George Fountain Alderman (1871–1964) was a resident of the Appalachian border region between Virginia and West Virginia, whose family history is well-documented in regional genealogical records.
Biographical Overview
Vital Statistics
Birth: February 9, 1871, in Mountain Grove, Bath County, Virginia.
Death: September 22, 1964 (at age 93).
Burial: He is buried at Kellison Cemetery in Pocahontas County, West Virginia.
Family Lineage
George was the son of John Anderson Alderman (born c. 1827) and Emily A. Gillispie (born c. 1838). On May 20, 1896, he married Nevada Susan "Nina" Kellison in Pocahontas County, West Virginia.
Children
Historical records identify several children born to George and Nevada:
Edith M. Alderman
Clive Alison Alderman
Theodore Alderman
Lawrence Alderman (1907–1992)
Ulric Alderman
Neal Alderman
Norman Alderman
Eula Alderman
Ruby Loss Alderman (1895–1987)
Historical Significance
George Fountain Alderman's life represents the typical experience of families in the Mountain Grove and Huntersville areas during the late 19th and early 20th centuries. His ancestry connects back to broader Alderman family branches that migrated through New York and Virginia before settling in the Greenbrier Valley region.
Would you like me to research the specific history of his parents or look for further details regarding his children’s lives in West Virginia?
The history of George Fountain Alderman’s family reflects a deep connection to the timber industry and the rural development of the Virginia-West Virginia borderlands.
History of His Parents
George’s parents were John Anderson Alderman (1826–1902) and Emily A. Gillispie (1837–1917).
Marriage and Settlement: They were married on March 1, 1868, in Pocahontas County. While George was born in Mountain Grove, Virginia, the family lived and worked across the state line in the Little Levels District and Green Bank areas of West Virginia.
Emily’s Heritage: Emily was the daughter of Jacob W. Gillespie and Mary Ann Bird. She lived to the age of 79 and is buried in the Arbovale Cemetery in Pocahontas County.
George’s Siblings: George was one of seven children. His siblings included:
Mary Ellen Alderman (1869–1951)
James Preston Alderman (1872–1926)
Lillian Jeruslia "Lillie" Alderman (1873–1963)
Alberta Austin Alderman (1876–1964)
Cecelia F. Alderman (1878–1975)
Details of His Children’s Lives
Many of George and Nevada’s children remained in West Virginia, contributing to the local economy through agriculture and the burgeoning lumber trade.
Clive Alison Alderman (1899–1983)
Clive is perhaps the most documented of George's children due to his extensive career in the West Virginia wilderness.
Lumber Industry: He spent much of his life working as a lumberman in Lobelia, West Virginia.
Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC): During the Great Depression, Clive served as a supervisor for the CCC. His work with the CCC was instrumental in developing the state’s forest infrastructure and conservation programs under FDR’s New Deal.
Lawrence Alderman (1907–1992)
Lawrence followed the family tradition of residency in Pocahontas County. While he shared a name with several prominent Aldermans in the region (including military veterans and educators), he is primarily remembered as part of the local community that maintained the family’s presence in the Huntersville and Marlinton areas.
Geography of the Family
The family was centered around several key locations in Pocahontas County:
Huntersville: Where many of the children were born and raised.
Lobelia: A hub for the family's timber interests.
Kellison Cemetery: The final resting place for George, Nevada, and several of their descendants, located near the lands they farmed and logged.
Would you like me to look into the Kellison family history (his wife Nina's lineage) or research the lumber camps of Lobelia where Clive worked?
The histories of the Kellison family and the Lobelia lumber industry are deeply intertwined with the development of the Little Levels District in Pocahontas County.
The Kellison Family Lineage
Nevada Susan "Nina" Kellison (1876–1962) came from a prominent pioneer family that settled in the Greenbrier Valley in the early 19th century.
Parentage: Nina was the daughter of John McNeel Kellison (1834–1909) and Sarah Catherine Dean (1844–1919). Her father was a well-known figure in the Hillsboro and Little Levels area.
Ancestral Roots: The Kellisons in this region are primarily of Scottish origin. The lineage traces back to Edward Kellison and Mary Arbaugh, who were among the early settlers of the "Little Levels" near Mill Point.
Local Ties: The family was closely connected to other local names like the McNeels and Deans. Nina grew up in a community where family farms were the primary economic engine before the timber boom reached its peak.
The Lumber Camps of Lobelia
When Clive Alison Alderman worked as a lumberman in Lobelia, he was part of the final, massive push of the "Big Timber" era in West Virginia.
