Based on the detailed "Teacher's Guide to the Westest" provided, here is a comprehensive analysis of Somewhere School's performance compared to the State average.
Executive Summary
This report acts as a Gap Analysis. The "L-S" column (Local minus State) is the most critical metric here.
Overall Trend: Somewhere School is generally outperforming the state. On the majority of the "Hard" items (where State < 51), the school is actually ahead (e.g., Identify Angles, Distributive Property).
The Critical Flaw: There is a specific, severe deficit in Geometry Properties (Quadrilaterals, Circles, Plane Figures). This is the only area where the school is significantly trailing the state.
1. Critical Weaknesses (Red Flags)
The items at the top of the list show negative "L-S" scores, indicating areas where the school is underperforming compared to the state average.
| Topic | State Score | School Score | Gap (L-S) | Notes |
| Compare Quadrilaterals | 45 | 25 | -20 | Critical Priority. Marked with ****. This is a massive gap on an item that is already difficult statewide. |
| Identify Circle Parts | 52 | 39 | -13 | Marked ***. Students likely struggle with vocabulary like radius, diameter, or chord. |
| Identify Plane Figures | 80 | 72 | -8 | Marked **. Basic shape identification is below expectation. |
| Compare 3D Shapes | 79 | 73 | -6 | Marked **. |
Analysis: The deficit is consistent across "Shape Properties." While students can Identify Symmetry (Score 93, +1 vs State) and Identify Angles (Score 55, +10 vs State), they struggle to classify shapes. This suggests they understand spatial concepts but lack the specific vocabulary or definition rules for shapes (e.g., defining a rhombus vs. a square).
2. Significant Strengths
The bottom of the list shows areas where Somewhere School is dominating the state averages.
Identify Fractions: Score 100 (State 90). Every single student mastered this.
Elapsed Time/Clock: Score 82 (State 65). A massive +17 point lead. Time calculation is often a struggle point for 4th graders, so this is a major win.
Organize Graph: Score 80 (State 64). A +16 point lead. Students are excellent at creating/structuring data, even if they struggle slightly to interpret chart data (-4 gap).
Multiply/Whole Numbers: Score 91 (State 78). Computational fluency is very strong.
3. Performance on "HARD" Items
The report defines "HARD" as any topic where the State Score is < 51. There are 5 such topics. Interestingly, the school is winning on 4 out of 5 of them:
Add Fractions/Using Models: State 18 | School 25 (+7). Note: This question was incredibly difficult for the entire state.
Round Decimals: State 29 | School 32 (+3).
Identify Angles: State 45 | School 55 (+10).
Distributive Property: State 47 | School 50 (+3).
Compare Quadrilaterals: State 45 | School 25 (-20). The only "Hard" item where the school failed significantly.
Recommendation
The data points to a very specific actionable step: The "Shape Properties" Unit.
Since the students are already good at angles and symmetry, the cognitive foundation is there. The issue is likely terminology.
Action: Implement a targeted review on the definitions of Quadrilaterals (Trapezoid, Parallelogram, Rhombus, Rectangle, Square hierarchy) and Circle anatomy (Radius vs. Diameter).
Action: Since "Compare Quadrilaterals" only had a count of 1 item on the test, the low score of 25% suggests that specific question might have been a "trick" question or relied on a definition the curriculum missed (e.g., "Is a square a rectangle?").
Would you like to see a sample lesson plan specifically for "Comparing Quadrilaterals" to address that -20 gap?
Here is a targeted lesson plan designed to bridge the gap between your students' strong understanding of components (angles/lines) and their struggle with the definitions of the shapes themselves.
Lesson Title: The Quadrilateral Family Tree
Target Audience: 4th Grade Math
Time: 45–60 Minutes
Objective: Students will define and compare quadrilaterals (Square, Rectangle, Rhombus, Parallelogram, Trapezoid) based on their attributes (angles and parallel sides).
1. The Strategy (Why this works)
Your data shows your students excel at Identify Parallel Lines (+5) and Identify Angles (+10). They know the "ingredients" (angles and lines) but struggle with the "recipe" (the shape definition). This lesson explicitly links their strengths to the weak area.
