Leveraging Exemplars to Enhance Assessment Transparency and Student Success
I. Introduction: Demystifying Exemplars in Educational Assessment
The effective use of expert texts, commonly known as "exemplars" or "models," is a cornerstone of transparent assessment practices designed to illuminate the characteristics of successful student outcomes. Understanding their definition, purpose, and distinction from other assessment aids is crucial for educators seeking to enhance student learning and achievement.
A. Defining "Exemplars" or "Model Texts"
In educational assessment, exemplars are defined as "carefully chosen samples of student work which are used to illustrate dimensions of quality and clarify assessment expectations".1 This definition, frequently attributed to Carless & Chan (2017), underscores their primary function: to showcase varying degrees of quality and make the often-implicit expectations of assessors explicit to students. Exemplars can be sourced from authentic student work from previous cohorts or be constructed by teachers based on their experience with common student challenges and desired outcomes.3A critical distinction must be made between exemplars and "model answers".2 While a model answer might imply a singular, perfect response, potentially encouraging surface learning or direct imitation 5, exemplars serve as tools to help students "develop their ability to identify and understand different aspects of quality".2 They are not necessarily flawless but are selected to illustrate various performance levels and demonstrate how assessment criteria are met in practice.4 The fundamental purpose of exemplars is to illustrate these dimensions of quality, clarify assessment expectations for a specific task 1, and promote a deeper student understanding of the required skills, content, or knowledge.1 A key strength of exemplars lies in their ability to make the "tacit knowledge" of assessors—those unstated understandings and judgments about quality—more comprehensible to students.7 To be most effective, exemplars should align with or directly match the specific assessment task students are undertaking.2The value of exemplars extends beyond merely presenting a "good product." Their core utility lies in demystifying the process and reasoning that contribute to a high-quality outcome. This involves making explicit the often-unstated knowledge and evaluative frameworks that experts (instructors) use. Many educational sources emphasize that exemplars help students understand why a piece of work is considered good, not just what good work looks like.2 This implies a more profound cognitive engagement than simple replication. The dialogue, analysis, and reflection surrounding exemplars are therefore indispensable for unlocking this deeper understanding of quality.
B. The Core Purpose: Making Assessment Standards Transparent and Illustrating Success
The central aim of employing exemplars is to make assessment standards transparent by providing students with concrete illustrations of what different levels of quality look like in practice.2 This approach moves beyond relying solely on abstract descriptions of criteria or rubric statements, which students may find difficult to interpret.3 Exemplars effectively "show students rather than just tell them what is expected" 3, a method that students typically find more beneficial than standalone lists of criteria or rubrics.3Transparency in assessment, a broader pedagogical concept, involves clearly communicating to students the rationale behind learning particular course concepts and skills, and how educational activities and assessments are designed to facilitate that learning.11 Articulating how assessments will be graded—whether through detailed criteria, rubrics, or the provision of exemplars—is a fundamental component of this transparency.11 While explicitly stated criteria are one avenue to transparency, some argue that they alone cannot fully capture the tacit knowledge inherent in assessment.12 Exemplars play a crucial role in bridging this gap by making these implicit understandings more explicit and accessible.7
The emphasis on exemplars for fostering transparency signals a potential shift in assessment culture. Traditionally, assessment has often focused on the summative judgment of learning. However, the use of exemplars to clarify standards and demonstrate successful outcomes aligns more closely with assessment for learning. This formative approach empowers students by providing them with the tools to understand expectations from the outset, enabling them to take greater ownership of their learning journey and work more effectively towards achieving desired outcomes. This suggests that exemplars are not merely an assessment tool but can be a catalyst for a broader pedagogical shift towards more student-centered and developmental approaches to education.
II. The Pedagogical Power of Exemplars: Benefits for Student Learning
The integration of exemplars into educational practice offers a multitude of benefits that extend beyond simple clarification of tasks. These benefits touch upon cognitive understanding, metacognitive development, affective engagement, and ultimately, academic performance.
A. Clarifying Expectations and Understanding Quality
A common challenge for students is deciphering abstract assessment criteria and forming a clear conception of what constitutes "quality" in a given academic task.9 Exemplars address this by providing tangible, concrete illustrations of work that meets varying levels of expectation.9 They allow students to "see what work that meets expectations looks like" 9 and, crucially, to understand why certain pieces of work are considered good or less effective.2 This understanding is fundamental if students are to produce high-quality assignments themselves.2 Furthermore, exemplars can effectively demonstrate the required style, layout, structure, and language conventions for specific academic genres, such as essays, reports, or presentations.4
B. Developing Student Self-Regulation and Metacognitive Skills
Exemplars are powerful tools for fostering self-regulation, a key competence for academic success. They help students develop the ability to make informed judgments about the quality of their own work and the work of others.9 This evaluative skill is a core component of self-regulated learning.9 By comparing their work-in-progress to exemplars representing different performance levels, students can more effectively self-monitor their learning, identify discrepancies between their current work and the desired standard, and pinpoint areas requiring improvement.13 Active engagement with exemplars, such as activities involving grading samples or discussing their inherent qualities, aids students in generating internal feedback and refining their understanding of expectations.14While some research has posited that overly detailed criteria might inadvertently hinder self-regulation by limiting students' autonomy in setting their own learning goals, a compelling counter-argument suggests that transparency, particularly as facilitated by exemplars, is essential for promoting students' self-regulatory capacity.12 The crucial factor appears to be the
manner in which exemplars are utilized—not as rigid templates to be copied, but as heuristic tools for understanding and internalizing standards.