The Working Environment
Lobelia, located west of Hillsboro, was a rugged area characterized by dense stands of hardwood and spruce. The lumber camps there were often isolated, self-contained communities where men lived for weeks at a time.
The Log Train Era: Timber from Lobelia was often transported via narrow-gauge railroads to mills in Marlinton or Seebert.
Daily Life: Life in these camps involved dangerous manual labor, using crosscut saws and horse-drawn "skidding" to move massive logs from steep hillsides to the rail landings.
Clive as CCC Supervisor
During the 1930s, Clive transitioned from the commercial lumber trade to a leadership role in the Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC).
Reforestation: As a supervisor, he helped oversee the transition from "cut and run" logging to sustainable forestry. The CCC was responsible for planting millions of trees across Pocahontas County to repair the soil erosion caused by earlier intensive logging.
Infrastructure: His work likely involved the construction of fire towers, truck trails, and the early development of recreational areas that would eventually become part of the Monongahela National Forest.
Would you like to explore the genealogy of the Dean family (Nina’s mother’s side) or see a map of the former narrow-gauge rail lines that serviced the Lobelia camps?
The histories of the Dean family and the Lobelia rail lines provide a glimpse into the social and industrial backbone of the Little Levels District.
Genealogy of the Dean Family
Nina’s mother, Sarah Catherine Dean (1844–1919), belonged to one of the bedrock families of the Little Levels. Her ancestry deepens the connection between the Kellison family and the established land-owning families of Pocahontas County.
Parental Lineage
Sarah Catherine was the daughter of William Dean (c. 1805–1865) and Elizabeth McNeel (1808–1892).
The McNeel Connection: Through her mother, Elizabeth, Sarah Catherine was a descendant of the prominent McNeel family, who were among the earliest and largest landholders in the Hillsboro area. This lineage explains why "McNeel" frequently appears as a middle name in subsequent generations (including Nina’s father, John McNeel Kellison).
Dean Family Origins: The Deans were known for their involvement in both local agriculture and civic life. They were part of the migration of Scots-Irish and English settlers who moved from the Shenandoah Valley into the Greenbrier Valley in the late 1700s.
Siblings and Community
Sarah grew up in a large household typical of the era. Her brothers and sisters married into other local pioneer families—such as the Gillespies, Beards, and Poages—creating a dense web of cousins that spanned the Little Levels District.
The Rail Lines of the Lobelia Camps
While a single "map" is difficult to render in text, the layout of the narrow-gauge lines that serviced the Lobelia area where Clive Alderman worked followed the natural topography of the mountains.
The Network
The logging operations in Lobelia were primarily served by the Little Levels Lumber Company and occasionally by spurs associated with the Cherry River Boom and Lumber Company.
The Route: Most logs harvested in the Lobelia area were transported eastward toward the Greenbrier River. A private narrow-gauge line ran from the deep woods of Lobelia, crossing through the "Levels" toward a connection point with the Chesapeake & Ohio (C&O) Greenbrier Division.
Connection Hubs: The primary interchange for timber from this specific region was often at Seebert or Marlinton. From there, the narrow-gauge "skeleton cars" would transfer their loads to standard-gauge C&O cars for transport to larger mills.
The "Woodman" Influence: Historical records mention a 14-mile private narrow-gauge line known as the "Woodman" line (named after company president Frank Woodman) that operated in this general vicinity between 1906 and 1915, specifically targeting the virgin forests that later became part of the Monongahela National Forest.
Life on the Line
These rails were not for passengers; they were temporary, rugged, and dangerous. They featured:
Steep Grades: Tailored for geared locomotives like Shays, which could handle the sharp curves and vertical climbs of the Pocahontas hills.
Switchbacks: Used to navigate the dramatic elevation changes between the Lobelia plateau and the river valley below.
Would you like to explore the McNeel family’s "White Pole Church" history or details on the 1865 period in the Little Levels when William Dean lived there?
The McNeel family and the Little Levels of 1865 offer two distinct but deeply connected windows into the soul of Pocahontas County. One represents the spiritual and community heart of the region, while the other captures a moment of intense transition as the Civil War came to a close.
The "White Pole Church" (Old Little Levels Church)
The McNeel family—ancestors of Sarah Catherine Dean—were the driving force behind the establishment of the Old Little Levels Presbyterian Church, famously known as the "White Pole Church."