2. Warm-Up: "The Ingredients Check" (5 Mins)
Goal: Activate prior knowledge of parallel lines and right angles (known strengths).
Activity: "Simon Says" with arms.
"Show me Parallel Lines!" (Arms straight up like the number 11).
"Show me a Right Angle!" (One arm up, one arm out).
"Show me an Obtuse Angle!" (Wide arms).
Teacher Script: "You are all experts at finding lines and angles. Today, we are going to see how putting these ingredients together creates different members of the Quadrilateral family."
3. Direct Instruction: The "Always, Sometimes, Never" Rules (15 Mins)
Concept: The Hierarchy. Most students lose points on "Compare" questions because they think categories are exclusive (e.g., believing a Square is not a Rectangle).
Visual Aid: Draw a large "Family Tree" or Venn Diagram on the board.
Key Definitions (The "Rules"):
Parallelogram: The "Parent." Needs 2 pairs of parallel sides.
Rectangle: A picky Parallelogram. Needs 4 right angles.
Rhombus: A picky Parallelogram. Needs 4 equal sides.
Square: The "Perfectionist." Needs to be both a Rectangle (right angles) AND a Rhombus (equal sides).
Trapezoid: The "Cousin." Only has 1 pair of parallel sides.
The "Trick" Question Practice:
Write these on the board and have students vote:
Is a Square a Rectangle? (YES – because it has 4 right angles).
Is a Rectangle a Square? (NO – sides aren't always equal).
Is a Square a Rhombus? (YES – because it has 4 equal sides).
4. Guided Practice: "Shape CSI" (15 Mins)
Materials: Cutouts of shapes or images on a screen.
Activity: Present a "suspect" shape (e.g., a Square) and ask students to check off every name that applies to it.
Example: Hold up a Square.
Is it a Quadrilateral? (Yes, 4 sides).
Is it a Parallelogram? (Yes, 2 pairs parallel).
Is it a Rectangle? (Yes, right angles).
Is it a Rhombus? (Yes, equal sides).
Result: It has 4 aliases!
5. Independent Practice: The "Creation Station" (15 Mins)
Task: Students draw shapes based on strict rules. This forces them to "create" the evidence rather than just look at it.
Draw a quadrilateral with exactly one pair of parallel sides. (Trapezoid)
Draw a quadrilateral with 4 right angles but sides that are not all equal. (Rectangle)
Draw a quadrilateral with 4 equal sides and no right angles. (Rhombus)
6. Assessment: The Exit Ticket (5 Mins)
(This mimics the test style)
Question:
"Compare a Square and a Rhombus. List one thing that is the same and one thing that is different."
Expected Answer (Same): Both have 4 equal sides / Both are parallelograms.
Expected Answer (Different): Square must have right angles; Rhombus does not have to.
Differentiation Note
For students struggling with Interpret Graph (+2) or visual clutter, provide a checklist they can place next to the shape so they can physically tick off attributes (e.g., "Does it have square corners? [ ] Yes [ ] No").
Here is a "Shape Detective" checklist designed to reduce visual clutter and cognitive load. This tool separates the visual analysis (looking at the shape) from the vocabulary retrieval (naming the shape).
You can print this on a small card or laminate it for students to use with dry-erase markers directly on top of their worksheets.
The "Shape Detective" Checklist
Name of Student: ___________________
Shape #: ______
Step 1: The Side Count
Does the shape have exactly 4 straight sides?
[ ] YES $\rightarrow$ It is a Quadrilateral. (Keep going)
[ ] NO $\rightarrow$ STOP. It is not a quadrilateral.
Step 2: The Parallel Check
(Look for "train tracks" – lines that will never touch)
How many pairs of parallel sides do you see?
[ ] 0 Pairs $\rightarrow$ It is just a general Quadrilateral.
[ ] 1 Pair $\rightarrow$ It is a Trapezoid.
[ ] 2 Pairs $\rightarrow$ It is a Parallelogram. (Keep going to Step 3)
Step 3: The "Special Features" Check
(Only answer these if you have 2 Pairs of Parallel sides)
A. Look at the Corners (Angles)
Does it have 4 Square Corners (Right Angles)?
