Differing Views on the Book of Ecclesiastes
1. Introduction
The Book of Ecclesiastes stands as a distinctive and frequently debated text within the Old Testament's collection of wisdom literature 1. At its core is the figure of Qoheleth, often translated as the Teacher or the Preacher, whose reflections open and repeatedly return to the theme of "vanity," rendered in Hebrew as hevel, which can also be understood as meaninglessness 1. The seemingly pessimistic tone of Ecclesiastes, situated within a collection of sacred texts generally associated with hope and divine purpose, presents an immediate interpretive challenge. This has led to a wide array of scholarly interpretations attempting to reconcile its message with the broader biblical narrative 1. This report aims to explore these diverse perspectives across theological, philosophical, literary, and historical domains, examining how the book has been understood and applied throughout history and its relevance to contemporary concerns.
The structure of Ecclesiastes is commonly understood as a frame narrative 6. In this structure, an anonymous author introduces the words of Qoheleth and then concludes the book with a reflection on Qoheleth's teachings 6. However, alternative structural analyses have been proposed, including divisions based on distinct prologues within the text or the identification of multiple voices speaking through the narrative 16. This structural complexity, with its potential for various layers of authorship or perspective, significantly contributes to the multiplicity of interpretations. Depending on whether scholars prioritize the voice of Qoheleth or the perspective of the frame narrator, the overall message of the book can be understood quite differently.
2. Theological Interpretations: Life, Death, and the Afterlife
One prominent theological interpretation views Qoheleth as a cynical or pessimistic figure 1. This perspective emphasizes Qoheleth's reflections on the apparent futility of earthly pursuits when considered without God and the seemingly final nature of death as experienced "under the sun" 2. From this standpoint, Ecclesiastes is sometimes seen as a "foil" to the rest of the Bible, presenting a contrasting view of life devoid of direct divine intervention or the promise of an afterlife 8. The book's emphasis on the shared destiny of the wise and the fool, coupled with the observation that neither is remembered in the long run, further supports this interpretation 2. This reading often takes Qoheleth's statements about vanity at face value, leading to the perception of a deeply negative outlook on the human condition.
Conversely, another significant theological interpretation posits Qoheleth as a wise believer who realistically portrays the transient and often frustrating aspects of life to encourage readers to find their true delight in the blessings provided by God 1. This view underscores the book's ultimate message, which is often seen as the necessity of fearing God and adhering to His commandments as the bedrock of genuine happiness and purpose 3. Proponents of this interpretation often suggest that the "under the sun" perspective represents a limited view of life experienced apart from a relationship with God, and that the book implicitly encourages readers to adopt an "eternal" perspective grounded in faith 9. The exploration of life's vanities, in this light, serves as a pedagogical tool to highlight the true and lasting source of meaning and joy found in God.
The Book of Ecclesiastes presents a seemingly bleak outlook on death, suggesting that both humans and animals share the same fate of returning to dust, with little explicit hope offered beyond the grave 11. Some interpretations emphasize that Ecclesiastes primarily focuses on the realities of life "under the sun" and does not directly engage with the concept of an afterlife 22. This contrasts with theological perspectives that find subtle hints of God's judgment and the potential for a resurrection within the text 6. Notably, early Rabbinical and Christian interpreters often employed allegorical readings to understand Ecclesiastes. In this tradition, seemingly mundane activities like "eating and drinking" were interpreted in light of spiritual realities such as the Torah or the Eucharist, while the theme of vanity served as a warning against excessive attachment to worldly things as opposed to eternal life 23. The ambiguity surrounding the afterlife in Ecclesiastes remains a significant point of interpretive divergence, with some scholars focusing on the immediate earthly context and others seeking connections to broader theological doctrines of judgment and resurrection.
3. Philosophical Perspectives: Meaning, Wisdom, and Vanity
Philosophically, the Book of Ecclesiastes delves into the fundamental question of life's meaning 13. Qoheleth meticulously examines various avenues through which humans seek purpose, including the pursuit of wisdom, the indulgence of pleasure, the accumulation of wealth, and the dedication to work 2. His repeated conclusion that all these endeavors are ultimately "vanity" underscores the idea that lasting meaning cannot be found in earthly pursuits alone 1. Instead, the book often suggests that true meaning is intrinsically linked to the fear of God, the adherence to His commandments, and the grateful acceptance of the simple joys and gifts that He provides 3. Qoheleth's philosophical journey resonates with the existential human quest for meaning, a search that transcends specific historical periods and philosophical traditions. His systematic exploration of potential sources of meaning and his eventual dissatisfaction reflect a universal human experience, making the book relevant to philosophical discussions that extend beyond its immediate theological context.
