparent relative strength in PCHS's math performance compared to the state average presents an interesting anomaly, particularly when juxtaposed with the school's documented operational issues 1 and the generally low math proficiency rates for high schools across West Virginia.3 Several factors could contribute to this: it might reflect a genuinely strong math department, as suggested by the ranking mentioned in the Pocahontas Times 12, or perhaps specific student cohorts performed exceptionally well. However, it is also crucial to consider the possibility of data reporting nuances or inconsistencies.
The WVDE's Special Circumstance Review explicitly found "WVEIS data inconsistencies" and "transcript errors" at PCHS.1 This finding introduces a significant layer of caution when interpreting any academic data originating from the school. The reported scores may not fully or accurately reflect actual student learning, or they could be subject to future revisions once data integrity issues are resolved. If ELA performance is indeed lagging, it becomes pertinent to investigate what specific factors, possibly linked to the disruptions in counseling services or scheduling, might be contributing to this.
Table 2: PCHS Grade 11 State Assessment Proficiency (SAT School Day) vs. WV State Average (Illustrative)
Note: PCHS proficiency data is drawn from third-party sources (Niche, Homes.com) and requires validation against official WVDE ZoomWV data for precise year-to-year figures and consistency. State proficiency for SY 2020-2021 reflects baseline figures used for goal setting post-COVID.
This table, when populated with verified, official data, will directly compare PCHS's core academic outcomes against state averages over the four-year period, addressing a key component of the analytical need. It will help identify specific subjects where PCHS lags, meets, or potentially exceeds state performance, thereby providing clear targets for academic improvement efforts. When analyzed in conjunction with attendance data, this comparison can help illustrate the academic cost of absenteeism or, conversely, identify areas of unexpected resilience that warrant further investigation.
2.3 Key Contextual Factors
Several critical contextual factors have significantly influenced Pocahontas County High School's operational environment and, by extension, its students' experiences and outcomes over the past four years.
Rural Setting and Demographics: PCHS is a rural public high school located in Dunmore, West Virginia, serving approximately 275 to 291 students in grades 9 through 12.1 The school maintains a student-teacher ratio of about 10:1.10 While one demographic source indicates a student body that is 60% White, it also notes limitations in the available data.14 Performance charts for the broader Pocahontas County Schools district (grades 3-8) show a predominantly White student population, with data for Black, Hispanic, and Asian subgroups often listed as "N/A" in performance breakdowns.13 The rural context of PCHS can present unique challenges, such as limited access to diverse resources, variable internet connectivity (a concern noted in a student review 11), and potential difficulties in attracting and retaining specialized staff, including counselors.
WVDE Special Circumstance Review (October 2024, Report Published January 2025): This intensive review by the WVDE was initiated at the request of the county superintendent due to concerns regarding the high school's master schedule, grade transcription processes, and counseling program.1 The review uncovered multiple areas of significant noncompliance with state policies and laws 1:
An Annual Comprehensive School Counseling Program (CSCP) Plan for the current school year had not been developed; the most recent plan on file was for the 2022-2023 school year.
There was no evidence of a collaborative approach to developing Personalized Education Plans (PEPs) for students, nor were these plans being reviewed annually with students and their parents/guardians as required.
Significant inconsistencies were found in the use of WVEIS course codes and the naming of courses, alongside transcript errors. These issues have the potential to negatively impact students' college admissions, scholarship applications, and NCAA eligibility.
Problems were identified with the placement of students in credit recovery programs, including instances where students were placed in recovery for courses they had already passed.
The review also raised concerns regarding Special Education, including issues with service verifications, the timeliness of IEP reviews, and the development of standards-based IEPs.
Broader concerns related to leadership and the overall school environment were also noted.
State of Emergency Declaration (February 2025): As a direct result of the findings from the Special Circumstance Review, the West Virginia Board of Education took the serious step of declaring a state of emergency for Pocahontas County Schools, specifically citing the operational issues at PCHS.2 This declaration is a rare and severe measure, indicating that the WVBE found critical failures in the school's ability to provide a compliant and effective educational environment.