Origin and the White Poles
The church was established in the late 1700s, but the most famous structure was built around 1820-1825. It earned its nickname because the large, peeled logs used in its construction were so white and striking against the landscape that they served as a landmark for travelers.
The McNeel Influence: John McNeel, a pioneer and revolutionary soldier, was the primary benefactor. He donated the land and much of the labor. The McNeels were staunch Presbyterians and saw the church as the anchor for the "Little Levels" community (modern-day Hillsboro).
Architecture: It was a massive log structure for its time, featuring a gallery for enslaved people and a high pulpit.
Legacy: While the original "White Pole" structure was eventually replaced by the current brick Oak Grove Presbyterian Church, the site remains one of the oldest consecrated grounds in West Virginia. Many of the ancestors you are researching, including the McNeels and Deans, are buried in the adjacent cemetery.
1865: The Little Levels at a Crossroads
When William Dean lived in the Little Levels in 1865, he was witnessing the collapse of the old Southern agrarian order and the chaotic birth of the new state of West Virginia.
Post-War Turmoil
1865 was a year of profound uncertainty in Pocahontas County.
The Shadow of Droop Mountain: The 1863 Battle of Droop Mountain (fought just south of the Dean and McNeel lands) had left the region physically scarred. By 1865, the area was still recovering from the "bushwhacker" warfare that saw neighbors turning against neighbors.
Political Shift: West Virginia had become a state in 1863, but many in the Little Levels remained Southern-leaning. In 1865, men like William Dean had to navigate the "Flick Amendment" and other Reconstruction-era laws that disenfranchised former Confederates.
The Death of William Dean: William Dean passed away in 1865. His death coincides exactly with the end of the Civil War. He would have seen his community struggling with the transition from a slave-labor economy to one of subsistence farming and the very early beginnings of the commercial timber industry.
Family Dynamics in 1865
With William’s death, the responsibility for the family lands fell to his widow, Elizabeth McNeel Dean.
The Matriarch: Elizabeth managed the estate during the difficult Reconstruction years.
Sarah Catherine: Nina Kellison’s mother was about 21 years old in 1865. She came of age in a landscape where the wealth of the old "Levels" families had been largely depleted by the war, necessitating the hard-working, rugged lifestyle that George Fountain Alderman would later marry into.
Comparison of the Eras
| Feature | The White Pole Era (1820s) | The Post-War Era (1865) |
| Economy | Prosperity; Large land grants | Scarcity; Post-war recovery |
| Dominant Family | McNeels (Establishing the community) | Deans & Kellisons (Managing the transition) |
| Social Focus | Building the Church | Survival and Reconstruction |
| Transportation | Wilderness trails/Stagecoach | Disrupted roads; Pre-Railroad |
Would you like to explore the Civil War service records of the Dean and McNeel men, or should we look into the legal disputes over land that many families faced in the Little Levels after 1865?
The Civil War and its aftermath in the Little Levels were defined by divided loyalties and a complex legal landscape that made land ownership particularly precarious for families like the Deans and McNeels.
Civil War Service: The McNeels and Deans
While individual records vary, the McNeel family was prominently aligned with the Confederate cause, while the Dean family’s records reflect the heavy toll the war took on the local civilian population and the transition of estates.
The McNeel Family: Military and Administrative Roles
The McNeels were central to the Confederate organization in Pocahontas County.
Captain Andrew G. McNeel: In the spring of 1861, he organized the first Confederate company in the Little Levels. Although the company was short-lived (disbanding in the fall of 1861 due to a lack of equipment), it marked the beginning of organized resistance in the area.
Isaac McNeel (1830–?): Beyond military service, Isaac played a key administrative role. In 1862, he was appointed Provost Marshal of Pocahontas County by the Confederate Army. He also served as the county sheriff and managed mercantile interests at Mill Point.
Edgar McNeel: A soldier who experienced some of the war's harshest conditions, Edgar was wounded at the "Bloody Angle" during the Battle of Spotsylvania Court House and became a prisoner of war. He was notably part of the "Immortal 600," a group of Confederate officers held under fire at Morris Island, South Carolina.
The Dean Family: A Time of Transition
Records for the Deans often highlight the domestic and legal struggles of the era.
William Dean: As previously noted, William died in 1865, just as the war ended. His death during this period of "bushwhacker" warfare and general lawlessness meant that his widow, Elizabeth McNeel Dean, had to navigate the legal complexities of the new state of West Virginia alone.
