Pocahontas County Surname Summaries
- Arbogast: A foundational German Palatine line descending from Michael Arbogast, who settled in Crabbottom before his sons pushed across the Alleghenies into the upper Greenbrier River and Deer Creek drainages. Progenitor Adam Arbogast served as a Revolutionary War scout, and family members cleared the high valley of Arbovale ("Arbogast's Vale").
- Baxter: An English/Scotch-Irish family originating along Back Creek. Colonel John Morgan Baxter served as the first militia colonel and helped organize Pocahontas County in 1821–1822, while his son William established an estate near Edray.
- Beard: A Scots-Irish pioneer dynasty founded by John Beard, Sr. in the 1770s. Centered at Mill Point, Hillsboro, and the Little Levels, the family established early gristmills, bluegrass stock farms, Oak Grove Presbyterian Church, and Hillsboro Academy.
- Boggs: A Scots-Irish lineage (Francis Boggs, Sr.) settled across the Little Levels, Mill Point, and Edray. Francis Boggs, Jr. and John Boggs served as inaugural justices of the peace, land processioners, and county surveyors during the 1822 county organization.
- Bridger: Early Greenbrier River settlers led by John Bridger, Sr. near Swago Creek and Buckeye in the 1770s. The family is historically remembered for a late 18th-century Shawnee raid in which John Sr. and his son James were killed on their homestead.
- Brown: Established by Joseph Brown and Hannah McAfferty, who moved from the Bullpasture River to bottomlands along the Greenbrier River, Edray, and Indian Draft. His son Josiah Brown anchored the Indian Draft community.
- Bruffey: A pioneer line founded by John Bruffey, Sr. along Bruffey’s Creek and Droop Mountain. Namesakes of Bruffey's Creek and Bruffey's Sinks, the family produced Captain George W. Bruffey, who wrote memoirs detailing antebellum life and the Battle of Droop Mountain.
- Burgess: Descended from Irish weaver John Burgess, Sr. and his son John Jr., who migrated from New York through Rockingham County to establish family lines across Edray, Marlinton, and Onoto.
- Burner: A Swiss-German (Berner) family established near the forks of the Greenbrier River by brothers Abraham and Daniel Burner in the 1790s. They helped found Travelers Repose and gave their name to Burner Mountain and the logging town of Burner.
- Burnside: An Ulster Scot pioneer family (John and James Burnside) rooted in the high-elevation pastures of Slaty Fork, Old Field Fork on the Upper Elk River, and Edray. They operated extensive livestock droving boundaries in partnership with the Hannah family.
- Buzzard (Bussard): A German/Swiss (Bossert) line tracing from Pendleton County. Patriarch Reuben Rudolph Buzzard settled along Sitlington Creek near Dunmore and Frost around 1800, operating a homestead and mill seat.
- Carpenter (Zimmerman): A Swiss/German (Zimmermann) lineage descending from iconic long hunter and scout Jeremiah Carpenter and his kin. Local branches settled along Deer Creek, Thomas Creek, and Huntersville.
- Cochran: An Ulster Scot line founded by John Cochran, Sr. in the late 1770s around Edray, Buckeye, and the Greenbrier River. Family members established early sawmills, gristmills, and livestock droving operations.
- Curry: An Ulster Scot line established by magistrate John Curry, Esq.. His son William Curry, long-serving County Clerk, heroically saved 40 years of Pocahontas County public records by hiding them in mountain caves during the Civil War.
- Cutlip (Gottlieb): A Palatine German line (George Gottlieb/Cutlip, Sr.) that settled along Stamping Creek, Mill Point, and Lobelia, producing early mountain farmers and timbermen.
- Dilley: A French Huguenot family arriving via Maryland, led by brothers Martin and Henry Dilley around Huntersville, Knapps Creek, Thorny Creek, and Cummings Creek. They were widely known for master blacksmithing and mechanical trades.
- Gatewood: A Tidewater Virginia planter family (Samuel Vance Gatewood and Col. A.C.L. Gatewood) with large estates at Mountain Grove and Linwood/Big Spring. Col. A.C.L. Gatewood was a VMI cadet, Civil War cavalry officer, and thoroughbred stock breeder.
- Gibson: An Ulster Scot Presbyterian family (John Gibson) settled along Stony Creek, Edray, and Slaty Fork, closely allied across generations with the Hannah family.
- Givens (Given): An Ulster Scot family from Augusta County that settled the Upper Elk River (Slaty Fork, Old Field Fork) and Edray, operating high-altitude bluegrass grazing runs connecting to Webster and Braxton counties.
- Graham (Grapham): A Scottish Clan Graham lineage (Christopher Graham, Col. James Graham) settled across the Little Levels, Droop Mountain, and Lobelia. They were major livestock breeders and co-founders of Hillsboro Academy.
- Gum (Gumm): A German/English line (Isaac, Abraham, and John Gum) settled along Deer Creek, Dunmore, Arbovale, and Green Bank. Active as livestock drovers, millers, and turnpike commissioners.
- Halterman: A German Palatine family (Michael and Christian Halterman) from the South Branch Potomac settled along Deer Creek, Arbovale, and Back Mountain as cool-climate stock farmers and mechanics.
- Hamilton: An Ulster Scot family founded by William Hamilton in the 1770s along Swago Creek and Buckeye. Active in Revolutionary border defense and early county road construction.