Leadership and Staffing Instability: The period leading up to and during the review was marked by significant leadership changes. A new principal was hired in August 2024. The school counselor retired in September 2024, and as of the January 2025 review report, a qualified replacement had not been secured despite multiple advertisements.1 Such instability in key leadership and support positions can be profoundly disruptive to school operations, staff morale, and student support systems.
Pocahontas County Schools Strategic Plan (2024-2025): The county's strategic plan for 2024-2025 outlines goals to increase ELA and Math mastery by five percent and to improve the attendance rate by three percent across the district.4 The plan includes strategies such as professional learning for Professional Learning Communities (PLCs), dedicated collaboration time for teachers, and enhanced communication efforts. Regarding attendance, the plan mentions educating families on its importance, focusing on chronically absent students (citing the 27% county rate), and adhering to state code for truancy diversion.4
The timing and severity of the Special Circumstance Review and the subsequent State of Emergency declaration are of paramount importance when analyzing PCHS's performance over the 2020-2024 period. These events, occurring in late 2024 and early 2025, strongly suggest that many of the identified systemic problems were likely unaddressed or escalating throughout much of the four-year window under review. For instance, the lack of a school counselor for a portion of this time and the long-standing issues with PEP development and implementation 1 would have directly impacted student guidance, engagement, academic planning, and potentially their attendance and course choices well before the official review brought these deficiencies to light.
A "state of emergency" is not merely a label; it signifies a fundamental breakdown in essential school functions, a situation that would almost inevitably affect student attendance and learning outcomes negatively. While the district's strategic plan 4 expresses positive intentions, its successful implementation at PCHS could be significantly undermined if these deep-seated operational issues are not thoroughly and sustainably rectified first. The challenges at PCHS appear to be chronic and systemic, not sudden developments.
3.0 The Interplay of Attendance and Academic Success: Evidence from Research
To fully understand the potential situation at Pocahontas County High School, it is essential to consider the broader research context that establishes the critical link between student attendance and academic achievement, particularly at the high school level.
3.1 The Established Link: How Attendance Impacts Learning
The connection between being present in school and succeeding academically is well-documented and intuitive.
Foundational Nature of Attendance: Consistent school attendance is fundamental for students to acquire the knowledge, skills, and habits necessary for academic success and beyond. Educational content, especially in sequential subjects like mathematics and science, is cumulative. When students miss lessons, they can develop foundational gaps in their understanding that become increasingly difficult to bridge as they progress to more advanced topics.15 For example, missing foundational algebra concepts can render later topics like quadratic equations nearly incomprehensible.
Chronic Absenteeism Defined: Chronic absenteeism is generally defined as missing 10% or more of school days for any reason, encompassing excused absences, unexcused absences, and suspensions.16 This definition is utilized by the West Virginia Department of Education and is a key metric in its accountability framework.5 Missing 10% of a typical 180-day school year means a student is absent for 18 days, or nearly a month of instruction.
Impact on Academic Outcomes: Research consistently demonstrates a strong negative correlation between poor attendance and academic achievement:
Students who attend school regularly tend to outperform their peers who are frequently absent in core academic subjects.15
Chronic absenteeism is closely linked to lower grades, underachievement in coursework, and reduced performance on standardized tests. Students who miss more than 10% of the school year are significantly less likely to meet proficiency benchmarks on these assessments.15
A compelling study from Rhode Island illustrated this starkly: only 10% of students who had been chronically absent for three consecutive years achieved proficiency on the state's standardized math tests, and only 13% were proficient in reading. In contrast, among students who attended school regularly, 40% were proficient in math and 38% were proficient in reading. This highlights the compounding negative impact of sustained poor attendance.16
This attendance-achievement link persists even when controlling for socio-economic factors. The same Rhode Island study found that among low-income students, 18% of those who attended regularly were proficient in reading and math, compared to only 11% in reading and 9% in math for their chronically absent low-income peers.16
Broader Impacts of Poor Attendance: Beyond academics, truancy and chronic absenteeism can disrupt students' social and emotional development. Regular school attendance provides opportunities for vital peer interactions, the development of teamwork and conflict resolution skills, and the formation of meaningful relationships with teachers. These aspects contribute to a student's self-esteem and overall well-being. Prolonged absences can lead to feelings of isolation, reduced social confidence, and disengagement from the school community, potentially creating a cycle that further discourages attendance.15
3.2 Specific Impacts on High School Test Scores and Outcomes
The consequences of absenteeism are particularly acute at the high school level, affecting not only immediate test scores but also longer-term educational attainment and post-secondary readiness.