C. Enhancing Assessment and Feedback Literacy
The use of exemplars, especially when coupled with explicit marking criteria and opportunities for discussion, significantly contributes to building student confidence and developing their assessment and feedback literacy.2 Students learn to "decode" the often-complex language of feedback comments 15 and gain a practical understanding of how assessment criteria are applied in real-world evaluations.2 Through exposure to and analysis of exemplars, students become more familiar with the specific terminology used in assessment criteria and begin to internalize the norms and conventions of academic discourse within their discipline.5
D. Boosting Student Confidence and Motivation
The clarity provided by exemplars can have a significant positive impact on students' affective domain. A clearer understanding of what is expected can reduce student anxiety surrounding assessment tasks 5 and build their confidence in their ability to meet those expectations.2 Presenting achievable examples, particularly those characterized as "good but not perfect," can promote self-efficacy and be particularly encouraging for students who may be anxious about their academic abilities.4 For instance, a study involving business management students revealed that access to exemplars provided them with the motivation to initiate their writing tasks and fostered a greater sense of confidence in their work.16 This affective support—reduced anxiety and increased confidence—can be a powerful precursor to enhanced cognitive engagement and improved academic performance. When students feel less apprehensive and more assured about the assessment landscape, they are more likely to engage deeply with the learning material, persist in the face of challenges, and ultimately achieve better outcomes.
E. Impact on Academic Performance: What the Research Says
The relationship between exemplar use and academic performance is a subject of ongoing investigation, with research yielding varied findings. Several studies indicate that the use of exemplars can lead to improvements in student performance and contribute to achieving better grades.7 For example, one study in medical education found that incorporating exemplars into tutorials resulted in enhanced academic performance among students.7However, the impact on marks is not universally guaranteed or straightforward. Some research reports no significant difference in academic performance between students who used exemplars and those who did not 17, or suggests that any improvement is heavily contingent on the specific methods of implementation.14 An integrative review of literature concluded that while students generally value exemplars as a learning tool, these positive perceptions do not always translate directly into improved academic grades.17 For instance, a study comparing the effects of teacher feedback versus annotated exemplars on middle school students' writing found similar improvements in the quality of revisions across both groups; however, the use of exemplars offered a notable advantage in terms of long-term teacher time savings.18 Another study involving radiography students who used fictitious, varied-quality exemplars found that while average marks saw a slight decrease, there was an improvement in student confidence and a substantial increase in the proportion of students attaining high marks (80% or more).20 This suggests that exemplars might be particularly beneficial for students aiming for higher levels of achievement.The variability in these research findings points towards an important consideration: the mere provision of exemplars is often insufficient to guarantee enhanced academic performance. The quality and depth of the pedagogical engagement surrounding the exemplars appear to be critical determinants of their ultimate impact on grades. The most significant positive effects on student learning and performance are typically observed when exemplars are used as part of an integrated pedagogical strategy that also includes clear rubrics, structured opportunities for student dialogue, and activities promoting peer and self-assessment.13 This suggests that exemplars are not passive instruments; their effectiveness is mediated by the active and thoughtful pedagogical strategies employed by educators. When students simply view an exemplar without engaging in active processing—such as analysis, discussion, or comparison with their own work—the potential cognitive and metacognitive benefits, like a deeper understanding of quality and enhanced self-regulation, may not fully translate into improved performance.
It is also worth noting that the process of selecting, annotating, and discussing exemplars can serve as a valuable diagnostic tool for instructors. By observing how students interact with exemplars and interpret criteria, educators can gain insights into common student misconceptions or areas where assessment standards are frequently misunderstood. This feedback loop can then inform future teaching practices and lead to the refinement of assignment instructions or rubrics, representing an indirect but significant benefit to instructional quality.
III. Crafting Effective Exemplars: Selection, Creation, and Annotation
The effectiveness of exemplars as pedagogical tools hinges on their careful selection, thoughtful creation (if not sourced from student work), and meticulous annotation. These processes require attention to authenticity, ethical considerations, variety, and the art of making learning visible.
A. Sourcing Exemplars
Educators have several options when sourcing exemplars, each with its own advantages and considerations.
Authentic Student Work: Examples drawn from previous students' submissions are often considered the most effective.2 These are perceived by current students as representing an achievable target because they were produced by peers under similar conditions.8 However, their use necessitates obtaining explicit student consent and ensuring thorough anonymization to protect privacy.2
Teacher-Constructed Examples: When authentic examples are unavailable, or if an instructor wishes to highlight specific common errors or particular facets of quality that may not be present in existing student work, teacher-constructed exemplars are a viable alternative.2 These can be carefully designed based on the instructor's extensive experience with typical student issues and the desired learning outcomes.3 For instance, one study successfully used fictitious essays themed around a "baking profession" to illustrate common academic writing pitfalls without the risk of students plagiarizing content directly applicable to their assignments.20
AI-Generated Texts as Exemplars: An emerging source for exemplars is text generated by Artificial Intelligence (AI) tools.2 These can be used to quickly produce examples, particularly for students to analyze and critique.9 However, this approach introduces new ethical considerations regarding the authenticity of such texts and the potential for inherent biases within AI algorithms.21 The use of AI-generated exemplars necessitates fostering critical AI literacy among both students and educators, enabling them to discern quality, identify potential biases, and understand the limitations of such tools.
B. Ethical Considerations: Consent and Anonymization
The ethical use of student work as exemplars is paramount.