William McClenachan Dean Jr.: Coming of age during the conflict, his life (and the lives of his siblings) was shaped by the post-war economic shift from a plantation-style system to smaller-scale industry.
Land Disputes in the Little Levels (Post-1865)
After 1865, the "Little Levels" became a legal battleground. The creation of West Virginia in 1863 introduced laws that significantly impacted property rights for those who had supported the South.
The Suitor’s Test Oath (1865)
The most significant hurdle for local families was the Suitor’s Test Oath, enacted in February 1865.
The Barrier: This law required anyone filing a lawsuit (including those trying to protect their land from encroachment) to swear they had never supported the Confederacy.
The Impact: Since many McNeels and Deans had Confederate ties, they were effectively barred from using the court system to resolve land disputes or recover property for nearly a decade.
The Influence of Judge Nathaniel Harrison
The legal landscape of the Little Levels was dominated by Judge Nathaniel Harrison, who presided over the circuit including Pocahontas County.
Rigid Enforcement: Known as a "Radical" judge, Harrison was notorious for his strict enforcement of test oaths.
Disenfranchisement: Under his bench, many former Confederate families saw their land titles challenged or their legal standing stripped, leading to a period of intense bitterness and litigation that lasted well into the 1870s.
Overlapping Titles and Absentee Owners
Much of the conflict arose from overlapping land grants and "faulty surveys" dating back to the 1700s. After the war, northern speculators and land companies often moved in to claim "abandoned" or "delinquent" lands, forcing families like the Deans to produce iron-clad documentation at a time when they were legally hamstrung.
Would you like me to look into the specific legal cases heard by Judge Nathaniel Harrison involving Pocahontas County land, or shall we research the genealogy of the McNeel family specifically through the line of the "Immortal 600" soldier, Edgar McNeel?
Judge Nathaniel Harrison presided over the 7th Judicial Circuit, which during the Reconstruction era encompassed Pocahontas, Greenbrier, Nicholas, and Monroe counties. His tenure is historically significant not for a single landmark case, but for a systemic pattern of legal and administrative actions that targeted the former Confederate population of the Little Levels.
The following details are drawn from regional legal and historical records:
Enforcement of the "Test Oath"
Harrison was a primary enforcer of the Suitor’s Test Oath and the Forfeiture Acts.
Mass Disenfranchisement: He famously ejected almost all former Confederates from local offices in Pocahontas County, even those who had been popularly elected in the 1865 elections.
Legal Barricades: By strictly applying the test oath, he prevented many local landowners (including families like the Deans and McNeels) from testifying in court or bringing suits to protect their land titles against speculators.
Judicial Conduct and Controversies
Records from the West Virginia House of Delegates and Supreme Court of Appeals highlight several specific "practices" that defined his court:
The Legal Ad Monopoly: Harrison required that all legal advertisements—mandatory for land sales and estate settlements—be placed in a newspaper that he personally owned.
Fee-Splitting Schemes: He was accused of suggesting that litigants use a specific lawyer, from whom Harrison then received a percentage of the legal fees as a kickback.
Conflict of Interest: He frequently sat in judgment on cases in which he was an interested party, effectively acting as both judge and beneficiary.
Pardon "Fees": There were documented reports that he charged cash payments for approving the pardon applications of ex-Confederates who were seeking to have their civil rights restored.
Notable Legal Dissent
In the broader state legal landscape, Harrison was a vocal outlier. In a significant series of cases regarding Belligerent Rights and Confederate Money, he filed a strong dissent against the West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals. While the higher court began to move toward a more moderate stance on the legality of wartime actions, Harrison remained a staunch advocate for the continued punishment and legal restriction of Southern sympathizers.
Impeachment Proceedings
His conduct eventually led to multiple attempts to remove him from the bench:
1866 Attempt: A former Confederate officer traveled to the House of Delegates to file for Harrison’s impeachment. However, the officer was physically beaten and ejected from the chamber by House staff, who labeled his request a "malicious attempt to slander" the judge.
1870 Impeachment: As the political climate in West Virginia shifted, the Legislature of 1870 finally adopted articles of impeachment against him, though he resigned before the trial was completed to avoid a formal conviction.
Impact on the Little Levels
For families like the Deans, Harrison’s court represented a period of "legalized instability." Because land titles in the Little Levels often relied on older Virginia grants, Harrison’s refusal to recognize the legal standing of former Confederates allowed "Radical" speculators to challenge the ownership of established farms and timber tracts.
Would you like me to look for specific records of land sales or "delinquent" land auctions held in Pocahontas County during Harrison’s time on the bench?