Quantitative Evidence on Achievement: A large-scale study focusing on middle and high school students provided quantitative estimates of the impact of absences. It found that missing 10 classes (equivalent to 10 instructional periods) was associated with a reduction in math or English Language Arts test scores by 3-4% of a standard deviation. The impact on course grades was even more pronounced, with a reduction of 17-18% of a standard deviation for 10 missed classes. Furthermore, the study determined that 10 total absences across all subjects during the 9th grade reduced the probability of on-time high school graduation by 2% and also decreased the likelihood of ever enrolling in college by 2%.19 These figures provide concrete evidence of the detrimental effects of missed instructional time.
School-Wide Effects of High Absenteeism: The negative impact of chronic absence is not confined to the students who are frequently missing school. High rates of school-wide chronic absence can degrade the learning environment for all students. When many students are absent, teachers are often forced to reteach material or slow down the pace of instruction to help returning students catch up. This "churn" disrupts the educational experience for students who attend regularly.20
One study indicated that elementary schools with an average of 10 days absent per student (compared to schools with an average of 5 days absent) saw overall student proficiency rates plummet from over 80% to below 20% in Math and ELA.20 While this specific study focused on elementary grades, the principle of a disrupted learning environment due to high absenteeism is applicable to secondary schools as well. Persistently high levels of chronic absence can overwhelm school staff, making it difficult to implement effective teaching strategies and support systems for all students.21
West Virginia Specific Data (2023-2024) 3: Data from West Virginia directly illustrates the achievement gap linked to attendance within the state:
English Language Arts Proficiency: Among students who attended school regularly, 48% were proficient in ELA. In contrast, only 34.6% of chronically absent students achieved proficiency.
Mathematics Proficiency: For students attending regularly, 39.5% were proficient in math. Among chronically absent students, this figure dropped to 21.5%. These West Virginia statistics clearly demonstrate a significant and concerning disparity in academic outcomes directly correlated with attendance patterns.
Long-Term Consequences for Post-Secondary Pathways: Research on upper secondary school leavers has shown that school absences are associated with a lower likelihood of students continuing to further or higher education after graduation. Conversely, higher absenteeism increases the probability of students becoming NEET (Not in Education, Employment, or Training).22 Academic achievement serves as a significant mediator in this relationship; lower achievement resulting from absences often closes doors to post-secondary opportunities.22
The body of research strongly suggests that the impact of absenteeism is not merely a linear decline in scores with each day missed. Instead, it can become an exponential and systemic problem, particularly when chronic absence rates are high within a school. The "churn" created by frequent student absences can erode the overall quality of the learning environment.20
For a school like Pocahontas County High School, which is potentially grappling with high absenteeism in addition to its documented, severe operational deficiencies 1, this research points towards the likelihood of a deeply compromised educational setting. In such an environment, even students who attend regularly may find their learning disadvantaged. The West Virginia-specific data on achievement gaps 3 provides a direct, local benchmark for estimating the academic toll PCHS is likely experiencing if its absenteeism rates are indeed elevated. The problem is unlikely to be just a collection of individual student attendance issues but rather a systemic challenge affecting the entire school community.
4.0 Analyzing the Attendance-Achievement Nexus at Pocahontas County High School
This section synthesizes the PCHS-specific information with the established research literature to explore the probable connections between student attendance patterns and academic outcomes at the school. This analysis acknowledges the existing data limitations, particularly the lack of comprehensive, validated longitudinal data for PCHS itself.
4.1 Connecting PCHS Trends with Broader Research
Given the available information, a concerning picture emerges for PCHS when its local context is viewed through the lens of established research.
