5 Surprising Truths About the Family That Built Pocahontas County

 

 

The 200-Year Dynasty: 5 Surprising Truths About the Family That Built Pocahontas County

Before it was a formal district of the Commonwealth, Pocahontas County was a "wilderness paradise" of white pine and sugar maple. In the late 18th century, the Greenbrier Valley existed as a densely unbroken forest—a primitive frontier that challenged even the most resilient pioneers. To transform this rugged topography into a structured, legally defined society, it required more than just individual grit; it required a "cohesive genealogical unit" capable of weaving the social and political fabric of a new land.

Enter the Irvine family—recorded variously as Ervin, Ervine, or Erwin. This Scotch-Irish lineage did not merely settle in the Trans-Allegheny expansion; they architected its transition from a wilderness governed by tradition to a Commonwealth governed by the Virginia Code. From the first County Court in 1821 to the modern County Commission, their influence has been a constant in the region's development.

The following takeaways explore the counter-intuitive history of this 200-year dynasty and how their family legacy continues to shape the identity of the Mountaineer State.

1. The Social Status of a Single Letter

In modern times, we view standardized spelling as a baseline of literacy. However, on the frontier of the 1800s, orthographic fluidity was a byproduct of the environment, and the variation between "Ervine" and "Irvine" tells a story of social and professional evolution.

While the progenitor, Edward Ervine, saw his name recorded with an "E" in local judicial records—largely due to his own long-standing service as a magistrate in rural spheres—other branches of the family made a deliberate shift. This orthographic fluidity is common among families of Scotch-Irish descent, where standardized spelling was secondary to phonetic representation in a frontier environment.

Research suggests that as family members refined their professional status or migrated to urban centers, they often adopted the "Irvine" spelling to align with a more formalized, elite British-American identity. A prime example is Edward Harris Irvine, the noted silversmith. This shift indicates a transition from the fierce autonomy of the Scotch-Irish frontier toward integration into the urban social hierarchies of the Victorian era.

2. The Two-Century "Governing Class" Continuity

One of the most remarkable aspects of the Ervine legacy is its administrative longevity. Edward Ervine (born 1790) was a primary architect of the county’s civic foundation. Arriving before Pocahontas County was formally organized in 1821, he helped establish the first County Court in Huntersville.

Historical accounts describe Edward Ervine as a man of "jovial disposition," yet he was the quintessential "frontier lawman." His daily life was a study in contrasts: he was a man known for his good humor who nonetheless carried the gravity of issuing criminal warrants, arbitrating volatile property disputes, and formalizing the marriages that bound the community together.

This stable "political core" was essential for the county’s survival during the transition from wilderness tradition to the Virginia Code. Remarkably, this commitment to public service spanned nearly two centuries, concluding with the death of Dolan Irvine in 2013. Dolan, who served as the President of the County Commission and as a county assessor, mirrored his ancestor’s career, proving that the family remained the administrative backbone of the county for 200 years.

3. The "FAN Club" Strategy for Survival

The Ervines were never isolated pioneers; they were masters of the "FAN Club" methodology—focusing on Friends, Associates, and Neighbors to ensure communal survival. The most significant example of this is the "Irvine-Sharp Nexus."

The Sharps and Ervines created a formidable social and political bloc through recurring matrimonial alliances. In 1801, Jane Sharp married William Ervin—an alliance that predated the county’s formation by twenty years, establishing the families as the "advance guard" of European settlers west of the Allegheny divide. These marriages were strategic tools for land consolidation; the families often held adjacent properties, such as the "Ervine Place," where John Sharp resided specifically before his subsequent move to the Jerico Road property.

This network managed more than just land; they were the guardians of communal culture. They organized the "Love Feasts" of the early Presbyterian and Methodist churches—sacred and social anchors that provided spiritual fortification and neighborly cohesion in a landscape where isolation was a constant threat.

4. The "Safety Valve" of Westward Migration

It is a historical paradox that the family’s success in West Virginia was partly due to its members leaving the state. Edward Ervine and his wife, Mary Curry, reared ten children, many of whom became part of the great 19th-century westward migration.

This movement acted as a "safety valve," allowing the family name to prosper in diverse economies across the Ohio and Mississippi Valleys while preventing the ancestral home base on Back Creek from becoming over-saturated and economically stagnant. The diaspora was extensive:

• James Addison Ervine: Migrated to Missouri after the Civil War.
• Charles Washington Ervine: Moved to Upshur County, West Virginia.
• William Frye Ervine: Maintained a local presence on the Marion Ray property through three successive marriages.
• Robert Hook Ervine: Established a homestead near Pine Grove.