The soldier most famously associated with the "Immortal 600" in Pocahontas County history is Alfred Mallory Edgar (1837–1913), often referred to locally as Captain Edgar. While his surname was Edgar, he is a central figure in McNeel genealogy through his marriage to Lydia Ann McNeel, the daughter of one of the county’s most prominent patriarchs.
The Soldier: Alfred Mallory Edgar
Alfred Mallory Edgar’s life is a bridge between the Edgar family of Greenbrier County and the McNeels of the Little Levels.
Parentage: He was the son of Archer Edgar and Nancy Howe Pearis. His family operated "Edgar’s Mill," which is the present-day site of Ronceverte, WV.
Military Service: He served as a Lieutenant in the 27th Virginia Infantry (part of the "Stonewall Brigade"). He was wounded and captured at the "Bloody Angle" during the Battle of Spotsylvania Court House in 1864.
The Immortal 600: As a prisoner of war, he was part of the "Immortal 600," a group of Confederate officers placed under the fire of their own guns at Morris Island, South Carolina. He survived the ordeal and was released in June 1865.
The McNeel Connection (Lydia’s Lineage)
In 1875, Alfred married Lydia Ann McNeel (1849–1919), which fully integrated him into the McNeel family’s social and agricultural life in Hillsboro.
Lydia’s Father: Col. Paul McNeel (1803–1884)
Lydia was the daughter of Col. Paul McNeel, who was perhaps the wealthiest and most influential McNeel of his generation.
Property: He owned the "Brick House" estate known as Mt. Airy in Hillsboro.
Legacy: He was a son of Isaac McNeel and Anna Seibert, and a grandson of the pioneer John McNeel.
The Children of the "Immortal 600" Line
The union of the soldier Alfred Mallory Edgar and Lydia McNeel produced several children, further intertwining the two names:
Rachel Ann Edgar (1890–1975): She famously married Jacob Moffett McNeel, essentially "bringing the line back" to the McNeel name.
George Pearis Edgar (1887–1961): He remained in the Hillsboro area and was instrumental in preserving the family's historical records.
Summary of the Combined Lineage
| Generation | Ancestor | Key Fact |
| Pioneer | John McNeel | First permanent settler of the Little Levels (1765). |
| Grandfather | Isaac McNeel | Established the family's early landholdings. |
| Father-in-Law | Col. Paul McNeel | Influential leader; owner of "Mt. Airy." |
| The Soldier | Alfred M. Edgar | "Immortal 600" survivor; married into the family. |
| Descendant | Rachel Ann Edgar | Married back into the McNeel family (Jacob Moffett McNeel). |
The records of this specific line were famously compiled by Betsy Jordan Edgar in The McNeel Family Record, a book written within the walls of the "Mt. Airy" brick house.
Would you like me to look into the history of the Mt. Airy estate itself or research the remains of the "Immortal 600" monuments in the area?
The soldier most famously associated with the "Immortal 600" in Pocahontas County history is Alfred Mallory Edgar (1837–1913), often referred to locally as Captain Edgar. While his surname was Edgar, he is a central figure in McNeel genealogy through his marriage to Lydia Ann McNeel, the daughter of one of the county’s most prominent patriarchs.
The Soldier: Alfred Mallory Edgar
Alfred Mallory Edgar’s life is a bridge between the Edgar family of Greenbrier County and the McNeels of the Little Levels.
Parentage: He was the son of Archer Edgar and Nancy Howe Pearis. His family operated "Edgar’s Mill," which is the present-day site of Ronceverte, WV.
Military Service: He served as a Lieutenant in the 27th Virginia Infantry (part of the "Stonewall Brigade"). He was wounded and captured at the "Bloody Angle" during the Battle of Spotsylvania Court House in 1864.
The Immortal 600: As a prisoner of war, he was part of the "Immortal 600," a group of Confederate officers placed under the fire of their own guns at Morris Island, South Carolina. He survived the ordeal and was released in June 1865.
The McNeel Connection (Lydia’s Lineage)
In 1875, Alfred married Lydia Ann McNeel (1849–1919), which fully integrated him into the McNeel family’s social and agricultural life in Hillsboro.
Lydia’s Father: Col. Paul McNeel (1803–1884)
Lydia was the daughter of Col. Paul McNeel, who was perhaps the wealthiest and most influential McNeel of his generation.
Property: He owned the "Brick House" estate known as Mt. Airy in Hillsboro.