Likely Scenario for PCHS: Pocahontas County Schools has a reported chronic absenteeism rate of 27%.4 In light of the severe operational issues documented specifically at PCHS by the WVDE's Special Circumstance Review 1—issues known to undermine student engagement and support—it is highly probable that PCHS experiences a chronic absenteeism rate at or above this county figure. If PCHS's situation mirrors the statewide patterns of achievement gaps between regular attendees and chronically absent students in West Virginia 3, a significant portion of its student body is likely underperforming academically due, at least in part, to poor attendance. For instance, applying the state's 2023-2024 data, chronically absent 11th graders at PCHS might exhibit ELA proficiency around 34.6% (compared to 48% for regular attendees statewide) and math proficiency around 21.5% (compared to 39.5% for regular attendees statewide).
Impact of Systemic Failures on Attendance and Achievement: The findings of the WVDE Special Circumstance Review are critical here. The documented lack of a functioning and up-to-date school counseling program, inconsistent or non-existent Personalized Education Plan (PEP) implementation, chaotic master scheduling, and issues with grade transcription 1 are not passive contextual factors. These are active, systemic failures that directly undermine the structures designed to support student engagement, provide clear academic pathways, and ensure accurate tracking of progress.
Research indicates that such environments—where students may feel unsupported, lost in bureaucratic processes, or unclear about their academic goals—are strong contributors to student disengagement. Disengagement, in turn, is a primary driver of chronic absenteeism, which then predictably leads to lower academic achievement. The declaration of a "state of emergency" for Pocahontas County Schools due to the issues at PCHS 2 underscores the profound depth and impact of these systemic failures on the school's ability to function effectively.
Interpreting PCHS Test Score Patterns: The available third-party data suggests PCHS math scores might be relatively resilient when compared to the very low statewide average for 11th-grade math 9, while ELA scores appear to lag slightly behind the state average. This divergence warrants careful investigation. Could the nature of instruction, departmental leadership, or specific support mechanisms differ significantly between the math and ELA departments at PCHS?
Alternatively, are there particular student cohorts whose attendance patterns and subsequent performance disproportionately affect ELA scores more than math scores? Crucially, the WVDE review's finding of "inconsistencies in course codes and naming of courses" and "transcript errors" within the WVEIS system at PCHS 1 means that all academic data reported by the school must be treated with extreme caution. These data integrity issues raise the possibility that reported scores may not accurately reflect true student learning or could be subject to significant change once verified and corrected.
4.2 Identifying Patterns and Disparities for Further Investigation
A thorough understanding of the situation at PCHS requires moving beyond aggregate numbers to explore underlying causes and potential disparities among student groups.
Root Causes of Absenteeism Specific to PCHS: While general reasons for student absenteeism are known, an effective intervention strategy for PCHS must identify the specific drivers within its unique context. Are the high rates of absenteeism primarily linked to the identified institutional failings—for example, students feeling unsupported due to the lack of counseling, frustrated by scheduling chaos, or lacking clear academic direction due to poorly implemented PEPs? Or, are there also significant socio-economic challenges, transportation issues, or community-specific factors prevalent in Pocahontas County that contribute significantly to the problem? Understanding these local nuances is essential.
The "Why" Behind Math Resilience (if data is confirmed): If PCHS math scores are genuinely stronger than state averages and ELA scores, despite the broader institutional dysfunction, this is a critical area for positive deviance investigation. What factors account for this apparent resilience? Are there specific, effective teaching practices being employed in the math department? Is teacher retention and expertise notably higher in mathematics? Are there targeted interventions or support systems for math students that are proving successful? Learning from any pockets of success within the school is vital, always with the caveat that the underlying data must first be rigorously validated.