The book also grapples with the nature and limitations of wisdom 26. Qoheleth embarks on a quest for wisdom, only to discover that even the most profound human intellect has its boundaries and cannot guarantee a life free from hardship or provide ultimate understanding of the world's complexities 6. A distinction is often made between human wisdom, which is based on observation and experience "under the sun," and a more comprehensive wisdom that incorporates the foundational principle of the fear of the Lord 15. Ecclesiastes is often seen as providing a necessary counterpoint to the more straightforward and practical wisdom presented in the Book of Proverbs, adopting a more reflective and questioning approach to the complexities of life 3. By highlighting the inherent limitations of human reason and wisdom, Ecclesiastes subtly directs attention towards the necessity of a different form of knowledge or understanding, frequently interpreted as faith or divine revelation.
Central to the philosophical discourse of Ecclesiastes is the concept of "vanity," which translates the Hebrew word hevel 12. This term carries a range of nuances, including transience, futility, ephemerality, and even enigma 6. The choice of translation significantly influences the reader's understanding of the book's overarching message 9. Whether rendered as vanity, meaninglessness, vapor, or breath, hevel underscores the temporary, fleeting, often paradoxical, and ultimately uncontrollable nature of life and all earthly pursuits 6. Recognizing the multifaceted nature of this central concept is crucial for a nuanced interpretation of Ecclesiastes, moving beyond a simplistic negative assessment to an appreciation of the inherent uncertainties and limitations of human existence.
4. Literary Analysis: Structure, Genre, and Literary Devices
From a literary perspective, the structure of Ecclesiastes as a frame narrative is a key feature 6. The authorial voice introduces Qoheleth and his central claim that "all is vanity," and then concludes the book with a reflection on Qoheleth's words, urging the reader to "fear God and keep his commandments" 6. This framing suggests a deliberate editorial perspective, shaping how Qoheleth's discourse should be interpreted. Beyond this primary structure, scholars have proposed various thematic divisions within the book, or have identified multiple voices at play, including Qoheleth-as-prophet, Qoheleth-as-king, and the epilogist 12. The presence of prologues and epilogues in some structural analyses further highlights the layered nature of the text 16. Additionally, Wright's New Critical analysis, which focuses on patterns of verbal repetition, offers another approach to understanding the book's structural coherence 23. These structural elements indicate a carefully crafted text where different perspectives are presented and ultimately evaluated.
Ecclesiastes is classified within the genre of wisdom literature in the Old Testament 3. While sharing common ground with other wisdom books like Proverbs and Job, Ecclesiastes distinguishes itself through its more reflective and questioning tone 3. Unlike the often prescriptive nature of Proverbs, Ecclesiastes delves into philosophical discourse, incorporating autobiographical narrative and personal observations 23. The debate continues as to whether the book is primarily prose or poetry, with evidence supporting both classifications 23. Recognizing the genre of wisdom literature helps in understanding the book's aim: to explore the complexities of life and offer guidance on living well in light of eternity, often through contemplation and the examination of human experience rather than direct divine pronouncements.
The effectiveness of Ecclesiastes' message is enhanced by its use of various literary devices 6. Metaphors, such as "chasing the wind" and "vapor," and vivid imagery are employed to illustrate the fleeting and insubstantial nature of earthly pursuits 6. The recurring refrain, "Vanity of vanities! All is vanity!" serves as a powerful and memorable emphasis on the book's central theme 3. Furthermore, the text utilizes rhetorical questions to engage the reader, paradoxes to highlight the complexities of life, and antitheses to present contrasting perspectives 23. These literary devices contribute significantly to the book's impact, reinforcing its themes of transience, uncertainty, and the inherent limitations of human understanding in a fallen world.