- Hannah: An Ulster Scot family led by David Hannah, Sr., the first botanical physician in lower Pocahontas. His sons Joseph and David Jr. patented thousands of acres along the Slaty Fork and Old Field Fork of the Elk River.
- Hill: Founded by North Carolina frontiersman Richard Hill, who patented land on Hills Creek and married Nancy McNeel. Son Col. John Hill platted Hillsboro in 1843; descendants helped conceal and safeguard county records during the Civil War.
- Hull: A Palatine German line (Peter Thomas Hull, Maj. Peter Hull) spanning Highland and Pocahontas counties. Molly Hull married Abraham Burner, co-founding Travelers Repose.
- Jordan: Ulster Scot immigrant John Jordan married Miriam McNeel, served as an Oak Grove Church elder, and became Pocahontas County's first High Sheriff in 1822.
- Kelly / Kelley: Comprises early antebellum households (Anthony Kelley), direct 19th-century Irish immigrant Jonas Kelley of County Cork in Green Bank, and maternal ties to early settlers.
- Lockridge: An Ulster Scot line from the Calfpasture River. Patriarch Lancelot "Lanty" Lockridge established a large plantation on Knapps Creek near Minnehaha Springs in the early 1800s.
- McClure: An Ulster Scot line (Arthur McClure Sr. & Jr.) settled around Locust Creek, Hillsboro, and Droop Mountain, operating early sash sawmills and livestock farms.
- Nottingham: An English line from Virginia's Eastern Shore. Patriarch William Nottingham, Esq. settled Deer Creek (Dunmore/Green Bank) in the 1790s and served as an inaugural 1822 magistrate; descendants served as county clerks and church leaders.
- Peck: A German Palatine family (Garret Peck, John Peck) moving from Pendleton County to Clover Lick, Green Bank, and Sitlington, intermarrying closely with the Shinaberrys.
- Pence: A Palatine German family (Valentine Bentz/Pence, John Pence) from Rockingham County. Master blacksmiths, merchants, and hotel keepers in Huntersville and Knapps Creek.
- Riley: An Irish/Scotch-Irish line from the Shenandoah Valley settled in Green Bank, Deer Creek, and Arbovale, intermarrying with the Slaven and Arbogast families.
- Rogers: A Scotch-Irish/English family settled along Beaver Creek, Knapps Creek, and Huntersville as farmers, blacksmiths, and teamsters.
- Ryder (Rider): An English and Palatine German lineage settled on Deer Creek, Arbovale, and Back Mountain as self-reliant mountain farmers, blacksmiths, and wheelwrights.
- Sheets (Schütz): A German Palatine line on Deer Creek, Arbovale, and Back Mountain, renowned for expert marksmanship, mountain scouting, carpentry, and milling.
- Shinaberry (Schönberger): A German Palatine family (Jacob & John Shinaberry) settled around Clover Lick, Green Bank, and Cass, serving as early magistrates, farmers, and timber/observatory workers.
- Slaven: An Ulster Scot family (John Slaven Jr.) from County Tyrone settled along Deer Creek, Meadow Creek, and Green Bank, allied across vast acreages with the Warwicks and Tallmans.
- Snedegar (Snedeker): A Dutch lineage (Jan Louwe van Snedeker) settled atop Droop Mountain, Lobelia, and the Little Levels. Namesakes of Snedegar Cave, their farmsteads formed part of the Droop Mountain battlefield.
- Stewart / Stuart: Encompasses lower-county Stuarts (Col. John Stuart's legacy) and upper-county Stewarts (John Andrew Stewart at Linwood/Slatyfork), as well as Stewart Chapel in Marlinton.
- Tallman: A lineage connected to Abraham Lincoln and Daniel Boone's families. Patriarch James Boone Tallman served as an original 1822 county justice on the upper Greenbrier and Deer Creek.
- Varner (Werner): A German line (Adam Varner) anchored by John Varner at Linwood/Slatyfork and Rev. John Varner, an early Brethren preacher on "Top of Allegheny".
- Wagner / Waggoner: A German Palatine family (Solomon Waggoner, George Wagner) settled along the Crab Bottom/Huntersville border and at Huntersville/Knapps Creek.
- Walton: A Piedmont Virginia lineage (Washington C. and Norvell E. Walton) settled in Lobelia, Bruffey's Creek, and the Little Levels as stock farmers.
- Withers: An English Virginia line settled in Edray, Marlinton, and Huntersville, related historiographically to Chronicles of Border Warfare author Alexander Scott Withers.
- Wooddell: An Ulster Scot line founded by Revolutionary War veteran Joseph Wooddell, J.P., an original 1822 county magistrate who settled Deer Creek and Green Bank.
- Yeager (Jäger): A German Palatine line founded by John Yeager, Sr.. They established the famous Travelers Repose inn and stage stop at Bartow on the Staunton & Parkersburg Turnpike.
📜 Would you like me to compile a structured genealogical report comparing the migration paths or intermarriages of specific families?
I have compiled a comprehensive genealogical report titled Comparative Genealogical Analysis of Pocahontas County Families: Migration Corridors, Settlement Patterns, and Kinship Networks. The report synthesizes the migration routes, micro-regional geographic concentrations, and multi-generational intermarriage networks across all forty-nine pioneer surnames documented in your sources. It also includes an ethno-cultural breakdown, an examination of early civic leadership and frontier defense, and a comparative analytical matrix detailing each family's origins, pathways, and historical roles.