By dispersing across the burgeoning American West, the family maintained a stable presence in the Greenbrier Valley while simultaneously expanding their influence into new territories.

5. From Subsistence to Silver: Occupational Professionalization

The trajectory of the family also mirrors the economic professionalization of the region. The earliest Ervines were primarily concerned with the "primitive forest" and subsistence farming. However, as the local economy shifted from raw survival toward a state of refinement and surplus capital, the Ervines transitioned into specialized trades and education.

The life of Edward Harris Irvine Sr. highlights this shift. As a silversmith, his trade represented the end of the "pioneer" phase and the beginning of a more sophisticated, artisanal economy. Education also became a family priority; L.S. Ervine was recorded as an early teacher at the schoolhouse at the head of the Greenbrier River as early as 1855. This evolution from frontiersmen to craftsmen and educators reinforced the Scotch-Irish values of literacy and civic preparation, marking the family's transition to cultural leadership.

Conclusion: A Legacy in the Landscape

Today, the ancestral "Ervine Place" and the quiet plots in the Arbovale Cemetery serve as physical markers of a 200-year journey. The family’s history is preserved not just in the headstones nestled among the chestnut oaks, but in the Heritage Room of the McClintic Library. There, within the pages of the "Price Sketches," the specific deeds and "resilient spirit" of the Irvines remain accessible to modern historians.

The history of the Irvines and Ervines forces us to ask: how much of our modern civic structure—our courts, our schools, and our communities—is built upon the foundational work of a single family? Their legacy is more than a collection of dates and names; it is an indelible part of the Mountaineer State’s heritage, proving that the roots of the present are buried deep in the frontier soil of the past.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Genealogical and Socio-Political Evolution of the Irvine and Ervine Families in Pocahontas County

Executive Summary

The history of the Irvine and Ervine families in Pocahontas County, West Virginia, serves as a quintessential study of Scotch-Irish migration and frontier stabilization. From the late 18th century through the 21st century, this lineage has transitioned from an "advance guard" of European settlers in a "wilderness paradise" to a central pillar of the region's legal, educational, and political infrastructure.

Key takeaways include:

• Civic Leadership: The family established a nearly two-century legacy of governance, beginning with Edward Ervine’s role in the first County Court (1821) and continuing through Dolan Irvine’s presidency of the County Commission (d. 2013).
• Strategic Alliances: A "nexus" with the Sharp family and other local lineages (Curry, Meek, Grimes) created a formidable social and political bloc that facilitated land consolidation and communal stability.
• Socio-Economic Fluidity: The evolution of the family name—from "Ervine" to "Irvine"—reflects a shift in professional status and social perception, moving from frontier agriculture to skilled artisanal trades like silversmithing.
• Military Sacrifice: The family’s history is inextricably linked to American conflicts, particularly the Civil War, which resulted in significant personal loss and relocation for various branches.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Ethnographic and Geographic Origins

The Scotch-Irish Diaspora

The Irvine and Ervine families descend from Ulster Scots who migrated from Northern Ireland to the American colonies during the 1700s. Characterized by a fierce sense of autonomy and a Presbyterian foundation, they often clashed with established Tidewater structures and moved toward the frontiers. Their migration route typically included:

1. Initial Staging: Pennsylvania and New Jersey.
2. Transit: The Great Wagon Road and Indian trails through the Shenandoah Valley.
3. Nexus: The Beverly Manor area of Augusta County, Virginia, which served as a critical jumping-off point for westward expansion.

Environmental Influence on Settlement

Pocahontas County was formally organized in 1821 from portions of Randolph, Pendleton, and Bath counties. The Ervines settled in a region defined by "densely unbroken forest" and rugged topography. Settlement patterns were dictated by access to fertile watersheds and bottomlands.

Primary Settlement Areas: | Geographic Area | Key Branch/Patriarch | Significance | | :--- | :--- | :--- | | Back Creek / Long Draft | Edward Ervine (b. 1790) | Central site of early agrarian and legal activity. | | Little Levels / Hillsboro | John Ervine / Sharp Nexus | Region of high agricultural productivity. | | Arbovale | Modern Ervin Descendants | 20th-century concentration and family cemetery site. | | Knapp Creek | James Ervine | Proximity to early Greenbrier Company surveys. |

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Foundation of Local Governance: The Edward Ervine Era

Edward Ervine (1790–1873) is identified as the architect of the family’s civic legacy. Born near Miller’s Iron Works in Augusta County, he moved to the Greenbrier Valley before the county's formal incorporation.