Consent: The student author's explicit consent must be obtained before their work is used as an exemplar.2 Educational institutions may have specific consent forms and protocols for this purpose, requiring documented and stored permission.2
Anonymization: All names and any other personally identifiable information must be redacted from the exemplars to protect student privacy.3 This can be particularly challenging for non-text-based exemplars, such as video presentations, where complete anonymization is almost impossible.5 In such cases, or if full consent and anonymization are problematic, restricting access (e.g., not allowing students to take copies home) may be a necessary precaution.5 It is also important to consider that authentic assessments, from which exemplars might be derived, themselves involve ethical principles, such as respectful engagement with any community stakeholders involved in the assessment task.23
C. The Importance of Variety: Range of Quality and Multiple Examples
To maximize their pedagogical impact, exemplars should not be monolithic.
Range of Quality: Providing exemplars that span a range of grade bands or demonstrate different levels of quality (e.g., excellent, proficient, developing, or even "good but not perfect") is generally more effective than offering only "model" answers or examples of flawless work.2 This approach helps students to reflect on their own practice more effectively by seeing concrete examples of how criteria are met at various levels and understanding the continuum of quality.2 The deliberate use of "imperfect" exemplars, or those showcasing common errors 15, serves multiple pedagogical functions. It can lower the intimidation factor for students who feel that top-tier work is unattainable, encourage critical analysis (e.g., "What could make this exemplar better?"), and provide more relatable learning opportunities for a broader spectrum of students. Such exemplars are not just about illustrating lower bands of a rubric; they are active tools for teaching critical evaluation and self-correction, thereby making the pathway to success clearer for students who are not yet performing at the highest level.
Multiple Exemplars: Presenting students with multiple exemplars for the same task is highly recommended.10 This strategy demonstrates that there are often various valid ways to approach an assignment successfully and can effectively counter fears that exemplars might stifle creativity or lead to a single, formulaic response.3 This is particularly crucial for tasks where there isn't a single "correct" answer, and diverse, inventive responses are valued.4 Furthermore, students have reported that exemplars highlighting common problems are particularly helpful, serving as effective warnings and providing immediate guidance.15
D. The Art of Annotation: Making Learning Visible
Annotation transforms a static example into a dynamic learning tool by making explicit what is often implicit in expert judgment.
Purpose of Annotation: Annotations demystify the assessment process by clearly labeling strong rhetorical and cognitive features within the exemplar and explicitly showing how the work maps against the marking criteria.2 They make the expert's thinking processes visible, effectively apprenticing students into disciplinary ways of knowing and doing.24 This means annotations should be not merely evaluative ("This is good because...") but also procedural ("Here’s how the author achieved X, and why that’s effective in this discipline...").
Content of Annotations: Effective annotations should identify what the exemplar does well, how it meets specific criteria, and potentially, how it could be improved.2 They can highlight elements such as the clarity of the thesis, the organization of ideas, the development of arguments, the effective use of evidence, the precision of language, the maintenance of an appropriate tone, and the adherence to disciplinary conventions.24
Examples and Methods: Resources from institutions like the New Zealand Qualifications Authority (NZQA) for physics 25, McGill University for various disciplines 9, and California Polytechnic State University (CalPoly) Center for Teaching, Learning & Technology (CTLT) 24 provide excellent examples and guidelines for annotation. Methods of annotation can vary, including inserted comments in word-processing documents, digital sticky notes on PDFs, written comments on accompanying handouts, online annotations using social bookmarking tools (e.g., Diigo), or even oral commentary delivered via screencasts.24
The following table outlines key elements that educators might focus on when annotating exemplars, adapted from guidance such as that provided by CalPoly CTLT.24
Table 1: Key Elements to Annotate in Exemplars
By focusing on these elements, annotations can transform exemplars from mere samples into rich learning resources that actively guide students toward understanding and achieving academic success.
IV. Implementing Exemplars in Teaching and Assessment: Strategies for Success
The pedagogical value of exemplars is unlocked through thoughtful implementation. This involves strategic timing, integration with other assessment tools like rubrics, fostering active student engagement, and adapting their use across various educational contexts.
A. Timing the Introduction of Exemplars
The timing of when exemplars are introduced to students can significantly influence their impact. Many educational researchers and practitioners advocate for introducing exemplars after students have had an opportunity to engage with the assessment task themselves—perhaps by completing an initial draft, an outline, or at least by grappling with the requirements and formulating their own preliminary ideas.9 The rationale behind this approach is that students who have already attempted the task are better positioned to critically engage with the exemplars. They can compare the provided samples to their own work, more readily identify areas for improvement, and gain a deeper understanding of how to bridge any gaps.9 This timing can also foster greater creativity, as students will have had the chance to develop their own unique approaches before being exposed to other examples.13However, this does not preclude an earlier, more general introduction. Providing access to exemplars via a module website or learning management system from the beginning of a term can also be a valuable first step.2 In this capacity, exemplars can serve as general orientation tools, giving students an early sense of the overall expectations and the types of work valued in the course. The key distinction lies in the
nature of engagement: initial provision might serve as a broad "anchor" for understanding, while later, more focused interaction with exemplars, once students have their own work in progress, facilitates specific, comparative learning and refinement. The "sweet spot" for exemplar use likely involves both this early orientation and subsequent, deeper analytical engagement.