------------------------------------------------
Comparative Genealogical Analysis of Pocahontas County Families: Migration Corridors, Settlement Patterns, and Kinship Networks
The settlement history of Pocahontas County, West Virginia—established by an act of the Virginia General Assembly in December 1821 from portions of Bath, Pendleton, and Randolph counties—presents a compelling case study in Appalachian demographic formation. Nestled within the Allegheny Highlands and drained by the upper Greenbrier River, the Elk River, and Knapps Creek, the region served as a strategic nexus for distinct pioneer migration streams during the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries. Euro-American settlement was shaped by geographic contours, agricultural adaptations to karst sinkhole plateaus and high-elevation river bottoms, and the construction of turnpikes such as the Staunton and Parkersburg Turnpike and the Warm Springs routes.
Rather than settling in isolation, early households formed complex kin-based webs. Marriage alliances functioned as social and economic contracts, consolidating thousands of acres of bluegrass pasture, establishing cooperative milling seats, securing turnpike transport corridors, and founding early civic and religious institutions. This report provides an analytical synthesis of the major pioneer families of Pocahontas County, tracing their transatlantic origins, domestic migration corridors, geographic concentration within local watersheds, and multi-generational intermarriages.
1. Ethno-Regional Migration Corridors and Pioneer Origins
The early population of Pocahontas County originated primarily from three major migration waves moving down the Great Wagon Road through the Shenandoah Valley and across the Allegheny Front, alongside smaller specialized continental and colonial streams.
Transatlantic to Trans-Allegheny Settlement Flow
- Transatlantic and Colonial Roots:
- German Palatinate and Swiss: Originating in the Rhenish Palatinate and Upper Rhine Valley.
- Ulster (Northern Ireland): Originating among Scottish Covenanters in Ulster.
- English and Tidewater Virginia: Originating in the Eastern Shore, Essex, Stafford, and Fauquier counties.
- The Great Wagon Road Corridor:
- Movement from Pennsylvania ports (Lancaster and Berks counties) southward through Maryland into the Shenandoah Valley and the South Branch of the Potomac.
- Trans-Allegheny Frontier Crossing (1770s–1810s):
- Passage through parent Virginia counties: Augusta to Botetourt, Greenbrier, Bath, Pendleton, and Randolph.
- Pocahontas County Settlement Basins:
- Establishment in four micro-regions: Upper Greenbrier & Deer Creek, Central & Knapps Creek, Upper Elk River, and the Little Levels.
The German Palatine and Swiss-German Migration Stream
A major demographic pillar of northern Pocahontas County comprised families of Palatine German and Swiss-German Protestant descent. Fleeing religious conflict and economic devastation in the Upper Rhine Valley during the early eighteenth century, these families arrived through the Port of Philadelphia and settled initially in southeastern Pennsylvania (Lancaster, Berks, and Philadelphia counties). Pushing southward through Maryland into the Shenandoah Valley, they established secondary anchors in the South Branch of the Potomac and Crabbottom (Blue Grass) basins of Augusta, Rockingham, Pendleton, and Highland counties before crossing the Allegheny divide into the upper Greenbrier and Deer Creek valleys.
As documented in regional church registers, land patents, and Oren F. Morton's historical surveys, these families brought specialized highland farming practices, timber joinery, and mechanical trades. Their surnames were frequently phoneticized by English-speaking county clerks:
- Arbogast: Descended from Michael Arbogast (c. 1734–1812), who arrived in Philadelphia from the Upper Rhine and settled in Crabbottom by the 1760s. His sons Adam (a Revolutionary War scout), David, and John pushed into the upper Greenbrier and Deer Creek in the 1780s, clearing the high valley that became Arbovale ("Arbogast's Vale").
- Burner (Berner / Börner): Originating from Massanutten on the South Fork of the Shenandoah River, brothers Abraham and Daniel Burner settled at the forks of the Greenbrier in the late 1790s, establishing the wayside seat of Travelers Repose (Bartow) and Burner Mountain.
- Buzzard (Bossert / Boshart): Traced from Heinrich Bossert and Eva Elizabeth Alt of Pendleton County. Patriarch Reuben Rudolph Buzzard (c. 1772–1842) patented extensive bottomlands on Sitlington Creek near Dunmore around 1800.
- Carpenter (Zimmermann): Descended from Swiss/Palatine long hunter Jeremiah Carpenter and his kin along the Jackson and Greenbrier rivers, establishing branches on Deer Creek and Thomas Creek.
- Cutlip (Gottlieb / Guttlieb): Originating from Palatine immigrant George Gottlieb, Sr. (c. 1725–1785), whose sons settled along Stamping Creek, Mill Point, and Lobelia.
- Halterman (Haltermann / Haldiman): Migrated from the South Branch Potomac and Crabbottom to Deer Creek, Arbovale, and Back Mountain as cool-climate livestock farmers and blacksmiths.
- Hull (Hohl / Holl): Ancestral line of Peter Thomas Hull (arrived 1742), whose son Major Peter Hull acquired vast land warrants across Highland and northern Pocahontas.
- Peck (Böck / Pek): Traced from Garret (Gerhardt) Peck (c. 1750–1810) of Pendleton County, whose children crossed into Clover Lick and Green Bank.
- Pence (Bentz): Descended from Valentine Bentz of Rockingham County; patriarch John Pence settled on Knapps Creek prior to 1821 as a master blacksmith and landholder.