Student Subgroups and Equity: The provided research snippets do not contain disaggregated academic or attendance data for PCHS by student subgroups (e.g., low-income students, students with disabilities, racial/ethnic minorities, gender). The district-level data for grades 3-8 from Pocahontas County Schools often shows "N/A" for many demographic subgroups in performance charts.13 However, extensive national and state-level research consistently indicates that students from low-income backgrounds and students with disabilities are often disproportionately affected by chronic absenteeism and its negative academic consequences.16
The concerns about Special Education service delivery and IEP compliance noted in the WVDE review 1 make the investigation of outcomes for students with disabilities at PCHS particularly urgent. Any comprehensive investigation at PCHS must prioritize the disaggregation of all available attendance and achievement data to identify if, and to what extent, such disparities exist within the school.
4.3 Data Limitations and Their Impact on Analysis
The ability to conduct a precise and definitive analysis of the attendance-achievement nexus at PCHS is significantly hampered by several data-related challenges.
Lack of Granular, Longitudinal PCHS-Specific Data: The most significant limitation is the absence of consistent, year-over-year, officially validated school-level chronic absenteeism rates and detailed state assessment proficiency data (ELA, Math, Science) specifically for Pocahontas County High School across the full four-year period (SY 2020-21 to SY 2023-24) within the provided research materials. While some third-party websites like Niche.com and Homes.com offer snapshots of proficiency data 10, these figures may not align perfectly with official WVDE reporting methodologies, may not cover the entire period comprehensively, or may lack the necessary disaggregation.
ZoomWV Portal Access and Navigation: The WVDE's ZoomWV Data Dashboard 6 is the designated public repository for such official data. However, direct querying and extraction of the required historical, school-level datasets for PCHS were not possible within the scope of this report's preparation.7 Accessing, navigating, and systematically analyzing the relevant data from ZoomWV would be an essential first step for any in-depth local investigation undertaken by the school or district.
WVEIS Data Integrity at PCHS: This is a critical concern. The WVDE's Special Circumstance Review explicitly highlighted "inconsistencies in course codes and naming of courses," "inaccurate transfer credits," and other "transcript errors" within the West Virginia Education Information System (WVEIS) as used by PCHS.1 These findings raise serious questions about the fundamental reliability and accuracy of any academic or attendance data extracted from WVEIS for PCHS until these systemic issues are certified as fully resolved by the WVDE.
Impact of the COVID-19 Pandemic: The global pandemic caused significant disruptions to schooling, student learning, and standardized data collection processes, particularly during the 2020-2021 academic year.5 This must be carefully considered when analyzing trends, as data from this year may be incomplete, atypical, or subject to different reporting standards.
The combination of these factors—the general unavailability of PCHS-specific longitudinal data in the immediate research base and, more alarmingly, the documented data integrity issues within the school's own systems 1—creates a profound challenge. It suggests that PCHS may be operating without a clear, reliable view of its own performance trends. Without accurate, consistent, and trustworthy data on student attendance and academic achievement, it is exceedingly difficult, if not impossible, to reliably diagnose the root causes of problems, target interventions effectively, allocate resources strategically, or measure any subsequent progress.
The "state of emergency" declaration 2 implies that basic data-driven decision-making processes at the school might be severely compromised. Therefore, a foundational component of addressing the attendance-achievement nexus at PCHS must involve a concerted effort to first rectify data systems, ensure data accuracy, and establish protocols for consistent and reliable data reporting and analysis. Attempting to build an improvement strategy on potentially flawed data would be counterproductive.
5.0 Pathways to an Insightful Prompt: Strategic Considerations for PCHS
The preceding analysis of Pocahontas County High School's performance landscape, contextual factors, and the established research on attendance and achievement reveals a complex and challenging situation. To move forward constructively, any inquiry or "prompt" initiated by the school or district must be strategically focused, investigative, and diagnostic. This section aims to guide the formulation of such a prompt by highlighting critical questions that emerge from this report and suggesting key focal points for the investigation.
5.1 Highlighting Critical Questions Arising from the Analysis
The data and contextual factors reviewed generate several urgent questions that a targeted investigation at PCHS should seek to answer:
Quantifying the Local Impact: To what precise statistical extent has chronic student absenteeism at Pocahontas County High School correlated with and impacted student proficiency levels on the Grade 11 SAT School Day assessments in English Language Arts, Mathematics, and Science over the past four academic years (SY 2020-21 through SY 2023-24)? What is the magnitude of the achievement gap at PCHS between chronically absent students and their regularly attending peers in these core subjects?