Legacy: He was a son of Isaac McNeel and Anna Seibert, and a grandson of the pioneer John McNeel.
The Children of the "Immortal 600" Line
The union of the soldier Alfred Mallory Edgar and Lydia McNeel produced several children, further intertwining the two names:
Rachel Ann Edgar (1890–1975): She famously married Jacob Moffett McNeel, essentially "bringing the line back" to the McNeel name.
George Pearis Edgar (1887–1961): He remained in the Hillsboro area and was instrumental in preserving the family's historical records.
Summary of the Combined Lineage
| Generation | Ancestor | Key Fact |
| Pioneer | John McNeel | First permanent settler of the Little Levels (1765). |
| Grandfather | Isaac McNeel | Established the family's early landholdings. |
| Father-in-Law | Col. Paul McNeel | Influential leader; owner of "Mt. Airy." |
| The Soldier | Alfred M. Edgar | "Immortal 600" survivor; married into the family. |
| Descendant | Rachel Ann Edgar | Married back into the McNeel family (Jacob Moffett McNeel). |
The records of this specific line were famously compiled by Betsy Jordan Edgar in The McNeel Family Record, a book written within the walls of the "Mt. Airy" brick house.
Would you like me to look into the history of the Mt. Airy estate itself or research the remains of the "Immortal 600" monuments in the area?
While there is no single monument specifically and exclusively dedicated to the "Immortal 600" within Pocahontas County, the "remains" of their legacy in the area are found in the physical graves of its survivors and the broader Confederate memorials that honor the men who returned from that ordeal.
Local Gravesites and Memorials
The McNeel Cemetery (Hillsboro, WV)
The most significant local "monument" to the Immortal 600 is the gravesite of Captain Alfred Mallory Edgar (1837–1913).
Location: Located on a hill overlooking the Little Levels, this cemetery is the final resting place for the man who became the local face of the "Immortal 600."
The Inscription: His headstone serves as a primary marker of the group’s history in the county, often visited by historians tracing the lineage of the Stonewall Brigade and the Morris Island prisoners.
The Confederate Statue (Marlinton/Jacob Marshall Farm)
Dedicated on July 23, 1913, this statue is the most prominent Civil War monument in Pocahontas County.
Significance: While it honors all Confederate soldiers from the county, it was erected during the twilight years of the survivors' lives. Captain Edgar was still alive during the planning of such local tributes, and the monument represents the community's effort to "keep the memories alive" for the very men who had endured the starvation rations of Fort Pulaski and Morris Island.
The Literary "Monument"
In the Hillsboro area, the most enduring monument is not made of stone, but of paper.
"My Reminiscences of the Civil War": Captain Edgar wrote a detailed memoir of his time as one of the 600. For decades, this manuscript was a "hidden" monument in the McNeel/Edgar family until it was formally published in 2011. It remains the most definitive local account of the torture and survival of the 600.
National Monuments (Where the 13 Died)
For those looking for a formal monument specifically titled for the "Immortal 600," one must look to the sites of their imprisonment, where the men who didn't return to Pocahontas County are memorialized:
Fort Pulaski National Monument (Georgia): A granite marker was dedicated here in 2012 by the Sons of Confederate Veterans. It lists the names of the 13 officers who died at the fort during the "retaliation rations" period.
Immortal 600 Memorial Highway: A stretch of US 80 leading to Tybee Island in Georgia is officially named in their honor, marking the path the prisoners took as they were moved from the ships to the fort.
Summary of "Remains" in the Area
| Site | Type | Connection to Immortal 600 |
| McNeel Cemetery | Gravesite | Burial of Capt. A.M. Edgar (Survivor). |
| Marlinton Statue | Monument | General tribute including the county's 600 survivors. |
| Mt. Airy Estate | Private Residence | The home where the McNeel/Edgar records were preserved. |
Would you like me to find the full list of the 13 men who died at Fort Pulaski, or would you prefer to see excerpts from Captain Edgar’s memoir describing his return to Pocahontas County?
The "Immortal 600" prisoners were subjected to extreme "retaliation rations" during their stay at Fort Pulaski (and nearby Hilton Head) between October 1864 and March 1865. While records of the total number of deaths among the 600 vary (as many died later at Fort Delaware or on the transport ships), historical markers and the National Park Service recognize 13 Confederate officers who died specifically during their incarceration at Fort Pulaski.