- Sheets (Schütz): Meaning "marksman," this Palatine family cleared high pastures along Deer Creek and Back Mountain, renowned for marksmanship and mountain scouting.
- Shinaberry (Schönberger): German line founded by Jacob and John Shinaberry, whose descendants anchored agricultural and timber holdings around Clover Lick, Green Bank, and Cass.
- Varner (Werner): Traced from Adam Varner of Pendleton County; settled by John Varner at Linwood/Slatyfork and Rev. John Varner on the "Top of Allegheny."
- Wagner (Waggoner): German cartwright line settled near Crab Bottom/Huntersville (Solomon Waggoner) and Huntersville (George Wagner).
- Yeager (Jäger / Jaeger): Descended from John Yeager, Sr. (c. 1750–1833), who cleared the junction of the Greenbrier forks around 1795 and established the celebrated Travelers Repose inn at Bartow.
The Ulster Scot (Scotch-Irish) Frontier Stream
The largest single cultural group in southern and central Pocahontas County comprised Scotch-Irish Presbyterians originating from Ulster (Northern Ireland). Descended from seventeenth-century Lowland Scottish Covenanter migrants, they arrived in Pennsylvania and Delaware during the great migration waves of the 1730s and 1740s. Moving down the Great Wagon Road into Augusta County, Virginia, they settled the Great Calfpasture and Bullpasture river basins before pushing across the mountains into the Little Levels, Swago Creek, and Edray.
As chronicled by Rev. William T. Price in Historical Sketches of Pocahontas County, these families established Presbyterian meetinghouses (such as Oak Grove near Hillsboro), cleared vast limestone bluegrass boundaries for commercial cattle droving, and led early military and civil affairs:
- Beard: Founded by John Beard, Sr. in the 1770s at Mill Point and the Little Levels, establishing early gristmills, bluegrass stock farms, and Hillsboro Academy.
- Boggs: Ulster Scot line of Francis Boggs, Sr.; settled across Mill Point, the Little Levels, and Edray, supplying early county magistrates and land processioners.
- Burnside: Settled by John and James Burnside on the upper Elk River (Slaty Fork, Old Field Fork) and Edray, operating extensive high-altitude livestock boundaries with the Hannah family.
- Cochran: Founded by John Cochran, Sr. in the late 1770s along the Greenbrier River, Edray, and Buckeye, establishing sawmills and early magistrate benches.
- Curry: Ulster Scot line of magistrate John Curry, Esq. and County Clerk William Curry, whose family preserved forty years of county public records during the Civil War.
- Gibson: Early Augusta Presbyterian line (Tinkling Spring Church) settled by John Gibson along Stony Creek, Edray, and Slaty Fork.
- Givens (Given): Ulster Scot line from Augusta County settled along Slaty Fork, Old Field Fork, and Edray, forming a vital link to Webster and Braxton counties.
- Graham: Descended from Christopher Graham of the Calfpasture River; Col. James Graham and brothers settled the Little Levels and Droop Mountain, co-founding Hillsboro Academy.
- Hamilton: Founded by William Hamilton in the 1770s along Swago Creek and Buckeye; active in Revolutionary border defense and road construction.
- Hannah: Ulster Scot line led by pioneer botanical physician David Hannah, Sr. (c. 1745–1826) and sons Joseph and David Jr., who patented thousands of acres along Slaty Fork and Old Field Fork of Elk River.
- Lockridge: Ulster Scot line from the Great Calfpasture; Lancelot "Lanty" Lockridge established a prominent plantation on Knapps Creek near Minnehaha Springs around 1802.
- McClure: Descended from Arthur McClure, Sr. (c. 1725–1800); Arthur Jr. settled Locust Creek and Droop Mountain, operating early sash sawmills.
- Slaven: Ulster Scot family of John Slaven, Sr. (from County Tyrone); John Jr. married Elizabeth Warwick and settled Meadow Creek and Deer Creek.
- Stewart / Stuart: Encompassed lower-county Stuarts (Col. John Stuart's early land grants) and upper-county Stewarts (John Andrew Stewart at Linwood).
- Wooddell: Founded by Revolutionary War veteran Joseph Wooddell, J.P., an inaugural 1822 justice who settled Deer Creek and Green Bank.
English and Tidewater Virginia Lineages
A distinct third stream comprised English families originating from Tidewater and Piedmont Virginia or the Eastern Shore, moving westward through Bath County:
- Baxter: English/Scotch-Irish family originating along Back Creek; Col. John Morgan Baxter served as inaugural militia colonel in 1822, while William Baxter established an estate at Edray.
- Gatewood: Tidewater planter line tracing to John Gatewood (c. 1654–1706) of Essex County. Samuel Vance Gatewood and Col. A.C.L. Gatewood maintained vast estates at Mountain Grove and Linwood.
- Nottingham: Traced to Richard Nottingham (c. 1620–1692) of Northampton County on the Eastern Shore; William Nottingham, Esq. settled Deer Creek in the 1790s, serving as an inaugural magistrate.
- Rogers: English/Scotch-Irish line settled along Beaver Creek, Knapps Creek, and Huntersville as farmers, blacksmiths, and teamsters.
- Ryder (Rider): English and German line settled on Deer Creek, Arbovale, and Back Mountain as self-reliant mountain farmers and wheelwrights.