5. Authorship and Historical Context
The traditional view attributes the authorship of Ecclesiastes to King Solomon 2. This attribution is often based on internal clues within the text, such as the author's self-identification as the "son of David, king in Jerusalem," and references to exceptional wisdom, extensive wealth, and significant achievements, all of which are associated with Solomon's reign 6. External evidence from Jewish Talmudic tradition also supports Solomonic authorship 25. The traditional ascription to Solomon lends considerable weight to the book, framing it as the reflections of a renowned wise and experienced king contemplating the ultimate meaning of life. Solomon's reputation for wisdom makes his apparent disillusionment with earthly accomplishments particularly impactful, serving as a cautionary narrative for readers.
However, many contemporary scholars argue against Solomonic authorship, suggesting instead that Ecclesiastes was likely written by an unknown Jewish author around the late third century BCE, during the Hellenistic period 16. This view is supported by linguistic evidence, including the presence of Persian loanwords and Aramaisms within the Hebrew text, which are more characteristic of a later period 10. Additionally, some scholars point to the historical setting implied in the book, such as references to multiple preceding kings in Jerusalem and the observation of social injustices, which might better reflect the realities of a later era, possibly under foreign rule 10. The title "son of David" could also refer to any descendant of King David, not exclusively Solomon 10. The possibility of a later Israelite teacher adopting a "Solomon-like persona" as a literary device has also been proposed 6. The scholarly debate over authorship underscores the importance of historical and linguistic analysis in understanding biblical texts and their potential contexts. If Ecclesiastes was indeed written in a later period, the prevailing social and political conditions of that time, such as Greek influence and imperial rule, might have shaped the author's perspective and the themes explored in the book.
Regardless of the specific dating, the historical context provides a crucial backdrop for interpreting the author's concerns and the intended audience of Ecclesiastes. Whether the book reflects the reflections of a powerful king in ancient Israel or the musings of a wise teacher in a later, more politically complex time, it engages with enduring human questions about meaning and purpose within specific historical circumstances. Some scholars argue that Ecclesiastes reflects a skeptical reaction against the more optimistic views of wisdom found in earlier texts like Proverbs 23. Understanding this potential intellectual and historical backdrop can enrich our interpretation of the book's message regarding power, justice, and the search for meaning in a world often marked by uncertainty and change.
6. Historical Interpretations and Applications
The Book of Ecclesiastes has been interpreted and applied in diverse ways throughout history. Early Jewish and Christian interpretations reveal a Rabbinical debate concerning its canonical status, suggesting initial literal readings of the text 23. However, by the fourth century AD, an allegorical reading of Ecclesiastes became dominant among both Jewish and Christian scholars 23. In this interpretive framework, seemingly straightforward passages were imbued with deeper spiritual meanings. For instance, "eating and drinking" were often understood as references to the study of the Torah or the participation in the Eucharist, while the theme of vanity served as a caution against excessive attachment to the temporal world in contrast to the eternal life promised in faith 23. This allegorical approach remained the prevailing mode of interpretation until the Reformation. Early interpreters sought to harmonize the challenging message of Ecclesiastes with established theological doctrines by finding symbolic meanings within its text.
The Reformation witnessed a significant shift in the interpretation of Ecclesiastes with the revival of literal interpretation 23. Reformers like Martin Luther advocated for a more direct engagement with the text, leading to new understandings of passages previously interpreted allegorically. For example, the concept of "eating and drinking" began to be seen as a legitimate enjoyment of the creation bestowed by God 23. This shift moved the focus away from solely spiritualized readings towards a more grounded appreciation of the book's reflections on human experience in the world.
As historical-critical methods of biblical analysis developed, they were also applied to Ecclesiastes 23. This approach involved a more rigorous examination of the book's historical context, authorship, and literary composition. Source criticism, which seeks to identify the various sources that may have been combined to form the final text, was applied to Ecclesiastes, and the traditional Solomonic authorship came under increasing scrutiny 23. Figures like Hugo Grotius in the 17th century were among the first since Luther to argue against Solomon's authorship, suggesting that the book might be a collection of different opinions on happiness compiled by a later author 23. Modern biblical criticism has significantly influenced the understanding of Ecclesiastes, prompting a greater emphasis on its historical context and literary features, often leading to interpretations that differ from traditional views.