The 13 Who Died at Fort Pulaski
These men were buried on Cockspur Island outside the walls of the fort. Most succumbed to the effects of scurvy and dehydration caused by a diet of rotten cornmeal and onion pickles.
Captain W. E. McCaslin – 4th Arkansas Infantry
Captain J. B. Harris – 5th Mississippi Cavalry (sometimes listed as H. B. Harris)
Lieutenant J. C. C. Cowper – 33rd North Carolina Infantry
Lieutenant G. B. Fitzgerald – 12th Virginia Cavalry (a West Point graduate)
Lieutenant J. H. B. Shuler – 5th South Carolina Infantry
Lieutenant D. B. Lathrop – 10th Virginia Cavalry
Lieutenant P. B. Akers – 11th Virginia Infantry
Lieutenant W. B. Barker – 10th Virginia Cavalry
Lieutenant J. W. McRae – 67th Georgia Infantry
Lieutenant J. L. Fannin – 61st Alabama Infantry
Lieutenant W. P. Callahan – 25th Tennessee Infantry
Lieutenant J. J. Lewis – 1st Virginia Cavalry (sometimes listed as A. J. Lewis)
Lieutenant J. C. Childers – 60th Tennessee Infantry
The Remains of the Men
Archaeological Evidence: For over a century, the exact location of their graves was lost to the elements and shifting sands of the island. In 1999, archaeological surveys at Fort Pulaski identified 37 graves on the island, a portion of which are believed to be the remains of these 13 officers, alongside Union soldiers who also died at the fort.
The Memorial: Today, a granite marker stands near the fort’s cemetery area, dedicated to their memory. It serves as the physical "monument" you were looking for, explicitly naming the 600 and noting the sacrifice of those who died during the "retaliatory" period.
A Note on the 14th Death: Some historical accounts list 14 deaths at the fort; however, official military records usually categorize the 14th man as having died during the transfer back to Fort Delaware or at the hospital in Hilton Head just after departure.
Would you like me to find excerpts from Captain Alfred Edgar’s memoir regarding the day-to-day survival of the 600 at Fort Pulaski?
Captain Alfred Mallory Edgar’s memoir, My Reminiscences of the Civil War, provides a haunting, firsthand account of the "retaliation" period at Fort Pulaski. While many Civil War journals focus on battles, Edgar’s writing during this time is a visceral study of human endurance under systematic starvation.
Below are key excerpts and themes from his account of the day-to-day survival of the Immortal 600.
The "Retaliation" Diet
The most famous—and infamous—part of Edgar’s memoir describes the rations issued by Union General J.G. Foster in retaliation for the treatment of Union prisoners at Andersonville.
"Our rations consisted of ten ounces of cornmeal and about half a pint of onion pickles. The cornmeal was from two to three years old, and was filled with black weevils and white worms. We had to eat it, worms and all, or starve."
Edgar notes that the prisoners eventually developed a method for "cleaning" the meal, though it was rarely successful. They would stir the meal into water; the weevils would float to the top, where they could be skimmed off, but the larvae remained inside the "mush."
The "Cat Soup" Incident
As hunger turned into a "gnawing, constant companion," Edgar describes how the officers began to hunt the animals that lived within the fort’s damp casemates.
"The rats were caught and eaten with a relish. I have seen as much as a dollar in greenback offered for a good-sized rat. Even the cats that were about the fort disappeared... One of the officers caught a large cat, killed it, and made a soup of it. He invited a few friends to the feast, and they all pronounced it excellent, better than any squirrel soup they had ever tasted."
The Physical Toll of Scurvy
Because the diet lacked any fresh meat or diverse vegetables (outside of the acidic pickles), scurvy ravaged the men. Edgar describes the daily sight of the "sick line":
"Our legs became as black as a coal from the knees down to the toes... our teeth became loose in our gums so that we could almost pull them out with our fingers. Many of the men could not walk and had to be carried about by their comrades."
The Psychological Battle
Perhaps most striking is Edgar's reflection on the mental state of the 600. Despite the physical decay, he emphasizes the internal resolve required to refuse the "Oath of Allegiance," which would have granted them immediate freedom and food.
"The North kept a book open at the gate, and any man who would go up and sign the oath of allegiance to the United States would be taken out, fed, and clothed. But to the honor of those six hundred officers, only a very few—I think not more than five or six—ever accepted the offer. We preferred to die in the casemates of Fort Pulaski rather than prove recreant to the cause we had espoused."
Key Takeaways from Edgar's Account
Communal Support: Edgar frequently mentions how the stronger officers (like himself, initially) would divide their meager portions to help those who were too sick to stand.