- Withers: English Virginia line from Stafford and Fauquier counties settled in Edray and Marlinton, historiographically tied to Chronicles of Border Warfare author Alexander Scott Withers.
French Huguenot and Dutch Lineages
- Dilley: French Huguenot family arriving via Maryland; brothers Martin and Henry Dilley settled around Huntersville, Knapps Creek, Thorny Creek, and Cummings Creek as master blacksmiths and mechanics.
- Snedegar (Snedeker): Dutch lineage tracing to Jan Louwe van Snedeker (c. 1608–1679) of New Amsterdam and Flatbush, Long Island; settled atop Droop Mountain and Lobelia, namesakes of Snedegar Cave.
- Tallman: Lineage connecting early Rhode Island and Pennsylvania Quaker lines with Lincoln and Boone family ancestry. Patriarch James Boone Tallman (son of Benjamin Tallman and Dinah Boone) served as an inaugural 1822 justice on the upper Greenbrier and Deer Creek.
2. Micro-Regional Settlement Basins and Topographic Adaptation
The physical geography of Pocahontas County dictated early land utilization, economic focus, and spatial distribution of pioneer surnames across four distinct micro-regions.
Geographic Distribution Across County Watersheds
- Upper Greenbrier and Deer Creek Basin (Green Bank, Arbovale, Dunmore, Cass, Durbin, Bartow):
- Elevational Range: 2,400 to 3,000 feet.
- Agricultural Focus: Cool-climate rye and buckwheat, mountain sheep and cattle grazing, timber milling, turnpike inns.
- Key Surnames: Arbogast, Burner, Buzzard, Halterman, Hull, Gum, Peck, Sheets, Shinaberry, Yeager, Slaven, Wooddell, Nottingham, Tallman, Riley.
- Central, Edray, and Knapps Creek Basin (Huntersville, Marlinton, Buckeye, Edray, Minnehaha Springs):
- Elevational Range: 2,100 to 2,500 feet.
- Agricultural Focus: Rich river bottomland corn and wheat farming, county administration, trade, blacksmithing.
- Key Surnames: Baxter, Brown, Burgess, Cochran, Curry, Dilley, Gatewood, Hamilton, Lockridge, Pence, Rogers, Wagner, Withers.
- Upper Elk River High Grazing Plateau (Slaty Fork, Old Field Fork, Linwood):
- Elevational Range: 2,500 to 3,500 feet.
- Agricultural Focus: High-altitude mountain bluegrass sod, summer cattle pasture, commercial livestock droving.
- Key Surnames: Burnside, Gibson, Givens, Hannah, Stewart, Varner.
- Little Levels, Droop Mountain, and Lobelia Basin (Hillsboro, Mill Point, Academy, Seebert, Lobelia):
- Elevational Range: 2,200 to 3,100 feet.
- Agricultural Focus: Karst limestone sinkhole pastures, commercial beef cattle breeding, classical academies, gristmills.
- Key Surnames: Beard, Boggs, Bridger, Bruffey, Cutlip, Graham, Hill, Jordan, McClure, Snedegar, Walton.
3. Strategic Kinship Networks and Intermarriage Alliances
In frontier Pocahontas County, intermarriages were critical mechanisms for consolidating land boundaries, managing turnpike infrastructure, uniting milling and blacksmithing operations, and establishing civic hegemony. Three major regional intermarriage networks emerged across the county.
Network 1: The Northern Turnpike and Upper Greenbrier Alliance
In the Green Bank and Bartow districts, early German and Scotch-Irish families formed interlocking matrimonial networks centered around stage stop hospitality along the Staunton and Parkersburg Turnpike, milling on Deer Creek, and timber boundaries on Back Mountain.
As recorded in Pocahontas deed and marriage registers, key matrimonial links included:
- Yeager – Arbogast – Burner – Hull: Margaret Arbogast married John Yeager, Jr.; Moses Arbogast married Elizabeth Yeager; Benjamin Arbogast married Rachel Yeager. Elizabeth Arbogast married George Burner (1788–1861). Andrew Yeager married Elizabeth Burner. Mary "Molly" Hull married Abraham Burner (c. 1760–1827), co-founding Travelers Repose.
- Slaven – Warwick – Tallman – Wooddell: John Slaven, Jr. married Elizabeth Warwick (daughter of pioneer William Warwick of Clover Lick). Reuben Slaven married Rebecca Ann Tallman (daughter of Magistrate James Boone Tallman). William Slaven married Margaret Wooddell (daughter of Magistrate Joseph Wooddell). John Wooddell married Mary Slaven. Col. Benjamin ("Benny") Tallman married Elizabeth Warwick.
- Shinaberry – Peck – Buzzard: Peter Shinaberry (1802–1881) married Christina Peck (daughter of John Peck and Elizabeth Beverage), uniting German lines across Clover Lick and Sitlington Creek.
- Gatewood – Yeager – Warwick: Col. A.C.L. Gatewood married Mary Skillern Warwick of Clover Lick; two of Col. Gatewood's sons (William Beale Gatewood and Andrew Warwick Gatewood) married Yeager sisters (Goldie and Brownie Yeager).
Network 2: The Central District and Upper Elk Grazing Network
Across Edray, Indian Draft, Stony Creek, and the Upper Elk River, Scotch-Irish families established multi-generational cattle-droving and milling partnerships:
Key matrimonial links included:
- Hannah – Burnside: Dual marriage alliance: Elizabeth Burnside married Joseph Hannah (1805); Margaret Burnside married David Hannah, Jr. (1815). Together they held thousands of contiguous grazing acres on the upper Elk River.