[ ] YES $\rightarrow$ It is a Rectangle.
[ ] NO
B. Look at the Sides (Length)
Are all 4 sides exactly the same length?
[ ] YES $\rightarrow$ It is a Rhombus.
[ ] NO
Step 4: The Final Verdict
Did you check YES for both Rectangle AND Rhombus?
[ ] YES $\rightarrow$ SUPER SHAPE ALERT! It is a Square.
How to use this in the classroom:
Transparent Overlay: If possible, print this checklist on a transparency or clear plastic sheet. Students can place it over the test question to isolate the shape from the surrounding text/graphs.
The "Stop Sign" Method: Teach students that if they stop at "Trapezoid" in Step 2, they are done. They don't need to worry about square corners or equal sides. This prevents them from confusing a Trapezoid with a Rectangle.
Vocabulary Reference: Keep a small "Key" at the bottom of the checklist with simple visual cues:
Parallel =
(Train tracks)
* Square Corner =Shutterstock
(Corner of a paper)
* Equal Sides = (Tick marks)
Would you like me to generate a few "practice problems" that specifically test the hardest distinctions on this checklist (e.g., distinguishing a Rhombus from a slanted Square)?
Here are 7 practice questions designed to test those tricky distinctions, specifically focusing on the rules from your "Shape Detective" checklist.
Encourage your students to use the "Shape Detective" checklist while answering these! If they can spot the "Square in disguise" (Question 1), they've mastered the hardest part of the unit.
----------------------------------------------
Appendix
Based on the "Teacher's Guide to the Westest" data provided, this class appears to be a 4th Grade cohort.
The data indicates significant struggles in Geometry (specifically quadrilaterals and circle parts) and Consumer Math (making change). However, the students are strong in Elapsed Time and Basic Operations.
Because there are 37 distinct test items, providing a 2-page formal plan for each would be overwhelming. Instead, I have created 37 Targeted Micro-Lesson Plans. These are grouped by mathematical domain for easier implementation, but each test item has its own dedicated objective and activity.
Items marked [PRIORITY] correspond to the skills where your students had the largest negative gaps compared to the state (L-S score < -5).
Domain 1: Geometry (Critical Need Area)
The data shows this is the weakest area (-20 gap for Quadrilaterals).
1. Compare Quadrilaterals [PRIORITY]
Objective: Students will distinguish between parallelograms, trapezoids, rectangles, rhombuses, and squares based on parallel sides and angle types.
Activity: "Quadrilateral Family Tree." Give students a bag of paper shapes. Have them create a hierarchy chart. They must prove why a square is a rectangle, but a rectangle isn't always a square, using "Attribute Checklists" (e.g., Must have 4 right angles).
2. Identify Circle Parts [PRIORITY]
Objective: Students will identify the radius, diameter, chord, and center of a circle.
Activity: "Human Circles." Use a large rope in the gym. Have students stand in a circle. One student stands in the center. Use yarn to have students connect to each other to physically form a radius, diameter, and chord.
3. Identify Plane Figures [PRIORITY]
Objective: Students will name polygons up to decagons based on side count.
Activity: "Polygon Scavenger Hunt." Students walk around the school with clipboards. They must find and sketch real-world examples of triangles, pentagons, hexagons, and octagons found in architecture or floor tiles.
4. Compare 3D Shapes [PRIORITY]
Objective: Students will compare prisms, pyramids, cones, cylinders, and spheres by counting faces, edges, and vertices.
Activity: "Mystery Bag." Students reach into a bag, feel a solid shape, and describe it to a partner using geometric terms ("It has one distinct vertex and a circular base") before pulling it out.
5. Identify Symmetry
Objective: Students will draw lines of symmetry on irregular and regular polygons.
Activity: "Mirror Paint." Students fold a paper in half, paint a design on one side, and press it together. After opening, they draw the line of symmetry down the crease.
6. Identify Rectangle
Objective: Students will identify rectangles based on specific properties (4 right angles, opposite sides parallel and equal).