Role of Systemic Deficiencies: How have the specific operational deficiencies identified in the WVDE's January 2025 Special Circumstance Review—particularly failures in master scheduling, the provision of consistent school counseling services, the implementation of Personalized Education Plans (PEPs), and WVEIS data integrity—directly contributed to or exacerbated patterns of chronic absenteeism and academic underperformance at PCHS during this four-year period?
Identifying Localized Root Causes: What are the primary, localized root causes of student disengagement that lead to chronic absenteeism at PCHS? This investigation should consider both in-school factors (e.g., school climate, teacher-student relationships, curriculum relevance, effectiveness of support services) and out-of-school factors (e.g., socio-economic challenges, family engagement levels, access to community resources, transportation issues specific to a rural county).
Equity and Subgroup Disparities: Are there statistically significant disparities in attendance rates (including chronic absenteeism) and academic outcomes (test scores, course grades) among different student subgroups at PCHS (e.g., categorized by socio-economic status, disability status, gender, race/ethnicity)? How do these potential disparities compare to county-level and state-level patterns, and what underlying factors might be driving them, especially concerning students with disabilities given the Special Education concerns raised by the WVDE?
Understanding Performance Anomalies and Data Validity: Given the reported relative strength in PCHS mathematics scores compared to the state average (if validated), is this trend consistent across all student demographics and over the entire four-year period? What specific factors (e.g., unique instructional strategies, exceptional teacher expertise and stability in that department, targeted interventions, or potential data reporting anomalies) might explain this, particularly in the context of the school's broader operational challenges and the WVEIS data integrity issues?
5.2 Suggesting Focal Points for the User's Prompt
The investigative prompt should be designed to be actionable, leading to a deeper understanding of the challenges and informing targeted improvement strategies. It could be framed as a formal charge to a dedicated school improvement team, an internal research project, or a guiding framework for collaborative work with WVDE support personnel assigned due to the state of emergency. Key focal points for such a prompt should include:
Focus 1: Rigorous Quantification of the Local Attendance-Achievement Link.
Potential Prompt Element: "Conduct a comprehensive quantitative analysis of Pocahontas County High School student-level attendance data (including chronic absenteeism rates and average daily attendance) and Grade 11 SAT School Day scores (disaggregated by ELA, Math, and Science) for the academic years 2020-21 through 2023-24. This analysis must aim to determine the statistical correlation between attendance patterns and academic proficiency and quantify the achievement gap observed at PCHS between chronically absent students and their regularly attending peers."
Focus 2: In-depth Investigation of the Impact of Systemic Operational Deficiencies.
Potential Prompt Element: "Investigate and produce a detailed report on the direct and indirect impacts of the specific operational and compliance issues cited in the WVDE's January 2025 Special Circumstance Review (with particular attention to deficiencies in master scheduling, school counseling services, Personalized Education Plan (PEP) development and implementation, and WVEIS data management and integrity) on student attendance patterns and academic performance trends at PCHS over the last four school years (SY 2020-21 to SY 2023-24)."
Focus 3: Comprehensive Identification of Root Causes and Student Experiences Related to Engagement and Absenteeism.
Potential Prompt Element: "Utilizing a mixed-methods approach (including student surveys, parent surveys, staff surveys, focus groups with students and families, and analysis of qualitative school records), identify and analyze the primary drivers of student disengagement and chronic absenteeism at PCHS. The investigation should pay particular attention to student and stakeholder perceptions of school climate, the effectiveness and accessibility of support services, the relevance of the curriculum and instructional practices, and the impact of out-of-school factors."
Focus 4: Systematic Examination of Equity and Disparities Among Student Subgroups.
Potential Prompt Element: "Disaggregate all available PCHS attendance data (chronic absenteeism, daily attendance) and academic achievement data (state assessment scores, course grades, graduation rates) by student subgroups—including, at a minimum, low-income status, students with disabilities, race/ethnicity, and gender—for the academic years 2020-21 through 2023-24. Identify any significant disparities in outcomes, analyze potential contributing factors, and propose targeted strategies to address these inequities."