- Hannah – Gibson – Cochran: Pioneer physician David Hannah, Sr. married Elizabeth Gibson. James Cochran married Nancy Hannah. David Hannah III married Sarah McClure.
- Brown – Friel – Waddell – Poage: Joseph Brown married Hannah McAfferty; son Josiah Brown married Jennie Waddell of Mill Point. Anna Brown married pioneer Jeremiah Friel (veteran of Point Pleasant under Jacob Warwick). Jennie Brown married John Friel; Mary Brown married Rankin Poage.
- Varner – Stewart – Hannah: John Varner married Isabella Hannah (daughter of David Hannah); their daughter Alice Belle ("Allie") Varner married John Andrew Stewart in 1879.
Network 3: The Southern Little Levels, Droop Mountain, and Knapps Creek Network
In the southern limestone basin around Hillsboro, Mill Point, and Knapps Creek, elite landholding families intermarried to sustain pastoral bluegrass estates and municipal governance:
Key matrimonial links included:
- Hill – McNeel – Bruffey – Poage: Frontiersman Richard Hill married Nancy McNeel (daughter of pioneer John McNeel, Sr.) around 1787. Son Col. John Hill (who platted Hillsboro in 1843) married Elizabeth Poague. Elizabeth Hill married John Bruffey, Jr. of Bruffey's Creek.
- Jordan – McNeel – Callison – Beard: Immigrant tailor John Jordan (first High Sheriff in 1822) married Miriam McNeel. Their children intermarried with the Callison, Edmiston, Beard, and Hill families.
- Lockridge – Benson – McNeel – Slaven: Lancelot "Lanty" Lockridge married Elizabeth Benson (1802); daughter Harriet Lockridge married into the McNeel family, while Eleanor Lockridge married into the Slaven family.
- Curry – Gatewood – Warwick: County Clerk William Curry married Lucinda E. Gatewood, uniting civil record keepers with Tidewater-descended stock breeders.
- Walton – Snedegar: Norvell E. Walton of Lobelia married Ellen Elizabeth Snedegar (1880–1980) of Droop Mountain in 1907, connecting prominent farming lines across the southern karst plain.
4. Civic Leadership, Frontier Defense, and Public Record Preservation
Beyond agriculture, the pioneer families of Pocahontas County established civil governance and military defense.
Frontier Defense and Revolutionary War Service
Living on the western border during Lord Dunmore's War (1774) and the American Revolution, pioneer heads of household served as Indian scouts, rangers, and militia officers garrisoning Fort Greenbrier and Fort Donnally:
- Battle of Point Pleasant (1774): Participated in by Major Andrew Lockridge (who commanded garrison troops), Jeremiah Friel, and Jeremiah Carpenter.
- Revolutionary War Pensioners & Scouts: Adam Arbogast dictated his pension declaration (S.8037) before the Pocahontas Court in 1832 detailing border scouting; Joseph Wooddell, J.P. served under Capt. John Givens; Richard Hill served under Capt. George Clendennin; John Burgess, Sr. and William Hamilton served in frontier defense.
The Inaugural County Court of March 1822
When Pocahontas County convened its first court at the home of John Bradshaw in Huntersville on March 5, 1822, key patriarchs took leadership roles:
- First High Sheriff: John Jordan, with Abraham and Isaac McNeel posting his $30,000 bond.
- First Militia Colonel (127th Virginia Militia): Col. John Morgan Baxter.
- First County Clerk: Josiah Beard.
- Inaugural Magistrates / Justices of the Peace: Francis Boggs, Jr., John Boggs, John Curry, Esq., William Nottingham, Esq., James Boone Tallman, Benjamin Tallman, Joseph Wooddell, J.P., and John Shinaberry, J.P.
Wartime Preservation of County Archives (1861–1865)
During the Civil War, Pocahontas County witnessed severe conflict, including the Battle of Huntersville (Jan. 1862), Battle of Greenbrier River (Camp Bartow, Oct. 1861), and Battle of Droop Mountain (Nov. 1863).
In late 1861, as Federal raids threatened Huntersville, County Clerk William Curry, assisted by youth Richard W. Hill (grandson of Richard Hill), evacuated forty years of county deed, probate, and marriage books. For four years, through ten clandestine mountain transfers, the records were concealed in remote caves and private cellars, including the home of Joel Hill near Hillsboro. In 1865, Clerk Curry returned every volume intact, making Pocahontas one of the few regional mountain counties with undamaged antebellum archives.
5. Comparative Analytical Matrix of Pocahontas County Surnames
The following matrix synthesizes the ethno-cultural origins, primary migration paths, geographic strongholds, and key historical contributions of all forty-nine surnames documented in the notebook sources.