Activity: "Rectangle Detective." Provide a worksheet with various quadrilaterals (some clearly parallelograms but not rectangles). Students must use the corner of an index card (a right angle checker) to circle only the true rectangles.
7. Identify Parallel Lines
Objective: Students will identify parallel, intersecting, and perpendicular lines.
Activity: "City Map Design." Students draw a street map that must include Main Street parallel to 1st Ave, and Broadway perpendicular to both.
8. Identify Angles [HARD ITEM]
Objective: Students will classify angles as acute, obtuse, or right.
Activity: "Yoga Angles." The teacher calls out an angle type, and students must use their arms or legs to form that angle.
Domain 2: Numbers and Base Ten
9. Identify Numbers to 100,000 [PRIORITY]
Objective: Students will read, write, and identify the value of digits up to the hundred-thousands place.
Activity: "Place Value Dice Roll." Students roll a die 6 times to create a 6-digit number. They must write it in standard form, expanded form, and word form.
10. Identify Place Value
Objective: Students will identify the value of a specific underlined digit.
Activity: "Digit Value War." Students draw cards. The teacher says "Show me the Tens place." High card in that spot wins.
11. Whole Numbers To Millions
Objective: Students will read and comprehend numbers in the millions period.
Activity: "Million Dollar Budget." Give students a fake budget of $5,000,000. They must select items to buy (houses, cars) from a catalog, subtracting the large numbers to see what is left.
12. Round Decimals [HARD ITEM]
Objective: Students will round decimals to the nearest whole number or tenth.
Activity: "Number Line Jump." Draw a large number line on the floor (e.g., 4.0 to 5.0). A student stands on 4.7. They must physically jump to the closer whole number.
13. Compare Change/$ [PRIORITY]
Objective: Students will determine the correct change due from a purchase.
Activity: "Subtraction Algorithm focus." Use play money. Students "buy" items costing $3.45 with a $5.00 bill. They must calculate the change using the subtraction algorithm, then verify it by counting up with coins.
14. Make Change/$10.00
Objective: Students will calculate change specifically from a $10 bill.
Activity: "The 10-Dollar Challenge." Rapid-fire drill. Teacher holds up an item price card (e.g., $6.50). Students write the change from $10 on whiteboards ($3.50).
15. Subtract Decimals
Objective: Students will subtract decimals, focusing on lining up the decimal points.
Activity: "Button Alignment." Students write problems on grid paper. They must glue a real button over the decimal points to ensure they are physically aligned before subtracting.
Domain 3: Fractions
16. Order Fractions W/Models [PRIORITY]
Objective: Students will order fractions with unlike denominators using visual models.
Activity: "Fraction Strips Construction." Students cut and color their own fraction strips (1 whole, 1/2s, 1/3s, 1/4s). They lay them out to physically prove that 1/3 is larger than 1/4.
17. Subtract Fractions W/Model
Objective: Students will subtract fractions with like denominators using area models.
Activity: "Pizza Removal." Draw pizzas divided into slices. Shade in the starting fraction (e.g., 5/8). Students cross out the subtracted amount (2/8) to find the remaining slices (3/8).
18. Add Fractions/Using Models [HARD ITEM]
Objective: Students will add fractions using number lines or circle models.
Activity: "Jump the Line." Use a number line marked in fractions. Students move a game piece forward 3/10, then add another 4/10, to see where they land (7/10).
19. Identify Fractions
Objective: Students will identify the fraction represented by a shaded region.
Activity: "Flash Card Blitz." Teacher shows complex shapes where parts are shaded. Students must write the fraction of the shaded area.
Domain 4: Operations & Algebra
20. Identify Pattern [PRIORITY]
Objective: Students will identify the rule in a geometric or numeric pattern.
Activity: "Pattern Detectives." Give students a sequence (Triangle, Circle, Square, Triangle, Circle...). They must predict the 10th shape and state the "Core" of the repeating pattern.
21. Identify Number Pattern
Objective: Students will find the rule for arithmetic sequences (e.g., +5, -2).
Activity: "What's the Rule?" Write a sequence on the board: 4, 8, 12, 16. Students must identify the rule (+4) and the next three numbers.