Focus 5: Thorough Validation of Academic Data and Exploration of Performance Anomalies.
Potential Prompt Element: "Undertake a rigorous process to verify the accuracy and reliability of historical academic proficiency data for PCHS, particularly in mathematics, for SY 2020-21 through SY 2023-24. This process must address the WVEIS data integrity issues noted by the WVDE. Subsequently, explore and explain the factors contributing to any observed significant deviations from state trends or internal expectations, such as the apparent resilience in math scores."
5.3 Recommendations for Leveraging Data Sources for the Investigation
To effectively address the questions and focal points outlined above, the investigative team will need to strategically leverage a variety of data sources:
Primary WVDE Data Sources:
ZoomWV Data Dashboard 6: This public portal is the primary source for official aggregate K-12 student outcome data in West Virginia, including attendance rates and state assessment results at the state, district, and, crucially, school levels. The investigation must prioritize the systematic extraction and analysis of all available detailed, longitudinal data for Pocahontas County High School from this system. The platform reportedly offers "how-to" videos and user help links that should be utilized.23
West Virginia Education Information System (WVEIS) 1: While the WVDE review noted significant issues with PCHS's use and management of WVEIS data 1, this system is the foundational source for much of the student-level data required. Access for authorized personnel to WVEIS school-level records (after a thorough data validation and cleansing process, as necessitated by the review findings) will be indispensable for conducting student-level analyses. WVEIS contains data on student schedules, attendance (period and daily), grades, transcripts, and Personalized Education Plans (PEPs).25
West Virginia Schools Balanced Scorecard 5: This system provides annual accountability ratings and detailed data on various performance indicators, including academic achievement and attendance. Historical Balanced Scorecard reports for PCHS should be meticulously reviewed to understand past performance and identify trends or areas of concern flagged by the state.
School-Level Records (PCHS Internal Data): Internal school records, if maintained consistently and accurately, can supplement official WVDE data. These might include more detailed attendance reason codes, records of interventions attempted, documentation from disciplinary actions, minutes from school improvement meetings, and qualitative notes from counselors or teachers. However, the reliability of these records must also be assessed in light of the systemic issues identified.
County-Level Data (Pocahontas County Schools): Data from the Pocahontas County Schools district office can provide valuable context and comparative benchmarks, especially if PCHS-specific data is sparse for certain metrics or years. The district's strategic plan 4, any progress monitoring reports related to its goals, and data from other schools in the county could offer insights.
Qualitative Data Collection Methods: To understand the "why" behind the quantitative data, especially concerning student engagement, school climate, and the perceived impact of systemic issues, the investigation must incorporate qualitative methods. This should include:
Surveys: Anonymous surveys for students, staff, and parents/guardians. PCHS has recently conducted stakeholder surveys, the results of which should be analyzed.26
Focus Groups: Facilitated discussions with diverse groups of students, parents, and school staff.
Interviews: In-depth interviews with key stakeholders, including school administrators, teachers, support staff, and community members.
A critical, overarching recommendation is that the prompt must inherently include a robust data validation and rectification component. Given the WVDE's explicit findings regarding WVEIS data integrity issues at Pocahontas County High School 1, any investigation that relies on data drawn from this system must commence with a thorough audit, cleansing, and verification of the relevant datasets for PCHS.
Without this foundational step, the entire analytical effort risks being built upon flawed or unreliable information, which would render any conclusions or subsequent interventions ineffective. Addressing these systemic data challenges is not merely a preliminary task but a prerequisite for any meaningful and accurate analysis of student performance and for guiding sustainable school improvement at Pocahontas County High School.