B. Integrating Exemplars with Rubrics
Exemplars and rubrics are complementary tools, and their combined use often yields the most significant pedagogical benefits.10 Rubrics, when used in isolation, may present criteria in an abstract manner that students find difficult to fully grasp; exemplars can bring these abstract descriptors to life.13
Clarifying Rubric Language: Exemplars make the language of rubrics—criteria and performance standards—more meaningful and concrete.3 Annotated samples of student work can directly exemplify what a "proficient" analysis or "emerging" use of evidence looks like in practice, as described in a rubric.6
Reciprocal Relationship: The relationship can be reciprocal. Students can use a provided rubric to analyze and grade exemplars, thereby deepening their understanding of both the rubric and the qualities of effective work. Alternatively, an activity could involve students analyzing a set of exemplars and then collaboratively co-constructing a rubric based on their observations and discussions.3 This active involvement in rubric development can lead to a more profound understanding and ownership of the assessment criteria.
C. Fostering Dialogue and Active Student Engagement
Simply providing students with access to exemplars is often insufficient for deep learning. Active student engagement through discussion, analysis, and reflection is crucial for unlocking their full potential.2
Structured Activities: Educators can design various activities to facilitate this engagement. For example, students can be asked to:
Apply marking criteria (from a rubric) to one or more exemplars, assign a grade or performance level, and draft constructive feedback, identifying strengths and areas for improvement.2
Match pre-written feedback comments to the relevant sections of different exemplars.2
Participate in whole-class or small-group discussions where they share their observations about exemplars, justify their conclusions about the quality of the work, and engage in constructive disagreement or debate about interpretations.7
Teacher Guidance: Teacher-guided analysis and mediation of student interpretations are vital, especially in helping students navigate ambiguities and understand the more nuanced aspects of quality.8
Promoting Ownership: Such dialogic approaches help students take ownership of the learning process. Instead of viewing exemplars as mere templates to be copied, they begin to see them as tools for understanding and internalizing standards, which they can then apply to their own work.13
D. Using Exemplars for Peer Review and Self-Assessment
Exemplars are invaluable resources for developing students' evaluative judgment, a skill essential for effective peer review and self-assessment.7
Peer Review Activities:
Exemplars can serve as a benchmark or reference point when students are tasked with reviewing and providing feedback on their peers' work.3
Conducting a "mock" peer review session using a carefully chosen sample paper (which functions as an exemplar) can be an effective way to teach students the principles of constructive feedback and how to apply assessment criteria.27 This process of analyzing how an exemplar meets (or fails to meet) criteria equips students with the critical faculties needed to assess a peer's work with discernment.
Self-Assessment Activities:
After analyzing and discussing exemplars, students can be guided to apply the same critical lens to a sample of their own work, identifying its strengths and areas needing development.2
Rubric-based self-assessment becomes more meaningful when students can compare their work not just to abstract descriptors but also to concrete exemplars that illustrate different performance levels.13
Tools like learning logs or reflective journals can incorporate prompts that encourage students to reflect on how their work compares to exemplars, especially when setting learning goals or planning revisions.29
E. Adapting Exemplar Use Across Disciplines and Levels
While the fundamental principles of using exemplars—such as promoting clarity, fostering dialogue, and developing self-regulation—are universally applicable, their specific manifestation and the nature of the exemplars themselves will vary significantly across educational levels and disciplines.
K-12 Education:
In early years, such as kindergarten, exemplars can be as simple as a teacher highlighting a student's work that effectively demonstrates a concept, like text-to-text connections. In one documented case, a teacher identified a student who grasped the concept and had that student share their thinking with the class, thereby using a live student explanation as an exemplar to redirect the lesson and clarify understanding for others.31
In elementary and middle school mathematics, platforms like the "Exemplars" library of problem-solving tasks are used. The Co-op School, for example, utilized such tasks along with rubrics to enhance student perseverance, critical thinking, and the ability to represent mathematical thinking in diverse ways, thereby creating a shared language around problem-solving within the school.32
For students with specific learning needs, such as autism, the principle of using multiple exemplars is key for teaching generalization. For instance, when teaching the concept of "apple," using flashcards with varied depictions (red, green, sliced, cartoon, photo) helps the student recognize the object in multiple contexts.33
Higher Education (General, STEM, Humanities):
General Higher Education: Exemplars are widely applicable for various assessment types, including traditional writing assignments, problem sets in quantitative courses, creative projects, and visual presentations like infographics.9
STEM Disciplines:
In Physics, MIT has used transparent assignment descriptions that function as exemplars for tasks like analyzing the structure of a research article.11 The NZQA provides extensively annotated physics exemplars for specific standards (e.g., AS91522), clearly illustrating different achievement levels and the reasoning behind them.25 The teachHOUSTON program features a physics education exemplar where mentoring is integrated with an inquiry-based course.34
In Medical Education (e.g., Biochemistry, Physiology), exemplars of short-answer questions (SAQs) from past examinations have been used in tutorials. These sessions involve discussions on analysis, scoring, characteristics of high-quality responses, and common misconceptions. Students also engage in grading ungraded exemplars and providing peer feedback on responses in an online environment.7
In Engineering, the concept of learning from past "exemplars" (successful designs) and failures is crucial in fields like building design, though it is sometimes overlooked in contemporary practice focused on new theoretical models.35 A case study explored the use of "design exemplar" technology as a CAD query tool in tire manufacturing to retrieve geometrically similar mold inserts, highlighting practical challenges in authoring complex real-world exemplars but ultimately validating the strategic approach.36 Problem sets and lab reports are common assessment types in STEM where exemplars can be highly effective.9
Humanities:
In History, universities provide guidance on writing historical essays, including example prompts (e.g., assessing FDR's New Deal) and advice on formulating a thesis and using evidence.38 Sample essays, sometimes categorized by achievement level (e.g., "college level" vs. "not college level"), are offered for subjects like philosophy (Hobbes), mythology, and art history.40 Annotated graduate school admission essays for history applicants also serve as powerful exemplars.41
Generally, exemplars are very common for writing assignments in the humanities.3 Institutions like King's College utilize past assignments, examination questions, and student presentations as exemplars, against which students apply assessment criteria to deepen their understanding.5
Online Learning Environments:
Exemplars can be effectively deployed in online settings. Studies have shown that online facilities allowing students to view exemplars and engage in discussions (e.g., via forums) are generally valued by students, although the direct impact on marks may depend on the facilitation of rich dialogue.15
A qualitative study focusing on an online exemplar-based class found that students perceived exemplars illustrating common problems as particularly beneficial.15
Hybrid approaches are also common, such as the medical education study where face-to-face exemplar discussions were followed by online peer assessment of SAQ responses.7
The common thread across these diverse applications is that the principles of using exemplars—clarifying expectations, fostering dialogue, promoting self-regulation—remain consistent. However, the manifestation of these principles, including what constitutes a "good" exemplar and which features are critical to annotate, will necessarily vary according to the specific epistemic and communicative conventions of each discipline and the developmental stage of the learners.