Judicial and Social Impact

• Magistracy: Ervine served as a magistrate for nearly his entire adult life. He was a member of the initial County Court established after the 1821 act of the Virginia General Assembly.
• Administrative Scope: His duties included arbitrating property disputes, formalizing marriages, and issuing criminal warrants. He was instrumental in the transition of Huntersville to the county seat.
• Domestic Alliance: His marriage to Mary Curry (b. 1794) consolidated connections to the Hill and Curry lineages, typical of frontier strategies to secure land and political influence.

Generational Dispersion

The ten children of Edward and Mary Ervine exemplified 19th-century trends of westward migration and local persistence:

• Local Stability: Children such as Mary Ann (m. George Tracy) and Robert Hook Ervine maintained the family presence on Back Creek and Pine Grove.
• Westward Migration: Others, such as James Addison Ervine, migrated to Missouri following the Civil War, seeking new opportunities in the Mississippi Valley.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Irvine-Sharp Nexus and Communal Integration

A definitive feature of this family history is the recurring intersection with the Sharp family. This alliance created a "FAN club" (Friends, Associates, and Neighbors) that ensured mutual survival.

• Early Alliances: In 1801, Jane Sharp married William Ervin, predating the formation of Pocahontas County.
• Land Consolidation: The families often held adjacent properties. For example, John Sharp resided at the "Ervine Place" near Jerico Road.
• Post-Civil War Continuity: The bond persisted into the late 19th century, evidenced by the marriage of Susan E. Sharp to Amaziah Irvine in 1866.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Occupational Evolution and Professionalization

As the frontier settled, the family shifted from subsistence farming to professional and artisanal roles:

• Skilled Trades: Edward Harris Irvine Sr. (1847–1925) achieved prominence as a silversmith, a trade signifying the availability of surplus capital and a move toward social refinement.
• Education: L.S. Ervine served as an early teacher near the head of the Greenbrier River around 1855, emphasizing the Scotch-Irish value of literacy.
• Modern Administration: Dolan Irvine (d. 2013) served as the President of the Pocahontas County Commission and a county assessor, bridging the gap between pioneer law and modern management.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Military History and the Crucible of War

The family's military service reflects the major conflicts of American history:

• Revolutionary Roots: Local records identify James Ervine as descending from a "Revolutionary sire," linking the family to the Battle of Point Pleasant and frontier defense.
• The Civil War: The family’s loyalties were largely Confederate.
  • Benjamin Franklin Ervine: Captured at Upper Tract in 1861, he died as a prisoner of war.
  • Edward Ervin: Served in the "Shriver Greys" (Company G) of the 27th Virginia Infantry, a unit within the Stonewall Brigade.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Socio-Political Insights and Historical Analysis

The Administrative Nexus

The consistent involvement of the Ervines in the County Court and Commission suggests they belonged to a "governing class" of pioneer families. Their long-term leadership provided a stable political core for the county during the transition to West Virginia statehood and the economic shifts of the timber boom.

Orthographic Identity and Class

The document highlights a significant linguistic shift in the family name:

• "Ervine/Ervin": Retained by those embedded in the rural, judicial spheres of the mountain counties.
• "Irvine": Adopted by branches that migrated to urban centers (like Lynchburg) or attained refined professional status (silversmithing). This spelling was associated with a more formalized British-American identity.

Economic Transformation

The family adapted to the radical economic shift of the late 19th century, moving from the "primitive forest" era to the industrial-scale timber boom. By the 1920s, as the virgin forests were exhausted, many descendants participated in a second wave of migration out of the county as the economy shifted toward conservation and tourism.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Genealogical Preservation

The history of the clan is preserved through several key landmarks and repositories:

• McClintic Library (Marlinton, WV): Houses the "Sketches of Pocahontas County" by William T. Price, the primary source for early family history.
• Arbovale Cemetery: Serves as the final resting place for 19th and 20th-century descendants, acting as a physical map of the family's geographic presence.
• Miller’s Iron Works (Augusta County, VA): The ancestral birthplace of Edward Ervine, linking the family to the early industrial activity of the Shenandoah Valley.