22. Division/Whole Numbers
Objective: Students will perform long division with remainders.
Activity: "Does McDonald's Sell Cheese Burgers?" (Divide, Multiply, Subtract, Check, Bring down). Students chant the mnemonic while solving a problem on the board.
23. Estimate Multiplication
Objective: Students will round factors to the nearest ten or hundred to estimate products.
Activity: "Grocery Estimation." Show a cart of 4 items costing $2.95 each. Students round to $3.00 x 4 to estimate the total cost.
24. Multiply/Whole Numbers
Objective: Students will multiply multi-digit numbers (e.g., 2-digit by 2-digit).
Activity: "Lattice vs. Standard." Teach the Lattice method as an alternative to the standard algorithm for students struggling with place value holders.
25. Order Of Operations
Objective: Students will use PEMDAS to solve expressions.
Activity: "PEMDAS Hopscotch." Draw a hopscotch board. Squares are labeled P, E, MD, AS. Students solve a step of the equation as they hop on the corresponding letter.
26. Distributive Property [HARD ITEM]
Objective: Students will break apart multiplication problems (e.g., 4 x 13 = (4x10) + (4x3)).
Activity: "Area Model Breakup." Draw a 4x13 rectangle on grid paper. Cut it into a 4x10 and a 4x3. Calculate the area of each piece and add them.
27. Word Problem/2 Steps
Objective: Students will solve word problems requiring two distinct operations.
Activity: "Storyboarding." Students read a problem and draw a 2-panel comic strip. Panel 1 is the first operation; Panel 2 is the second operation.
28. Number Sentence W/Variable
Objective: Students will solve for $n$ in addition/subtraction equations ($5 + n = 12$).
Activity: "Balance Scales." Use a balance scale. Put 5 blocks and a mystery bag on one side, and 12 blocks on the other. Students remove 5 from both sides to find what's in the bag.
29. Input/Output Model
Objective: Students will determine the function rule of an input/output table.
Activity: "The Function Machine." Create a cardboard box "machine." Put a card "In" (3), and pull a card "Out" (9). Students guess the machine's rule (x3).
Domain 5: Data & Measurement
30. Interpret Data On Chart [PRIORITY]
Objective: Students will extract information from a table or tally chart to answer comparison questions.
Activity: "Class Survey." Create a tally chart of favorite ice creams. Ask "How many more students liked Vanilla than Chocolate?" emphasizing the subtraction.
31. Interpret Graph
Objective: Students will read bar graphs and pictographs.
Activity: "Graph Analysis." Project a bar graph without a title. Have students analyze the data to propose a creative title that fits.
32. Interpret Circle Graph
Objective: Students will understand circle graphs represent parts of a whole (percentages/fractions).
Activity: "Human Pie Chart." Use colored streamers. Divide the class into groups based on eye color. Form a circle to visualize that "Brown eyes" take up half the circle.
33. Organize Graph
Objective: Students will take raw data and plot it correctly on a graph.
Activity: "Skittle Statistics." Give each student a small pack of Skittles. They sort by color and create a bar graph of their specific packet.
34. Measure Length
Objective: Students will measure to the nearest 1/4 inch or centimeter.
Activity: "Broken Ruler." Give students paper rulers that start at "3 inches" instead of "0". Ask them to measure a pencil. This forces them to count the units rather than just look at the end number.
35. Interpret Temperature
Objective: Students will read a thermometer (Fahrenheit and Celsius).
Activity: "Thermometer Builders." Students make a paper thermometer with a sliding red ribbon to simulate rising and falling temperatures based on weather scenarios read by the teacher.
36. Read Time/Minute
Objective: Students will tell time to the exact minute on an analog clock.
Activity: "Clock Gears." Use geared instructional clocks. Set the time to 4:00. Move the minute hand slowly and have students count by 5s and then by 1s.
37. Elapsed Time/Clock
Objective: Students will calculate the duration between two times.
Activity: "Timeline Method." Draw an open number line. Start at 3:15. Jump to 4:00 (+45 min). Jump to 4:30 (+30 min). Add the jumps (75 min = 1 hr 15 min).