The Weather: He describes the "damp, salt air" of the casemates as an enemy almost as formidable as the hunger, noting that the blankets were never truly dry.
The Return: When Edgar finally returned to Pocahontas County in 1865, he was so emaciated that his own family struggled to recognize him until he spoke.
Would you like me to research the specific location of the "Mt. Airy" estate in Hillsboro where these memoirs were preserved for over a century?
The Mt. Airy estate, more commonly known locally as the "Brick House," is a prominent historic landmark located on the northern outskirts of Hillsboro, West Virginia.
Location and Setting
Mt. Airy is situated along the east side of Seneca Trail (US-219), approximately one mile north of the and about three miles south of the historic . The estate lies within the fertile Little Levels district, a region long recognized for its agricultural value.
Estate Grounds: The house was the centerpiece of a sprawling plantation that once encompassed over 1,000 acres of prime limestone land.
Related Landmarks: The estate is adjacent to Dick McNeel Road, which leads into the "Sinking Springs" section of the family lands, where the McNeel family continued farming for generations.
Historical Significance
Built in 1838 by Col. Paul McNeel (1803–1884), the house was designed to be a grand statement of the family's influence in Pocahontas County.
The "Brick House": It was one of the first substantial brick residences in the area, built using bricks fired on the property. Col. McNeel reportedly built it to provide ample room for his ten children after outgrowing a smaller log structure.
Civil War Era: During the Civil War, the house was a known center of Confederate activity. Paul McNeel was a major supporter of the Southern cause, and his son-in-law, Captain Alfred Mallory Edgar (the "Immortal 600" survivor), eventually made his home in the nearby area after marrying Lydia Ann McNeel.
Preservation of the Memoirs
The house gained literary fame in the 20th century as the home of Betsy Jordan Edgar, the historian and author who compiled the definitive genealogical records of the region.
The Front Parlor: Betsy Edgar famously used the "Front Parlor" of Mt. Airy as her study, where she synthesized the 13 notebooks of research left by Dr. John O. McNeel to write The McNeel Family Record.
Captain Edgar's Papers: It was within these walls that the memoirs of Captain Alfred Mallory Edgar were preserved for over a century before their eventual publication, providing the world with his firsthand account of life at Fort Pulaski.
Would you like to see a list of other McNeel family properties in the Little Levels, or should we research the history of the Sinking Springs Farm specifically?
The Sinking Springs Farm in Hillsboro, West Virginia, is the ancestral home and agricultural heart of the McNeel family, representing over 250 years of continuous stewardship in the Little Levels district of Pocahontas County.
Origins and Early History
The farm is situated on a portion of the original 1,000-acre land grant settled by John McNeel (1745–1825), the first permanent pioneer of the Little Levels, who arrived in the region around 1765.
The Name: The farm takes its name from the local karst topography, characterized by limestone "sinking springs" where water emerges from the earth only to disappear back into underground caverns and "sinks."
Family Continuity: The land has remained in the McNeel family through generations, passing from John to his descendants, including influential figures like Isaac McNeel, who constructed the nearby between 1860 and 1868.
20th Century Agricultural Legacy
In the modern era, the farm became widely known for its excellence in livestock production and its role in regional agricultural leadership, particularly under the late Jacob Moffett "Mac" McNeel Jr. (1928–2020) and Lanty F. McNeel (1941–2021).
Livestock and Records: The farm was a premier site for beef, swine, and sheep production. It gained national fame for record-breaking sheep-shearing contests, a tradition that still holds several records today.
Size and Scale: At its peak in the mid-20th century, the family operation encompassed approximately 880 acres of prime limestone farmland, making it one of the largest and most productive tracts in the Greenbrier Valley.
Civic and Educational Impact
The farm served as more than just a commercial enterprise; it was a center for community and educational outreach.
Youth Engagement: Moffett McNeel hosted over 2,000 children on tours of the farm during his lifetime, teaching them about sustainable agriculture and 4-H principles.
National Youth Science Camp: The McNeel family was instrumental in the 1963 establishment of the National Youth Science Camp (NYSC) in Pocahontas County, a legacy that continues to bring top science students from across the country to the region.
Preservation: The farm overlooks the historic and is closely tied to the McNeel Cemetery, where generations of the family are buried. Lanty McNeel was specifically noted for his extensive work in restoring the ancient "table-stone" markers in the family graveyard.
.png)
.png)