7. Modern Interpretations and Contemporary Relevance
The themes explored in the Book of Ecclesiastes, such as the search for meaning, the experience of futility, and the inevitability of death, resonate profoundly with contemporary audiences living in a secularized and often uncertain world 2. Its honest and sometimes unsettling portrayal of life's complexities has made it particularly popular among younger individuals who have encountered pain and instability 20. The book's engagement with fundamental human concerns about work, relationships, and the pursuit of happiness also contributes to its enduring relevance in modern society 36. The enduring appeal of Ecclesiastes lies in its candid and unflinching exploration of universal human experiences of frustration, uncertainty, and the quest for purpose, rendering it remarkably applicable to contemporary life. In an era where traditional sources of meaning are frequently questioned, Ecclesiastes offers a biblical perspective that grapples with similar existential concerns, presenting both a critique of worldly pursuits and a potential path toward finding meaning in a relationship with God.
Secular readers often interpret Ecclesiastes as a piece of ancient literature that reflects on the inherent futility of existence without necessarily invoking a divine resolution 28. From this viewpoint, the book provides a "secular" analysis of life's apparent meaninglessness, prompting reflection on the human condition and the transient nature of earthly endeavors 29. The raw honesty of Ecclesiastes about the challenges and uncertainties of life resonates with individuals regardless of their religious beliefs, encouraging contemplation on fundamental questions of existence.
Modern theological approaches to Ecclesiastes often emphasize the book's ultimate message of fearing God and finding joy in the simple gifts He provides as a corrective to its apparent pessimism 1. Some interpretations suggest that Ecclesiastes serves to expose the limitations of false worldviews and ultimately directs readers toward a God-centered perspective 9. The book is also seen as encouraging gratitude for the blessings of life and contentment with God's provision 5. These modern theological interpretations often aim to reconcile the challenging aspects of Ecclesiastes with core Christian beliefs, highlighting its ultimate message of faith, obedience, and the discovery of meaning in a relationship with God. In this light, Qoheleth's exploration of vanity is not an end in itself but a necessary step in recognizing the limitations of a life lived apart from God and the true source of fulfillment.
8. Comparison with Other Biblical and Philosophical Texts
Comparing Ecclesiastes with other books within the biblical canon and with philosophical texts reveals its unique place in the landscape of human thought. Within the wisdom literature of the Old Testament, Ecclesiastes stands in contrast to Proverbs, which generally offers a more optimistic and practical approach to acquiring wisdom 3. While Proverbs often presents wisdom as a reliable path to a good life, Ecclesiastes adopts a more reflective and questioning stance, acknowledging the complexities and uncertainties that even wisdom cannot fully address 3. Similar to the Book of Job, Ecclesiastes explores themes of suffering and the limitations of human understanding, but it approaches the resolution of these issues differently 3. Some scholars suggest that Ecclesiastes can be seen as a response to or a counterpoint to the more simplistic wisdom presented in Proverbs, offering a more nuanced perspective on the realities of life in a fallen world 4.
The themes explored in Ecclesiastes also find resonance with various philosophical traditions 2. Parallels can be drawn between Qoheleth's reflections and ideas found in existentialism, nihilism, and hedonism. His exploration of pleasure, for instance, can be seen as a form of hedonism, albeit one that he ultimately finds unsatisfying 2. If Ecclesiastes is indeed dated to the Hellenistic period, it is also possible to consider its engagement with Greek philosophical thought 16. Comparing Ecclesiastes with philosophical texts highlights its engagement with fundamental human questions about meaning, purpose, and the nature of existence, suggesting a cross-cultural and timeless relevance to these inquiries.
The relationship between Ecclesiastes and other books of the Bible is complex, with apparent contradictions or tensions arising between its seemingly pessimistic views and the more hopeful or straightforward messages found elsewhere in scripture 2. Various interpretive strategies have been employed to reconcile these tensions, such as emphasizing the frame narrative which provides a theological perspective on Qoheleth's words, or focusing on the ultimate conclusion of Ecclesiastes which calls for fearing God and keeping His commandments 27. Additionally, there are instances where New Testament authors reference concepts found in Ecclesiastes, suggesting an awareness and integration of its wisdom within the broader biblical narrative 13. The inclusion of Ecclesiastes, with its challenging perspectives, necessitates a careful consideration of its place within the overall narrative and theological framework of the Bible.