Surname | Ethno-Cultural Origin | Primary Virginia Migration Path | Primary Pocahontas Geographic Basin | Historic Civic & Economic Roles |
Arbogast | Palatine German | Lancaster PA -> Shenandoah -> Crabbottom | Upper Greenbrier, Deer Creek, Arbovale | Rev. War scouting (Adam), founding Arbovale, stage stops |
Baxter | English / Scotch-Irish | Rockbridge & Bath Co. -> Back Creek | Edray, Anthony's Creek, Huntersville | First Militia Colonel (1822), agricultural estates |
Beard | Ulster Scot | Lancaster PA -> Augusta Co. -> Little Levels | Mill Point, Hillsboro, Academy | Milling at Mill Point, Hillsboro Academy, Presbyterian elders |
Boggs | Ulster Scot | PA -> Shenandoah -> Upper Greenbrier | Little Levels, Mill Point, Edray | Inaugural Justices (1822), county surveyors, droving |
Bridger | English / Scotch-Irish | Augusta & Bath Co. -> Swago Creek | Buckeye, Greenbrier River bottomlands | Early pioneer settlement (1770s), Shawnee raid tragedy |
Brown | Ulster Scot | Bath Co. (Bullpasture) -> Greenbrier River | Edray, Indian Draft, Buckeye | Frontier homesteading, Edray community development |
Bruffey | British / Ulster | Bath & Greenbrier Co. -> Bruffey's Creek | Bruffey's Creek, Droop Mtn, Lobelia | Namesakes of Bruffey's Sinks, Civil War memoirs (Capt. Geo. W.) |
Burgess | Irish (via New York) | Albany NY -> Rockingham Co. -> Greenbrier | Edray, Marlinton, Onoto, Woodrow | Mountain farming, timbering, trade networks |
Burner | Swiss-German (Berner) | Massanutten (Shenandoah) -> Pendleton | Travelers Repose (Bartow), Durbin, Burner | Founding Travelers Repose, turnpikes, Burner townsite |
Burnside | Ulster Scot | Augusta Co. -> Upper Elk River | Slaty Fork, Old Field Fork, Edray | High-altitude livestock droving, Hannah land partnership |
Buzzard | Palatine German (Bossert) | Lancaster PA -> Pendleton Co. (South Branch) | Sitlington Creek, Dunmore, Frost | Milling on Sitlington Creek, early county sheriff (J.H.) |
Carpenter | Swiss-German (Zimmermann) | Jackson River / Alleghany -> Deer Creek | Deer Creek (Green Bank), Thomas Creek | Frontier scouting (Jeremiah), Dunmore settlements |
Cochran | Ulster Scot | Augusta Co. -> Central Valley | Edray, Buckeye, Stony Creek | Early grist/sawmilling, magistrate bench, stock droving |
Curry | Ulster Scot | Augusta & Bath Co. -> Back Creek | Huntersville, Knapps Creek, Minnehaha | Saved county public records (William Curry), magistrate bench |
Cutlip | Palatine German (Gottlieb) | Shenandoah -> Bath / Greenbrier border | Stamping Creek, Mill Point, Lobelia | Mountain farming, timbering, western migration lines |
Dilley | French Huguenot | Maryland -> Bath Co. -> Huntersville | Huntersville, Knapps Creek, Thorny Creek | Master blacksmithing, mechanical trades, Thorny Creek mills |
Gatewood | Tidewater Virginia English | Essex Co. -> Bath Co. (Mountain Grove) | Linwood, Big Spring, Mountain Grove | VMI cadet/cavalry officer (Col. A.C.L.), thoroughbred breeding |
Gibson | Ulster Scot | Augusta Co. (Tinkling Spring) -> Greenbrier | Edray, Stony Creek, Slaty Fork | Frontier scouting, Stony Creek agricultural estates |
Givens | Ulster Scot | Augusta Co. -> Upper Elk River | Slaty Fork, Old Field Fork, Edray | High mountain cattle grazing, turnpike construction |
Graham | Scottish Clan Graham | Calfpasture River (Augusta) -> Little Levels | Little Levels, Hillsboro, Droop Mtn | Graham's Fort defense, Hillsboro Academy charterers |
Gum | Palatine German / English | Rockingham -> Pendleton (Bullpasture) | Deer Creek, Dunmore, Arbovale, Green Bank | Livestock breeding, Deer Creek mills, Radio Quiet Zone lands |
Halterman | Palatine German | Pendleton Co. (South Branch) -> Crabbottom | Green Bank, Deer Creek, Arbovale | Cool-climate stock farming, blacksmithing, Civil War service |
Hamilton | Ulster Scot | Augusta & Bath Co. -> Swago Creek | Swago Creek, Buckeye, Greenbrier River | Rev. War Indian ranger (William), Swago homesteading |
Hannah | Ulster Scot | Greenbrier Co. tax rolls (1782) -> Elk River | Slaty Fork, Old Field Fork, Locust Creek | First botanical physician (David Sr.), vast Elk River patents |
Hill | North Carolina English | Greenbrier Valley -> Hills Creek | Hillsboro, Hills Creek, Lobelia | Platted Hillsboro (Col. John), protected county records |
Hull | Palatine German (Hohl) | Augusta / Pendleton / Highland Co. | Travelers Repose, Green Bank, Dunmore | Major land warrants (Maj. Peter), Burner alliance at Bartow |
Jordan | Ulster Scot (Irish native) | Bath Co. -> Little Levels (Locust) | Little Levels, Hillsboro, Locust | First High Sheriff of Pocahontas (1822), Oak Grove elder |
Kelly | Irish (Antebellum & Post-Famine) | Bath Co. & Direct from Co. Cork, Ireland | Green Bank, Dunmore, Deer Creek | Agrarian workforce, Dunmore/Green Bank business |