V. Navigating Challenges and Ensuring Ethical Use
While the pedagogical benefits of exemplars are significant, their implementation is not without challenges. Addressing concerns about creativity, student intimidation, and ethical use, particularly with emerging technologies like AI and the imperative for diversity and inclusion, is crucial for maximizing their positive impact.
A. Addressing Concerns: Stifling Creativity, Surface Learning, and Mimicking
A primary apprehension among educators is that providing exemplars might inadvertently lead students to simply copy or mimic the provided examples, thereby stifling their creativity, encouraging surface learning, or resulting in formulaic responses.8 This concern is valid if exemplars are presented as rigid templates rather than tools for understanding.
Mitigation Strategies:
Use Multiple and Varied Exemplars: Showcasing a range of successful approaches to the same task, including examples of different styles or structures, demonstrates that there is no single "right" way to achieve quality. This encourages students to find their own voice and approach.6
Strategic Timing: As discussed earlier, introducing exemplars after students have engaged with the task and developed their own initial ideas can preserve originality.13
Foster Dialogue: Engaging students in critical discussions about the exemplars—analyzing their strengths, weaknesses, and underlying principles—shifts the focus from surface features to deeper understanding and promotes student ownership of the learning process.8
"Good But Not Perfect" Exemplars: Using examples that are strong but still have identifiable areas for improvement encourages students to think critically rather than just emulate. It also makes high standards seem more attainable.3
Mirrored but Different Content: Provide exemplars for tasks that are structurally similar to the assessed task but differ in specific content (e.g., if the assignment is an analysis of one author's work, use an exemplar analyzing a different author in a similar style).3
Flexible Assignment Design: Designing assignments that allow students to pursue topics of personal interest or offer choices in format can inherently promote creativity.3
Explicitly Emphasize Originality: Clearly communicate to students that exemplars are for guidance and understanding, not for replication, and that originality and creative thought are valued.3
Focus on Emulation versus Imitation: A crucial conceptual shift involves guiding students towards emulation rather than imitation.42 Imitation implies copying actions to achieve the same ends. Emulation, conversely, involves understanding and adopting the underlying values, principles, or goals demonstrated by the exemplar, but finding one's own means and methods to achieve similar ends. This encourages students to adapt strategies to their own context and voice, fostering deeper learning and critical thinking. While particularly discussed in moral education 42, this distinction has broad applicability to all uses of exemplars. By teaching for emulation, educators help students extract transferable skills and principles, rather than merely replicating surface features.
B. Mitigating Student Intimidation and Ensuring Accessibility
Exposure to very high-quality exemplars can sometimes be counterproductive, leading some students to feel that such standards are unattainable, thereby causing intimidation or discouragement.3
Strategies:
Use Achievable Examples: Employing "good but not perfect" or "sound-standard" exemplars can boost student confidence by demonstrating that high quality is achievable and that improvement is a process.3
Avoid Over-reliance on "Perfect" Models: Refrain from using only "close to perfect" or exceptionally high-scoring exemplars, as these might represent unrealistic expectations for many students and could inadvertently discourage effort.6
Provide Scaffolding: Offer clear pathways and incremental steps to success, showing students how they can build towards the qualities demonstrated in the exemplars.44
Promote Self-Efficacy: The selection and presentation of exemplars should aim to promote students' belief in their own capabilities to learn and succeed.4
C. Ethical Use of AI in Generating and Analyzing Exemplars
The advent of sophisticated AI tools presents both opportunities and ethical challenges in the context of exemplars.
AI for Creation and Critique: AI language models can assist in generating draft exemplars, which educators can then refine.2 They can also produce texts specifically for students to analyze and critique, honing their evaluative skills.9
Ethical Concerns with AI:
Academic Integrity: The ease with which AI can generate essays, solve problems, or simulate answers poses a significant risk to academic integrity if students misuse these tools for their assignments.21 Clear institutional and course-level guidelines on the permissible uses of AI are essential.
Bias and Fairness: AI models are trained on vast datasets, which may contain inherent biases related to race, gender, or other characteristics. These biases can be reflected in the AI-generated content, potentially affecting the fairness of educational experiences if not critically addressed.21 Ensuring diverse training data for AI tools and conducting regular audits for bias are necessary mitigation measures.