9. Conclusion
The Book of Ecclesiastes presents a rich tapestry of differing views, reflecting its unique voice within the biblical canon and its enduring engagement with fundamental questions of human existence. Interpretations diverge significantly on the tone of Qoheleth, with some viewing him as a cynic highlighting life's inherent meaninglessness, while others see him as a realist urging readers to find joy and purpose in God amidst life's vanities. The understanding of the central term "hevel" also varies, impacting the overall interpretation of the book's message. The significance of the afterlife, the authorship and historical context of the text, and its ultimate theological message remain key areas of scholarly debate.
Despite these differing views, Ecclesiastes continues to fascinate and challenge readers across centuries and diverse worldviews. Its unflinching honesty about the complexities and frustrations of life, coupled with its persistent search for meaning, resonates with the human condition in any era. The book's willingness to grapple with difficult questions, even those that seem to challenge conventional wisdom, makes it a valuable contribution to our understanding of life, faith, and the enduring human quest for purpose in a world marked by both beauty and transience.
Works cited
Top 5 Commentaries on the Book of Ecclesiastes - Ways to Learn at Ligonier.org, accessed March 25, 2025, https://learn.ligonier.org/articles/top-5-commentaries-ecclesiastes
Ecclesiastes: The Inspired Book of Error - RayStedman.org, accessed March 25, 2025, https://www.raystedman.org/bible-overview/adventuring/ecclesiastes-the-inspired-book-of-error
Why Study the Book of Ecclesiastes? | Crossway Articles, accessed March 25, 2025, https://www.crossway.org/articles/why-study-the-book-of-ecclesiastes/
bibleproject.com, accessed March 25, 2025, https://bibleproject.com/explore/video/ecclesiastes/#:~:text=The%20book%20of%20Ecclesiastes%20is,there%20any%20point%20at%20all%3F
Ecclesiastes - Bible Book Chapters and Summary - New International Version, accessed March 25, 2025, https://www.christianity.com/bible/niv/ecclesiastes/
Book of Ecclesiastes | Guide with Key Information and Resources - The Bible Project, accessed March 25, 2025, https://bibleproject.com/guides/book-of-ecclesiastes/
Book of Ecclesiastes Summary | Watch an Overview Video - The Bible Project, accessed March 25, 2025, https://bibleproject.com/explore/video/ecclesiastes/
The Viewpoint of Ecclesiastes: Cynicism or Realism? - Faith Pulpit, accessed March 25, 2025, https://faithpulpit.faith.edu/posts/the-viewpoint-of-ecclesiastes-cynicism-or-realism
Three Approaches to Ecclesiastes - Knowable Word, accessed March 25, 2025, https://www.knowableword.com/2019/05/31/three-approaches-to-ecclesiastes/
TGC Course | Knowing the Bible: Ecclesiastes | 12-week Bible Study, accessed March 25, 2025, https://www.thegospelcoalition.org/course/knowing-the-bible-ecclesiastes/
What Is the Background of Ecclesiastes? - Bibles.net, accessed March 25, 2025, https://www.bibles.net/book-background/background-of-ecclesiastes/
The Vanity of ECCLESIASTES - Biblical Viewpoint, accessed March 25, 2025, https://biblicalviewpoint.com/2022/09/30/the-vanity-of-ecclesiastes/
Summary of the Book of Ecclesiastes - Bible Survey | GotQuestions.org, accessed March 25, 2025, https://www.gotquestions.org/Book-of-Ecclesiastes.html
Happiness, Death, Anxiety, Resurrection – Part III: Ecclesiastes - Conciliar Post, accessed March 25, 2025, https://conciliarpost.com/philosophy/ethics/happiness-death-anxiety-resurrection-part-iii-ecclesiastes/
Ecclesiastes · GitBook - Bible Research, accessed March 25, 2025, https://bible.hightower.space/notes/old_testament/wisdom_literature/ecclesiastes.html
Ecclesiastes - Wikipedia, accessed March 25, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ecclesiastes
Ecclesiastes Commentaries - Precept Austin, accessed March 25, 2025, https://www.preceptaustin.org/ecclesiastes_commentaries