Lockridge | Ulster Scot | Great Calfpasture River (Augusta) -> Knapps | Knapps Creek, Minnehaha Springs | Battle of Point Pleasant (Maj. Andrew), Knapps Creek estate |
McClure | Ulster Scot | Augusta Co. -> Greenbrier / Locust Creek | Locust Creek, Droop Mountain, Hillsboro | Rev. War patriot (Arthur Sr.), Locust Creek sash sawmills |
Nottingham | English (Eastern Shore VA) | Northampton Co. -> Bath Co. -> Deer Creek | Deer Creek, Dunmore, Green Bank | Inaugural Justice (1822), Wesley Chapel Methodism, clerks |
Peck | Palatine German (Böck) | Pendleton Co. (Crab Run) -> Clover Lick | Green Bank, Clover Lick, Sitlington | Mountain stock grazing, Shinaberry intermarriage bridge |
Pence | Palatine German (Bentz) | Rockingham Co. (Peaked Mtn) -> Bath Co. | Huntersville, Knapps Creek | Master blacksmithing, Huntersville town development |
Riley | Irish / Ulster Scot | Shenandoah Valley -> Green Bank | Green Bank, Arbovale, Bartow | Slaven & Arbogast alliances, turnpike trade, Cass timber |
Rogers | Ulster Scot / English | Augusta & Bath Co. -> Beaver Creek | Beaver Creek, Huntersville, Knapps Creek | Blacksmithing, teamstering, C&O railroad growth |
Ryder | English / Palatine German | Bath & Highland Co. -> Deer Creek | Deer Creek, Arbovale, Back Mountain | Self-reliant mountain farming, wheelwrighting, roads |
Sheets | Palatine German (Schütz) | Pendleton / Highland Co. -> Deer Creek | Deer Creek, Arbovale, Back Mountain | Expert marksmanship, carpentry, Green Bank Observatory lands |
Shinaberry | Palatine German (Schönberger) | Pendleton & Randolph Co. -> Clover Lick | Clover Lick, Green Bank, Cass | Inaugural Justice (John), Cass timber & NRAO support |
Slaven | Ulster Scot (Co. Tyrone) | Augusta Co. -> Meadow Creek / Deer Creek | Green Bank, Deer Creek, Back Allegheny | Clover Lick Warwick alliance, vast northern landholdings |
Snedegar | Dutch (van Snedeker) | New Amsterdam -> NJ -> Shenandoah Valley | Droop Mountain, Lobelia, Little Levels | Droop Mtn farming, Snedegar Cave / Friars Hole cave system |
Stewart | Scottish / Ulster Scot | Augusta & Bath Co. -> Linwood / Elk River | Linwood, Slatyfork, Edray, Marlinton | Varner alliance at Linwood, Stewart Chapel in Marlinton |
Tallman | German / English (Berks Co. PA) | Rockingham Co. -> Upper Greenbrier | Green Bank, Cass, Dunmore | Inaugural Justice (1822), Lincoln & Boone kin ties |
Varner | Palatine German (Werner) | Pendleton Co. (Brushy Fork) -> Linwood | Linwood, Slatyfork, Durbin, Back Mtn | Linwood homestead, pioneer Brethren ministry ("Top of Alleg.") |
Wagner | Palatine German (Waggoner) | Pendleton & Highland Co. -> Huntersville | Huntersville, Knapps Creek, Marlinton | Crab Bottom / Pocahontas stock trade, Huntersville merchant |
Walton | English (Piedmont Virginia) | Albemarle Co. -> Little Levels / Lobelia | Lobelia, Bruffey's Creek, Little Levels | Pastoral livestock farming, Bruffey's Sinks photography |
Withers | English (Northern Neck VA) | Fauquier & Culpeper Co. -> Central District | Edray, Marlinton, Huntersville | Central district farming, Chronicles of Border Warfare link |
Wooddell | Ulster Scot | Augusta Co. -> Deer Creek / Green Bank | Green Bank, Deer Creek, Arbovale | Inaugural Justice (1822), Rev. War veteran (Joseph Sr.) |
Yeager | Palatine German (Jäger) | Pendleton Co. -> Upper Greenbrier | Travelers Repose (Bartow), Green Bank | Founding Travelers Repose inn, turnpike crossroads seat |
6. Synthesis and Historical Implications
The genealogical landscape of Pocahontas County illustrates how geography, ethno-cultural traditions, and kinship networks intersected to shape Appalachian settlement.
First, the division between Palatine German families in the northern district (Deer Creek, Arbovale, Travelers Repose) and Ulster Scot families in the southern district (Little Levels, Hillsboro, Mill Point) reflected distinct agricultural traditions. German families adapted to cool-climate mountain benches through buckwheat farming, heavy timber joinery, and specialized trades, while Ulster Scot families utilized natural limestone sinkhole plains for large-scale bluegrass cattle droving and classical preparatory education.
Second, strategic intermarriages served as the primary mechanism for regional stability. Alliances between turnpike innkeepers (Yeager–Burner–Hull), central grazing partners (Hannah–Burnside–Gibson–Cochran), and southern landholding gentry (Beard–McNeel–Hill–Graham) consolidated acreage, reduced boundary litigation, and ensured cooperative civil leadership.
Finally, the commitment to civic organization—demonstrated during the inaugural court of March 1822 and highlighted by the wartime preservation of forty years of public archives by Clerk William Curry and Richard W. Hill—enabled Pocahontas County to retain an intact historical record. This preserved legacy allows modern researchers to trace the continuous evolution of trans-Allegheny pioneer society.