Data Privacy and Security: The use of AI tools in education, especially those that process student data, raises concerns about data privacy and security that must be carefully managed.21
Informed Consent and Transparency: Students, parents, and educators should be fully informed about how AI tools are being used in the educational process, including their potential benefits and limitations.21 Transparency regarding AI algorithms, data sources, and decision-making processes is crucial.21
A proactive, rather than reactive, approach to the ethical integration of AI is necessary. This involves establishing clear guidelines before widespread adoption and educating both students and faculty on responsible and critical AI engagement. Instructors should engage in open discussions with students about the evolving nature of AI tools and collaboratively explore appropriate boundaries for their use in academic work.22
D. Ensuring Diversity and Inclusivity in Exemplar Selection
To create an equitable learning environment where all students feel valued and see pathways to success, the selection of exemplars must prioritize diversity and inclusivity.45 This is not merely about representation but is an active strategy to combat stereotypes, broaden students' understanding of who can succeed, and challenge dominant narratives within disciplines.
Strategies:
Re-evaluate and Diversify Materials: Actively seek out and incorporate exemplars from authors, creators, and thinkers representing a wide range of backgrounds, perspectives, and experiences. This means consciously moving beyond traditionally dominant narratives (e.g., those centered on Western, white, male perspectives).45
Represent Diverse Voices and Identities: Include examples that reflect different races, ethnicities, genders, sexual orientations, socio-economic statuses, cultures, religions, abilities, and other facets of human diversity.45
Use Representative Images and Names: When creating or contextualizing exemplars, use images and fictitious names in scenarios or problems that reflect this diversity.47
Highlight Marginalized Contributions: Where relevant, particularly when discussing the history or development of a field, use exemplars to showcase the often-overlooked contributions of individuals and groups who have been marginalized.47
Connect to Students' Lives: Make learning more contextual and relevant by choosing exemplars that resonate with the diverse experiences and backgrounds present in the classroom.48
Address Inequality and Bias: Be prepared to facilitate discussions about issues of inequality, bias, or power dynamics that may be reflected in, or absent from, the chosen exemplars.45 If students only see exemplars from a narrow demographic, it can reinforce stereotypes about who "belongs" or excels in a particular field. By intentionally showcasing diverse creators and perspectives, educators can actively challenge these implicit biases.
The following table summarizes key challenges associated with exemplar use and practical, evidence-based strategies for their mitigation.
Table 2: Strategies to Mitigate Common Challenges with Exemplars
By proactively addressing these challenges, educators can harness the full pedagogical power of exemplars in an ethical and effective manner.
VI. Conclusion and Recommendations for Practice
The use of exemplars, or model texts, stands as a potent pedagogical strategy for making assessment standards transparent and demonstrating the characteristics of successful student outcomes. When implemented thoughtfully, exemplars transcend their role as mere examples, becoming dynamic tools that foster deeper understanding, enhance student self-regulation, and promote a more equitable and supportive learning environment.
A. Synthesizing Key Insights on the Value of Exemplars
The evidence reviewed underscores the multifaceted benefits of exemplars. They provide crucial clarity on assessment expectations, helping students to understand not just what quality looks like, but why certain attributes contribute to success.1 This demystification of standards can significantly boost student confidence and reduce anxiety associated with assessment.5 Beyond clarifying expectations, exemplars are instrumental in developing students' metacognitive skills and their capacity for self-regulation. By engaging with exemplars—analyzing them, comparing them to their own work, and discussing their merits—students learn to make more accurate judgments about quality and to identify pathways for their own improvement.9Crucially, exemplars are most powerful when they are integrated into a pedagogy of active learning and dialogue, rather than being presented as passive models for imitation.7 Their use often signals and supports a shift from assessment
of learning, focused solely on grading, towards assessment for learning, where the primary goal is to guide and enhance student development. The process of selecting, annotating, and discussing exemplars is not a one-time setup but should be viewed as a continuous cycle of improvement, where educators reflect on student feedback and observed impacts to refine their approaches.
B. Actionable Recommendations for Educators and Institutions
To effectively leverage exemplars, both individual educators and educational institutions play vital roles.
For Educators:
Strategic Selection and Creation: Invest time in sourcing or creating a diverse range of exemplars, including those that illustrate different levels of quality and varied approaches to a task. Prioritize authentic student work where possible, always adhering to ethical protocols for consent and anonymization.2
Purposeful Annotation: Annotate exemplars meticulously to make tacit knowledge and expert thinking processes explicit. Focus annotations on how the exemplar meets (or does not meet) specific assessment criteria and why certain features are effective.24
Foster Active Engagement: Design learning activities that require students to actively engage with exemplars through analysis, discussion, peer review, and self-assessment. Move beyond passive viewing to active deconstruction and reconstruction of understanding.2
Integrate with Other Tools: Use exemplars in conjunction with rubrics, clear assignment guidelines, and constructive feedback to create a coherent assessment environment.9
Mindful Implementation: Be strategic about the timing of exemplar introduction, often after students have made an initial attempt at the task. Explicitly address concerns about mimicking and emphasize the goal of emulation and understanding underlying principles.13
Reflective Practice: Continuously solicit student feedback on the usefulness of exemplars and observe their impact on student learning and performance. Use these insights to refine your approach to exemplar selection and use over time.
For Institutions:
Professional Development: Provide ongoing professional development opportunities for faculty and teaching staff on the theory and practice of using exemplars effectively, including strategies for annotation, fostering dialogue, and ensuring inclusivity.49
Resource Development and Sharing: Support the creation and maintenance of shared banks of anonymized and consented exemplars, potentially organized by discipline or course level. This can reduce individual educator workload and promote consistency in quality.
Promote Collaborative Practice: Encourage cross-departmental and inter-faculty dialogue on best practices for using exemplars, allowing educators to learn from each other's experiences and innovations.