Ecclesiastes: The Ultimate Meaning of Life - Something Good Radio, accessed March 25, 2025, https://www.somethinggoodradio.org/blog/ecclesiastes-the-ultimate-meaning-of-life/
The Afterlife (or not) in Ecclesiastes - The Bart Ehrman Blog, accessed March 25, 2025, https://ehrmanblog.org/the-afterlife-or-not-in-ecclesiastes/
Book of Ecclesiastes Overview - Insight for Living Ministries, accessed March 25, 2025, https://insight.org/resources/bible/the-wisdom-books/ecclesiastes
The Book of Ecclesiastes: Summary - InfoPlease, accessed March 25, 2025, https://www.infoplease.com/religion/old-testament-ecclesiastes-summary
Eternity in Our Hearts? ...Ecclesiastes 3:11 Revisited, accessed March 25, 2025, https://www.ccef.org/eternity-our-hearts-ecclesiastes-311-revisited
Qoheleth in the Canon?! Current Trends in the Interpretation of Ecclesiastes, accessed March 25, 2025, https://www.thegospelcoalition.org/themelios/article/qoheleth-in-the-canon-current-trends-in-the-interpretation-of-ecclesiastes/
The meaning of life – wisdom from Ecclesiastes - Bible Feed, accessed March 25, 2025, https://www.biblefeed.org/podcast/the-meaning-of-life-wisdom-from-ecclesiastes/
Who Wrote Ecclesiastes? - Thomas Nelson Bibles, accessed March 25, 2025, https://www.thomasnelsonbibles.com/blog/who-wrote-ecclesiastes/
8 - The Vanity of Wisdom - Christ Church Plano, accessed March 25, 2025, https://christchurchplano.org/study/8-the-vanity-of-wisdom/
Thoughts on Ecclesiastes? : r/Reformed - Reddit, accessed March 25, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/Reformed/comments/1haggv8/thoughts_on_ecclesiastes/
reflections on ecclesiastes: the philosophy of "vanity" and impermanence : r/literature - Reddit, accessed March 25, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/literature/comments/1hm2azk/reflections_on_ecclesiastes_the_philosophy_of/
Understanding Ecclesiastes: A Secular Bible Analysis - Logically Fallacious, accessed March 25, 2025, https://www.logicallyfallacious.com/cgi-bin/uy/blog.cgi?ns_articles+understanding-ecclesiastes-a-secular-bible-analysis.html
Ecclesiastes: A Biblical Philosophy of Life | Countryside Bible Church, accessed March 25, 2025, https://countrysidebible.org/sermons/20140629p-111215
Ecclesiastes and Wisdom - PsalterMark, accessed March 25, 2025, https://psaltermark.com/2018/03/14/ecclesiastes/
Ecclesiastes: Reading Wisdom Literature - AWS, accessed March 25, 2025, https://grace-marketing2018.s3.amazonaws.com/documents/22_CL_Article_Ecclesiastes_WisdomLiterature_8.5x11.pdf
13/23- Reading "Ecclesiastes": Genre and Translation - Wenglinsky Review, accessed March 25, 2025, https://www.wenglinskyreview.com/wenglinsky-review-a-journal-of-culture-politics/2019/4/12/1323-reading-ecclesiastes-genre-and-translation
insight.org, accessed March 25, 2025, https://insight.org/resources/bible/the-wisdom-books/ecclesiastes#:~:text=With%20Solomon%20as%20the%20author,but%20short%20on%20lasting%20rewards.
A Theological Introduction to Ecclesiastes (Pt. 1): Authorship, Authority, and Intertextuality, accessed March 25, 2025, https://davidschrock.com/2013/11/07/a-theological-introduction-to-ecclesiastes-pt-1-authorship-and-authority/
Preaching from the Most Relevant Book in the Bible, accessed March 25, 2025, https://www.preachingtoday.com/exegesis/ecclesiastes/preaching-from-most-relevant-book-in-bible.html
Background of Ecclesiastes - Enter the Bible, accessed March 25, 2025, https://enterthebible.org/courses/ecclesiastes/lessons/background-of-ecclesiastes
Ecclesiastes and contemporary argument - Jewish Quest, accessed March 25, 2025, https://jewishquest.org/writing/ecclesiastes-and-contemporary-argument/
Ecclesiastes in Context: Reclaiming Qoheleth's Canonical Authority - The Gospel Coalition, accessed March 25, 2025, https://www.thegospelcoalition.org/themelios/article/ecclesiastes-in-context-reclaiming-qoheleths-canonical-authority/
No comments:
Post a Comment