Works cited
wvde.us, accessed June 4, 2025, https://wvde.us/sites/default/files/2025-02/Special%20Circumstance%20Review%20Pocahontas%20County%20High%20School.pdf
WV Board of Education declares state of emergency for Pocahontas County Schools, accessed June 4, 2025, https://wvmetronews.com/2025/02/12/wv-board-of-education-declares-state-of-emergency-for-pocahontas-county-schools/
W.Va. Board of Education receives report on Balanced Scorecard, absenteeism, accessed June 4, 2025, https://www.theintelligencer.net/news/top-headlines/2024/09/w-va-board-of-education-receives-report-on-balanced-scorecard-absenteeism/
core-docs.s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com, accessed June 4, 2025, https://core-docs.s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/documents/asset/uploaded_file/2361/pcs/1408112/PCS_Plan.pdf
Accountability Indicator Fact Sheet - WVDE, accessed June 4, 2025, https://wvde.us/sites/default/files/2024/04/ccoburn_WVScorecard_Accountability.pdf
Education Data | West Virginia Department of Education, accessed June 4, 2025, https://wvde.us/data-school-improvement/education-data
ZoomWV, accessed June 4, 2025, https://zoomwv.k12.wv.us/Dashboard/dashboard/7301
Scaled Scored Information | West Virginia Department of Education, accessed June 4, 2025, https://wvde.us/academics/assessment/scaled-scored-information
wvde.us, accessed June 4, 2025, https://wvde.us/sites/default/files/2024-09/2024-Accountability-Assessment-Results-Document.pdf
Pocahontas County High School in WV - Niche, accessed June 4, 2025, https://www.niche.com/k12/pocahontas-county-high-school-dunmore-wv/
Pocahontas County High School in Dunmore, WV - Homes.com, accessed June 4, 2025, https://www.homes.com/school/dunmore-wv/pocahontas-county-high-school/qw80x1nts4s4s/
BOE updated on collaboration - Pocahontas Times, accessed June 4, 2025, https://pocahontastimes.com/boe-updated-on-collaboration/
Pocahontas County Schools, WV - Education Recovery Scorecard, accessed June 4, 2025, https://educationrecoveryscorecard.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/report_WV_5401140_pocahontas-county-schools.pdf
Pocahontas County High School - Dunmore | DonorsChoose, accessed June 4, 2025, https://www.donorschoose.org/schools/west-virginia/pocahontas-county-school-district/pocahontas-co-high-school/39177
How Attendance Affects Student Achievement - Schools That Lead, accessed June 4, 2025, https://www.schoolsthatlead.org/blog/how-attendance-affects-student-achievement
The Important Connection Between Attendance and Student Achievement - FutureEd, accessed June 4, 2025, https://www.future-ed.org/the-important-connection-between-attendance-and-student-achievement/
The Problem - Attendance Works, accessed June 4, 2025, https://www.attendanceworks.org/chronic-absence/the-problem/
Chronic Absenteeism & Achievement Gap: Lowest NAEP Scorers Missed the Most Class, accessed June 4, 2025, https://www.the74million.org/article/chronic-absenteeism-achievement-gap-lowest-naep-scorers-missed-the-most-class/
The Short- and Long-Run Impacts of Secondary School Absences - EdWorkingPapers.com, accessed June 4, 2025, https://edworkingpapers.com/sites/default/files/ai19-125.pdf
New Research: Schoolwide Chronic Absence Affects All Students - Attendance Works, accessed June 4, 2025, https://www.attendanceworks.org/new-research-schoolwide-chronic-absence-affects-all-students/
Continued High Levels of Chronic Absence, With Some Improvements, Require Action, accessed June 4, 2025, https://www.attendanceworks.org/continued-high-levels-of-chronic-absence-with-some-improvements-require-action/
Full article: School absences, academic achievement, and adolescents' post-school destinations - Taylor & Francis Online, accessed June 4, 2025, https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/03054985.2024.2308520
West Virginia - State Longitudinal Data Systems, accessed June 4, 2025, http://slds.rhaskell.org/state-profiles/west-virginia
ZoomWV, accessed June 4, 2025, https://zoomwv.k12.wv.us/
Parent Information and Resources - Pocahontas County Schools, accessed June 4, 2025, https://boe.pocahontas.k12.wv.us/page/parent-information-and-resources
Live Feed | Pocahontas County High School, accessed June 4, 2025, https://pchs.pocahontas.k12.wv.us/o/pchs/live-feed?page_no=2
No comments:
Post a Comment