Establish Clear Ethical Guidelines: Develop and disseminate clear institutional policies regarding the ethical use of student work for teaching purposes, including robust consent procedures and data privacy protocols. Provide guidance on the ethical considerations of using AI-generated content in relation to exemplars.21
Foster a Culture of Assessment for Learning: Champion a broader institutional culture that views assessment primarily as a tool for learning and improvement, with exemplars playing a key role in making this philosophy tangible for students.
The following checklist offers a practical tool for educators and institutions to guide the planning, implementation, and refinement of exemplar use.
Table 3: Checklist for Effective Exemplar Implementation
C. Future Directions in Exemplar Research and Practice
While the existing body of research provides valuable guidance, several areas warrant further investigation to deepen our understanding and refine the use of exemplars:
Longitudinal Impact: More rigorous longitudinal studies are needed to assess the sustained impact of exemplar use on student learning, self-regulation, and academic achievement over time.51
Disciplinary and Contextual Nuances: Further research should explore the specific nuances of how exemplars are best utilized in diverse disciplines (particularly in STEM fields beyond writing-intensive tasks) and within various learning environments, including fully online and blended contexts.15
AI-Generated Exemplars: The cognitive and affective impacts of using AI-generated exemplars, both for students and educators, require careful study. This includes understanding how students perceive and interact with such exemplars and how to best leverage them for critical analysis.
Student Perspectives on Quality: Investigating how exposure to exemplars shapes or aligns with students' own evolving perspectives on academic quality could yield valuable insights for tailoring their use.53
Development of Non-Cognitive Skills: While some research touches upon "moral exemplars" (as individuals) influencing character 54, exploring how engagement with textual or performance exemplars might contribute to the development of other non-cognitive skills (e.g., perseverance, attention to detail, critical thinking dispositions) could be a fruitful avenue.
By embracing the principles outlined in this report and continuing to explore innovative and ethical applications, educators and institutions can harness the full potential of exemplars to not only make assessment standards transparent but also to empower students as confident, self-regulated, and successful learners.
Works cited
www.frontiersin.org, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/education/articles/10.3389/feduc.2018.00060/full#:~:text=1)%20define%20exemplars%20%E2%80%9Cas%20carefully,content%2C%20or%20knowledge%20in%20addition
Using exemplars : Assessment design - Staff Hub - University of Sussex, accessed May 7, 2025, https://staff.sussex.ac.uk/teaching/enhancement/support/assessment-design/exemplars
Using Exemplars in the Classroom | Office of Teaching and Learning | Utah Valley University, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.uvu.edu/otl/blog/exemplarsintheclassroom.html
lta.hw.ac.uk, accessed May 7, 2025, https://lta.hw.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/GUIDE-NO9_Exemplers.pdf
Exemplars – Assessment for Learning at King's - King's Blogs, accessed May 7, 2025, https://blogs.kcl.ac.uk/aflkings/exemplars/
Using Exemplars to Support Student Success with Assessments ..., accessed May 7, 2025, https://tlconestoga.ca/using-exemplars-to-support-student-success/
The use of exemplars and student discussion to improve performance in constructed-response assessments - PMC, accessed May 7, 2025, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6129159/
hub.hku.hk, accessed May 7, 2025, https://hub.hku.hk/bitstream/10722/287738/1/Content.pdf?accept=1
Use exemplars to clarify assessment expectations, accessed May 7, 2025, https://teachingkb.mcgill.ca/tlk/use-exemplars-to-clarify-assessment-expectations
How to use exemplars and rubrics to improve student outcomes ..., accessed May 7, 2025, https://researchoutreach.org/articles/exemplars-rubrics-improve-student-outcomes/
Transparency & Purpose - Teaching + Learning Lab - MIT, accessed May 7, 2025, https://tll.mit.edu/checklist-transparency-purpose/
Editorial: Transparency in Assessment—Exploring the Influence of Explicit Assessment Criteria - Frontiers, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/education/articles/10.3389/feduc.2018.00119/full
The Power of the Exemplar - Floop, accessed May 7, 2025, https://floopedu.com/the-power-of-the-exemplar/
(PDF) A systematic review of the educational uses and effects of ..., accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/356913868_A_systematic_review_of_the_educational_uses_and_effects_of_exemplars
From copying to learning: Using exemplars to engage students with ..., accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/241683445_From_copying_to_learning_Using_exemplars_to_engage_students_with_assessment_criteria_and_feedback
(PDF) Effectiveness of Assessment Exemplars in a Business Management Course - ResearchGate, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/383670379_Effectiveness_of_Assessment_Exemplars_in_a_Business_Management_Course
Students use of exemplars to support academic writing in higher ..., accessed May 7, 2025, https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29547812/
www.anastasiyalipnevich.com, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.anastasiyalipnevich.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/tf-v-ae.pdf
Students use of exemplars to support academic writing in higher education: An integrative review - University of Wollongong Research Online, accessed May 7, 2025, https://ro.uow.edu.au/articles/journal_contribution/Students_use_of_exemplars_to_support_academic_writing_in_higher_education_An_integrative_review/27744006
Half-baked essays: the embedded use of writing exemplars to ..., accessed May 7, 2025, https://journal.aldinhe.ac.uk/index.php/jldhe/article/view/1028
Generative AI in Education: The Impact, Ethical Considerations, and Use Cases - Litslink, accessed May 7, 2025, https://litslink.com/blog/generative-ai-in-education-the-impact-ethical-considerations-and-use-cases
Ethical use of AI in writing assignments | Center for Teaching Excellence, accessed May 7, 2025, https://cte.ku.edu/ethical-use-ai-writing-assignments
Using experiential learning and authentic assessments to support students to become competent health promotion practitioners - PMC - PubMed Central, accessed May 7, 2025, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9825918/
Annotating Exemplars - CTLT - Cal Poly, San Luis Obispo, accessed May 7, 2025, https://ctlt.calpoly.edu/annotating-exemplars
AS 91522 Annotated exemplars - NZQA, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www2.nzqa.govt.nz/ncea/subjects/past-exams-and-exemplars/physics/as-91522/
Peer and self-assessment for students - NSW Department of Education, accessed May 7, 2025, https://education.nsw.gov.au/teaching-and-learning/professional-learning/teacher-quality-and-accreditation/strong-start-great-teachers/refining-practice/peer-and-self-assessment-for-students
Planning and Guiding In-Class Peer Review - Center for Teaching and Learning, accessed May 7, 2025, https://ctl.wustl.edu/resources/planning-and-guiding-in-class-peer-review/
Teaching students to evaluate each other, accessed May 7, 2025, https://teaching.cornell.edu/resource/teaching-students-evaluate-each-other
Benefits and Examples of Student Self-Assessments - Wilson College Online, accessed May 7, 2025, https://online.wilson.edu/resources/examples-of-student-self-assessment/
Discover 7 Student Self Assessment Examples | ISHCMC, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.ishcmc.com/news-and-blog/student-self-assessment-examples/
Redirecting A Lesson With Exemplars - EL Education, accessed May 7, 2025, https://eleducation.org/resources/redirecting-a-lesson-with-exemplars/
Case Study - Brooklyn Co-op School | Exemplars, accessed May 7, 2025, https://exemplars.com/resources/case_studies/Co-op
Using Multiple Exemplars in Teaching {VIP} - The Autism Helper, accessed May 7, 2025, https://theautismhelper.com/using-multiple-exemplars-teaching-vip/
Multi-layered mentoring: exemplars from a U.S. STEM teacher education program - NSF Public Access Repository, accessed May 7, 2025, https://par.nsf.gov/servlets/purl/10563525
The Importance of Studying Exemplars when Designing Stone Facades - Journal of Biomechanical Engineering, accessed May 7, 2025, https://biomechanical.asmedigitalcollection.asme.org/books/chapter-pdf/7210113/10_1520_stp10927s.pdf
a case study on the use of design exemplar as a search and retrieval tool - Clemson OPEN, accessed May 7, 2025, https://open.clemson.edu/all_theses/230/
On the Ground with Active and Collaborative Learning in STEM Gateway Courses: Findings from Classroom Observations, Year 6 Geor - University of Colorado Boulder, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.colorado.edu/eer/sites/default/files/2025-03/LaursenGatewayObservationReportNov23.pdf
Writing a History Paper: The Basics (Example Essay Included) - William & Mary, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.wm.edu/as/history/undergraduateprogram/hwrc/handouts/handouts/writingahistorypaperexampleessay.pdf
Writing Historical Essays: A Guide for Undergraduates - Department of History, accessed May 7, 2025, https://history.rutgers.edu/academics/undergraduate/writing-historical-essays
Writing Samples - Arts Humanities West - Valencia College, accessed May 7, 2025, https://valenciacollege.edu/academics/departments/arts-humanities-west/writing/samples.php
4 SAMPLE GRADUATE SCHOOL ESSAYS - CSU Channel Islands, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.csuci.edu/careerdevelopment/services/sample-graduate-school-admissions-essays.pdf
philarchive.org, accessed May 7, 2025, https://philarchive.org/archive/ENGIOE
the intersection of teacher modelling and student emulation in moral education, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.oneducation.net/no-19_april-2024/the-intersection-of-teacher-modelling-and-student-emulation-in-moral-education/
The Problem with Exemplars - Ideas and Thoughts, accessed May 7, 2025, https://ideasandthoughts.org/2014/12/03/the-problem-with-exemplars/
7 Ways to Support Diversity in the Classroom [With Examples], accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.prodigygame.com/main-en/blog/diversity-in-the-classroom
Inclusive Teaching: 5 Strategies & Examples - Mentimeter, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.mentimeter.com/blog/education/inclusive-teaching-strategies
Infusing Diversity and Inclusion Related Content | Center for ..., accessed May 7, 2025, https://teaching.unl.edu/resources/inclusive-teaching/infusing-content/
Culturally Appropriate Curriculum Design for Educators, accessed May 7, 2025, https://education.purdue.edu/2024/01/curriculum-design-culturally-appropriate/
Tips for Getting Started With Exemplars Classic Math, accessed May 7, 2025, https://exemplars.com/resources/using/classic/getting-started
We Set the Standards! - Exemplars, accessed May 7, 2025, https://exemplars.com/sites/default/files/inline-files/the_guide.pdf
Learn locally, think globally: Exemplar variability supports higher-order generalization and word learning - PMC - PubMed Central, accessed May 7, 2025, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3144952/
Does providing exemplars to students lead to a change in their grades? An examination of the available data on this question, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.alleducationjournal.com/assets/archives/2017/vol2issue3/2-2-37-115.pdf
(PDF) Student perspectives on quality in higher education - ResearchGate, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/270888864_Student_perspectives_on_quality_in_higher_education
Maranges et al. 2024 - Exemplars of Purpose.pdf - Hoover Institution, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.hoover.org/sites/default/files/research/docs/Maranges%20et%20al%202024%20-%20Exemplars%20of%20Purpose.pdf
No comments:
Post a Comment